I have to admit, I've got a soft spot for places like George's on Park Avenue in Winter Park--it's got that effortless charm...The kind where the atmosphere wraps around you, the location couldn't be more ideal for a lazy morning stroll, and the food is amazing....it hits the mark without trying too hard. But, and here's where it gets a tricky, service can make or break a place, especially one with so much going for it. I've seen enough eateries come and go on Park Avenue to know that a stumble there is like forgetting the punchline in a joke--everything else falls flat. Take my visit, for instance. Rolled in around 8:25 a.m., figuring since they open at 8, the breakfast buffet would be all set up and steaming. Nope. Not quite. Everyone has those mornings...So I hung back the recommended 20 minutes, no big deal, and then dove in. Asked for a coffee first--simple enough. Loaded up on those eggs (amazingly fluffy, by the way), some well cooked bacon that snapped just right, creamy grits, fresh fruit, and yeah, I grabbed a pastry. It all tasted spot on, like they'd nailed the basics with a quiet confidence. But then... the coffee arrived, and poof, my server vanished into thin air. No pop-bys to see if I needed a top-off or, heaven forbid, a napkin. Zero. It was almost comical, in a sad sort of way, like being the last kid picked for dodgeball. I finished up, feeling oddly abandoned, and headed to cash out. Joined by another patron, we stood there at the register, watching the chef and staff buzz around like they were in a different dimension. Felt eternal, but probably just five minutes. Not the vibe you want, especially when the food's begging for a return visit. Look, perhaps it's just an off day, or maybe training could use a nudge--nothing major, but fix that, and George's could be the go-to I'd enthusiastically tell my friends. For now, though? I'd hesitate. It's got potential, sure, but service like that leaves you wondering if the next time will be any different. read more

George's Cafe - Just peeking... - Bakeries Near Me - Winter Park, Florida

We came for lunch on our anniversary because Brandywine's (the former cafe here) was a place we came while dating. George's Catering also did our daughter's wedding reception, which was outstanding. But today? Not so much. It was a cold day so we came for the homemade chili. I got the cup and my husband got the bowl. We shared the 1933 Salad because it sounded delicious. My cup of chili came out cold! When I sent it back it was reheated to warm--not hot. I finished my cup before my husband's bowl was served. It came with fresh bread but we had to ask for butter. The chili was mediocre at best. When the salad arrived it was piled with a good portion of meats and cheese, a lot of romaine, two olives and two small tomatoes. The dressing was great! The man working in the kitchen seemed terribly confused--not knowing a cup from a bowl. The cookies George is known for were no where to be seen, just a sign in the empty case that said, "peanut butter cookies". I don't know if this was an off day for them, but at 12:00 p.m. there were only three customers, strange for Park Avenue. Not sure if we'll return. read more

See all

George is a great guy and his employees are wonderful. Very accommodating. Everything on the menu is outstanding. Best Havana ever. The cookies and pastries are delicious. I could not get him to share his recipes however. You must try one of everything. My favorite place. I take all of my friends. Go early. It fills up fast. Wish he would open another cafe in Port Orange. Love the quaintness and decorations as well. A must go place. Thank you George. read more

After visiting the Morse Museum, I walked over to George's Cafe for lunch. The interior was very cozy and eclectic. The girl working at the front counter was very nice and helpful when ordering. I ordered the chicken salad sandwich with the house made potato chips. The sandwich was very good and a plentiful serving of chicken salad. The house made potato chips were SO GOOD. You must order those as a side! There is a soda machine to help yourself when it comes to drinks. My food only took a short amount of time to come out. After lunch, I saw cookies come out. I ordered the chocolate chip and oatmeal cookies. The oatmeal was so good with the icing on top. The chocolate chip had a ton of chocolate chips. I would recommend just having another staff member up front helping clear tables and serve because there was only one employee doing all these jobs. read more

See all

Omg absolutely best salads on Park Ave! We had the beet salad and brie apple salad Absolutely delicious and generous portions! Highly recommend this cozy cute cafe!! Right by the museum. read more

George's Cafe - Brie and Apple salad - Bakeries Near Me - Winter Park, Florida

3-parking 10-service 8-ambiance 7- food I stopped in on a whim while on my way to a nail appointment. The place reminds me of a cafe you'd see in a hallmark movie or Stars Hallow. I got a homemade lemonade and a cookie to go then came back and got the puddsy to go - In house fresh roasted turkey breast, Applewood bacon, muenster cheese, homemade sun dried tomato dressing, served on a fresh baked French Baguette. Everything was tasty and I want to come back and have the burger while enjoying the surroundings. They have plenty of indoor & outdoor seating. Definitely worth the circling for a parking spot. read more

