This place was outstanding! Super friendly staff (older women), great sandwiches and clean comfortable seatinfg inside or outrside and clean restrooms! Bread is made daily and super fresh. Club sandwich had great flavored meats with perfect combo of LTO. Meatball sandwich was also great with the meatballs cut in half so they don't fall all over the place. Unlike most messy meatball sandwiches, you can actually eat this like a sandwich! Bread also great on this. read more

See all

My husband loved this place from his college days. The marbled rye particularly. It is still delicious. They are heavy handed with the filling which pleases him. Meats are yummy and fresh. Veggie option is good. Love the pickle. Mind you, neither of us has been to NY. read more

Authentic Its not. No real milk or cream for coffee. Only Fake Coffee Mate. No Bialys either. Bagel was pesto & Parm cheese and delicious. Not enough cream cheese, oh and no other flavors of cream cheese. Staff were great. Place is empty for breakfast. 2nd and last time giving this place a try. I'm from Miami/Ft Lauderdale Florida and I have been to a few Bagel places in 50 years. read more

Heidi's Brooklyn Deli - Authentic Brooklyn would have real milk/cream for coffee? Plain cream cheese only? Parm/Pesto Bagel was fresh & delicious. - Sandwiches Near Me - Montrose, Colorado

The food is very good but it's not fast so be prepared for a wait, about 15 minutes. It's also a little pricey.

My wife and I had trouble choosing since the menu is vast. We both chose the Heidi club that had Turkey, ham, roast beef and bacon. The homemade bread selection was also very good- we chose the whole wheat. This was one of the best sandwiches I've ever had. Fresh and great quality. Service was excellent and friendly. Give them a try- I'm sure you'll agree read more

Clean Nice Staff plenty of seating Open and airy lunch vibe The food was good and quality, quantity and price were all in line. Food came out quick, so good for lunch hour time constraints. My only - tiny critique.... The condiment packets are kept in a super hot spot, so not appetizing... Mayo on request, it's kept cold read more

Do you sell day old bread? Any style of your breads,rolls and bagels. How late are you open?

Absolute show stopper!! The sandwich I had put a pep in my step! Randomly stopped in on the way to Telluride from Airport. Great decision, scratch that, best decision!!! Juliana's Fav was exceptional and wifie got spicy ham and cheese both on sourdough! My taste buds are still reeling from such a wonderful meal. Will absolutely be a must stop atleast once every trip!! Good job Heidi!!! read more

Great food, and excellent service. Convenient location, next to shopping. I personally like the salmon lox samwitch.

Great vibes great food great atmosphere... sandwiches are amazing leaving your tastebuds wanting more

Excellent sandwiches excellent service. Not a bad thing to say I highly recommend this deli. One of the best anywhere read more

Amazing pace. The hells kitchen is my go to.every one is super nice there as well. The bread is amazing.

A fine quick meal. Reuben sandwich was satisfying. The special Turkey sandwich was great too. Good good and good people.

Wow, the pictured meal cost me over $18. Employees should be wearing hairnets, the women's hair is blowing all over the place. The restaurant was extremely messy, I sat at the one table that wasn't as sticky and crummy as the rest of them. I was hoping for more given it was my first time here but I definitely won't be back! $18 for a turkey sandwich, chips and a drink is outrageous. read more

Heidi's Brooklyn Deli - Sandwiches Near Me - Montrose, Colorado

The pastrami Reuben is amazing you will not be disappointing quick service friendly staff welcoming place

Had the best hot corned beef sandwich on dark rye that I have found in a long time! Friendly helpful staff! Very satisfied will be returning soon! read more

So, expecting a New York type of sandwich. Instead, stale buns, very very little meat on sandwich and absolutely ridiculous prices.

Don't let the strip mall location fool you. This place is really good. I had the half a Reuben sandwich with corned beef with potato salad and both were legit. My wife had the chicken noodle soup and half Italian sub! She loved it. We also picked up a couple of cookies and a cheesecake. All are scrumptious. We'll be back! read more

Really good sandwiches and will customize to order. The soups however? Meh. They could do better than foodservice-made soup. Same with the Cole slaw, salads and dressings. Service was competent and prompt, so no issues there. Dining room was clean and counter help was friendly and made good suggestions. I'll be back. Please up the quality on the soups and sides. Nothing straight out of a container please. For the prices paid you can do better! read more

I popped in this morning for a sandwich and was SO pleased!! The staff were extremely kind! The place was very clean!! Can't wait to enjoy my sandwich. Awesome place!! Excellent menu- lots of choices! read more

