One of the best regular slices in the area. Service quick and staff are nice. has seating for dining area. read more

This pizzeria is a local establishment located in a shopping center. The pizza is mediocre. It lacks cheese and the crust is thick. Usually it's overcooked and edges are slightly burnt. Most of the regular pies feel stale. They have a variety pies so there is a big choice. They also have soup, pasta dishes, wraps made to order. Usually this is a better choice. The pizzeria has tables in the back for seating. The employees are conscientious and if you stay to eat they will bring your order to the table. read more

I love this pizza spot for a quick bite! The pizza is crunchy and delicious, not sure you can ask for much more at a pizzeria! The staff behind the counter are super nice and bring our pizza out after it's been warmed. Plenty of seating in the back of the store. No frills but a great place to grab a quick lunch. P.s. for those that prefer a sweeter than savory sauce, this is your spot! read more

See all

**"I absolutely love Gigi's Pizza--hands down one of the best pizza places I've been going to for years. From the moment you walk in, they treat you so well and make you feel welcome. The customer service is always great, and the staff is friendly, attentive, and consistent every visit. The atmosphere is amazing--great music playing, a clean space, and I really love the updates they've made to the dining area. It feels modern, comfortable, and inviting, which makes you actually want to sit and enjoy your meal. Overall, Gigi's Pizza never disappoints. Great food, great service, and a great vibe. Highly recommend!"** read more

See all

I ordered a calzone and a sausage roll. The calzone was more ricotta with very little low quality mozzarella. Then this so called Sausage Roll if that's what the person making it thinks he makes these rolls, this roll had maybe a few paper thin slices of sausage not even then length of an Italian sausage ( who makes a sausage roll with paper thin slices of sausage)? The onions and peppers in it were so thinly sliced it was pathetic as well. I'm sorry my first time getting food at GiGi's but trust me I'll never go back, what they called a calzone and a sausage roll was and should be an insult. I should've taken a pic of both items but I was in a hurry to eat and believe me everyone reading this post would say where's the sausage. read more

I've eaten here a few times usually I get a plain slice which is good. Today I had the eggplant slice and it was off the charts. I enjoyed bit till no end. When we hit stop n shop again I will get that slice read more

Great that its right next to stop and shop. Picked up a couple of slices right after grocery shopping. Loved the chicken roll and plain pizza. been here a couple of times and it doesn't disappoint. I would come here more often if they offered Hawaiian pizza which they were pretty clear they would never do. The service is fast but you have to always ask for plates and the plates are so thin. They have a large selection in the front and the place is overall very clean and crispy. If you want to make it a park once shop then eat I would recommend coming here ! read more

They have a special posted on their window saying 2 slices and a drink. Went in, bought 2 slices and they wouldn't honor the special. Said I need to pay more. For $4 a slice there's much better than here . Also, a little friendliness goes a long way. Won't be back. read more

It was my first time coming to this pizza store. They have a wide selection of different pizza's. The staff is very nice it does get a little crowded but the staff moves quickly to get everyone's order in. The pizza is really good. The crust is nice and crispy, and the sauce tastes great. They have seats in the back if you decide to eat in. The staff is always wiping down the tables as soon as the customer leaves. I will definitely come back and try their other slices. read more

See all

The back of their pizza is black. This has me thinking that they don't clean their ovens.

Pizza was horrible. Called in and ordered a regular pie for pick up. Got it home and it was cold and old. You can tell it wasn't made fresh. So many better pizzerias in the area....not worth it. read more

My wife and I had a few errands to run and we wound up the Stop & Shop shopping center at lunchtime. We ran into GiGi's Pizza for a slice and drink. It's a small shop up front with some booths in the back, a comfortable location. They had a plethora of pizza in a small area up front on display. Honestly, anything you can think of was there. (Except the slice with Pineapple.) A friendly team member took our order and asked kindly to wait just a few minutes. It was just that... a few minutes for get our slices. Well cooked, tasty sauce and cheese with a crispy crust. One slice of Pizza and they passed all the tests. We go to that area often so I am looking to try some more of their items. I always like to experiment. KUDO's to the team at Gigi's Pizza read more

Gigis Pizza - Some good looking food here. - Pizza Near Me - New Hyde Park, New York

See all

I ordered for pick up which was quick and easy. Pizza was fresh and made well. No complaints. Service was kind when I walked in.

