Typically I never leave reviews but today I think I just have to. This mom & pop ice cream store is…read moreexceptional in both its service and it's ice cream itself. To begin, the service at this place is exceptional. Typically they have a set of ice cream flavors that they serve for a day. However today I asked if they had a flavor that they weren't serving for that day. I'm just visiting from another state and just thought it wasn't on the menu. (100% my bad) However even though they didn't offer it, they were able to get it for me from their back freezer. This process of preparing it for me took time since it wasn't pre-prepared. But this goes to show you that this place priorities customers over comfort. Additionally, their ice cream is exceptional. It is all homemade and the flavor and texture of the ice cream is perfect. Would come again. If you are visiting Gettysburg this place is 100% worth coming to

Our group of six had a great time here! The building has a historic charm that made the wait (about…read more15 minutes) more enjoyable, and the outdoor line even had a fun game to keep us entertained. We passed another ice cream shop to try this one after a tour guide mentioned it was among the best in the country according to a recent news article. While my two-scoop cone definitely hit the spot on a warm August afternoon, my daughter pointed out that the article's author might not have sampled some of the fantastic dairy stores and ice cream shops we have back home in the Midwest. I'd have to agree--I've had better in Minnesota and Wisconsin. Still, this is a charming stop with tasty treats and a fun vibe--worth a visit if you're in the area!

If you're driving on route 30 in New Oxford, Pennsylvania, you will pass a big antique store…read more However, if you blink, you might miss the amazing little Mexican ice cream building in the same parking lot. Their ice cream is very clearly homemade and you can taste the love that went into making it. They use real ingredients and it is some of the best ice cream I've ever had. Their popsicles are also made specifically for this shop and they are awesome. On our first visit here, my wife had strawberry cheesecake ice cream and I had oreo ice cream. We loved both. Coming through the area again, this time with our friend George, my wife got blueberry ice cream, which was delicious (I got to taste it), and I got a peanut butter ice cream that was excellent. We were also looking at popsicles today and got some to try. My wife tried the coffee/cappuccino one, which was very strong but good, she said. I saw "lemon" on the menu board and asked for it. I got "limon", or lime instead. I was very happy with it though, and loved the flavor. I'd definitely get it again. All in all, a very happy visit to this neat little place today. I look forward to the next time I'm passing through this area when they are open.

Look for the Black Shutter Antique Center and in their parking lot you will find this gem! Truly…read morehomemade ice cream. Along with the traditional flavors you will find some Latino flavors you can only find south of the border. Get your standard favorites at your local shop. Try something different here and you won't be disappointed!

Food is great service is quick and the price is a bit high would recommend two person that comes byread more

Finally got the chance to check out this ice cream shop located in McSherrystown, PA in a small…read morelittle strip plaza, next to Choice Family Pharmacy and Brothers Pizza. We decided on trying the Wild Thang, Freak Shake and let's just say it was well presented and very unique and a nice size. The chocolate cake that topped it was amazing in itself and the milkshake was in the money. They had a staff of three working and it was just a bit slow but efficient, needs a little refinement, especially with the volume of people waiting in line, it did move along .... Staff was extremely friendly and accommodating. Very unique twisted ice cream flavors, there is such a nice assortment to choice from, they have various shakes, waffle sundaes, all are extremely unique ! This is a really nice family owned business and it's highly recommended to stop in here and get your ice cream fix in. You will enjoy it Side Note: Not sure what food service protocol is in PA, but in our opinion the workers should wear gloves and hair protection, neither being used by staff and it could be a violation since they are reaching across ice cream containers and standing over them ! Also, did not see any Food-Serve Certifications ? * This was the reason of not giving a 5-Star, 3-Star is warranted due to improper food handling

The market is nice and cozy with a variety of meats to select from: beef, pork, lamb, and goat. I…read morealso noticed eggs, various cheese products and milk. Even duck eggs this time! I grabbed a tomahawk steak and ossobuco. There's also honey, jellies, sauces, spices and other treats. I got the soft cone ice cream and it was delicious. The maple flavor was to die for. The staff was very accommodating as I came in pretty close to their closing time. There are plenty of tables to enjoy your ice cream outside, some rocking chairs and picnic tables. Even a John Deere frame to take a picture.

I would always drive by this place on my way home from work and decided to stop by for some soft…read moreserve ice cream, and I'm glad I did! The staff there were super friendly and the ice cream tasted creamy and fresh. I ordered the vanilla ice cream with their signature sprinkles (green and yellow) along with strawberry whipped cream. That strawberry whipped cream was glorious!!! They do also have few seating available outside but my ice cream was quickly melting so I sat in the car. Very cute place!