George's Cafe - Bakeries Near Me - Winter Park, Florida

I've been wanting to visit this place for a while, so my husband and I finally stopped by to order something to go. We got the chicken salad sandwich, and I believe it was Douglas who helped us--he was kind enough to offer us a cookie to try after I mentioned I've heard great things about them. It did not disappoint! Everything was delicious, and I'll definitely be coming back for more. ( apologies if I got the name wrong but whoever it was that helped us, was so kind!! ) read more

George's Cafe - The inside - Bakeries Near Me - Winter Park, Florida

George's on Park Avenue This one's a bummer for me. As a new Winter Park resident, I really wanted this to be my neighborhood sandwich spot. I gave it many chances, but the experience just kept letting me down. From my very first visit, service felt off -- including a cashier making a rude comment about "old, white-haired men paying with cash"! Sometimes the food is good, sometimes it feels rushed and careless. My most recent sandwich was over-toasted, barely filled, and missing the side it was supposed to come with. Other visits have been fine -- which honestly makes the bad ones more frustrating. It's also common to find out items aren't available because they're reserved for catering, and the dining area often feels neglected with uncleared tables. I wanted to like George's, but after multiple inconsistent experiences, I'm just disappointed and done giving it chances. read more

George's Cafe is a great stop on trendy Park Avenue in Winter Park, Florida. It has a pleasant and comfortable ambiance. It is a nice place to grab a meal and the staff was friendly and professional and the food was very good. They have a great brunch and I woukd definitely recommend stopping by for a great brunch. All in all, this was a very positive experience and I will give it five stars. read more

George's Cafe - Bakeries Near Me - Winter Park, Florida

See all

I went on a Sunday afternoon. There was one employee working the front counter. There was a sudden rush of people right after I arrived. She did a good job keeping things moving, but she definitely could have used help. I ordered a chicken salad sandwich on a croissant with a side of potato salad. Both were kind of plain to me and not the most flavorful. The portions were fairly generous. I had enough to eat, but I was a tad underwhelmed. read more

George's Cafe - Homemade Chicken Salad sandwich - Bakeries Near Me - Winter Park, Florida

The food was fine. We ordered French dip, Brie and apple salad, and a chicken sandwich. Nothing in particular to write home about, the French dip was a bit salty, and the au jus is served on top of the sandwich, so the bread is super soggy. The Brie and apple salad was large and had lots of fruit, which was good for my kids to snack on while they waited for their chicken sandwich. The service is so odd though - we walked in, and went to the counter and literally 3 different staff members walked by without greeting us, looking at us or asking if we were ready to order. The last few times we've come it's been the same situation, it's very off putting. read more

Had an excellent lunch and respite from the heat. It was the perfect laid back atmosphere to spend time with old friends. No crowds and no wait since it's a block north of most of the busyness of Park Ave. Highly recommended. All of our sandwiches and salads were excellent and good portions too. There were several regulars it seemed sitting at the 'bar'. We walked in at prime lunch hour and got two four top tables without a wait. It's counter ordering the. They bring it to your table. Cozy Americana memorabilia including The Beatles, and an old piano that my daughter indulged the customers with some ragtime. Definitely worth the short walk, and very convenient to the Morris Museum and the Catholic Church. Will be back. read more

See all

Cute restaurant! Very comfortable atmosphere. The food was amazing!! Chicken salad was the best I ever had. The chicken soup had small homemade noodles. The cookies are delicious. The staff was so friendly and helpful. I've been going a few days a week. I just love the food! Thank you Chef George!! read more

Went today during the art festival. Service is poor. We walked in at lunch time and waited about 15 minutes before staff said anything to us. 3 different servers walked by us without saying anything to us. After 15 minutes, a server finally asked if we were ready to order. I asked if we could order cookies and she gave me a rude look and said "we don't have cookies". Their sign literally says "cookies and catering" and tons of cookie options on their menu. She didn't elaborate and kept staring at me smugly. I said thank you and left. While we waited the 15 minutes I overheard a server say that two tables were missing items and the table next to me was also complaining about how they forgot their grilled cheese. Food for thought. Cute seating outside but the poor service is enough for me to not come back. read more

Beautiful salads. Best in town! Yummy breads. Large portions. My order was easily enough for two people, or a to go box. So fresh! Comfortable seating and clean. Lovely garden seating if it's nice outside. The ONLY bad thing I can say is minor, and that is that sometimes it's hard to find parking on the same block. So be prepared to walk a short while. read more

George's Cafe - Garden salad, homemade Basalmic dressing, sourdough bread, a side of tuna salad and a house made pickle. - Bakeries Near Me - Winter Park, Florida

Everything was great. Good large sandwiches. Generous salads. And the best amazing cookies.

