1. Hallmark Subaru

0

Birmingham, AL

Cancel

Open app

Search

Hallmark Subaru

2.3 (3 reviews)
Closed • 9:00 am - 1:00 pm

Hallmark Subaru Photos

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Hallmark Subaru

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

1 year ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 1

3 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Car Dealers 1,027 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Edwards Chevrolet - This is how they left my vehicle after aggressively arguing my car was fine.

Edwards Chevrolet

(36 reviews)

I'm writing a complete and honest review. If any employee gives you attitude, BEWARE--they might…read moresabotage your car. I came in thinking I had a connection issue. My Corvette sometimes wouldn't start, and I had just had an engine replaced in August. It turned out to be something as simple as the car being a manual transmission with a neutral lock--something no one at Edwards Chevrolet could tell me. This leads me to believe not only are the service clerks (Luci was a great clerk) unexperienced, but the technicians must not be very knowledgeable either. The service clerk Brooks literally told me over the phone, before he acted like a grown man, that no one wants to work on my car. I immediately replied, "Well then let me speak to a manager so I can figure out why." He then changed his attitude and started being professional all of a sudden. That made me suspicious. I told two managers at Edwards Chevrolet that their employee spoke to a customer in that way, and they didn't seem the slightest bit surprised. (Marty Phillips and a Mr. Short.) Manager Mr. Short at Edwards Chevrolet said there were cameras positioned at every bay and he would follow up with me to ensure there was no foul play with my vehicle on 10/16. Since then he's ignored my calls and texts. Marty Phillips didn't even care to investigate. He started mentioning how long everyone had worked there, as if that would prove I'm lying. After reviewing their work on October 16, I found three faults: Drained oil A hose that was detached and not placed back A connector disconnected from my starter I am a 27-year-old United States Army veteran, and I think this business is TRASH. No communication. No accountability. No integrity. I'm ashamed that an American business like Chevrolet is attached to Edwards. Very emotionally charged staff. Very unprofessional. Don't trust this dealership.

In 2020, I purchased a brand new 2020 Chevy Blazer (Silver) and had an excellent experience. Fast…read moreforward to 2026, that vehicle was totaled due to a system issue that caused me to crash into another vehicle. On February 6, 2026, I purchased a used 2022 Chevy Blazer Redline Edition (Black). After having the vehicle for just over a month, the radio and display screen stopped working, and the car completely died, which also caused the key fob to stop functioning. When we attempted to use the physical key inside the fob, we discovered it was not the correct key for the door. After several days of communication with the dealership, the vehicle was finally towed to the service department. The car remained there for almost a week, and after multiple follow‑ups from me, I was finally given a diagnosis. Due to extenuating circumstances, I was unable to purchase the extended warranty, so I understood that the financial responsibility would fall on me. I approved the repair, which totaled $1,085. Today, when I followed up on the status of the vehicle--having now been without a car for a week and a half--I was informed that although the original diagnosis had been repaired and the radio was functioning, the display screen was still not working. I was told this would require an additional $621. This entire experience has been extremely frustrating. I am deeply concerned about how this vehicle passed inspection prior to being sold. I also question why the technician did not identify the issue with the display screen during the initial diagnosis, especially since it was directly related to the radio problem. Based on my experience, I would caution anyone purchasing a used vehicle from Edwards Chevrolet Downtown to secure a warranty immediately. Without one, the experience can be extremely costly and stressful. I am very disappointed, as I previously had a positive relationship with this dealership. I work hard for my money, and I value businesses that demonstrate loyalty, accountability, and integrity. Unfortunately, this situation has left me feeling dismissed and financially burdened due to issues that should have been identified and addressed before the vehicle was sold. Two weeks ago, I underwent major surgery and am currently on medical leave from work, so my finances are extremely limited. After being without a vehicle for a week and a half--and despite requesting a loaner--I was never provided one, nor did I receive a response regarding my request. As a result, I will now be picking up my vehicle in the same condition in which I brought it to the dealership: still not functioning properly. I am already out $1,085 for the initial repair, and I simply cannot afford the additional $621 that was quoted. When I dropped off my vehicle, I provided detailed information, along with photos and a video clearly showing the issues the car was experiencing. It appears that this information was disregarded. Instead, it feels as though only part of the problem was addressed, resulting in an incomplete diagnosis and additional costs. Furthermore, the issue regarding the physical key inside the key fob not fitting the door was never acknowledged or addressed. This has been a difficult lesson, and I will not be doing business with this dealership again. I understand that I am only one customer, and my decision not to do business with this dealership again will not impact them financially. However, I cannot continue to support any company that takes my hard‑earned money and leaves me feeling as though I have been taken advantage of or made to feel foolish and I feel like BOTH!

