Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Guffey's Pizza

    4.3 (48 reviews)
    Closed • Closed

    Order Guffey's Pizza Takeout or Delivery

    Guffey's Pizza Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Guffey's Pizza

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    I tried the hamburger pizza and thought it was great. Pickles were fresh and crispy and the mustard was surprisingly great on pizza.

    Fly
    Kevin D.

    Found a fly in my sandwich!!! Gave a 1 star just cuz the fried pickles were good. The guy was actually pretty nice about the fly but did little to compensate for our unfortunate guest in our sandwich. Edit: Guffey came out right after I posted this review and wanted to me to take this review down. He reimbursed us for the sandwich, which wad nice. Gave him another star just cuz he was nice. Food for thought: rename this place to Fly's pizza. Fyi sandwich was greasy as fuck ;) Edit to the edit: I'm a different person reviewing. The food was actually quite good and he only seemed to reimburse when we made this review. Guffey was however a nice guy and stood for his establishment. Go Guff. Watch the flies next time buddy.

    Supreme Pizza- 16" takes up the whole box.
    Sam H.

    I give this place 4 Stars on Quality and Location. It's just a hop off of the interstate. I expected to have to go into Pacific but it's just the plaza down from the gas station. The staff was very friendly and polite. They acknowledged me as soon as a came in, even though the cashier was on the phone taking another order. I ordered the Supreme Pizza. It had Sausage, Mushrooms, Onion, Black Olive, Green Pepper, Hamburger and Pepperoni. All of the ingredients were fresh except the Mushrooms, which were canned. This was why they lost a Star. The sausage was good sized hunks of regular pork, no fennel that I could taste, which is of course what St.Louisans expect, but was of very good quality. I did not care for the crust, not as thin as Imo's and not as thick as hand tossed. It was pretty blah, but if you are one that the crust is the least of it, it was fine. Again, good quality, just nothing special and it's plainness did showcase the toppings. I would just maybe add some garlic butter or something. I would definitely try this place again, their Sandwich menu looks pretty awesome as well as their appetizers. The things about the pizza that I didn't care for were personal choices and not anything lacking in quality or inventiveness. I would up the game with fresh mushrooms instead of canned. Canned are why people don't like mushrooms. My order was ready very quickly and they brought it out to the car with a smile. I recommend that you try this place. Prices were reasonable too.

    They are back!

    See all

    6 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    6 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 years ago

    This was awful and had five billion tons of grease. Would not recommend. Pizza was very bland and cold.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 3
    Oh no 0

    8 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 years ago

    Great pizza and a great staff. Glad to see Guffey's pizza back after all these years! Great job Nick and crew!!

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 2 of 2

    Ask the Community - Guffey's Pizza

    Review Highlights - Guffey's Pizza

    “Pizza is Saint Louis style but better than imos and the buffalo chicken salad and fried pickles were awesome.”

    Mentioned in 6 reviews

    Read more highlights

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Pizza 1,007 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Coal Fire Grill & Tap - Coal Fire Bar & Tap

    Coal Fire Grill & Tap

    4.5(40 reviews)
    3.5 mi

    Wow! An amazing hidden gem in a small town that is sure to please any palate!…read more The service - 5 Stars! The staff treats you like family and are on it, no matter how busy. They are fun and made us want to keep coming back (which we did)! * Sammy - you are SPECTACULAR! The food - 5 stars! From the pretzel and yummy cheese to the pizza, absolutely spot on. The French onion soup had a depth of flavor and topped with an oversized piece of bread covered in cheese - heavenly! The salads are fresh and the dressings are on the top of the list I have tasted. The atmosphere - 5 stars! It's a lovely, yet smaller restaurant that is decorated to suite any person that walks in. Extremely clean and the patrons all know each other. The owners are welcoming and care about their customers. It's like dinner and a show with the entire interactions. I need to try the BBQ next time I'm in town!

    A charming little bar & grill with standard pub fare. Service was quick on a busy Saturday…read moreafternoon. I had the "Best" French Dip, which was decent but far from the best I've ever had. Their fries are shoestring, almost similar to McDonald's, which isn't my favorite style at a sit-down restaurant. Next time I would probably order one of their specialities as they sound a little more exciting than what I got.