When you first walk in, it looks a little small, but as you go through the front of the store, the back area where you eat at is very spacious for two or a group service was quick and friendly a Mom and pop type pizzeria vibe. Great neighborhood pizzeria. If I may say the pizza was off the chain straight up delicious old school style Pizza crispy cheesy saucy with a thick crust style. They had the TV on there was some music playing. Looks like they were getting for dinner rush, but if you're in new Hyde Park area and a hungry or got the munchies stopping to Gigi's pizzeria you will not be disappointed! read more

See all

Great pizza when your full order is ready on time , had my pizza sitting for 20 mins while waiting for an order of wings and my food was cold. Only ordered wings for the buffalo sauce to dip my pizza , they said I couldn't just purchase a side of sauce so I had to order wings and they don't give any sauce... read more

Gigis Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New Hyde Park, New York

Came in today with my partner, sat at a table, the blonde haired waitress with the ponytail was a real bitch to us. Tells us with an attitude we should go to the counter to order pizza. Fuck this place. Wouldn't spend my money here. Be nicer to your customers. You're not giving away free fuckin food. read more

Traditional pizzeria inside, seating area to eat in located towards the back and pizza/ordering right when you walk in. 2 folks ahead of us when we came in, service was fine. Nothing terrible but nothing outstanding either. We got a vodka penne slice, grandma slice, chicken bacon ranch slice, and Buffalo chicken slice. The slices are large, which is cool. The flavor was unfortunately bland, I threw a good amount of garlic on my slices to get some level of flavor. The crust was thin and crunchy, which was nice. They charge a 3.99% fee to use a card, all together came to just over $20, which aligns with price of pizza nowadays. Probably won't be running back any time soon. read more

Gigis Pizza - Buffalo chicken and grandma slice. - Pizza Near Me - New Hyde Park, New York

Very quaint pizza shop, the food looks so picture worthy through the glass. Customer service was average, I asked if they could cut my slices in half because they are very large and they did. Very mediocre taste, I was quite disappointed by the penne vodka slice, I've had it at other places and have loved it but this one was super greasy and you couldn't taste the vodka sauce at all... it was just like having basic macaroni thrown on a slice of pizza. The plain slice was surprisingly the best of the three I tried but still nothing to rave about... read more

See all

My two year old was hungry and we took her here for a slice. The plain cheese was fresh and tasted perfect! They also cut it up into small slices for my daughter to pick up and eat. Wonderful relaxing experience! read more

Had an amazing margarita slice today at Gigi's, awesome crust, nice thickness to the slice, sweet tomato sauce and cooked to perfection. Not many places make a traditional slice margarita style, home run! Will be back and they said they deliver. Win win! Great service by the guys behind the counter as well! read more

Gigi's is the best local pizza spot! Flavorful, fresh, and friendly! I go there weekly with my family, and everyone is kind and helpful. Aside from making the best pizza around, they treat us like family. We won't go anywhere else. Get a side of sauce to dip your crust in; it's unique and delicious! read more

I got a buffalo chicken slice hmm this is the worst buffalo slice I've had .:. It was terrible the chicken taste nasty the buffalo sauce was sweet . Def will not come back . I was trying to force my self to eat it but I couldn't ... read more

Gigis Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New Hyde Park, New York

See all

Pizza isn't the greatest. Tastes sweet. I tried their regular pizza slice. It was sweet. I also tried a chicken parmigiana slice. It was too thick. read more

