Ok, my first visit here was for a walk in & take out order. I originally looked at their menu online intending to call ahead, I opted to peruse their counter and scope out what looks good once I got there. Once there I was suprised how small this place was. A handfull of tables and a small help counter with none of their food samplings in sight. With lots of menu options I settled on my typical standby for testing out a new place... a large chicken parmesan sandwich and a slice of plain pizza.The young lady at the counter gladly took my order. I walked in about 6pm on a Friday and had my dinner in hand within 15-20mins, not bad. Now for my thoughts... THE CHICKEN PARMESAN~ typical style sandwich, my large was 12 inches. I found it kinda dry & llight on the sauce but I think the right amount of sauce is subjective from person to person and don't hold that against them, I'd just order extra the next time. Overall it was good. As usual, I was super hungry this night and forgot to take pics of my dinner, my apologies! THE PIZZA~ Finally a great slice!!!!! I'm hoping like heck that this was not just a fluke. It's hard to get the full picture from just one slice, but this one slice had it all! What made it great your thinking, I'll explain... 1. The most important is the crust, this slice had the perfect combination of crisp crust and textured chew, apparently so hard to nail down for these parts. It's what I've been looking for. 2. Right amounts of cheese and sauce 3. A nice fresh basil flavor To sum up, I was very happy with my dinner. I'm already looking forward to my next visit and see if I can find that pizza bliss again!!! read more

Food was good but prices in the downloadable PDF menu are WAY off. They list the sub I got at $7.95. Current price was $11.99. Please update online menu. read more

Ordered a margherita pizza and Caesar salad. The pizza appeared not to be completely cooked as the cheese was not all the way melted. But The pizza was flavorful. I had a microwave in my room so I was able to heat up a slice at a time as I ate it. The salad was very good. Plenty of dressing and the shaved parm was delicious. I ordered using Yelp delivery and it was delivered 10 minutes earlier than expected so that was pretty nice. A nice touch for folks like me in a hotel, they inclided good napkins and plenty of them. read more

Good Times Pizzeria - Margherita Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bethlehem, Pennsylvania

In the Bethlehem area for business and staying at the Homewood Suites near the airport. Was interested in some pizza and after some digging, I decided to order from Good Time Pizza. All I can say is PERFECT!! The crust is spot on! Not flimsy, nice bite to it and just the right chew. Sauce and toppings weren't overdone so the whole pie "makes sense". Will now be my "go-to" in the area. Nice job Good Times! read more

Good Times makes a pretty good pizza. We had a pepperoni and it was hot and ready on time with an appropriate of pepperoni. The crust was flavorable, not greasy. Since I was getting it to go, I asked for some paper plates and they happily provided them. The guy at the counter even bagged them up for me. However, he did not offer me any Parmesan or pepper flakes to go with my "to go" order. I would order from here again. read more

Consistently great take out! We come here every week and have had a lot of the menu. We love the pizza! Good crust and sauce. Their strombolis are always super stuffed! Always quick and pleasant service. Glad they are open during the quarantine. Thanks for the good grub! read more

See all

So i have been ordering pizza from this place for awhile,usually hit or miss mostly order from here because there aren't any good pizza places near me.But it has gotten worse hardly any cheese and cardboard crust,2 stars cause the sicilian pizza is edible. read more

So I admit I have only ordered here twice. The second time I asked for it my pizza to be cooked "well done" and it came out absolutely perfect. Some places don't even really care or listen when you tell them that, or they don't really know what well done means, and they come close to burning it to a char. This pizza was a perfect example of a very good Lehigh Valley/Eastern Pa pizza read more

Good Times Pizzeria - Well done pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bethlehem, Pennsylvania

Delicious thin crust Sicilian pizza. (You must ask for this!) Ordered half onion, half pepperoni. Delivered hot and crispy! read more

Good Times Pizzeria - Sicilian Pizza today. Half Pepperoni, half thinly sliced onion, extra crispy. Was delivered HOT and was delicious. - Pizza Near Me - Bethlehem, Pennsylvania

THE BEST white pizza with ricotta cheese and lots of garlic. Crispy crust, not too thick. Excellent pie! Will try more items. read more

They have a pretty good variety on the menu. Whoever listed the prices though may want to update. The menu lists many specialty pizzas for $10, but they're charging about double (as of Oct 2022) on pies with toppings. The pizza was good except for a piece of string cooked in with the pizza dough found in one slice (out of 2 pies). I don't recommend the boneless wings. The wings had an old/used cooking oil taste from deep frying and seemed more like nuggets with barely mild hot sauce when it called for hot & spicy. read more

