Absolutely delicious - real pizzeria style pizza. Also recommend the wings - they're crispy fried buffalo wings that have amazing buffalo flavor without the mess of sauce. We used Door Dash read more

Delivered every item wrong. Ordered eggplant parm dinner with a salad. Received a sandwich and no salad. Ordered a Caesar salad. It came with chicken. I'm vegetarian. They wouldn't fix the order and hung up on us. Terrible. Don't order from here. read more

Pizza was greasy and sloppy/ undercooked. Antipasto looks like a kindergartner sliced some huge wedges of provalone, threw in some salami and a few more mediocre ingredients and called it good to go. Place used to be great! They've gone WAYYYYY down hill. read more

Love this place! Great service and the owner is awesome! His food is absolutely delicious! His linguine and clams are off the charts! Amazing!!! read more

Love this place. Vinny is the best. The Sicilian pie ars serving to none.cooked perfectly with an amazing sauce. Fantastic dinners. Give the cheese steak and pizza steak try, delicious. read more

Screw this place. Owner behind the counter is straight up rude for no reason. My biggest problem is he charges a service fee on debit cards which is ILLEGAL in all 50 states. If you're cool with the owner being incredibly rude to his customers and for illegally charging extra money then by all means go here read more

The pizza is one of the best I've ever had. I went to New Jersey over the summer and I enjoyed having Giuseppe's. The service is always fast. read more

No pizza around Crust is perfect every time along with the sauce and just the ratio of cheese. Everything is always delicious fresh and perfect. Franchise dishes are always made and preferably and food is always nice and fresh read more

Place seems busy... Ordered a large chicken parm sub (dry as a bone) and a large cheesesteak (which was A+ awesome) as well as a pasta fagioli soup (which was just NOT pasta fagioli). Soup was indescribable outside of NOT being anywhere in the proximity of pasta fagioli haha, bland, tasted like flour... horrible read more

Giuseppe's Pizza & Restaurant - Pasta Fagioli ???? - Pizza Near Me - Hazlet, New Jersey

I usually have no problems. Today the wings I received were spicy chicken nuggets. I ate three and threw the rest out. They were awful. I won't be ordering from here again. read more

Giuseppe's Pizza & Restaurant - Chicken Buffalo Wings - Pizza Near Me - Hazlet, New Jersey

The food here is simply to die for! Go... Just do yourself a favor and go! I'm so happy I found you Giuseppes! read more

The costumer service was great. The food was delicious. I highly recommend this place.

Ordered and received the worst chicken parmigiana pizza I've ever had. The crust was think and soggy. The over bread chicken was dry and extremely salty. Not like the pizza I get in Bayonne. It was crazy expensive at $24. read more

So delicious! Hot and fresh! The crust is amazing!!!! Ive had almost all the places around but this one is too notch!! Crust stays fresh doesn't turn into a rock!!! Must try!!! Friendly service! read more

Waiter was great. Dropped our soda and the restocker dropped a whole case of iced tea. Pizza was still very good and the cheese was perfect. Thank you Mr.Waiter you deserve the tip we gave you read more

Giuseppe's Pizza & Restaurant - a half eaten pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hazlet, New Jersey

See all

I am reading some of these reviews and not a person who usually posts anything but i am going to weigh in. NJ pizza for a long term new yorker is always hard , But Giusesppes is by far the best quality we have in our area imho. Besides the good pizza the salads and pastas are always on point . 25 years in this area tried them all and this is where we order from hope that helps read more

Last week we ordered a Sicilian pizza from this place. New to the neighborhood several neighbors recommended Giuseppes as the go to place for a good meal. The pizza was inedible barely cooked and tasted like a loaf of bread with raw mozzarella on it. The person who answered the phone accused me of wanting a free pizza, I said no I just want an edible one. Stay away, stay far away. read more

