I stopped by Gretchen's Goodies for the first time before Thanksgiving to pick up a couple extra desserts. I picked out the key lime and red velvet. Both were so good! That was probably the best red velvet I've ever had. I can't wait to go back! The lady who helped me (assuming the owner) was extremely friendly! I can't wait to go back and try more flavors. read more

Gretchen's Goodies - Display - Bakeries Near Me - Riverview, Florida

See all

My friend ordered Gretchen's Goodies for our Love Island watch party and safe to say I'll be back! These little cups pack so much flavor. I got the Biscoff Cookie Butter Pie. It was delicious! I forget what my friends got, but I had a bite of theirs and it was delicious as well. I will say they are very sweet so I couldn't eat it all in one sitting. I've been inside before to pick up delivery orders and I've anyways wanted to try it. I'm glad I got to! read more

Gretchen's Goodies - Bakeries Near Me - Riverview, Florida

See all

Having keto friendly choices made my entire day. They had three keto flavors peanut butter, chocolate and triple berry cheesecake. The taste was pleasing and delicious. The overall ambiance was nice and very visibly appealing on the inside of the business. It is located inside the gas station store. You can get gas and a dessert. It has a very wide variety of other desserts although not all keto friendly I was very impressed with the flavor of the keto cheesecake. I would recommend to anyone who may be in the area or passing by. It is worth a try. I will be back! read more

See all

It's been a while since we stopped into Gretchens Goodies. Came in and looked Over the cakes, cheesecakes, etc., while we were waiting for somebody to take our order. Somebody finally came out of the back and we ordered one cheesecake and also a cake as well. One thing I noticed right off the bat is at they tasted frozen. They lost a lot of flavor unfortunately and the cake was dry. The cheesecake was okay but again digging in it had a frozen taste. Her treats used to taste so fresh and delicious but unfortunately these were the opposite. read more

See all

I'm a fan of the cheesecake, I've tried so many delicious flavors. I like the biscotti's, I hope they make a cheesecake biscotti one. I also like the s'more cheesecake, it's probably my favorite. I'm not a huge fan of the cake ones or maybe I just haven't had one that I enjoy as much as the cheesecake ones but overall, I'd highly suggest trying Gretchen's Goodies if you want something sweet. I'd recommend starting off with a cheesecake flavor then move to the cakes. Definitely give them a try read more

Gretchen's Goodies - S'Mores Cheesecake - Bakeries Near Me - Riverview, Florida

See all

Yummy so happy i came across this place. It's inside a gas station lol so don't be alarmed. Had the funfetti cake White chocolate raspberry cheesecake and the biscoff cake All were great my fav funfetti and the biscoff! Just wish there was biscoff cookie crumble in the middle of the cup as well. I would just say the cake was a little tad bit dry nothing outrageously bad. Will return to try other flavors they have pies too read more

See all

It's a great place for those who love dessert cups. They have just about every pie, cake, or cheesecake flavor combination imaginable. It's actually a very cool concept for travelers, or anyone who wants a little something sweet. My visit was in August 2023. I was greeted right away by a very nice & knowledgeable young man. I wish I could remember his name. He was very helpful. He explained the deals and rewards, and gave me a menu. I decided to go with Chocolate Peanut Butter Banana Cream Pie, and the Coconut Lime Cake. I wasn't in love with the CPBB Cream Pie. The bananas just didn't taste fresh, and it was all rather mushy. I liked the Coconut Lime Cake flavor and texture. I just thought that the cream cheese frosting was overly sweet. I shared both with my husband. Neither one of us was able to eat it all in one sitting. It's a big portion, and maybe too rich of a frosting. Again, it's a good concept. It just wasn't for me. However, I do want to try the keto dessert cups one day. I thought it was great that there are low sugar dietary options. They have cheesecake flavors in blueberry, chocolate, lemon, key lime, strawberry, peanut butter, and pumpkin spice. Some of these may be seasonal. It's just something to note if you happen to be on a keto diet. It's located in a very clean Zoom Zoom Mobile station off of I-75. It's difficult to turn into if you're heading west on Gibsonton Drive. It's definitely worth a try if you're in the area. read more

See all

Phenomenal dessert inside of a gas station? Yes yes, indeed. My love introduced me to the spot and I'm going to beg him to take me back so I can try more flavours. So far, I've tried the salted caramel cheesecake, and the Biscoff pie. These desserts are layered in a cup. Everything is beautifully packaged. They are six bucks a pop, and if you buy six, you get one free. And by the way, the spot is open 24/7. I see why people come down from Georgia to get these. read more

See all

So you'd never expect this in a gas station but legit homemade desserts in a cup. 6$ ish per piece. Yummy, not too sweet lots of options from cheesecake to cake to keto cake. Super friendly staff!! Stop and get a road treat!!! read more

See all

24/7 Desserts!!...Yep im in, this by far the cleanest fuel station you will ever see. We got three cip desserts. Cashier was super nice and informative saying most of their business is late night. Go figure! guess Tampa peeps get late night cravings. read more