I came in for lunch and got a slice of sausage and pepperoni pizza. I was pleasantly surprised at how good the pizza was. The crust was very light and had a great crunch. They did not skimp on the sausage and pepperoni. They seasoned the pizza well to give it that elevated taste. If I had one critique, it would be about the sausage. It's more like ground pieces of sausage on the pizza. It didn't add much flavor and a lot of it fell off when I'd pick it up to eat. I'd definitely come back for another slice! read more

Good Times Pizzeria - Sausage & pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bethlehem, Pennsylvania

Excellent pizza place! These guys make an incredible bruschetta Sicilian pie, and they always remember your favorites! Tasty, consistent, and dependable. They will be called Good Times in January 2015. read more

Good Times Pizzeria - Bruschetta Sicilian. The smell - basil olive oil and fresh tomatoes reminds me of my old farm. - Pizza Near Me - Bethlehem, Pennsylvania

Very good food at decent prices. Great sized portions. Covid-protocols. Delivery available.

Not the greatest. I had mushroom topping and it was like they put a few on from a jar. The crust was hard and not comfortable to eat. I would find an alternative place next time. read more

Good Times Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Bethlehem, Pennsylvania

We stumbled upon this place while at a bowling tournament in the area. What a pleasant surprise! The food was fantastic and the team so hospitable. If we are ever in the area again we be back for the rice balls, Stromboli and cannoli. Thanks for a great experience. read more

Great pizza. Fast delivery. Sandwiches also very very good. We usually order for pickup and delivery and we have had dinners as well. Fair priced and very good quality. The portion sizes are generous enough for sharing. Open late which is a plus as well. read more

This place has the best pizza in BETHLEHEM and is very affordable!! The have excellent cheese steaks!!! Amazing Rice ball's!!! The Conolies are Delicious!!! And they are now open Sunday's!!! The owner is a great Family man!!! read more

This is my go to pizza place. Nice, friendly and quick service. Go to order.... Pizza, calzone or Stromboli with the antipasto salad.

I've lived in the Lehigh Valley for over 35 years, and am constantly on the lookout for new "go to" pizzerias. Recently, I stumbled on to Good Times, and, as is my custom, the first thing I tried was a plain slice. It was, in a word, perfect. The crust was absolutely cooked to perfection, the cheese was of a sincerely high quality, and the sauce, though simple, is still unique, and, in this writer's opinion, the best in the area. The second time I went there--which, incidentally, was only five days later--I also tried the rice ball, which is absolutely incredible and reminiscent of a top quality veal parm! Simply outstanding, and the prices cannot be beat either. Give Good Times a try and you will not be disappointed! read more

First time I had ever been here! I've been around the Lehigh Valley my whole entire life and there's pretty much a pizza shop every other block; I decided to try this place for the first time. I got a large pie with pepperoni - the pie was delicious and it has a slight, slight bit of kick - I couldn't tell if it was in the pepperoni or the sauce, but very good! I think my total was about $14. I like this pizza a lot better than the two other places that are located on the same road.... read more

First experience at Good Times Pizzeria and very satisfied as a new customer. We chose this establishment because of Groupon and glad we found it. Food was of the utmost quality and presentation was excellent. The only downside of this place is seating. High End Italian restaurant food but the seating is limited, like a small pizzeria. Definitely recommend for take out for large groups, cozy dining in for a couple. read more

Good Times Pizzeria - Penne Vodka with Grilled Chicken - Pizza Near Me - Bethlehem, Pennsylvania

Fabulous, fresh food. The mozzarella salad was fresh, unusual and delightful- artichokes and oranges give it a sweet and unique twist. Pizza crust the best! The meatballs are huge and flavorful. Exceeded our expectations. Unpretentious atmosphere and outstanding! read more

Good Times Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Bethlehem, Pennsylvania

A very nice change-up from Lehigh Pizza. Have ordered delivery 3 times. Twice they were at my doorstep in 20 minutes. One time they were backed up on a Friday night and it took an hour. They showed up with an 2 litter bottle of coke to apologize for the delay. Truly going above and beyond. Also, just feel entrepreneurial and honored to get business. Again, nice change-up from Lehigh Pizza. From my history of ordering: The Fresh Mozzarella Salad is amazing. Chicken Caesar is ok. California Fresh Chicken Cutlet Sub is great. Boneless Chicken Wings felt a little bit like they were microwavable kind and dunked in BBQ sauce. Feel like I am judging harshly though as this is primarily a pizza place. Have yet to order pizza but am sure we won't be disappointed when we do. read more

Stopped by here on a whim and not disappointed! Had the grilled chicken salad with their house sweet balsamic. Excited to go back and try more! There gyro Stromboli is literally the best thing I ever ate! read more