I'm a little torn about this review, so that's why I'm giving Heidi's an extra star. We had been coming to Heidi's on a regular basis because the food is pretty darn good. I usually get the Chefs Salad and my boys are fans of the Philly Cheese Steak Sandwich. It's a typical deli...decor is decent and seating is plentiful with both booths and tables/chairs. Here's the problem. It can get really busy at times and their order system just doesn't seem to cut it...it's slow and inefficient. When you're up for ordering don't expect a team approach. The person that takes your order is "IT" from beginning to end, and by "END" I mean they're likely to be your cashier as well because they never seem to have a dedicated person doing this...this is another cog in the wheel because they may be busy taking another persons order so you wait, and wait... Seriously, it's a no-brainer...food is really great and the staff is friendly...all they need to do is implement a team approach during the ordering process and have a dedicated cashier. Love Heidi's and always will...just hope you'll heed my advice. :) read more

I'm surprised by the low scores on Yelp, tbh I think is a solid place for a and holds it's own against other chain sandwich places. Of course the sandwiches aren't gourmet or artisanal, but it def hits the spot for a quick lunch. The bread was good and the portions were sizable. My husband and I split a "Da Bomb" sandwich on Italian bread. The sandwich was toasted well with crispy edges, melted cheese and decently tasty. And they aren't skimping on the stuff inside the sandwich, this is key. I do feel like maybe the chicken salad filling would have benefited from some extra salt or maybe spice. We also got the Greek salad, chock full of peppers, feta and olives. I loved that they made the salad with the items evenly dispersed throughout. Also the staff were really friendly at this location, which is always greatly appreciated. read more

I absolutely love This place. It's a hidden gem in montrose and everything Ive ordered has been wonderful read more

Stopped by for lunch. Large sandwich menu. Wanted a salad. Choices were; chef, Caesar, Greek, Awesome, chicken salad. Chose the Greek. Iceberg, tomatoes, banana peppers, onions (which I asked them to hold), Greek olives & grated Parmesan. No dressing (you pick a to-go packet). Not worth the $8. Insult to injury was the terrible country music station they had blaring. I HATE country music and would not expect it in a "deli" even if it was in Montrose. read more

Heidi's Brooklyn Deli - customers at the counter - Sandwiches Near Me - Montrose, Colorado

My family has had lunch at Heidi's twice in the past month. Everything was delicious. We have tried the rueben, the bomb, the brooklyn, the turkey and two different soups. Large portions, friendly service, and calm atmosphere. We all enjoyed it. I have since gone back and purchased their loaves of bread to take home. $2.99 for "yesterday's loaves," not a bad price for a giant homemade loaf of marbled rye and ciabatta. We will keep going back. read more

I went here with my husband and his parents while visiting the western slope. My in-laws like to go to this place often when they're in the Montrose area - they love all the choices on the menu. I, too, was excited when I saw the menu - my mouth started watering when I saw the soup of the day was broccoli cheddar and I could get it in a bread bowl - but I guess I was a little late for lunch (we got there around 1pm), and they were out of the soup I wanted. The other soups didn't jive with my vegetarian diet, so I went for a cold veggie sandwich. It was a great combo, including avocados, but I was still mourning the lost chance of that bread bowl soup. My MIL had a similar experience on this particular day - she was excited to see they offered gluten-free bread, but they were also out of this by the time we got there. So, they had two strikes...but I would still recommend this spot if you're in the area. They have a lot of sandwich, bread, and salad options, and also make coffee drinks. If I recall, they had a breakfast menu as well. Look for the giant pinecone outside! read more

Heidi's Brooklyn Deli - the entrance to the restaurant - Sandwiches Near Me - Montrose, Colorado

impeccable service. great food. good vibes. cold water. great chip selection. ac is working. smells clean. "It's all about the food." read more

Heidi's Brooklyn Deli - me and my sammy - Sandwiches Near Me - Montrose, Colorado

It's noon on a Saturday. They're out of lox, Italian and French rolls, potato soup that's listed on their menu. There may have been more. That's just the stuff we asked for that they didn't have. The line wasn't super long, maybe 4 people ahead of us but the employees all seemed new and they moved at a glacial pace. I ordered a cheesesteak and it took so long to order and pay that it wasn't even warm when I got to the table to eat. The sandwiches aren't big for the price. They taste okay but I would never come back and waste 35 minutes in line. The sides are awful. They food processored the coleslaw to a paste. read more

