Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Good Company

    2.9 (161 reviews)
    Open • 11:00 am - 8:00 pm

    Order Good Company Takeout or Delivery

    Good Company Photos

    Business Info

    GOOD COMPANY ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?
    Moderate noise
    Good for kids
    Good for groups

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Good Company

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Cookie Skillet
    Kylie W.

    THE GOOD COMPANY WAS IN FACT NOT GOOD! We came in a group of 31 so we knew what we were getting into. We had two servers for our two tables, one was absolutely fantastic she had a smile on her face the whole time but the other one was either having an off day or is bad at her job. She forgot about one of our meals and the cook was not happy. The food was mid... personally I had the French Dip which was one of their specialties (not done right). Some others in the group enjoyed their steaks and wraps. We were told we couldn't do separate checks by the one waitress but the other was not on the same page because she was ready to split for our table. One positive to add... the desserts were AMAZING!

    Lobster bisque soup
    Megan K.

    Food was better than expected, service was nice prompt, being a full house they did well. Ambiance is amazing old fashion- did not expect the inside to be so full of character. Mia our server was wonderful!!

    Queso Dip with Beef Added
    Ally S.

    Highlights/Lowlights 1. Friendly Service 2. Average Food 3. Good/Basic Menu with a Lot of Options Stopped in at Good Company on a Sunday afternoon for lunch. We did not have a reservation but there were plenty of tables available for seating. Ambiance is cozy and a little dated which makes it charming. The space is really big with several dining rooms, a big bar area, and an events room. Our server was friendly and pretty quick to get our order in and get us drinks. The menu is big with a good selection of soups, sandwiches, salads, appetizers and entrees. This is a good menu for picky eaters as there are a lot of very basic pasta/sandwich/entree options. We ordered wine first. The wine list is very average/grocery store wine varieties. My friend and I split the queso dip and added beef. The appetizer was average. Queso was pretty good, chips just tasted like your standard grocery store variety. I had the California Chicken Salad for lunch. Again, this item was very average. You could definitely tell the chicken was pre-cooked/frozen as it had that slightly rubbery texture but not inedible. Overall, I enjoyed my time here and would probably visit again as you don't need a reservation and it's centrally located. The food, unfortunately, is not the star of the show here.

    Brandy Old Fashioned
    Jack G.

    Great ambiance with quirky decor and a maze of rooms add to the dining experience. The food was good but unremarkable (above average pub fare). My wrap was very good, but I could not taste the avocado that was listed in the menu description. The French Dip was tasty. The French Fries could use improvement. My Brandy Old Fashioned was well made (our pleasant server politely steered me away from the cocktails that were premixed) - I ordered a second one! Good service and reasonable prices. Good Company is also a great wedding venue (they have separate rooms to accommodate wedding parties). I observed a wedding ceremony during one visit here.

    Lasagna
    David E.

    This was our first visit to Good Company, we plan to return. We found the prices to not be out of line, even reasonable for the times. Our food was delicious and hot when served. Our server was very new, and although she needed a bit more training and support, she was very pleasant and personable. We enjoyed the historic focused decor. I selected -1 star as the lasagna only had cheese in 1 layer, with meat sauce between the rest.

    Blue cheese and horseradish tenderloin. Side of cream cheese/chive mashed potatoes, loaded with cheese and bacon
    Jane J.

    Service was nice, seemed to be a lot of younger wait staff, some still training (glad to see they are recruiting successfully in the legit shortage). My tenderloin was awesome and they let me add the "loaded" option to my mashed potatoes. There were fairly busy for lunch but everything was timely. I'm eager to sit in the bar just for drinks sometime as I've never tried any while dining. Never a bad experience

    Gluten free menu- you need to ask for it
    Kris T.

    Had a nice gluten free menu. Attentive waitress. Food was great! The gluten free bun was pretty good compared to others I've had. My husband loves the Cajun salmon. The queen and chips made a good appetizer.

    Just sat down for lunch

    See all

    12 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 5 of 5

    Ask the Community - Good Company

    You might also consider

    Bazil's Pub & Provisions - Jalapeño Burger & Fries.....really good & they made it rare for me.

