DO NOT LET YOUR MONEY GO TO WASTE! on December 10th I ordered a pizza with wings and a pop. Upon opening my pizza box, my pizza was missing about 3 PIECES! I immediately called the store to ask WHY MY PIZZA WAS MISSING SLICES, the "manager" asked for a picture and I sent it. He very rudely said to me "THAT IS NOT how you received your pizza" and started arguing with me. I wasn't even asking for a refund, I was more concerned that my pizza was fresh and safe to eat? I was then offered a new pizza but I HAD TO GO AND PICK IT UP read more

Geneo's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Food service to the best . I'll took a drive from Indiana to get the best pizza & wings in Chicago , no regrets on my purchase. Awesome service and perfect food , I'm willing to wait 30-40 min for my pizza . read more

Geneo's Pizza - Cheddar cheese beef garlic pizza - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Good is always fresh and we always choose this place to order local pizza. Restaurant is always clean. read more

Geneo's Pizza - Pizza Potato Skins - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Me and my husband placed an order to pizza by geneo's I got a small pizza and a Mostaccioli w meat sauce. The pizza was delicious but the pasta was not giving its was a zero no cheese over cooked meat and no seasonings my family of two did not eat it. I called the restaurant to tell them the concern I had for it and they told me I couldn't exchange it when we have the full container of it. Nor can we get the money back for our pasta we had received. The owner is name temo nerrez and he offered me 10% but we didn't want to buy something else we already had pizza and he wasn't working with us. To get another pizza or something that they knew taste good. I have a food license and I know we can exchange food if we don't like it or refund the money, I provided the photo to show you guys we have not touch this pasta. As well as I could have got this order for free as the lady in the front told me it was paid for, but I kindly said I didn't pay for it, and this is what us customers get for being honest nasty food yuck read more

Geneo's Pizza - a pizza in a pie pan - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

Just a weird vibe, no waiters or waitresses, but food was good. People were great, Just a different vibe.

My food never arrived. I would not order from here. On top of everything they lie to you about it.

I had mixed feelings when writing this review. The pizza I ordered was delicious. I had it delivered; I had to wait about an hour for it to be delivered to my hotel. It was in the evening on the night of the AFC final so the time was understandable. The cost is where I begin to have issues. A 12 inch meat lovers thin crust pizza is listed for $15.35. I can understand that the price of a pizza has increased thanks to 'Brandon" but when it arrived my bill said $25.75. I understand that there is a charge for delivery the ad says $4.00. So just the advertised price so far was $19.35 for a 12 inch meat lovers pizza; as I said before the total on my bill was $25.75 a difference of $6.40. Insert your pic of "Brandon" saying I did that. But the Icing on the cake was that I signed the bill and took my pizza and walked away and the delivery driver added another $3.78 onto the bill for a grand total of $29.53 for a 12 inch thin crust meat lovers pizza. The pizza tasted good though. Overall not impressed! read more

Holly crap they suck! I ordered at 6pm it's 9:15 I got nothing had to cancel . When I called they avoid my calls by putting me on hold!!

I live only 4 minutes away from this place and I placed an order it toke about 2 hours for me to receive the pizza. As well when I was giving my card information I had to repeat it over 5 times and the the address 3 times and still got the delivery address incorrect. To top it off the pizza wasn't even the size I ordered. I'm not sure what this place has turned into but almost 100% sure the person on the other line was under the influence. read more

I order pizza here all the time. The large looks like medium. So we usually order jumbo. So its big enough. The people who answer the phone are very rude. Now here's the part that messes me up. When I order. Pizza for pick it'll be ready in 30 minutes. But for delivery it takes 2 1/2 hours. For my cold pizza. After 2 hours I always have to call them and say ... Hey where's my pizza?!?! Which the reply it'll be there in 20 minutes which is usually 45. Hate having delivery! The. Cheese sticks are good. But the marinara sauce is not the best. It has huge chunks of ground beef? Would be better with out the meat read more

Geneo's Pizza - Hate this place - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