This is literally the only good place to eat in town! I am so grateful to the beautiful ladies that work here. No matter how busy they are they always have a smile and are extremely polite and friendly. My food is always perfect and the ingredients are top of the line. When my husband is in town he makes sure he comes in three times for his week at home. They have made a positive lasting impression on the many many times that we have been here and now they are a weekly staple. read more

We ordered #13 the sand ice was terrific I like the spicy sauce. I ordered sourdough and the bread was delicious but more like a wheat bread. The reason I only gave 4 stars was the young teenager that waited on me around 3:00 in Sunday January 15 gave me the incorrect change I gave him a $20 and he ga e me the change for a $10 bill. He already put it in the drawer when I told him I had given him a twenty. He insisted it was a ten. Nice move. read more

Ordered online as no one answered the phone. Got there and stood by the carry out sign. No one greeted or spoke to me (3 people working). After 12-15 mins a woman asked if I had ordered on line and I said yes, and she said I should have told them. What?! What happened to greeting the customer and asking if you can help?! Never asked name or about order, just gave me the 3 bags on the back table. Got home and my Brooklyn Dog had NOTHING ON IT! A bun and dog. What a waste of money . Overall disappointing encounter and I'll never be back! read more

Love this location of Heidi's Brooklyn Deli. Been to a few and this is the best. Everything used is FRESH. Service is great--quick, easy, accurate. I always got a chef or cobb salad and I LOVE when they give you an actual salad instead of mostly lettuce with a few chunks of meat, tomatoes, etc. There's several eatery options in the complex, and this is the healthiest--which made me frequent it more than any other place. Only thing is they close at 630pm and when I don't get done with my work visit until about 7 or after, its a bummer that they're closed. read more

We were very hungry by the time we stopped here, and we came here on purpose because...who doesn't love a good deli?! The choices look awesome. Three of us all tried something different. The kid said his BLT with avocado was good (I didn't look to see how much bacon was in it). Husband likes his club. I had the Ruben with corned beef. It was more like a sauerkraut sandwich with a touch of meat. Ant the corned beef wasn't trimmed up very well, it was 1/4 fat. Some probably would't mind the gristle...I'm not some. Bread was good. As we were eating, I overheard the older lady behind the counter tell a younger man to go wash his hands (loud enough to hear from the dining area). He was making sandwiches. A few minutes later, I noticed him eating, right behind the counter, not trying to be discreet. Dude, take a break and grab a seat in the dining room. At least DON'T wipe your mouth with your hand just before you ask the people who just walked in what they would like... read more

Wanted a sammich and remembered seeing this place off S. Townsend. I stopped in and opted for the Coney Island Reuben on marble rye.. nom nom nom. The bread was fresh, sammich was on the large side, but not OMGWTF Big. $8 (with tax) gets you the sandwich, pickle and a side. Mean was moist, cheese melty, kraut not overpowering.. might be a bit on the blander side, but that may be a taste preference.. thousand island rounded it off. MUCH better than sandwiches from the underground railway chain. Service was good and quick. Main drawback to this place is trying to find the best way to meander through the parking lots to get to it. Someone was drunk when planning this place, I think. I'm looking forward to trying another item on the menu. read more

We drove out of our way due to ratings. off Hwy 50 - don't. It is a good "FAST FOOD" deli with great fresh bread but still a fanchise deli. Must have 20 other places to eat near and all would be just as good. read more

I'm done with this place 4 times in a row they couldn't make what I wanted from their menu. most of the kids working there look like they are very stressed. It's just a sandwich! on my last visit I stood there for ten hole minutes waiting for service as they were goofing around in the back. I finely walked out and as I was going out the door someone yelled. "Can I help you?" I said no and kept walking. Also when you can get a sandwich they are very inconsistent. Its not worth my time going there. read more

Our sandwiches were pretty good, tons of meat, but super expensive. My family of four ate for $60.

This was a sad visit today. What used to be one of my favorite fall lunch places is no more. This place has obviously changed hands recently. I ordered soup which no longer has bread bowls plus it was less than a scoop for a large. The chicken gumbo I ordered in no way resembled chicken gumbo. In fact had no chicken even in it or rice!! Sad sad day. read more

We stopped on vacation. Good choice. Very friendly, helpful. Homemade bread, several kinds. Had the crooned beef, it was good. My sister had chicken salad sandwiche, it was decent. Homemade dessert, also. read more

What a great locally owned/CO based Sandwich shop!! Fantastic service, super clean location & plenty of options. Highly recommends a Black Sunrise smoothie & Cajun Avocado sandwich. Can't wait to stop in again!! read more