I ordered through the Slice app. The app allows the restaurant to notify the customer when the order is being prepared, an estimated time it's ready, then again when it's done, so you don't have to wait around inside. I got the third notification right at the estimated time...then had to wait around 25 minutes anyway. Apparently they did have half the order done on time, as it was cold by the time the rest was ready. Additionally, they shorted me one chicken wing on an order of 12, which is no big dealer unless you plan to split the order three ways. The Stromboli was quite good (after we warmed it up in our own oven) but the wings were small and dry. A previous order of pizza was slightly above average. read more

Called in an order, was told 15-20 minutes. Ordered 2 pizzas and garlic knots..pizzas were sitting 25 minutes until they made the knots. Ordered extra cheese, asked owner if this was "extra cheese " said it was, it was pathetic! Order was ready over 45 minutes after calling. Dude didn't offer to comp at all, just said sorry dude. Other pizza was a veggie pie and they looked like they were sauted before they were put on the pizza. Don't know why they are getting good reviews, I think they suck! read more

Had delivery and have to say bacon cheeseburger deal is great. Coconut shrimp was tasty as well. House rice ball is nice combination. Pizza is okay but tasted like it was made on pre-made frozen crust. Delivery was on time and driver was pleasant and food was really hot. Overall I will order again. read more

Eggplant was excellent! Pizza is great too! Service was friendly and the place was clean- watch out Westgate Pizza! read more

The best of everything Italian! You won't be disappointed. Friendly staff. Good prices. Best quality! Good quantity. No short cuts. If you are in this area and looking for Italian food head for Good Times! read more

Good Times Pizzeria - a menu on a chalkboard - Pizza Near Me - Bethlehem, Pennsylvania

Great pizza had the white pizza with garlic delicious fresh nice tasty thin crust. The thermonuclear wings were great as well. Fast delivery. I would recommend for delivery pizza and wings for certain. read more

Was in a hurry to leave the city so I didn't get to grab a slice :( came here to get something close to NYC pizza before heading back to Los Angeles. Pizza is not bad. Its appears to be very clean and fast! Plenty of parking. Dinning area is small 5 tables. Staff was friendly. Fake brick walls made me chuckle ;) read more

Good Times Pizzeria - Not bad - Pizza Near Me - Bethlehem, Pennsylvania

Just called in on the back of some good yelp reviews looking for something quick to eat. We were out of town so were eating in and not taking out. The place itself is fine - nothing to write home about but the pizza was good. Once again not great but very good. What blew me away was the service. The two guys taking orders were unbelievably friendly and accommodating. It was a real pleasure to receive such great service - great job guys. The pizza was good and I would gladly go back for that. But the service was top notch. Oh - and if you like garlic then try their garlic knots. They were incredible too. read more

Did not go through YELP or any other service.Excellent all around ! Food & employee's give 5 stars!

Five stars! The salads are amazing, every single ingredient was ridiculously fresh; tomatoes, mozzarella, oranges, romaine, I can't even think of one thing I'd do differently. Pizza was excellent as well...we ordered the plain pizza so I can't comment on the toppings, but the sauce & cheese on the plain were done to perfection. Absolutely will be back! read more

Phoned in an order. It was delivery. Guy showed up and told me I hadn't paid; we had paid by card. Instead of telling me let me check with the restaurant, he tried arguing that we didn't pay. I made him call and sure enough we had. The pizza was definitely not worth the argument. Decent but nothing to write home about. read more

Ordered an "Eggplant Parmesian Pizza", got a regular pie with some skinny peices of eggplant spread over the top (certainly not battered dipped and fried and covered with sauce and cheese as described on the menu). When I called they said that is what it is. Okay, it was a decent one topping (eggplant) pie but not what I expected at all. Live and Learn. If that is what you want then just order a regular pie with eggplant and save yourself a few bucks.... read more

Best pizza in the area by far. They are always our go-to when we need a pizza or Italian fix. Great service, love the family that owns and runs the place. We have never had a bad experience. If you're looking for authentic Italian cuisine without the high price tag, this is the place! And they deliver! read more

I think this is a really solid pizzeria in the Lehigh Valley. Love their NY style pizza, calzones and rice balls. I just wish they were open on Sundays. read more

Terrible pizza. Undercooked and super greasy. We couldn't even pull a slice out of the box without taking all the cheese with it. Wings were burnt to a crisp and the hot wing sauce was nearly nonexistent. Will never order pizza from there again. Called to complain and all I got offered was another pizza. Really unfortunate circumstance because of how close they are. read more