Maggie H.

Want a cookie addiction? This is the place to start haha they have the most delicious cookies and always have new ones to try. The best part... you can add whatever cookie you want with icecream! The staff are always phenomenal and the place is a must go all year round. They also have a cooler filled with lunch goodies too!

Sara P.

All I can say is run, don't walk to this amazing bakery and ice cream parlor in one! No seriously, why are you still reading this, just get there and try everything! We met some friends here and I had no idea what to expect. Usually ice cream is much more of a draw for me than cookies, but after seeing the thick, delicious looking cookies I knew I wouldn't be able to choose. Luckily the "half baked" is their for anyone as indecisive as me. Basically an ice cream sundae that includes 3 toppings and your choice of any of their cookies. I opted to only put half of my cookie on the sundae and get the other half in a to go bag, which was smart as although it delicious, it as very rich and filling. I opted for the Chocolate PB, dark chocolate dough with peanut butter chips and a peanut butter cup center, but man was it a difficult choices. The cookies all looked delicious, more reason to go back for more! The place has a great seating area, both indoors and outdoors, and is across the street from a park if you need any more reason to come, but believe me the cookies and ice cream are more than enough!

Friendly staff in a clean place. Plenty of parking, gluten free options and veteran discount.

Susan N.

I've been dying to try this place out and finally had the chance! The cookies are HUGE and there are so many options to choose from. I got a variety 4 for $18. They were definitely delicious and lived up to their hype. They also weren't too sweet!

Laura G.

No joke, we drove 50 minutes to get to Half Baked because I couldn't stand drooling over their Instagram page any longer. I had scored a gift card deal on Black Friday and was anxious to take the family to enjoy some grand, fresh baked cookies. They had a flavor for everyone, including a couple gluten-free choices that were separated from their gluten-containing counterparts. We had Chocolate Peanut Butter (sprinkled with pb chips throughout and pb cookie dough in the middle), Brownie Stuffed (chocolate chip cookie with ooey, gooey brownie in the middle), Monster (packed with Oreos and M&Ms), Mocha Truffle (chocolate with a hit of espresso, a melty center, and rolled in Oreo dust), Chocolate Chip (an oversized classic). All cookies were soft with just the right amount of mix-ins. You might want to grab some Hoover's milk (available in a variety of flavors) to wash it all down. Definitely give them a follow. You won't be disappointed in the sweet concoctions they bake up, plus they show their cookie line-up for the day. We will be coming back to try one of their over-the-top sundaes with a cookie and mix-ins. Tip: They offer a rewards system (using your phone number) and send out coupons every now and then.

Devin W.

Just a quick stop to drop off my empty Hoover dairy bottles. Can't leave without seeing what yummy creations they had and to use my credits for returning the bottles. 2 bottles returned $2 discount on cookies

Jenna R.

THE BEST COOKIES I'VE EVER HAD. Omg my fiancé and I just picked up a 4 pack of these cookies and we are already obsessed. They all have the perfect texture and balance of flavors. The girls behind the counter were super friendly. These are our new favorite cookies and we will definitely be returning! Highly recommend to all cookie lovers

Aly W.

Half-baked is a cookie and ice cream shop conveniently located across from Day Road Park. I think I was about halfway home when I realized the name probably related to the gooey goodness of their thick supersized cookies. I always say I like my cookies like I like my steak - medium rare - so naturally I'm a fan of their chewy cookies. I ordered the half-baked sundae for $7.50. You pick a cookie, a flavor of ice cream, and two toppings. They have several flavors of Perry's ice cream, as well as vanilla and chocolate custard. I chose a sea salted caramel cookie, vanilla custard, hot caramel sauce, and chocolate chips. They topped it with a dollop of whipped cream. So yummy. I could only finish half the cookie so my husband enjoyed the rest at home. Individual cookies are $4, and they are sized like a $4 cookie, or $3.50 for a dozen or more. Their ice cream cones begin at $1.25 for a tiny cone so prices are as good if not better than any other place dishing up Perry's. They also have a bunch of other sundaes, or you can create your own from their extensive topping bar. Service is excellent. There's several tables or you can enjoy your treat across the street at the park.

Anne P.

I found this place via a Facebook comment where someone said it was better than Crumbl. As a Crumbl addict, I started following them on Instagram and saw the daily list of a dozen plus flavors and the mouth-watering photos. I decided to finally visit last week on a rainy day. It was pretty slow since it was a weekday and there was plenty of seating. They also have high chairs which I appreciated. I got four cookies and split two of them with my daughter. I saved the other two to give to a friend for her birthday. We got classic chocolate chip, salted caramel, apple cider and carnival (I think! Had m&ms). The cookies are huge, were all still warm and gooey on the inside. They were delicious and I had to stop myself from eating all of them. The prices went up to $18 for 4 the day I went which is pricy but it was due to inflation and you are supporting a local business. The variety is insane and it seems to be like Paula's Donuts where they just keep rolling them out all day and put them out warm on the counter. I live about a half hour from here so I'm not sure if I would return unless I was out that way but the cookies are definitely delicious. It's hard to compare to Crumbl as it's like oranges to apples. Half baked are more thick and better quality overall IMO and most don't have frosting. It also depends on what kind of cookie you are looking for. Crumbl's are more flat and some of the flavors are more unique.

Benjamin K.

Cookies don't come more delicious than the ones here. I made a quick stop by this week to pick up specialty Eclipse Cookie Moon-Pies. Good thing I got extra because my family devoured them and asked to go back!

Maureen W.

Wow...these cookies are amazing! We got there about 20 minutes after they opened so they had a very good selection of their 6 oz cookies available! We decided to get a 6 pack - they seem to have staple flavors and then specialty flavors that are around for a certain amount of time. We got a specialty flavor which was the "pot of gold" - it was a chocolate cookie with gold on top, and when you open it m&ms poured out! So fun. I also really loved their Cookie Monster and the peanut butter lovers! All the cookies were still warm you can also get an ice cream sundae made with one of the cookies as well! These cookies are heavy - they do not skimp on ingredients. I liked that It was very clean inside. Also, I noticed there is a cute park across the street so it would be fun to take your kids for cookies, and then play at the park after to run off their sugar high!

Sarah K.

Yaassss!! Bought some cookies to take home to my son and he cannot stop asking to go back. They're so thick and buttery, a great variety. Hoover's dairy milk is also sold here and was a delight! Cute little cafe, off the beaten path but worth the drive.

Rebecca E.

Was always such a fan of Half Baked Cookies. And I'm so glad they finally have a storefront to get cookies!!! It's definitely worth the drive from wherever you live in the Buffalo area. They have a plenty of parking, lots of seats inside to sit and eat your treats. They also offer plenty of beverages and ice cream to create cookie sundaes!! Half baked always had the most delicious seasonal flavors. Highly recommend, will be returning for more delicious cookies.