Wow wow wow wow!!!! I live around the neighbourhood and just found out about this place. And I…read morenever knew about this till I walked around my neighbourhood looking for food one night with my family. The decor is bland and again, these mom and pop shops aren't known for their decors. We are here for the food. I ordered a fish and chip and it came out fresh and piping hot. Not too burnt but very crispy. The boss lady came by to check in on us and it's nice to connect with small businesses around the corner in the neighbourhood. Her service is personable and just friendly.

Not a bad fish and chips spot. It's actually pretty good. I…read moreordered the halibut and it was nice and tender, white and the batter was nice and light and crispy. I would have liked the fries to be hand cut. I think they were frozen but to each restaurant their own. The price was very reasonable for a halibut fish and chips. The service was amazing. The 2 waitress that served me were very fast and efficient. Which a 25% tip was deserving. The only down side was the decor and ambiance. The inside and furnishings were a bit on the old and used too much side. I would recommend they do some renovations to spruce the place up. I would also recommend all yelpers and patrons to try this spot as the halibut fish and chips are worth the visit and money. Side note: I didn't try any of the other fishes like cod and haddock so no comment on those.

Excellent fish & chips. The thinner cut of chips is great. Wonderful friendly service…read more Very busy on Fridays and only taking pre orders for Goof Friday - that is how popular they are!

This fish & chips place also sells burgers and souvlaki and get 3.5 stars…read more Had haddock & chips and shrimp & chips. The haddock was good - tasty & reasonably crispy even eaten 15 mins later as takeout. The chips had an authentic British crispiness, so they'd have been better when fresh. The shrimp was coconut shrimp rather than being normal battered shrimp (this isn't mentioned on the main menu, but elsewhere). It was decent, though the slightly spicy cocktail sauce did not really go with it. There was quite a bit of "shrimp" (i.e. reformed shrimp patty with a shrimp tail stuck in). Both dishes came with a small serving (sauce container) of coleslaw. It was decent - crisp & tasty, though a touch sharp.

Came by for a quick dinner and was pleasantly surprised. They make it to order and everything is…read moresuper tasty. Fish and chips piping hot I think I burned myself. But service was quick and there is seating. It's not the nicest place but value was excellent and I will come try the shrimp or scallops next time.

I haven't been here in like 1-2 years now and came on a whim because I was craving fish and chips…read more Amy's hit the hunger spot though. I ordered 2 of their specials (Haddock and chips including a pop) for $12.50 + tax each. I was a little hesitant about the haddock being fishy? And was debating on paying more and getting their halibut. I was worried sick all the way home. But Upon eating the haddock, I was truly genuinely surprised at how good it was. Honestly, I couldn't tell the difference between this and halibut which is saying a lot about fish and chips. When my food was done, I saw the cook ( a lady ) and it was the same one from my previous visits a long time ago. Oh boy, I hope they don't change as the lady cook is a keeper! I know that this place was up for sale a while back and that is why I was hesitant to come here recently. But, after seeing that the cook is the same, I will be sure to make a few more visits and into my regular rotation of take out food. To all the yelpers out there. This is by far the best haddock I've tried and is comparable to halibut at a portion of the price. It's an easy recommendation.

Ordered early for Good Friday along with hundreds of other people! The fish was good, not overly…read moregreasy, and didn't leave that heavy feeling in your gut after. Service was slower than expected...even considering the rush, and a little unorganized. If someone was going the payment only, not trying to also manage everything else, it would have gone much smoother. Staff were almost cordial, as much as expected. Looks like a strip mall fish and chips joint, not much to the decor or ambiance...but it is what you'd expect. I would get the fish again.

We ordered the light and fluffy battered halibut with a side of thick cut fries with a side of…read morecoleslaw and gravy. The gravy was a great add-on to the fries we had! The coleslaw was fine (does anyone realllllly like coleslaw? Haha) It was $41 for two boxes of fish and chips (1 piece of halibut each) + the gravy + the coleslaw. A little pricey, but I would go again :)

I visited on a Sunday after 2pm it took less than 10 min for my order to be ready. I got 2 haddock…read morelunch specials, they were all out of cod. I also got a side of small gravy which was that nice thick poutine gravy! Not too salty. The fries were good but there was quite a bit of small crunchy bits. The fish was big portion for lunch size. I did not taste grease or excessive oil! Thank God. I ordered inside and they brought it out to my car for me

Tonight was our last visit to Heritage Fish & Chips. The Halibut was $20 per piece. After 2 people…read moredining in, and a bill that cost $100, we've decided we like the other Fish and Chips place, called Atlantis Fish & Chips (across from Harvey's) a lot better and for 1/2 the price. Server said, she should have told us the price (as we just ordered without looking at the menu)... but, failed to do so. Now, we know not to eat there ever again (our fault). Food was not as nice as Atlantis Fish and Chips.