Outstanding! The beet and goat cheese salad was generously sized and delicious. Loved the white chocolate and macadamia nut cookie. It was like eating 4 cookies. Great to share with my friends after lunch. Lovely outdoor seating on a perfect weather day. I would definitely return. I ordered water and they had sparkling water which was a pleasant surprise. read more

shrimp and grits, waffles, and chicken, best bacon I've ever ever had sausage,fruit, unbelievable ! very simple but elegant buffet.$15 per person. What a great fine. read more

George's Cafe - Bar - Bakeries Near Me - Winter Park, Florida

Food and service was excellent. Had a turkey breast sandwich which was really good. Very accommodating on tradeouts within the menu. Outside tables are very nice highly recommend read more

We ordered take-out and I was pleasantly surprised at how good it was even after it was transported and sat for a bit. The portions they give you are huge. I ordered a Turkey sandwich and each half has three thick chunks of turkey. And I'm not talking deli turkey. This is fresh sliced roasted turkey. It reminded me of what I'd eat for Thanksgiving. So juicy. While I enjoyed the amount of turkey and the flavor for the most part, I wasn't blown away. Half my sandwich was missing its bread which was a bit weird. It needed something more, too, like a spread or at least more than one packet of Mayo since the sandwich was so packed full. My sandwich came with two sides so I chose the fresh fruit and broccoli salad. The fruit was lovely, a good combination of so many fresh fruits, and plenty of it. One of the better mixed fruits I've had. The broccoli salad was just ok. It was a bit dry and flavorless for me. Let's talk about the cookies. Holy cow, they are so big and packed full of stuff. I ordered the white chocolate macadamia nut but instead was given the peanut butter. Kind of a disappointment since the white chocolate kind are my favorite. I'm not usually a fan of peanut butter cookies at all but let me tell you... this was the BEST peanut butter cookie I've ever had!! It wasn't just peanut butter flavored. There were chunks of peanuts and honey roasted peanuts and gooey honey and peanut buttery pieces. It was mouth watering. Definitely enough for two servings but I ate it all in one. I'd like to actually dine in soon and try something else because it truly seems like quality food. read more

See all

Christmas nightmare. Ordered a simple breakfast and Tom decides in his wisdom to put my breakfast in front of another person already eating the buffet items. Client stupidly says nothin. Now Tom had a 1 in 3 chance of getting this right if his brain was in the proper gear. Table of ladies almost done. Guy eating buffet. Or me. The guy with only coffee and the guy who he saw order the breakfast. Brainiac. My server was blamed wrongly and George sadly should have stepped up to make it right. But I think he just went back to eat some more cookies. Bad example. This was my treat to myself after being sick for days and what a nightmare. Thanks George. Could have been made right. My poor server needs to get a job somewhere that cares about running a business read more

Everything was awful. Don't let the price and the word "buffet" fool you Don't advertise buffet with just a few choices all of which were COLD. Drinks took forever. Not worth the $15. No ketchup for potatoes How does a restaurant not go buy some if not delivered because of storm. Barely ate a bite. We were 3. What a waste of money Can't order off menu until 11 but try the many other options Winter Park has to offer. Wish I could get my $ back. read more

I decided to stop by here out of whim while passing by over the weekend, the sandwiches and salad were surprisingly large, you definitely could get two meals out of each item. I was not expecting it to be counter service, and honestly if I had known it was before arriving I probably would have went somewhere else, but that is just a personal preference of mine, so no fault to them. We had the puddsey, havana, and 1933 salad, all of the items were tasty. I will note that the turkey sandwich was on the dry side, adding brown mustard was a must, I would not have enjoyed the sandwich without it. Also added on was a cup of the soup of the day (cream of chicken), and a cup of chili. The soup was originally sent out as a chili, which they quickly fixed once mentioned. Both the soup and the chili were honestly not good at all. The chili arrived cold, and not just room temp, but actually cold to the touch, and it did not taste good. The soup, while hot, tasted bland and only of carrot. The "service" that we received was decent-ish, the staff was friendly, but they tended to all speak over one another and were rather disorganized. With all that being said, I would gladly return for another sandwich, or maybe to try out some breakfast items. read more

See all

I ordered a 1933 salad with no ham. The girl brings out the salad with ham, I told her no ham, she walked in the restaurant and came right back out with the same plate with the ham. I took it in and they brought me out a salad with "almost" no ham. All they did was pick it off not knowing if I may have an allergic reaction. To their credit, they did get most of it off but, there was a reason I ordered no ham. My husband ordered the corn beef and he liked his very much so they get 3 stars. read more

George's Cafe - Ham - Bakeries Near Me - Winter Park, Florida

Breakfast brunch was awful. Cold food. Empty chafing dishes and flavorless. I would not recommend.

