This review is for their new ice cream offerings only. I've never been in the store before as…read moremacrons seemed like a lot of sugar I didn't need! But Ice Cream, I need! Service windows and a nice picnic table area have been added facing Chili Ave and there's plenty of parking. There's a zillion of flavors of hard ice cream to choose from along with sundaes, etc. I'm not sure what brand they use, but it tastes high quality. Soft ice cream is also available. Prices are fair for what you get :)

This was a first time experience after I had been eyeing this place for a while. We came with our…read moreneighbors and about 5 kids so the outside seating area was perfect. I opted for the sweet stack with Oreos, Cookie Monster ice cream and all the works. It was SO good but massive! I could only eat a quarter of it, so it would have been nice if they offered different sizes. Those run about $9. My kids got kiddie soft serve ice creams and my fiancé got the Nutella sweet stack which was yummy too. For everyone it was $29 total. My son got "super thirsty" since it was a hot day and the servers were nice and gave my fiancé a cup of water for him. Unfortunately my other son decided to stick his hands in it and ruin in. I went and asked for another cup of water and they told me they don't serve cups of water and only sell bottled water.... I didn't bother getting it at that point. Any other ice cream place we've been to around town has either a water jug outside or have offered a cup of water, so it was just odd. Anyways, it was good ice cream and I like all the fun stuff they offer.

Really long list of choices for ice cream: Sundaes, cones, dishes, milkshakes, etc., with two…read moreservice windows. The lines went quickly. There are no bathrooms, umbrellas or anything but cash allowed, so be prepared. There were lots of happy families there when we visited.

Service! I'm all about service and feeling welcomed or at least the proper treatment of customers…read more At multiple visits I've been treated with attitude because I ordered an item differently. Hard ice cream on a milkshake shouldn't be a big deal, am willing to pay extra, instead I get attitude and the feel of being dismissed. It's a shame, as a member of the community, I've brought in youth groups, neighbors, and friends... have waited the long lines at times in order to shop and give locally.... But today was it. It's simple... treat people well! You're an ice cream shop... should be the friendliest place in the summer!

Andy's is my favorite chocolate shop in Rochester! I especially love their peanut butter…read morechocolates, but everything is so good. Lots of fun shapes for all seasons and specialties, plus WNY favorites like Sponge Candy. I've always had very friendly service from their staff at multiple locations.

Ive been ordering for Years and it's the best candy. I love the quality of this product.read more

I had a feeling this would be my kind of place when I saw the name, and I was right. The chocolate…read moreis hand crafted and amazing. They hold themselves to such high standards, they were giving salted caramel away that weren't pretty off. I thought they looked fine and tasted even better. And then there's the wildflower collection. The violet and clover honey were my favorites, but the lavender, dandelion wine, and rise were great, too. And so pretty. The shop is bright and welcoming. Service is excellent. You can even make your own selection for gift boxes in different sizes. For now on, this is a must visit when I'm in town. They also serve their own small batch ice cream next door.

Surprise ice cream is the best ice cream. I had an ice cream craving the last time I was in…read moreRochester visiting my mom. She said "we have ice cream at home" and we did. A perfectly normal cardboard carton of vanilla ice cream from Wegmans. I said "no, let's get real ice cream", typed "ice cream" into google maps, and was led here. Hedonist ice cream, my friends, is not Wegmans. And I'm not knocking Wegmans - it's perfectly normal ice cream with a ton of ingredients I can't pronounce for purposes of preservation. Hedonist ice cream is so much more than a cardboard carton of ice cream. They have a rotating menu of flavors, all made fresh and in-house with no preservatives. I have never met a cookies n cream ice cream I didn't love, so I went with that. Mom had a salted caramel ice cream that was fabulous. I paid for both of us since the ice cream was my idea. She was shocked at the 12 dollar total for both of us. "That's three things of ice cream at Wegmans!" But at Hedonist, it's absolutely quality over quantity. Even my mom admitted it tasted better. She wouldn't go back there, and I may not because I live 400 miles away from there, but if I was in town again and I was screaming for ice cream, I'd happily make my way over there again.

Pro's: -Amazing prices on ice cream!…read more-Speedy service -Great ice cream cakes (u pick your cake flavors) -Open all year Con's: -Outdoor only, no eat in option

Definitely our favorite ice cream spot! Generous services and good service. Definitely recommend!read more

Located in the plaza across from East Avenue Wegmans , Countertop Creamery offers homemade ice…read morecream with unique flavors. Menu features core flavors and a monthly rotating menu. I ordered two scoops: strawberry patch and chocolate; a collab with local business laughing gull chocolates. Flavors were on point. I've had matcha ice cream before but none have tasted as genuine. During our visit we saw someone order the s'mores ice cream and they toasted the marshmallow to put on top in front of them! How fun! Service was quick and the owners were very nice. The location has an outdoor bench, as well as a few high top seats inside. The decor is fun and colorful inside, featuring artwork from local artists and a Polaroid wall of customers. You can also get an ice cream punch card with rewards for repeated visits. Will definitely come back to check out the rotating menu!

Small batch gourmet ice cream. A double serving will cost $8-$9 dollars but it definitely doesn't…read moredisappoint! They have very limited space inside and outside. This is more a once in awhile treat than a regular summer stop.

Ice cream is fantastic and service is excellent. Friendly atmosphere. Lots of flavors. Reasonable…read moreprices.

Molly V's has the best ice cream in the area! cute little spot where you can get one of their many…read moreflavors and sit outside on picnic tables or benches in the park. I'm so glad they opened up a storefront a few years ago! I do wish they had a more chocolatey vegan ice cream, but I do love their coconut pineapple one!

Love this location on Park Ave. it's convenient to get dinner on Park Ave and have a dessert option…read moreyou can walk to afterwards. The location sells pints of ice cream as well as assorted cold drinks, along with the ice cream offering. Very modern and spacious with prices and menu offerings clearly displayed. They also have a dessert case with cakes and tarts. Didn't grab one but they looked delicious. Service was fast and friendly. I enjoyed my one scoop of dirt ice cream in a traditional cone. If you want a waffle or sugar cone there is an up charge. Plenty of outdoor seating available.

We went here for ice cream and had a good experience! Their ice cream is reasonably priced and they…read morehave a large selection. I really enjoyed my peanut butter swirl ice cream that I had. The mocha chip was good, but I prefer smaller chips and more mocha flavor. We did also get some whole milk while we were here and it's the best milk we have ever had! Overall it was really tasty and we would come back again!