Gretchen's Goodies - Bakeries Near Me - Riverview, Florida

Talk about the perfect hurricane snack! I "evacuated" my apartment and stayed with some friends in Riverview, who are biiiig fans of Gretchen's Goodies. We ordered for delivery and it took me soooo long to even decide on one because there are SO many options! The ONLY reason I knocked one star off is because the delivery was partially wrong. I ordered a chocolate chip cookie mousse and my friends ordered chocolate oreo and carrot cake, but we received 2 chocolate oreos and one carrot cake. I ended up trying the oreo and eating most of the carrot cake, both of which were PHENOMENAL! I was bummed I didn't get what I ordered, but both of what I tried were literally insane so I wasn't too upset. I wish I could try all of them! They're a pretty solid portion for a $7 dessert, basically a layered cake/pie in a cup. VERY sweet and dense, but an incredible treat!! read more

OMG! Delicious! Nothing else to be said, just stop in if in the area. Lots to choose from. Everything is made fresh. Got the Red Velvet, Banna cream and Carrot cake. So far red velvet was delicious Great customer service, thanks to Eric Envey Maybe it's a good thing I live in New York read more

See all

Gretchen's Goodies is my favorite spot for when I am craving cake. I always get the tiramisu cup, and while it's not super traditional, it is absolutely fantastic. The service has always been great, and there is a huge selection of goodies--something for everyone. Plus, the place is very clean. Highly recommended for anyone with a sweet tooth read more

Gretchen's Goodies - Bakeries Near Me - Riverview, Florida

Had to try a couple more flavors and chose the Biscoff and Twinkie cakes and they were the best yet!! You seriously have to try both of them. I think the Twinkie cake was my favorite overall of everything I tried! read more

See all

The desert is delicious, amply sized and adequately priced. The team member was informative, cordial and patient during our selection. As a celiac the choices are super slim each time I've gone in I've had only one or two choices and they are always the same. Lastly the location is clean and inviting but slightly difficult to get to and you may prefer to take your treats to go. As clean as it is, the atmosphere is still as gas station. read more

Gretchens is a family favorite. We really have enjoyed every single flavor we've tried.

My mom visited this business and was asked to leave a review. This is her feedback (now that she's back safe to NY): Gretchen's Goodies is located inside Mobil gas station. They offer 75 different flavors of cakes, pies, and cheesecake in an easy-to-takeaway cup, all made fresh in store. If you order 6, you get one free. If you order 12, you get two free. They also offer a Veteran's discount. The tasty desserts stay fresh in the fridge for up to 4 days (just TRY making them last that long LOL). Otherwise, you can freeze them for up to 3 months. At this visit, we purchased yellow cake with chocolate frosting, peanut butter cake, cherry pie cheesecake, and Snickers cheesecake, among others. The yellow cake was a little dry, but the chocolate frosting totally made up for it. The chocolate frosting was out of this world! The cherry pie cheesecake was also very yummy. Keith & Justin (the proprietors) were very pleasant, willing to explain/describe everything, and I can't wait to go back and see them again. read more

This place isn't like it used to be the display is dirty, for a place that sells desserts in a cup, and the theory behind it the cups are pretty dirty. The lids are smashed in. It's the cleansing for me. Not so clean read more

I ordered a Mocha Starbucks Cheesecake and Strawberry Cheesecake. They were both really good and not overly sweet. I will be back to try other flavors. read more

Gretchen's Goodies - Strawberry Cheesecake Mocha Starbucks Cheesecake - Bakeries Near Me - Riverview, Florida

See all

It you don't know find out! Gretchen's is the best for cake, pies and cheesecakes. OMG this is like heaven in your mouth. Definitely a must try. Service was immaculate and Karissa was a doll I mean just sweet and so helpful from beginning to the end it was like the best experience ever. I love her spirit she's always a pleasure. Always clean and very inviting definitely go back again, I'm gonna say if you have not tried these great treats, give it a try well worth it. read more

See all

Never thought I'd call a gas station beautiful. But this is more than a gas station. It's like an upscale bakery with an assortment of cheesecakes. Honestly shout out to the owners for creating such an amazing concept with absolutely amazing dessert. read more

My husband and I checked out Gretchen's Goodies on a Friday (Good Friday) afternoon. It wasn't busy and we were met by the owner and her husband. We were given some suggestions as first time customers and decided to get two each. I picked the red velvet cake and pina colada pie. My husband chose the snickers and brownie cheesecake. I enjoyed both. My favorite so far is pina colada pie. It was very light and refreshing. Not too sweet. My husband liked the flavors of the snickers and brownie cheesecakes but didn't like the mousse topping. They have a variety of options and would definitely recommend them if you want to try something sweet. They also have keto options! read more