    Photos
    Coal Fire Grill & Tap - Bar and eating area by front door

    Bar and eating area by front door

    Coal Fire Grill & Tap - Delicious gyro! Big portions and the sweet potato fries were spot on

    Delicious gyro! Big portions and the sweet potato fries were spot on

    Coal Fire Grill & Tap - Big pieces of toasted raviolis for an appetizer

    See all

    Big pieces of toasted raviolis for an appetizer

    Domino's Pizza - Hot fresh delivered right to the truck quality excellent. 01/19/2023

    Domino's Pizza

    3.3(13 reviews)
    4.3 mi
    •$

    09/2023 Fantastic. This Domino's located near six flags just…read more4 miles up the road from the truck stop. I called as I was at Mr fuel and said do you deliver out to here I gave her the address and she said yes I said great. I ordered one of my usual favorites just a medium thin crust cheese and sausage. She said it'll be out there within a half an hour Nowadays you cant always tell by their eta's But this one definitely did. Says they have a dining area too I've never seen it cuz I don't know if it's in an area where you can park a truck. but according to the reviews here they do have dine in. Another review turned out was a let down they didn't like the service they got. I also know if there's only one recent review somebody was complaining all the rest of the older reviews were definitely older quite a few years so I'm going to add mine in. Because of the fact that it was prompt just like they said it was hot the pizza look perfectly fine I'm giving it the full five stars across the board I was definitely beyond impressed. In fact knowing that Mr fuel has beer if I get stuck here for a night I may just call and get another pizza and I got the Brew already set LOL. But I ate and had to go cuz I had to go truckin again. Originally I really wanted some food here at Mr. Fuell and I'm glad their food wasn't very good here at Mr fuel because I was able to call this Domino's location and get an excellent pizza. So it was a win-win all the way around for me. Lol

    ordered a pepperoni/sausage pizza from the Pacific Domino's when i picked it up they were putting…read morethe cooked sausage on the already baked pizza when i got home with it and as we ate it the sausage was just rolling off the pizza called them next day and was told yea they probably forgot the sausage and to add it later i said is that how you always do it she said no they just forgot could tell she didnt seem to care so i hung up wont be back lots of places to buy pizza around here

    Photos
    Domino's Pizza - How the pizza looked when I opened the box

    How the pizza looked when I opened the box

    Domino's Pizza - The inch of pizza missing

    The inch of pizza missing

    Domino's Pizza - Burnt pizza

    See all

    Burnt pizza

    Napoli Bros - Arugula pizza

    Napoli Bros

    4.3(234 reviews)
    18.0 mi
    •$$

    Incredible dinner experience at Napoli Bros for a girl's night!…read more Service, atmosphere and drink program were everything you'd expect and love from a Napoli restaurant experience. This is a sexy, upscale dinner option for Chesterfield. We started with the coal fried ciabatta, and it sounds crazy, but this bread alone merited a 5 star dinner. I've never had bread at a restaurant that managed to somehow be crispy and firm, but melt in your mouth at the same time. This is bread that's anything but overrated. Next, we shared the STL salad, a refreshing, light start to the meal that was perfectly balanced. For entrees, we shared a vodka pizza and the bolognese, both of which were stellar choices. The pizza had excellent char and the vodka sauce was a unique twist to a traditional pepperoni pizza. The bolognese was like a warm hug - super comforting.

    Friend dinner! This is a great choice, we enjoyed the food the service and the company!…read more I always order the coal fired ciabatta with rosemary butter. We shared it and enjoyed it so much, got a second order! It is soft and crisp at the same time, so good. We also shared the meatball appetizer. These are larger and plenty to share. Covered in sauce and a mozzarella cheese blend, these are one of only a few I order out - good meaty flavor with sauce and not overpowered by a parmesan or other cheese I don't like. I ate these without the mozzarella and they are so good. For dinner I went with Vodka pizza, Vodka sauce base, buffalo mozzarella, basil, and pepperoni. Great flavors together with a little kick. I love wood fired pizza and this is one of my favorites. Busy place, we made a reservation. Great food and staff!

    Photos
    Napoli Bros
    Napoli Bros - Vodka Al forno-- delicious

    Vodka Al forno-- delicious

    Napoli Bros - Ciabatta bread with Herb Butter

    See all

    Ciabatta bread with Herb Butter

    Guffey's Pizza - pizza - Updated October 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...