No shade on Mr. Gs and Cone Sweet Cone, but Half Pint Creamery is in a different league…read more The flavor choices are incredible. There had to be 20+. Add in the special toppings on top of the Gelato bases the aesthetics were incredible! We used to live in York and I would go here frequently because they make dog ice cream treats! They are awesome and our German Shepherd loves them! I got a 6 pack yesterday! I got a 2 scoop dish! Fluffernutter and Peanut Butter Egg! Incredible! They even place a waffle cone chip in your dish! No seating indoors at the Gettysburg location, but they had a few tables outside to sit at! The two girls serving up ice cream were phenomenal! Asked us about free samples, gave us recommendations, and we're very good at their jobs! The portions are definitely generous!

This was my first visit of the season to Half Pint Creamery on a sunny, 63 degree, but windy day in…read morelate March. Upon arrival there were only 2 vehicles in the parking lot, likely driven by the 2 young employees, however a couple arrived several minutes later. I chose a scoop each of Black & White and Fudge, both no sugar added with a small bag of cone fragments and a 20% tip for $14.30. The 2 young women behind the counter were pleasant and helpful. I ate outdoors in the sunlight in contradistinction to summer where I would hide from the scorching sun! It is my understanding that later this summer they will be moving their location north several hundredfeet on the same side of the road. The building construction is well underway, so this ought be nice. They have an assortment of flavors with typically 2 no sugar added choices, seemingly typical of ice cream shops, some of which have no options for those who need to be mindful. Check ot out!

A few months ago, they used to sell some Penn State Creamery ice cream, which was better quality…read moreand ingredients - I was willing to pay a premium price for that. Now they have cut costs to increase their profits - replacing all the good quality ice cream they had with Turkey Hill ice cream, using inferior bendy spoons, cutting their costs and letting you BLINDLY pay more. I'm done supporting this business that has decided to prioritize profits over anything else. If you want Turkey Hill ice cream, why pay these ripoffs for the worst quality product in the ice cream market? Go to the supermarket and pay the equivalent of 1 scoop for the whole tub. 1 scoop here is $3.75. 1 tub at the nearby Giant is $3.79

Stopped in here for a snack after dinner while in the area. It's an interesting spin on cookie…read moredough and ice cream. The staff was quite helpful and friendly. They serve ice cream from Penn State creamery! If you're in the area you should give them a try.

I've been supporting this business since day 1. I first tried them their first week in business at…read morethe original location in Mcsherrystown/Hanover. They always have unique and original flavors. I've never been disappointed in any flavor I've tried. Very clean on the inside and the staff are always friendly. Love the fact that the owners are hands on and still serve customers from time to time. One of the best local small business stories. Always grab a treat for the pup at home while here.

This is a small family owned business, which is simply outstanding…read more They have such an array of unique flavors along with your staples, such as chocolate, vanilla, etc., etc. Yes, they even have a corn flavored ice cream which taste like buttered corn. Can you imagine that! The staff is always welcoming, very friendly and the inside is absolutely spotless with plenty of seating and I'm sure this goes for all their locations . In their frozen cases, they have frozen dog treats, cakes, ice cream, cakes, and ice cream cookies and so many other items . trust us you'll find something you absolutely love and you'll be hooked on the ice cream.

We love the store, the Staff and the wonderful Ice Cream!…read moreRocky Sullivan, formerly of Finksburg, Md and now Rocky's Run,WV. I will drive the 150 mile one way to visit this store!

Great Ice Cream made the old-fashioned way in a old fashioned store in a old fashioned county. The…read morecustomer service is good, there is a kind old man who works there, and it definitely comes off folksy due to the large number of ornaments in the background. This makes the place feel very homey. Make sure to bring cash as they don't accept anything else!

Crabs Tropical Treat is a Hanover Institution!…read more There are not many of these Car Hops left in the USA and this is truly a special place. Plenty of bench seating under a pavilion and other areas, the goats will welcome you and for a quarter, you can get a handful of corn to feed them. You can also pull your vehicle under cover and they will bring the food to your vehicle. Don't forget to tip these young folks The food for the most part is good, service is outstanding and the ice cream plentiful! If you're in the area, stop in and you will enjoy this place !

Tropical Treat is open for the season and my granddaughter couldn't be happier! She absolutely…read moreloves to go and see the goats and we all love to enjoy the delicious food and icecream! With how busy they always are, their service is very good! Such a nice place to sit and enjoy the day/evening and relax while waiting for your food to be brought to you. We will return many times this Spring/Summer!!!!