We wanted to try this place since it was highly rated. We were not disappointed! We ordered takeout and the service was friendly. Loved the buffalo chicken ranch pizza with the thin and crispy crust. The pasta with veal cut parmigiana was a very large portion with lots of thinly breaded veal. Great Italian food if you are in the area. read more

Goodfellas Italian Kitchen - Buffalo Chicken Ranch Pizza - Italian Near Me - Saugus, Massachusetts

See all

I had the Chicken Broccoli Alfredo and wow -- absolutely amazing! The sauce was rich and creamy, the chicken was tender, and the broccoli was perfectly cooked. Honestly one of the best Alfredo dishes I've had anywhere. What really impressed me was that it was just as delicious the next day when I reheated the leftovers -- that says a lot about the quality. Goodfellas definitely delivers on flavor and portions. Can't wait to come back and try more of the menu! I can't really speak for the service and ambience because I got takeout. read more

If I could give more than 5 stars I would. Food is delicious and giant portions. Enough for at least two meals. Their customer service is amazing extremely friendly. Definitely need to check this place out for bite to eat. You won't be disappointed.​​ read more

Very disappointed. Admittedly I haven't been there for about 12-18 months, however I must say that the quality of the steak and cheese sub as well as the amount of steak and little if any cheese, has dropped dramatically. I was told it would be ready in 25 mins. got there in about 20 it must have been sitting for a while it was dry and not hot when I returned home. Also ordered onion rings, also terrible. plenty of them but not flavor of onion except for the batter. I think they may be frozen. Used to be a regular now won't be a customer. read more

The bbq chicking wings are the best wings I've ever had in my life 10/10. The garlic bread with cheese is highly recommended. Amazing customer service and even gave us extra garlic bread for free without asking! read more

Goodfellas Italian Kitchen - Bbq Chicken Wings Plate - Italian Near Me - Saugus, Massachusetts

Awesome food and great staff. We had the haddock and stuffed shells. Really tasty! Great for takeout.

The guy behind the counter with the glasses who took my order is incredibly rude. This is the second time I have dealt with him and both times he acted the same way. I walk in, he doesn't even look up at me, asks what I want, I tell him and he says nothing and doesn't even look up once. Then he brings me the food and I couldn't understand what he said, so I said "what?" And he completely snapped at me for questioning what it was he even said to me because he has a thick accent. I was so upset I couldn't even enjoy the food which was WAY too expensive anyways and the quality was not worth the price. I gave them 2 chances and now I won't be back. Response to business owner: you have me confused with another unhappy customer. I placed my orders at the restaurant and sat down to eat. I never made a phone order with your restaurant. Again, you sound confused. If you actually read my review instead of responding so defensively and aggressively, you would have understood that. Maybe this kind of thing happens often due to your horrible customer service skills, but that particular altercation was not me. Maybe you should just accept the fact that you are an extremely rude and unprofessional individual that has no business in in customer service. Also, if your service is that bad, you may want to think about improving the quality of your food so it can justify your high prices. The only reason I gave you 2 stars is bc I spoke with a really sweet lady who was preparing food in the back on my way to the restroom. Good luck to you though, it sounds like you have a lot of issues dealing with the public read more

Not just an average Pizzeria, this place is putting out some amazing pies and unique twist on classics. From inside to outside it is a well kept and tidy establishment. Service and kitchen staff, professional and friendly. Everything from the giant chicken tenders to the pizza and mozzarella sticks are to drool over. A go to is The Buffalo Chicken Pizza: Thin and crispy dough, tangy buffalo chicken pieces, perfect amount of mozzarella/ provolone blend cheese, finished with ranch and basil, A MUST TRY read more

Goodfellas Italian Kitchen - The sign to not drive past this delicious pizza joint! - Italian Near Me - Saugus, Massachusetts

See all

It's a good pitstop for a bite to eat. The Greek grilled chicken kebab wrap was very good.

Their subs are my favorite especially the eggplant and the Goodfellas sub which I used to special request and then they created it -- it should have been named after me! They have a few tables, but mostly a take out place. read more

Amazing place. Food was excellent. We ate in and the service was beyond excellent. Large serving, fresh ingredients.