Very disappointed. We ordered a cold ham and cheese sandwich, a blt, a goat cheese sandwich, chili and a French dip. Took 40 minutes to get some of our food and it all came out wrong. If I could give it 0 stars I would. My salad was supposed to have pine nuts on it. They brought it with none. When I asked they said they're out of pine nuts so they put onions on it instead. It also came with no dressing and I had to ask for dressing. My daughter got the ham and cheese on rye bread. My other daughter got the blt with sour dough. The first thing we got was a plate of rye bread, provolone cheese and bacon. Not sure who that was intended for. It took twice to remind them to bring ham. It took another 5 requests and 3 plates of wrong bread to get sour dough. My husband's French dip was cold and came out 15 minutes after the rest of our food. Keep in mind on the menu it was listed as "hot sandwiches." His chili came out wrong as well. It was supposed to have cheddar and bacon on top. Instead it came out with sour cream and chives. It also came out cold. This place should go out of business. I don't know how they could serve food like this. We paid $74 for our incorrect cold meal. And the only consolation they offered were two cookies for our kids. Very disappointing. read more

Was really looking forward to this place for breakfast on Saturday. We chose it due to good reviews and its proximity to the museum just a few steps away. We walked in about 8:15am and despite the website, yelp and even the front door listing 8am, the lady behind the counter informed us they didn't open until 8:30. . No problem... We came back at 8:40, asked about the breakfast menu and she told us the only thing available was the buffet but that it wasn't set up yet. (So nothing is available??) Apparently they were working on a catering order and couldn't be bothered with customers. So I asked if they could make a latte. She said they had drip coffee and cappuccino but couldn't make a latte. (Isn't a latte pretty much a cappuccino with more milk???) Enough said, we went somewhere else. I've since heard from several locals that this is a good choice if you want something catered but a crap shoot if you're looking to sit down and enjoy a meal. read more

We were heading down to the Winter Park library but decided to grab lunch first. My wife had been wanting to check out George's Cafe and thus, we found ourselves there. It wasn't busy and we ordered our food. The location and interior was really nice and I liked the decorations. The food was good, and large portions. I think that's the one thing I wish I had known ahead of time was how big the portions are. As a family of 5, we spent quite a bit there So, my recommendation if you go - split a sandwich. There's plenty to tide each person over. The staff there was wonderful and super kind to our kids and I think we will go back again. read more

I had seen a local news piece bragging about the Philly here, so we took our family for lunch and got there around 1:00 and when we started to order, the cashier basically slowly tells us that they are out of about half the items on the menu, including the Philly. I don't know why they couldn't have just written a quick sign to put on the door letting everyone know they were out of almost everything. So my wife and I ordered a couple of sandwiches with some chips, that were okay, and we ordered a grilled cheese with chips for our girls. Our sandwiches came out, and a few minutes after the waitress asked if we were missing anything. We said the grilled cheese. So she walks back to the kitchen and asks the cook about it, and we literally hear him say "Oh sh*t!" So they quickly cooked one up and brought it out without the chips to go with it. The server tells us that they had now run out of chips too, but were quickly cooking more. Ok, so we sat for another 15 minutes and no chips ever came out, so we just left. I know that busy restaurants run out of things sometimes, but the way that this was handled made me wish that I could have rescinded my tip. read more

Food quality very good. Best ingredients. Had Abigail sandwich (variation of Rueben) very generous on the Ingrediants.Very tasty. The potato salad was light and lively!! Nice texture. Same with the. Homemade chocolate chip cookies. Light and airey Delicious! read more

