I've been here a couple of times since it opened. The first time the COVID rules were a bit different and the gave you one of those devices that beeped when ready and you had to wait in the car until then. I was advised it would take about 15 minutes for my order, so I was happy to wait in the car.
The first time I went I ordered a fish and chips meal with halibut (because it's called Halibut House so I figured that's their specialty), and an additional piece of cod. I wanted to compare the two to see which one was better. I liked the flavour of the cod better, less fishy for some reason. I know, I know, they're fish, so obviously they're fishy, but I still liked the cod better, more moist, tender.
I heard about their house tartar sauce so I asked for it as well, but when I opened my takeout bag, I got the packets of tartar sauce that did not taste great, so I just ate it with the slices of fresh lemon. I thought both pieces fish were fried perfectly, nice and crispy, but the fries were not crispy, maybe because they were sitting underneath the fish. They didn't have any salt on them, either, so I added some salt at home and transferred them from the cardboard takeout container to a bowl and poured the malt vinegar packets on them.
The second time I went I ordered a fish and chips meal again but with just one piece of cod. The fish and chips were both the same as the first time I had time, consistent. I don't remember what the coleslaw was like, but it was more on the vinegar side and not creamy, which I actually like better, and not too sour, either.
I asked for the house tartar sauce again this time and they filled a small container. It was great, with just a touch of sweetness. Definitely better than the packets and highly recommended. You don't need much.
I also ordered some fried clams, which I didn't see on the menu the last time. They came with seafood sauce, which I don't normally care for, so I just ate them with lemon and a bit of the tartar. They were good, crispy as well, but some pieces were just too small to taste the clam.
I will definitely be back and this is now my go-to fish and chips spot in the area. Fish is fresh, fried well and not too greasy, good size portions, and there are weekly specials, as well as a $4-5 breakfast specials. read more