Their pizza is some of the best I've ever had - I crave their pizza once I leave Corolla. My…read morefavorite pizza of theirs is definitely the "works" pizza, but their cheese, pepperoni, and margherita pizza were all the bomb. Big size, hot and fresh, lots of ooey gooey sauce and toppings. Suchhhh good pizza, I highly recommend! The only downside was ordering was difficult during high season. They were so busy they did not answer the phone. We had to go order in person and then it took an hour wait for 5 large pizzas.

Look out OBX, the king of pizza is here! Well worth the wait and service was top notch. Love the…read morestatue of the Italian chef outside. The inside is your typical pizza joint. Classic pictures on the wall. My wife is always in search of a good white pizza. You would be amazed at often they miss the mark. Not Corolla Pizza & Deli. Y'all hit it out of the park! Fresh ingredients, delicious blend of mozzarella & ricotta cheeses with fresh garlic and spices. Crust was delicious. The other pizza we ordered was a cheese with pepperoni. The sauce was amazing and cupping was perfect. Everyone loved both pizza's. Worth the drive from Duck. Next time we will be in Nags Head and yes, we will make the drive. Keep on making great pizza!!!!

There are many reasons I would love to live in Outer Banks, and Lighthouse Pizza is definitely one…read moreof them! The pizza is delicious, and the service is so welcoming and kind! We will be back before we go home!

We grabbed several pizzas from Lighthouse on our first night of our vacation in Corolla (Outer…read moreBanks). The place is small and really seemed best for take out. They were really hopping on a Saturday in July. We got cheese, pepperoni, meat lovers, and some garlic cheese bread. The crust is on the thinner side and the pizza had a ton of flavor. Definitely the pizza I like. Everyone was friendly.

Pizza and beer was great. Awesome concept with the Great Wall of beer. Service was great as well…read moreespecially during the off season it can be tough

Really enjoyed pizzas. Fun environment with games for kids and right next to ice cream shop. I…read moredidn't partake in beer wall but those who did thought it was fun and tasty.

After a 7 hour drive, we were looking for a restaurant for dinner after 8:30 pm on a Thursday…read morenight. The only open sign was at Lucky's. As we walked in, we realized the "open" sign had just been turned off. The young man inside was cleaning but welcomed us in and said he'd be happy to make us a pizza. In about 10 minutes we had a delicious pie! The sauce is wonderful. I would definitely order pizza from Lucky's the next time I'm in Corolla. Great oizza and kind staff.

If you hate pizza, order here. The only lucky bit of this…read moreplace was the free grated cheese packets.

To start, very pleasant greeting by Shelby. Main dining room was full but she quickly prepared a…read morehigh top near the bar. She said it would be 5 minutes but it was more like 3 and the table was ready. John explained the specials and took our order. Drinks came promptly and the food came out in a few minutes and was very good. A wonderful experience and good food.

Went there for dinner on May 6, 2026. Very nicely decorated place. Now the overrated part. No bread…read morefor the table, first issue. I had the pasta limone and so did my sister. It was so darn lemony, we could hardly eat it. The shrimp were done well, but the pasta was so puckeringly lemony that it was impossible to enjoy. My sil agreed. They are doing this great dish wrong.

A tale as old as time..rolled into Corolla on a Sat and didn't feel like cooking for night one. I…read morecalled another pizza place (closer to our house) and they snickered and said that it would be a 2hr 45min wait for any order.. before breaking out the cooking stuff we tried Cosmos. They weren't open. The phone message said they were closed prepping for dinner and opened at 5pm, but that you could preorder online..so at 4:45 I ordered 6 large pies and the pick up time was 5:15. I sent my husband and told him to expect to sit for awhile...the pizzas were EARLY. Overall not my favorite pizza I like more sauce, cheese/toppings. Definitely was not greasy though! For the lightening fast turnaround time you cannot beat it!

We stopped for lunch after visiting Corolla's historic village and climbing Currituck Lighthouse…read more We were in a time crunch and had limited window for lunch (as we were headed to a horse tour). Hostess (bartender?) was friendly, patient, attentive and understanding of our circumstances. Realizing my kids wanted pizza, she advised they could split pizza to accommodate both preferences. Husband and I split a meatball sandwich (bread was soft yet crusty and slightly larger than meatballs--kept meatballs from popping out--and sandwich was tasty). Food came out fast, hot and fresh, although sandwich came out well before pizza (we were in a time crunch so not complaining!). Staff was personable and friendly. Atmosphere was casual with a bar and 2 dining areas. May want to call ahead for large parties as space is limited and verify hours as it's the off season.

Awesome pizza! Quick turn around! Super friendly staff and clean environment. I done a pick up…read moreorder.

Pizzazz Pizza impressed us with its stellar service and delicious pies. We ordered three large…read morepizzas--cheese and pepperoni--and were delighted by the quick, friendly service; our pizzas were ready in just 30 minutes. The staff went the extra mile, providing plates and napkins, which made our meal even more enjoyable without the dishwashing haha. The pizzas themselves were fantastic--cheesy, flavorful, and generously topped. With great value for the price, it's no wonder our tummies were left happy and full. A perfect choice for a satisfying meal! We cant wait to do our trip out there again and stop by for some pizza.

Best pizza around!!!!! Only wish they had delivery service and some specials every weekread more

Wiseguys is always good friendly service and great food i recommend the meatball sub and cheese…read moresticks Great local spot

Surprisingly stumbled onto this place with good food and service! Plenty of food options available.read more

Tried this nice place one warm evening. We sat on the patio, lower level, with our dog and they…read morebrought the dog a bowl of cold water. Nice. Food is good. Service is good. We'd go back.

10/10 experience here at The Paper Canoe. We seriously didn't have a bad dish here, everything was…read moreout of this world. Our server really went above and beyond knowing that we had an allergy at the table and talked through all the options to ensure we were safe and accommodated. My dirty martini was made with just the right amount of olive juice and blue cheese olives. My steak came out cooked perfectly rare the way I like it. The soft shell crab special was also out of this world. For appetizers we had the crab dip which was creamy and delicious. Ambiance wise it's pretty fancy in here - the bar was packed for sunset time which makes sense because the view here is spectacular. If you're looking for an amazing meal in the area with staff that'll take great care of you, come to The Paper Canoe.

Delicious food! Lovely room and cool view, service was underwhelming…read more We had good cocktails and then we had the duck egg rolls to start which were savory and delicious, hubby had shrimp and grits which he said were amazing... I had the catch of the day: pompano which was subtle and complex and quite simply delicious. Too bad the service was just so-so, perfunctory ... (like the waiter had been there and done that a million times -- ) ... otherwise an excellent meal and experience.