Birmingham Luxury Motors

Birmingham Luxury Motors

(33 reviews)

ONE STAR -- Extremely Disappointing Experience... possibly deceptive practices…read more My experience with Birmingham Luxury Motors was incredibly frustrating and disappointing. A mistake was made on their end, but instead of simply acknowledging it and working toward a fair solution, they tried to make it sound like there was an issue with the vehicle history report. I personally followed up with three other car dealers, and all three confirmed that the Carfax was perfectly clear. Even after that, Birmingham Luxury Motors would not concede to what I felt was a very reasonable $1,500 adjustment. Instead, I felt like I was being lowballed while the explanation for the situation continued to change. The communication was just as frustrating. I repeatedly had to chase them for updates instead of being kept informed. Andy was particularly difficult to deal with, and while Mary is apparently brand new, the overall handling of the transaction made an already frustrating situation even worse. When you're dealing with a luxury vehicle purchase, transparency, communication, and accountability should be the bare minimum. I did not feel I received any of those here. Based on my experience, I would strongly recommend doing your homework and considering other dealerships before doing business with Birmingham Luxury Motors.

**AVOID AT ALL COSTS - Sold Me a Damaged Tesla, Stole My Tax Money, Then Ghosted**…read more Bought a 2022 Tesla Model S from Birmingham Luxury Motors in March 2025. Currently out thousands of dollars with a car that's STILL broken. Here's my experience: **THE BAIT & SWITCH** Salesman Jimmy guaranteed the car was "mint" with the tilt-screen feature I specifically wanted (have it in writing). After my deposit, took days to send videos - which conveniently avoided showing any damage. Should've walked then. **WHAT THEY ACTUALLY DELIVERED** After keeping my money for days of "final inspections" before shipping to SC: * Front suspension clanking loudly (major mechanical failure) * Steering wheel looked like a dog's chew toy * Water inside the taillight (yes, really) * Center console broken * Hood paint damage * Rear fender collision damage * Missing the tilt-screen Jimmy swore was there Manager Andy's solution? "Call Tesla, they'll fix it." Not kidding. **THE REPAIR NIGHTMARE** Spent 5 days over multiple trips to Tesla Savannah. They had to: - Remove the ENTIRE front end - Tear out the whole center console - Major suspension work Tesla tech said he'd never seen a dealer sell a car in this condition. It's still not right. **THE LIES & BROKEN PROMISES** Andy promised (all documented): Paint repair reimbursement Compensation for missing features Travel expense reimbursement Would "call right back after checking with management" Plot twist: Andy IS management. That was May. Still waiting. **REGISTRATION DISASTER** - Took them a MONTH to even start paperwork - Gave me fake temp tags printed on copy paper - Got pulled over (cop was not happy) - 62 days and 3 DMV trips to get registered - Andy's response: "Don't worry about it!" while I'm driving illegally **THE ACTUAL THEFT** Paid BLM $859 for "state taxes." Had to pay $884 AGAIN at DMV because they never sent it to the state. They returned $300 and kept $584 of MY money. That's not a mistake - that's theft. **CURRENT STATUS** Haven't responded since June. Complete radio silence. Owe me thousands in documented damages. **PRO TIP:** When you leave your review, expect a generic response about how "management takes this seriously." They don't. It's a bot. I fell for it. **BOTTOM LINE:** This isn't just bad service - it's fraud. They knowingly sold a damaged car, stole tax money, and disappeared. Currently pursuing their dealer bond and legal action. Find ANY other dealer. Even Craigslist would be safer. --- *Documentation available. Ask me anything about this nightmare.*

Stivers Ford of Birmingham - Stivers ford of Birmingham

Stivers Ford of Birmingham

(94 reviews)

While I see all kinds of negative reviews, seriously if a place was this bad they would not remain…read moreopen, most of it it from the dealership side. I can speak on the service side, since I purchased my car (from someone else) in 2023, every bit of service has been done at Stivers and I've never had one issue. They have been honest when I need new tires and brakes, taking me into the shop and showing me for myself, the service writers have always been friendly and helpful. Some of these reviews must have been written by other Ford dealerships jealous of Stivers' success.

I recently had my 2014 Ford Fusion serviced here for recall repairs, and unfortunately, my…read moreexperience was very disappointing. When I dropped my car off, I was not offered a loaner or rental vehicle, even though the repair took several days. I also received no updates during the process and had to repeatedly call for information. When I picked up my car, it had new issues that were not present before service, including dashboard warnings ("Driver Door Ajar" and "Transmission Not in Park") and a driver's side door that no longer locks. Additionally, I noticed parts appeared to be missing or left loose inside the vehicle. Before bringing my car in, all doors locked properly and these warning messages did not exist. I returned to the dealership as instructed and requested a diagnostic, a reinspection of the work, and a loaner vehicle. I was ultimately told that no further work would be done, no diagnostic would be performed, and no loaner would be provided. My vehicle was returned in worse condition than when it was dropped off, and my concerns were not addressed. I would strongly encourage others to carefully consider their options before using this service department.

Hallmark Subaru - car_dealers - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...