I can only give it 2 stars. With pizza, for me, I like a well cooked pie. Meaning, the bottom isn't floppy. I like it when you try and fold it in half it snaps and a well cooked crust. With Giuseppe's, the bottom was browned at least unlike other places where it's all white ( that's when I ask them to put the pie back in for a few minutes) but no snap. The crust didn't have any browning at all which makes it too chewy. The sauce they use is too salty. The size of the pie seems to have gotten smaller and cost more just like Villa's in Holmdel plaza. A slice shouldn't be smaller then an average size hand. read more

It was Monday. 1/21/2019. Called up Guiseppes to order food at 9:30pm. The website states they are open until 10pm! Hell, even if I did not want to drive the half mile for the food; they should have honored the order so I could pick it up. That being said. It gets epic. I called up at 9:25PM EST and before I could even relay my order to them: I was greeted with a rude and basic employee that answered the phone with "Hey. This is Guiseppes. We are closed. No orders or deliveries." - to which I responded respectfully, "it's not even 9:30; and you're open until 10pm at least". To which she says "hold on. Let me get the manager". This was a waste of time. So I hung up. I called up a competitor that works up the block who answered my call with enthusiasm and not only delivered the food on time but also thanked me for choosing them. Guiseppes needs to fire the "customer service representative" they currently have hired because she single-handedly lost this company income for the evening because of her rude and unprofessional response when she answered the phone. Would I use Guiseppes's again? Not until they fire the rude employee and ensure that future orders will be adhered to; also. A $20 credit wouldn't hurt. Moral of this Yelp review is: make sure your employees don't treat your loyal customers like shit. Because pizza places are a "dime a dozen". I ordered from Tony's right after this phone call and they were able to provide quick, hot and excellent service. It must suck when you have shitty employees that degrade your brand you have worked so hard for. Enjoy. read more

I am not a picky pizza person but this was the worse pizza I have ever had. I ordered the grandma pie from this location which was disappointing. Do not recommend this place at all. This is not a pizzeria. read more

Very mediocre pizza. Extremely thin crust and barely any sauce that has no pronounced flavor.

For an Italian pizza and restaurant our party enjoys the cheesesteaks, which we find better than you can find in Philadelphia. Beef or chicken and you can add peppers, onions and mushrooms. The large is quite filling, but if you're not a big eater you will get the same satisfaction with the small. read more

Giuseppe's Pizza & Restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Hazlet, New Jersey

Ordered a half pepperoni half plain they gave me two halves of a house pie... wont ever go back there again read more

Giuseppe's Pizza & Restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Hazlet, New Jersey

See all

I've been coming here for over ten years. Today I noticed how great the dining room has been redone to where there are two doors to keep the cold air from coming into the dining room. There's also a separate dining area for sit in with a waiter and another area for quick bite to eat and take out. Sicilian slice is the best! read more

Giuseppe's Pizza & Restaurant - Very good sauce is great - Pizza Near Me - Hazlet, New Jersey

Awful customer service, ordered a slice and a cup of soup, slice was ready and getting cold, asked the guy to check on the soup he loses it starts yelling and gives me my money back. Never again read more

I ordered delivery from Doordash. Just got a large plain pie. From the time my order was processed, within 1 minute, the driver ahad picked it up 13 minutes later. We had suspicion that they just gave us a pie that was already made. When the pizza got here all of the cheese had slid to one side. Probably because of the driver, but it was small for a large pie. Almost makes me think they sent a medium unless their medium is just really small. It was a typical, solid NJ pizza. Would order again, but now know to order a little more based on the size read more

Just moved to Hazlet and trying to find my new pizza place. Unfortunately this place is not it. The pizza was beyond greasy ... overloaded with pepperoni as there were stacks of 4-5 slices be stacked. Also garlic knots were dry but flavor was decent. read more

In town for a baseball tournament, looking for intra game gluten free food and this place got the bill. My son had a very delicious gluten free pie with pepperoni and I had a large cheesesteak with onions. Cheesesteak came out piping hot, crispy fresh bread-yum!! This is your standard neighborhood pizza shop. This neighborhood is lucky!! read more