Stopped in for lunch and tried the Cuban sandwich, fries and fresh fruit. The Cuban was solid and the fries were more like potato wedges, but they were good too. The service was fast and friendly. We even ended up having a nice discussion about their cookies and sampling a few of the staffs' favorites and discussing the intricacies of of the various flavor options. ******** My Standardized Yelp Ratings 5 stars - This is for a place that I see as one of the best at what they do (steaks, sandwiches, BBQ, seafood, etc). 5s are for places I've been several times (typically) at least and never had an "off" experience. The food quality, service, price and atmosphere are all going to meet or exceed expectations. 4 stars - This is for a place that is good, I would drive a little out of the way to go, and the food and service is good, but maybe not amazing. Also for me, this could also be a great place that serves Pepsi products - automatic 1 star loss - bad management decision. 3 stars - This is for a place that I view as standard. Nothing special, nothing lousy, not a place you'd avoid like the plague, but a place that is not one you really look forward to either. 2 stars - This is for a place that had something go wrong or something perpetually wrong. The food and or service is likely consistently suspect here (they probably serve Pepsi too). 1 star - I can't see wasting time writing a review on a place that gets a 1 star. This is for a place that should consider closing. read more

George's Cafe - Cuban sandwich, fries, fruit cup - Bakeries Near Me - Winter Park, Florida

Great. Just love his food. He does from the heart!!! I have been their 5 x's and every time it is better and bigger.

I have made two visits to this Winter Park mainstay, one lunch and one brunch, and both were excellent. I am a fan of solid bakeries offering quality meals and George's does just that. For lunch we had a Roasted Turkey Melt with bacon accompanied by the best potato salad if I have had since leaving NY German Delis behind me. It was both chunky and creamy and well seasoned. They have hand crafted sodas and are making some awesome chocolate chunk cookies. On Saturdays & Sundays, they are doing an early brunch buffet (8am - 11:30am) for only $17, which was even better. Benedicts, Shrimp & Grits, quiche, fresh pastries, eggs, breakfast meats, fruits and freshly made pastries, with coffee and juice included. Friendly service and a hometown vibe. Put this place on your brunch list afterwards, stroll the shops of Park Avenue. Taste **** Quality/Freshness ***** Presentation/Uniqueness **** Service ***** Atmosphere ***** Bar Cleanliness ***** Price $$ read more

See all

Cookies are fantastic place is quaint and eclectic but the food is great check menu daily because items change

Had a business lunch with an acquaintance. The restaurant was fairly busy. You could tell the cashier was training. I ordered a turkey sandwich on sourdough toast. I repeated the "toast" 3 times b/c I could tell the young man was perplexed? Well, the bread came cold. I told the waitress and she commented that the cashier is new and he's learning things? Didn't offer to toast my sourdough. Do not recommend. Service for Park Ave is substandard. read more

Looking for a solid lunch spot! They Have a solid BLT! And the chili game is out of this planet! And it's walking distance on park ave winter park, FL read more

Have been a huge fan of George's Cafe for a number of years. My husband and I visited the Lee Road location regularly and got over to the new Park Avenue location this past weekend. The food is still amazing and it still has the same colorful and quirky atmosphere that I love. You really can't go wrong no matter what you order. The quality and quantity of the food are second to none and the cookies are the best you will ever eat in your life! We recently George's cater a dinner for six at our home. Our guests all raved that it was one of these meals they ever had. George's staff are friendly and professional. They arrived in plenty of time to set up, prepare and serve our meal, and did an excellent job cleaning up afterwards. I cannot recommend George's highly enough. read more

George's Cafe - a chocolate cake with strawberries on top - Bakeries Near Me - Winter Park, Florida

See all

The food was yummy and big portions. The service was good. The peanut butter cookies are excellent. The inside decor is cool.

Oh my goodness!!!! What a HIDDEN GEM! We just finished the Winter Park scenic boat tour (running since 1938!!!) and stopped here (accidentally) for lunch. Because I wanted to be off the hustle & bustle of super CROWDED Park Ave on a Saturday lunchtime. This place EXCEEDED our expectations, The Caesar salad was fantastic with homemade dressing, homemade croutons and plentiful portion! We had the The Puddsy sandwich which was house roasted turkey breast sandwich with applewood bacon, Munster cheese, sun dried tomato dressing. Again all freshly made - this was not sliced deli meat it was real pieces of turkey, homemade bacon ALL so delicious I overate by a margin!!! read more

See all

I was Severely Underwhelmed ‍... The Staff (especially the cashier) is great. I was waiting for over 30 minutes for a to go order, finally the gentleman that saw I was patiently waiting asked what my order was and got my order within 5 minutes. But the food and price - very disappointing. I ordered the Philly cheesesteak (it was just bread, unseasoned meat/onions/mushrooms and orange peppers with provolone shlepped on the top of it). The macaroni salad was only macaroni mixed with mayonnaise, literally that was it. ‍. Greatly disappointed in the food and flavor profile(or lack there of). I guess just stick with the cookies ‍? I really wanted to like this place, because of the reviews. Only kudos is the staff. Everything else...go elsewhere. read more

See all