Still the best pizza in town! Some of the other items are a little more hit and miss, but even their worst items are still fine. And what's most important is that a pizza place has great pizza! read more

12/10 WOULD RECOMMEND! The food was soooo good! This is only about half of the food we got but everything was delicious. The Buffalo chicken ranch pizza was the best I've ever had, so much flavor yet not too spicy where I felt my nose was running. The garlic bread with and without cheese were sooo crispy and soft. We also ordered the mozzarella sticks which were delicious, and just look at that cheese pull! The pasta with homemade meatballs were made with love because those are some of the best meatballs ever. The bread that came with the pasta was so warm and toasty, I could have eaten an entire loaf of that bread. Keep in mind, portions for pastas are family style. Even the steak and cheese sub was HUGE! We had so much leftovers afterwards. But honestly, I feel like you can't go wrong with ordering any item on the menu. Plus, the service was amazing. One of the co-owners was working at the time and he would bring our food and was constantly making sure we were doing okay, took the time to let us know about his business and how everything got started. But everyone else who was working at the time were super nice and helpful and you can really tell a lot goes into the ambiance and experience. They really are the "good" fellas! read more

See all

Just tried Goodfellas for the first time and must say, we've been missing out. We have tried every place around here almost. The pizza was thin and crispy and was delicious. The Ham Carbonara and the meatballs, were perfect, delivered fast, and still steaming. We also couldn't believe how incredible the Chicken parm sub was. (Our bellwether for a good Italian place!) Cannot wait to try more items!! You guys are the best!! Don't sleep on this place seriously. Unlike Big Paulie, these guys Do know how to make a restaurant!!! read more

Love this place! Food is always excellent and the service is the best! Have never had a bad experience here. So clean too!

We ordered a lot of different things (1 white pizza and 1 regular pizza, curly fries, salad, multiple appetizers) and while none of them were bad per se, none of them were good enough to justify ordering from here again. In credit to the restaurant, at least part of the problem was that the delivery person didn't ring the bell, text, etc. We suspect our food was sitting outside for 15+ minutes before we realized it was there. But it didn't seem like great food that had gone soggy - it was just mediocre in the first place. I did notice there were a *lot* of reviews that were marked as "not helpful". This makes me wonder whether the extremely positive reviews I read were simply fake reviews that had not been caught by the filter. Sorry... I wanted to like this place. Just didn't. read more

We had a work party here and ordered a lot of different food. We started with some cheese sticks, pizza and other appetizers. The buffalo chicken ranch pizza was divine. We ordered a variety of meals for each of us from pasta with eggplant and pasta with haddock on it to wrap sandwiches. Everyone enjoyed their food. No alcoholic drinks but an interesting selection of soft drinks. The service was very good. Parking in the lot behind the restaurant can get a little tight but there is parking on the side street. read more

This place is incredible! I had the gnocchi and never had better. My partner had the seafood platter and it was better than the Charthouse in downtown Boston! These guys are so cool and friendly chattin up all the regulars, they even turned off the a/c for us...bein desert folk haha. Give 'em a try! read more

Incredible pizza! The service was the best! We initially were going to eat in house, but since we are on vacation/tired we changed our mind. The staff promptly packed it up and gave us plates for us to eat it back at our place. We also got garlic cheesy bread too! We would definitely run back to Goodfellas! Thanks Again! read more

I wanted this place to be good, I've always seen in in my route from the dog park. But definitely this reminds me of how I felt when I came to Boston 10 years ago.... Bland and subpar ingredients! Definitely remind me of going to Quincy market... all this potential great food only to potentially being influenced by its clientele or perhaps they really just don't taste the food. I did see many people coming in while here and very excited but seemed like a particularly similar crown. I would avoid... even in a pinch! I will say that one of the owner seemed pretty nice and chill... also very clean. read more

Goodfellas Italian Kitchen - Chicken Parmesan and baked curly pasta - Italian Near Me - Saugus, Massachusetts

We were in town for a family wedding, wanted some good Italian... The calzones were fantastic, really filled with top quality ingredients, get the calzones, you'll be happy The management is awesome, we had a little mix up with our order which was handled well... read more

FIRST TIME IN MY LIFE.... That I actually walk in a take-out place (that I've never been in before) and the guy behind the counter gives me what I ordered free of charge and let me tell you it really was delicious!!! And I walked out of there saying this guy acted more like a goodfella then half the goodfellas I know!!! Thanks for keeping it gangsta buddy I am DEFINITELY going to give you more business in the future your a true Gentlemen!! read more

Goodfellas Italian Kitchen - Italian Near Me - Saugus, Massachusetts

the wings were crispy on the outside and super soft on the inside, the pizza was thin and super cheesy. all the food came out hot and made to order. the staff was extremely kind and personable. great hospitality def recommend! the store was extremely clean and welcoming. read more

Vegetarian received Chicken Parm! The photos lay it out clearly, i ordered an EGGPLANT Parm with Hot peppers, black pepper, and toasted. I received an untoasted, without hot peppers, CHICKEN Parm sandwich that i unfortunately took a bite of and am feeling messing with my stomach now as i have not had meat in years. You got 1 out of 4 correct and the most important ingredient wrong. What a shame when their pizza was good. read more

See all

I 1000% recommend, it was absolutely delicious! The service was great, they were so sweet! My mom thought the garlic bread looked a little sketch but it's amazing. The pizza was thin crust, super cheesy, cooked to perfection. If you're looking for a pizza place this is it! read more