I've been ordering from this place for a long time and every week, I request the pizza sauce (or "pie sauce," as one employee told me to call it) on the side so I can dip the pizza crust. More often than not, they've gotten it wrong sending their pasta sauce and never offered to correct it. For the last two weeks, however, they finally got it right--so I assumed the issue was resolved. Tonight, I called and specifically asked for the pie sauce, using the exact term I was told to use. The girl on the phone yessed me to death, but when my order arrived, it was the wrong sauce again. When I called to clarify, she immediately had an attitude, sighed while I was speaking, and eventually got the manager, who then claimed to be the owner. He told me they "don't do the pie sauce" because people could copy their recipe--something I've never heard in all the years I've been ordering. I pointed out that I've been given the sauce before, but he insisted that was a mistake and dismissed my concerns. On top of that, no other pizzeria pulls this nonsense. Every other place will give you a side of pizza sauce if you ask--especially with garlic knots. It's not some special sauce, it's just a marinara, the same sauce they use on their pizzas. That's like saying I'm not going to sell someone my chocolate chip cookies because they can copy my recipe, lol. It's absurd! Beyond the inconsistent delivery service, the customer service is terrible. No apology, no accountability--just excuses and attitude. If they had simply told me from the start that they don't give out the sauce, I wouldn't have wasted my time or money continuing to request it and order it. But charging me extra, giving me the wrong sauce, and then acting like I'm the problem? That's unacceptable. The only good thing about this place is the Friday night delivery guy--he's awesome. Too bad the rest of the staff doesn't have the same attitude. The so called "owner" was happy to lose a customer and I'm thrilled to oblige! Do better! Have you read your reviews?! read more

This pizzeria has great pizza. The slices are huge. The bathrooms are clean. The people are very nice. They have good prices two slices and a soda 675. We will be back. read more

I ordered a take out, Penne alla vodka. This was my first time ordering from here. I am not sure if all the dishes are made with no salt or the one I ordered, literally no salt. Not sure if I would order again from here. read more

I can't say enough good things about this pizza spot! From the moment I walked in, the welcoming atmosphere and the aroma of freshly baked pizza had me hooked. The pizza is absolutely incredible--perfectly crispy crust, rich and flavorful sauce, and toppings that taste fresh and high-quality. I tried the buffalo pizza and it was hands-down one of the best I've ever had. The cheese was melted to perfection, with just the right amount of stretch! read more

I have tried a few dishes from here and they have all been amazing. So choose whatever sounds good and get it. They renovated inside and it looks amazing. Very modern and clean. Very good service as well. Best pizzeria in town !!! read more

See all

Ordered a small Grandma Pie from GiGi's and it was pretty good, not too salty or any strong oregano taste. Like everything these days, price was a little on the high side, $20 plus tax for 8 (thankfully) large slices. The cashier taking my order and cook made no errors with my order, I didn't wait too long and they were a little busy, too. Sauce is slightly sweet and true Italian tradition, perfectly dotting the pizza with just enough cheese on top. The pizza was cooked perfectly on the bottom and wasn't greasy or soggy. Wish the crust had a little more of a bubbly rise to it, maybe if they can make it a bit lighter and less dense, but I'm also picky about my Italian food. read more

We came here for a quick bite on a Friday night. Grandma slices were a way to go and the spinach pie was also a good size. This is a place to go to for a quick bite but wouldn't go here if I had a choice. Place is in a good location but faces competition with Panera. read more

Gigis Pizza - Spinach pie and Slice Grandma Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New Hyde Park, New York

One of my favorite places for pizza and pasta! The server is amazing and professional! The place does get busy during dinner hours! read more

Gigis Pizza - a pizza with a slice taken out of it - Pizza Near Me - New Hyde Park, New York

I usually don't put up bad reviews but I've only walked into this place two times and unfortunately was met with terrible customer service each time. Pizza was average with nothing to write home about. Definitely will not be giving it a third chance, especially with so many other better options in the area. read more

We used to go here for our pizza years ago. I happened to be at stop and shop, so I figured i would go in and grab a slice or two. I'm so glad I did. The pizza is just as good as I remember, and the people there were so super nice! They have made a regular customer out of me again. read more

