This restaurant was all out surprising, and maybe because of its location. My wife and I do enjoy…read morea good meal, especially when we travel. It just makes the day whole. With our expectations in check, we chose this restaurant for last nights supper. What a pleasant surprise!! The menu was comprised of interesting dishes that you won't find every day. The service was spot on. Knowledgeable, friendly, patient, welcoming. Our dishes were a pure delight. We enjoyed Idaho trout, bison steak, their speciality salad, and blueberry bread pudding. Every dish was delightful; fresh, full of local flavors. If you visit West Yellowstone, this place is the second most important destination right after the park!

I had the fresh bison tenderloin served with asparagus and mashed potatoes and a side of wild rice…read more Chased it down with a huckleberry lemonade. The Huckleberry lemonade was very good and was recommended. While Reis was good, the asparagus and mashed potatoes were very good. The bison tenderloin was good, but I think it's better served as a ground meat in a burger form. It was tender, but not as flavorful as some of the other bison, I've recently had. The ambience is a pub/bistro setting. The service was exceptional as my server attended to me several times to check in on how was my meal

Great spot that even locals seem to love! Bit pricey, but the food and drinks were made so well…read moreyou don't feel ripped off. Service was great too! Love the rustic decor!

This place was suggested by my brother, when he heard we were eating in west Yellowstone. Ordered…read morethe buffalo burger and wings, both were great. The wings had a very flavorful Huckleberry bbq sauce. Was great. My wife ordered the quesadillas, very filling, but good.

After spending a few hours soaking in the nearby hot springs, we decided to give the Rail a try…read more My wife loved her double cheeseburger. My Buffalo Chicken sandwich had been ordered 'fried'; but it was soggy - not one bite of crunch. Overall tho, fries (sweet potato and original) and the onion rings had been tasty. Brian, our bartender / server, was very nice and attentive. The only negative thing that was a disappointment (other than soggy chicken) had been the beverage prices - the menu had lower prices than what had been billed. This is a Delaware North property, and they can easily update their menus to reflect current prices. Regardless, will go back

Our server was very accommodating. Great bartender! He was knowledgeable and helpful with all drink…read moreand food choices. The food was good, the service was even better.

Old Town Cafe was the last restaurant I ate at while staying in West Yellowstone. I decided to stop…read morein for breakfast before leaving to drive down to Grand Teton. The breakfast items we had were okay. The pork steak was a bit too salty and the breakfast burrito (I asked for it to NOT be deep fried) was meh. The "salsa" it came with tasted more like Pace picante sauce. The portion sizes were well worth the price. Ideally, 2 people could split the breakfast burrito. The highlight of my time there was the friendliness of the bartender.

This place was good but not great. They offered a good selection of burgers including the buffalo…read moreburger. Service was good enough but not spectacular. Overall, I liked it for the convenience. There was not many people eating inside, I think there should be some more.

We just stopped in for a drink. The restaurant next door was closed. Service was very good. Beer…read moreselection was limited for a place in this type of location. Ambiance was very nice. We kind of ended up here by default because there was nothing else available but I'm glad we ended up here. Next time we go to see Old Faithful I'll plan to stop in the Bear Pit for a while before and after the big blowoff . Really great spot to relax away from the crowds!

The Bear Pit is the bar inside The Old Faithful Inn, next to their main restaurant. It's a cute…read morelittle spot with a little menu. It can get busy or seem that way since there are only two people working there. We stopped in for a cocktail while we were waiting for Old Faithful to erupt- as most of the people in there were doing. There were out of a lot of stuff. We tried to order a cocktail, they were out of the moonshine they use in it. The people next to us tried to order two different drinks they were out of. Bartender put liquor in my mocktail but realized it before serving it to me. He was very easily distracted. Maybe he needed some help behind the bar??

Pros: - Very convenient location, located next to…read morerestaurants, grocery store, urgent care. - Very close to west entrance of Yellowstone - Free parking - Complimentary coffee and tea, cookies, popsicles, ice cream sandwiches - Water filling station and hot water - When our shower clogged, they sent someone immediately ~9pm to fix it - Recycling is available - 10% off the downstairs restaurant which has breakfast and dinner. - Nice service, let us have 12pm checkout - Pool and hot tub are nice - Gym is bare bones but present (dumbbells, elliptical, treadmill, bike machine) - Small convenience store is very convenient - Has a business center with printers. Has conference rooms that aren't used so you can use them if you need to hold a meeting Cons: - Price. Although it's comparable to all the other hotels in the area - Decor is ugly and outdated - Downstairs restaurant is very mid

Stayed here in March of 2025 after the road heading out of town got closed during a snowstorm…read more Super friendly and understanding staff. In the morning while checking out the front desk worker was giving everyone updates on the road conditions if they were heading out of town which is above and beyond in my opinion. Definitely would recommend this property

You guys are awesome ! Excellent food from scratch…read more The waiter so nice , knows a lot from the restaurant she looks like an owner. We came from Colombia and it is a good place for dining .

Decent BBQ - Nice Mountain Atmosphere. No reservations, Walk…read morein Only. We arrived at 5:30 on a Friday and had a 30 minute wait for a table. After being seated, the service was fast. Surprisingly, they still had fried chicken at 6:15pm - They offer a $7 chicken meal, which is a fantastic deal since you can't even get a fast food meal at that price. The server said they are often out by 5:30pm. The BBQ Pork plate was a large portion The food was good, but nothing spectacular.

Staff went out of the way to accommodate our family on Christmas Eve. Mom made Christmas Day…read morereservations- but blanked on Christmas Eve. They squeezed us in - a lovely lounge spot by the fire. We had two kids , 5 and 7, hangry from a day on the slopes - and they were so kind. Our server went way out of her way to work around my long list of food allergies. Food, service, staff, everything was top notch!

We were a party of eight and all food was bad. Cocktails were bad too. Do not order the Rodeo…read more Then again bartenders were very young and probably inexperienced. The burgers were way overcooked, like charcoal, and the cheese tasted like plastic. Fondu was very odd, too liquidy and served with berries and too flavorful overcooked veggies. The meatballs were dense and rubbery. But the worst was the carbonara, which was just a plate of noodles and cream. Server was nice and agreed to comp the pasta and two burgers but manager only compped one $36 burger, even though neither got eaten. I never write reviews, just don't go here. This place needs to step it up for where it is, the prices, and the competition that's coming.

Great beer selection and tasty appetizers! Fun atmosphere during happy hour! The history of the…read morebuilding as the old schoolhouse was interesting too.

Great place to visit if you are in the west Yellowstone area. Wife had huckleberry cider and a…read moregreat looking salad and I had a bowl of bison jambalaya that was excellent. They have a wide variety of hotsauces to use to spice up your meal as well. Staff is friendly and very helpful. Building was an old school so it is historic.

Sergei was an amazing bartender!! He was very attentive and engaging. Highly recommend.read more

Nice bar at the base of the lifts, on the second floor of Vista Hall, where the food court is. It…read morehas beautiful sweeping views of Lone Peak, some indoor bar and table seating, and big outdoor deck. The handcrafted cocktails are quite good, and they have been and wine, too. I stopped by apres ski and tired the Big Sky Bulldog, which was Orphan Girl (a bourbon cream liqueur), vodka, rootbeer and half & half - kind of like an adult rootbeer float - very good. Then I had the Willie's Hot Toddy, which I think is my new favorite warm drink -- Willie's Honey Moonshine (a local honey bourbon), lemon and water, garnished w/ cinnamon stick and cloves. Might be making that myself on our next ski trip. Met some super nice people at the bar, too, which happened to be from OB/Point Loma, where we live!