Amanda Shulman's Her Place Supper Club is a cozy, intimate, all women-chef powerhouse. I'd recommend only going for birthdays, but the high price tag does reflect the large portion of food!
---
The menu rotates every few weeks, Tock reservations are mandatory and there are 6 PM and 8:30 PM seatings- 2 hours of dining time. You will not be seated early. There are no dietary accommodations and no substitutions.
I dined on the first day of their summer bone in fillet menu, and it was such a treat. The dining experience is broken up into appetizer courses, break, entree courses, break, and then dessert. There are always optional add-ons (extra $$) which can be added after the appetizers. If you don't get the add-ons, you just sit around until other patrons are done eating to continue your meal wherever the set menu paused. The food is plated for 2 to share for most appetizers, and of your own portion for the entrees.
My table's favorite offerings were the pecorino popovers, crab cake, and bone in fillet. Everything was cooked to perfection and the menu was cohesive. The popovers were unbelievably fluffy, tender, and creamy. The crab cake was large and juicy. The bone in fillet was one of the best pieces of steak I've ever had- melt in your mouth tender. We felt the corn cappellettis were also very interesting, if not a bit too sweet. Overall, we were a little split on the rest of the set menu items- everything was cooked well but we disagreed on flavors. I personally felt many things were too salty/sweet, while others thought they weren't salty/sweet enough. However, I still would classify this meal as one of the most memorable I've had in a while based on the experience.
Although I know the small, dark, and cozy interior is part of the charm for some, I felt it made my dining experience really negative. The seating had ~8 small tables, and some limited kitchen counter seating where you can watch the food being cooked and speak with the staff, which seemed pretty cool! As an inherent issue with any set menu and because the tables are small, if you don't eat fast enough to "keep up" with the speed of service, there isn't much room to place other plates, so I felt very rushed as a slow eater. As a small space, I felt the restaurant was very loud, which for me didn't reflect an intimate dining space.
Lastly, the service was phenomenal but hurried. After the initial check in for drink orders, the wait staff was quick to replace utensils, bring plates, and clear them. However, as all staff was working at light speed to keep up with the courses, our table found it difficult to flag anyone down for anything "more", like more water, order more drinks, or to take a photo. I even put my hand up and was ignored and gave up.
As my group was there to celebrate a graduation and indicated it on the reservation that we had a "celebration," we were sad to see it was never acknowledged. The guests' who were there to celebrate their birthdays had party hats at their seats, were serenaded with the birthday song, and received an extra small "dessert." It wasn't a big deal, but felt a little disappointing seeing all the fanfare for birthdays and receiving no acknowledgement for other "occasions."
The set menu was priced at $125/pp, we got two additional plates, and our final rounded cost was $195/pp. For the amount of food and courses, we felt it was definitely fair! However, I personally would only recommend going for birthdays. read more