Gigis Pizza - Garlic knots - Pizza Near Me - New Hyde Park, New York

See all

Prices keeps changing Everytime I go to pay. Spoke with the owner.not too concerned.he has a poor attitude. In this climate, he should be grateful of every customer My advice...GO SOMEWHERE ELSE read more

I used to come here before (sit-down dining) but the review for today is for their delivery service. A team member from my church group placed a lunch order for a celebration. From the beginning, I could hear trouble starting in placing the order especially on the part that one of the group member ordered a salad pizza- no cheese. Sounded that the person got confused on how she wanted it. Clearly that there was something going on at their place as we need to call them twice after the 40 mins window she told us. My team mate has ordered from them before so she was not expecting any delay to have the food deliver to our current location. She even mentioned to call her when the delivery man arrived and she was willing to come out. Hour and 10 min has passed before we were served. I enjoyed my calamari and bread though - big serving for a single order and the pricing is standard.The others seemed happy with their own order. No complaint with the food except that we got hungry. I am going to give them another chance- I 'll dine in and hopefully get a better review that they deserve. read more

Gigis Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New Hyde Park, New York

Came here a few weeks ago to get dinner with a friend. Seems like a pretty standard pizza place; selection of slices wasn't the greatest but it was fine. We got our slices and sat in the back, where there was a decent amount of space. It's not the nicest seating area and standard pizza places on Long Island have pretty clean and spacious seating areas these days, so that could be better. I got a BBQ chicken slice and a Sicilian slice. The BBQ chicken slice and a coke was $6.50 and the Sicilian slice was $3 if I remember correctly. Both slices were actually very good. The flavor on the BBQ chicken slice was somewhat tangy and the chicken was adequetely moist. Very tasty. The Sicilian slice was good too; not sure how to describe it but the flavor was on point. Both slices were pretty sizable as well, which is a must if I'm going to give out 4 stars (value is huge on my criteria for good places). Solid 4 star rating for Gigi's. I'm not in New Hyde Park often but have noted this place when I'm in the area. read more

Gigis Pizza - BBQ Chicken Slice - Pizza Near Me - New Hyde Park, New York

See all

Pretty reliable place. The credit card machine doesn't always work so sometimes cash is required. The food is good. Pizza always taste good. read more

Gigis Pizza - IG: Tourguidebuddz - Pizza Near Me - New Hyde Park, New York

See all

Ordered Sicilian Pizza here and it was so delicious I had to grab my phone take a picture and write this review. Hands down the best pizza ever! I like the location too for dine in its very cozy. Service is fast. So delicious. Tried also the carrot cake and it's 10/10. THIS PLACE IS GREAT! TRY IT! read more

Gigis Pizza - Carrot Cake - Pizza Near Me - New Hyde Park, New York

See all

I love pizza but this place didn't really have it. They did have a good variety of specialty pizzas but the pizza tasted very bland. It smells good from the outside but the sauce didn't have much flavor. I ordered a plain slice and though the texture was there (the slight crunch in the crust and the hot melted cheese) I tasted nothing and no I don't have covid. My boyfriend didn't like the flavor of the sauce either, he said it was sweet. He however had a different slice than I did. I forgot what he ate but it was a thicker crust with chicken on it (not a grandma or Sicilian). I also ordered a beef patty with cheese. The cheese was melted but the patty was room temperature, I didn't like that. I like my food hot. And also when I first walked in, I asked for the minimum for card and they stated their card machine doesn't work. So I went to an ATM, when I returned to the store they had an ATM machine in there.... thanks guys. read more

Gigis Pizza - Beef Patty with Cheese - Pizza Near Me - New Hyde Park, New York

This place has the BEST tasting spinach rolls EVER! They also have great tasting pizza as well! They're quick at making the food, but the delivery is veryyy slow... so you're better off picking up the food yourself if you're super hungry, otherwise order in advanced! The shop itself is small, so I personally wouldn't stay to eat there, but you CAN if you want! read more