Excellent fish and chips Straight out of the 70/80s…read moreinterior. Top notch for Newmarket!!!

I ordered fish and chips and spring rolls. The fish and chips were very yummy can't complain at all…read more- couldn't ask for more they did a great job on my order. The spring rolls were a little different then the usual common veggie spring rolls but were still good, however not my favorite filling. I would still come back everyone has Thier own recipe and I still enjoyed them. Oh and don't forget to try the spiral potato!! So good!!

It's my first time at Halibut House and I wanted to try a variety from their menu so we ordered the…read morecod and chips, chicken souvlaki and calamari. The fish and chips are solid choices and they live up to their name. A good amount of chips that come with the meal. I think for the price we were a bit disappointed by the quantity of the calamari and for the chicken souvlaki, a bit sad looking (see pic) and not as flavourful or just below par. Definitely skip the souvlaki here and get what they're known for. Plenty of seating inside the restaurant. However, we just ordered for takeout.

I've visited this Halibut House location in Thornhill, this time for dine-in…read more I ordered the lunch size halibut And Right off the bat , the waitress said it is "this small with a hand gesture". I said ok no problem Upon my food arriving it was pretty small ( look at pic). And I would have given a 1 star review But I must say the halibut (even though miniature in size) was actually crispy and flavourful and even though I didn't take a picture, the fish was pretty thick. Therefore my reason for 3 stars. Also, the fries were not quite right for a fish and chips shoppe. Either they were frozen or they were re-cooked for too long and they were hard, bland and tasteless. I will still keep my review at 3 stars. But I don't think I'll be back anytime soon. Sorry, hope they can do better for other patrons.

Tip: There's a tip jar at the counter…read more A recent Yelp elite experience introduced me to The Big Catch in Newmarket. It recently opened a store in Markham, which I look forward to visiting. I have been to this plaza a few times over the years. I've been to the Tim Hortons a handful of times. I was at Mom's Pan-fried Buns a few months ago, which is a couple of businesses down from The Big Catch. This plaza has lots of parking. I pulled into a parking spot and walked in. I was immediately greeted by a friendly, efficient woman. I got halibut and chips as my main meal. I paid for a can of Diet Coke with a credit card. Tap. Done! I found a table. I caught up with some photos on my phone. It didn't take long for my food to arrive. I had to ask for my Diet Coke. She was running the entire fry-seating show, so I was patient. I finally got my drink. Yay! The halibut was a decent portion. I got a lot of fries. My meal came with a lemon slice and tartar sauce. There was also a bottle of ketchup on the table. I loved the halibut. The batter was light and crispy. The fish was flaky and yummy. I loved dunking my halibut in the tartar sauce that tasted homemade. The fries were good. Just too many of them for my liking. I dunked them in both ketchup and tartar sauce. My Diet Coke helped wash everything down. Thank goodness I got one. It was cold. I got a straw. The woman was great. She asked how my meal was while I was dining. It was a nice touch. I had to use the washroom twice. I came into the eatery after driving for 1.5 hours from Mississauga and downing a beverage. It's a single stall for everyone. It was clean, but dated. I used it again before I headed home. It's funny that I had washroom in mind when I got here that I completely forgot to grab some change to leave a tip. I went back to my car to get some, came back into the eatery, and let the woman know that I was back to give a tip. I thoroughly enjoyed my meal. I'd return again when I'm back in this plaza and have a craving for halibut. (373)

Came here for lunch with my kids. They have lots of 4-seater table and one larger 6-seater…read moreavailable. You order right at the counter for either take out or din-in. If you dine-in they bring the food at your table and clean up after you. Staff is very nice and patient despite it being busy. Prices are pretty standard to what it is now. Roughly $20 after tax. Got the chicken fingers for the kids with $4 extra for poutine. The poutine gravy was very salty though. Can't eat the whole thing. They also offer rolled ice cream with 3 free toppings for about $10. I would come here again if I'm in the area. Rating 3.5/5