    Bazil's Pub & Provisions

    4.0(50 reviews)
    0.4 mi
    •$$

    Bazil's Pub & Provisions is one of those places I can walk into without needing a plan--and that's…read moreexactly why I love it. Established in 1993, Bazil's has that classic old-school pub personality that you just don't manufacture. Dark wood, vintage bar vibes, a relaxed atmosphere and a massive beer selection that gives you plenty of reasons to hang around for a while. And honestly, the beer selection is the star of the show. Bazil's is known for having one of the biggest craft beer selections on College Avenue, and it's easy to see why people make this place a destination. Whether you already know exactly what you want or you're standing there thinking, "Okay...what the hell am I drinking today?" there's plenty to explore. But what I appreciate most is that they don't overcomplicate things. Good basic pub food. Cold beer. Comfortable surroundings. No need to dress it up with a paragraph of adjectives and culinary buzzwords. I went with the burger and fries, and it was exactly what I wanted from an old-school neighborhood pub: simple, satisfying comfort food that pairs perfectly with a cold beer. And then there's the fish tank. Seriously. That thing deserves its own Yelp review. There's something ridiculously relaxing about sitting at the bar, having a cold beer in front of you and watching the fish cruise around behind the glass. It adds this weirdly peaceful element to a classic pub environment. Bazil's is the kind of place you don't necessarily go to "experience." You go to hang out. And sometimes those are the places you end up remembering most. Brews. Views. Food. Repeat.

    Usually love Jen's bar. Usually love the employees. This Saturday I went to meet my husband in…read morethere, already had been in and said hi to everyone. The lady outside that I had never met told me I couldn't bring in my 2 espresso's. She didn't care about the soda and food. I had to leave my expensivecoffee drinks outside. Mind you I have been walk in with coffee for years. I was upset. The inside waitress said it was a city law. Really? When I walked out that same lady was letting 2 ladies she knew come in with coffee drinks. So not cool. The whole thing was very upsetting to a loyal longtime customer.

    Photos
    Bazil's Pub & Provisions - Märzen

    Märzen

    Bazil's Pub & Provisions - Bar

    Bar

    Bazil's Pub & Provisions - Inside

    See all

    Inside

    Cleo's Brown Beam Tavern - Christmas all year long

    Cleo's Brown Beam Tavern

    4.1(85 reviews)
    0.4 mi
    •$$

    I don't think I could love this place any more if I tried! We were staying in Appleton for a game…read moreup at Lambeau, and we found Cleo's just wandering the streets looking around. The painted window saying "Home of the Dirty Snowball" absolutely piqued my interest! LOL! Actually, it was that, plus the two giant nutcracker decorations out front that caught my eye. I'm a fan of (Christmas) holiday decorations, so I wanted to see what else they had, after spying some string lights through the window. Inside, it's like a wonderland of holiday cheer! Lights and ornaments and decorations everywhere! Sitting at the bar under the lights, I really felt like I'd discovered some secret bar under the Christmas tree! The staff were friendly, helpful, and quick with the libations! Kind of that "keep it real" attitude, but not in the rude way... in the honest and up front way! There is no food to speak of, save for a Chex-pub mix blend, but the drinks are why you want to visit! The famous Dirty Snowball is like a shake, but without ice cream, made with cocoa and related liqueur flavors (I can't remember what-all is in it, but it's GOOOOOOOD!). I highly recommend it! I also tried the Cleo's Trio, which is one part Dirty Snowball, one part Brandy Old Fashioned, and one part Suffering Bastard, I think? Not in the same glass! But, more like a flight. You get a little taste of Wisconsin or at least Appleton. Each drink is basically a full version, though, so you might need only one! I don't know what your favorite bar looks like, but if I lived in Appleton, this one would be mine. I would be in there at least once a week, if for no other reason the ambiance and the company. Great people, great drinks, and a legacy for holiday décor that I hope lives on forever!

    Stopped because someone suggested this place to us. Cool Christmas lights leave a warm red glow…read morethat gives the bar an intimate cozy feel. Love the dim lighting as it feels like a place I could stay forever Service is okay. And we are asking for nearby food recommendations

    Photos
    Cleo's Brown Beam Tavern - Wisconsin staple

    Wisconsin staple

    Cleo's Brown Beam Tavern - Bar partial area with drink specials

    Bar partial area with drink specials

    Cleo's Brown Beam Tavern

    See all

    Good Company - tradamerican - Updated October 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...