Gretchen's Goodies - Red Velvet Cake - Bakeries Near Me - Riverview, Florida

Gretchen's is a spot we go to when we are craving sweet food. All of their desserts are good but my favorite is the Mississippi mud pie. It is so good. They are also really quick when we go in person. Thank you Gretchen's for a good go to spot read more

Stopped in on Christmas Day to pick up some on the go desserts. There are so many flavor choices to pick from, and they all looked delicious! My husband and I picked up the tiramisu and sweet potato cheesecake cups. Both were amazing, perfect to split with a friend read more

Ran into this place after stopping for Gas off 75 from a trip back from Sarasota. WOW what a find!!!!!!! I ordered 3 desert and they were oh so so good the next better than the one before. Don't know why this is at a gas station but man I know where I am stopping for gas on the way back home from Sarasota every time. Simply DELICIOUS!!!!! One of my best finds in Florida to date. read more

I would prefer for it to be way much less cream cheese frosting in the middle of the cake cups. Also the price went up to $6. So you're pretty much paying for a cream cheese. I suggest the price goes back to $5 and limits the amount of cream cheese. This should help with the cost. Overall the cake itself still tastes really good. I definitely don't go to this store as much because they no longer carry the Krispy crunchy Chicken. read more

Today we tried the strawberry shortcake and red velvet cake. This is our 4th visit and they never disappoint. The cakes are always moist and taste hmm hmm delicious. Thanks Autumn for assisting us. read more

Gretchen's Goodies - Red velvet and strawberry shortcakes - Bakeries Near Me - Riverview, Florida

See all

Delicious little cake cups that are perfect to eat on the go! The have a bunch of different flavors each one better then the next!

I had a sample of the goodies at an event for my kid but was on the fence. One day on a whim I stopped into the Zoom Zoom gas station that this was in. I assumed it was a cold case of deserts or something small. I had no idea the non-chain gas station would be clean and trendy or that Gretchen's Goodies would have an entire counter. It was very impressive. We had a tough time choosing which flavor we wanted. We settled on REESE'S PEANUT BUTTER and BROWNIE. They were absolutely delicious. I 100% recommend this place and their desserts! read more

See all

I ordered it thru Uber eats. Not a huge fan of the apple cheesecake, but the biscoff cookie cake, OMG, so delicious. I can't really say anything other than, what you imagine it to taste like, it does. They were all so good. I had a sweet craving and this satisfied it perfectly. read more

Gretchen's Goodies - Caramel Apple Cheesecake Biscoff Cookie Butter Cake German Chocolate Cake White Chocolate Raspberry Cheesecake - Bakeries Near Me - Riverview, Florida

Delicious! Many choices and always stocked up. Would highly recommend visiting. Family owned and operated. I watched the gas station this place is inside of go from the worse owner I have ever seen to doing a full 360. The owner shows appreciation to his employees (from what I have witnessed) and has put love into this location. I will continue to visit this location for my munchies and smoke shop needs. read more

Absolutely delicious!! This little place in a gas station is amazing. The people and service is great. We had a salted caramel cheesecake and a double chocolate cheesecake and they was absolutely delicious. They have a lot of flavors and cake's so we can't wait to go and try some other flavors. You must give them a try. read more

I am impressed with the cleanliness of the store and the variety. I would like to see more keto goodies. That being said, what a good idea! The bakery manager was so attentive. Thank you! I look forward to one day meeting the owners of this place. Hard workers and it appears they hired the best. read more

Lots of selection. Inside a gas station. Amazing cakes. Light and fluffy. freshly made. read more

See all

We love to stop by and treat ourselves to these AMAZING desserts! We have tried the key lime pie, red velvet, chocolate cake and snickers cheesecake. They have all been delicious and we highly recommend!! They are also open 24 hrs which is a bonus if you have a craving for some quality desserts late at night! read more

Gretchen's Goodies - Chocolate cake, snickers cheesecake and ,key lime pie! Yum!! - Bakeries Near Me - Riverview, Florida

Omg. If you like desserts they have the best. Try them you be hooked, I sure em. The quality is fantastic

OMG!! This place never disappoints and I have a hard time finding my favorite! Everything is fresh and tastes delicious

Key lime pie is the best hands down. Personally I don't like the cake versions because of the icing but the cheesecake and pie versions are perfect. read more

I had high hopes for this place from all the reviews. Sadly I was extremely disappointed. Ordered the dulce de Leche cheesecake and the carrot cake cheesecake. The Dulce de Leche tasted like mouse rather than a cheesecake. The texture was similar also to a mouse. The carrot cake cheesecake was carrot cake with frosting in between and on top. The cake was dry and flavorless and so was the "cheesecake" in between. Overall probably would not come back again. Also the pricing is $6 per cup and although they look pretty they lack any remanence of cheesecake read more

Karissa was great! She offered samples and walked me through each of Gretchen's product types (cheesecake, cake & pie). This trip it was all about the Apple Crisp. When you have a craving for something sweet, I highly recommend. Especially when you consider they are open 24/7, so you can fill the craving any time of day. read more