I called up to place a delivery order tonight for a simple order of sauteed spinach. I probably, if treated respectfully, would have also ordered a pasta dish which I know Giuseppe's does very well. But I called at about 9 pm and the woman who answered, answered, "Hi, Giuseppe's, we're closed." Never in my life have I ever been greeted with "we're closed" an hour before they close. Actually, if the business were really closed, why would anyone be answering the phones? It kind of sounds like someone just didn't want to work late. I worked a full day on Martin Luther King day and I was tired, hungry & just wanted to pay for a convenient spinach and pasta dinner. I know Guiseppe's is a great Italian restaurant, but this was weird and disrespectful. I would be embarrassed as a quality restaurant losing customers to a lazy and apathetic phone receptionist. read more

I am in Staten Island transplant... And this is the best pizza I have ever gotten in my whole life... I love you guys, from the girl that answered the phone to the guy that delivered the pizza... read more

See all

Can't believe this place only received 3 1/2 stars. I recently moved from Staten Island to Hazlet. Just happened to google a pizzeria in my area. Thought I would give it a shot and I'm glad I did. Excellent food from the seafood salad to the philly cheesesteak hero and great panini's. The prices are beyond excellent staff is so friendly and every time it's time to order a pizza still the go to place . Instead of 5 stars this place should be a 10 read more

This is an awesome pizza place! Their food is top notch which is why I gave 5 stars. The atmosphere is a pizza place, so not the place for a quiet romantic dinner. Stop on in and give it a try. read more

Desperately wanted a pizza after seeing a show at the PNC Arts Center. Most places had already closed but we called because there was no times listed to see if we could still order. A very nice man took my order and when I arrived at the pizza place they were doing the final cleaning for the night. I felt terrible that I had made their night that 15 minutes longer and apologized profusely. The employees were absolutely courteous and provided one the best pizzas I've had in a long while. Could not have asked for a better experience or a better pizza. read more

We are a Giuseppe's family. We will always order pizza or main entrees from them! Their pizza always tastes super awesome and I'm pretty much craving it right now. The only downside is that there is this one guy who takes our orders on the phone and he isn't very friendly. I've also found that their pizza is a twinge too salty for me occasionally. Even so, I love their Sicilian pie with meatballs! And they always have great choices when you pop in for a slice or two! Pizza is always delivered quickly and the food is always hot! read more

As someone from the Great Kills / Eltingville area....this is my go to place. From ordering on the phone, always pleasant and efficient, Delivery guys, always polite. Pizza is so so so good for the best price. Big advocate for this place as people around here tend to follow the heard. Pizza is never disappointing, along w many of the other items I have tried. Catering and all. 10/10 + 20 read more

Food is always hot, fresh and consistent. We always get pizzas and subs. Subs are huge and very filling. We've tried venturing out and giving other places a chance but we end up regretting it and always come back to Giuseppes. Best pizza around! read more

Local pizzeria that seems to be the area go to. Solid pizza and their grilled chicken salads are good also.

we ordered pizza from them and it came in at room temperature, the cheese literally wasn't melted. We had 4 people over and when we each took a bite we were talking about it being cold. We called the owner to inform him and he asked if we touched any of the slices and he would only give us a pie if we returned the one we had. But at that point we had already taken a bite. Ive ordered from them the last three years and the pizza isn't bad but he's very argumentative and combative when we called so I will never go back. read more

In the last year I was diagnosed with celiac disease and one food I miss so much is PIZZA. Although there are gluten free pizza options out there, I've always felt they aren't at all nearly comparable to the "real thing". Well, yesterday, I had Giuseppe's gluten free pizza and I feel like I died and went to heaven! IT WAS PERFECT AND DELICIOUS! The closest to the real thing that I've ever had ! Thank you for making my tummy happy yesterday!!! read more

Terrible customer service and very RUDE behavior at this place. The entire staff need to get trained on the basic principles of customer service and how to respond to customers requests with respect and a humble attitude. Expressing daily frustrations and taking it out on customers who are asking for simple requests in my experience is not the way to run a business and wont help it flourish for sure. The experience I faced, will take up too much of my valuable time to write, so I wanted to keep it short and simple for everyone. Will not be giving this place my business going forward as they just dont know the value of a customer and how to be polite and respectful in customer interaction. read more