See all

Pizza is terrible I don't know why my sister keeps ordering it Salads are awesome and so is everything else the pizza are really bad and not cooked read more

Finally got to stop in and try this new spot opened not to long ago. Very friendly people. It was an hour before closing time and I had ordered the steak and cheese sub for pick up. My son wanted food also so we stopped in and he added an order of the fish and chips and I got a slice of pizza. I haven't had this pizza in a while so when I seen that u can buy them buy the slice my eyes lit up. The guy at the counter said the pizza was on the house and warmed them up for us. I usually never get anything on the house, if anything I usually get over charged so that was nice of him. The pizza was really good. The ranch sauce wasn't too much or too less, it was well balanced. My son said he really enjoyed their fish and chips. Overall, the food is good and the price is fair. Will recommend to friends and family. FYI: parking behind the building and steps to walk up to the entrance. read more

Goodfellas Italian Kitchen - Buffalo chicken ranch pizza - Italian Near Me - Saugus, Massachusetts

See all

OMG!!! I am obsessed with this place, everything it's so good. The only problem it's I live right above it and I want eat there everyday. We tried the salads, the pizza, the subs, the calzone, the pasta and u can tell you it's hard to pic a favorite. Food it's always fresh and the owner are all so nice. Great food in a friendly atmosphere. read more

Goodfellas Italian Kitchen - The Capital White pizza - Italian Near Me - Saugus, Massachusetts

Service is excellent and the food is top notch. Great ambience in the restaurant. They want me to keep writing more.

UM YUM! My fiancé and I checked this place out for the first time tonight we were SO impressed. The white buffalo chicken pizza was out this world good. My fiancé got the chicken scampi and let me say, this pasta dish tasted WAY better then some of the dishes we've been served in the North End! The sauce was unbelievable. We also got a ceasar salad to split and the pita bread that came with it tasted like heaven and FRESH. They gave a complimentary lentil soup to my fiancé when he was waiting for our order and he said it was amazing, such good customer service and hospitality. We will be adding this place to our weekly takeout rotation! Hidden Gem exposed. Bravo! SUPPORT LOCAL. read more

Goodfellas Italian Kitchen - Chicken Scampi - Italian Near Me - Saugus, Massachusetts

See all

The grilled chicken is a HUGE portion! Seasoned perfectly, served with rice and a side salad, it is enough for two. The kids pasta is a generous portion and enough for two meals for kids or a generous portion for an adult (take out.) kids chicken tenders and fries were cooked to PERFECTION! Juicy inside crispy outside. They know what they are doing in this place! Highly recommend this place! read more

Great service, incredibly friendly staff, huge portions and a great true Italian taste.

The service is good here. They are efficient, friendly, and I've never waited long for my food. The packaging for takeout is prob the best I've seen at any restaurant. Personally, I think there's way too much seasoning on the chicken they use for their salads. I wish they had a plain chicken option. They give a LOT of chicken, too, like a LOT?! read more

What a great place. Works are super nice and the portions are HUGE!!! Giant menu and food is good. My 2 young daughters are extremely picky and they loved it. Worth a try and I'll definitely be back! read more

Really good Sicilian pizza. Sauce and just grated cheese on top. Cold like bakery pizza. Nice arancini. Ordered chicken limon. A little bitter. Came with lemon slices and it's possible that sitting during the delivery meant the rind was in the pasta for too long. Good salad. Really good chicken cutlet and pesto sandwich. read more

Depending on the meal, it can be pricey, buy you'll eat twice as the portions are enormous. The service is amazing, variety of food. You won't go wrong. read more

This place is amazing! The staff strives to provide the best quality food to the public and never disappoint. I come here at least three times a week and not once have they let me down with the quality of the food. They are all super friendly and provide a very laid back ambiance in which you enjoy your food in person if you choose to. Also I would run to try their new Wise Chicken sandwich which is cooked to perfection and is the perfect tenderness. read more

After a long day of work i stumbled upon this heavenly restaurant. The staff is amazing and the pizza is out of this world. Highly recommend this place SUPPORT YOUR LOCAL BUSINESS read more

Goodfellas Italian Kitchen - Pizza - Italian Near Me - Saugus, Massachusetts

Great place for a meal after work. Stopped in thinking I 'd want to take out but convinced by the sweet staff to dine in. Great portion sizes and fresh tasting seafood! Loved it here and since I'm in the neighborhood, I'll be back! read more

Goodfellas Italian Kitchen - Fish and Chips Plate - Italian Near Me - Saugus, Massachusetts

Nice lil spot! We ordered a steak and cheese pizza and mozzarella sticks. Tried the cheesy garlic breads. The place was clean and the food was good. Every thing was great and the service was welcoming Will definitely re-visit if Im back in Saugus. read more