Ive been ordering from this place my whole life. This is the only pizza spot I can never get tired eating from. When the pizza is well done it has no competition. Their sausage is better than most spots and their sauce is just right. It is not sweet and it will not overwhelm you and give you any heartburn. They should go back to including their 2 liter of RC with pizza orders like they used to before. Pricing is pretty fair and I feel like you get more pizza for your money than at other spots, without compromising the flavor and quality. read more

Geneo's Pizza - Sausage & pepperoni pizza (ask for it well done and thank me later) - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

I've lived a block away all my life and the pizza has turned to shit. I found a hair in my slice of pizza I'm beyond disgusted. They usually take about a hour and a half to 2 hours to deliver. I was in there this Thursday and the place looked like trash. It was just 3 dudes in the back chilling they didn't even noticed I walked in even though there is a bell.They just built a new pizza place not to far. We are done. read more

See all

Much like my opinion prior on another local pizza place, I'm going with the same concept when it comes to Geneo's, which is that you're looking at a 50/50 chance of getting something great or something just okay. However, where Geneo's excels is that you have a better chance of getting pretty good food as opposed to the occasional miss that always tends to strike local pizza places. The pizza here, when it's good, it's really great and it seems to be shifts over large spans of time where the pizza can be amazing every time and suddenly it's just okay. That said, this is my go to local place for delivery because the amount of food for the money you get is always worthwhile. However, when the failed soda tax came, the free 2 liters were lost in the shuffle and unfortunately never came back. Another perk, though this tends to be common with most local places is the "Collect 20 coupons for a free large pizza" perk that comes with each order. If you order from them like I do, this adds up pretty fast and before you know it you're dining for free that night (they'll deliver the free pizza if you pay the delivery.) Like I've stated before and probably will in what I'm thinking will be upcoming pizza place reviews, this is definitely worth ordering up, you have a good chance of getting a decent pizza as opposed to other places more often than not. read more

Grew up in the neighborhood. Never had it until yesterday. Ordered it well done and by far one of my favorite pizzas I've had. Will be out family's go to for now on. read more

My family lives close to this joint. We're a regular here like almost every week. Love the pizza, staff there is friendly, and this place was recently remodeled so great place to dine in now. Definitely recommend this place if you're in the area. read more

I have been ordering from this place for 25+ years and today will be the last day I order. During a global pandemic, one of the dummy teenagers that they hire was not wearing a mask when we went to pick up. When told he should be wearing a mask while handling food (and at all times, really) he just shrugged his shoulders, as if to say "whatever". I can't begin to explain how disgusted I am with this. As long as management is allowing this to go on, I think I'll find another pizza joint. read more

This is my favorite pizzeria on the low all the ingredients are fresh and it stays consistent always a friendly atmosphere on time with the food havent changed and that what i love about them keep up the good work read more

I'll start off by saying that I'm a little biased since this place is run by my family. It hasn't been at this location for 40 years but the place has been around for almost that long in different locations. They used to be over on Lawndale, I think. I can't remember, since I was a kid. Anyhow, I absolutely believe they have some of the best pizza out there. I've yet to find one that tastes as good as they make it. They also have TONS of other things from sandwiches to pasta to fish and chicken. If you need it, they've got it and it's all pretty darn tasty. Geneo's was originally owned by my grandparents, Bob and Charlotte. Then my dad, Bob, took over several years ago (he's worked there the entire history of the place). My dad died this last July and the place has been taken over by my grandparents again. If you're there, say hi to my grandmother. Everyone calls her Char or Chi (shy). She's a pistol but a lot of fun! And ask for some garlic bread with cheese "Jennifer style". She'll load it up with garlic butter and it's the BEST! read more

This is my favorite pizza joint! I'd give it 5 stars but sometimes when i call to place an order 'Roseanne' picks up! Lol that's not really her name but she's a rude, older woman.. Other than that, the best pizza ever! read more

Delicious pizza if you're willing to wait 2 hours for your order. Ridiculous. Service is horrible. They say it's coming and it isn't. Then they tell you there isn't any supervisor or manager or owner to talk to apparently the kids run the place. Ridiculous service. read more

I've been eating this pizza for years and it's always been good pizza! But last week I ordered and for the first time in like 17 years they got my order wrong! The drivers always have a bad addituide, in an exception on like a couple of them the lady in charge always had a bad addituide until recently! All in all good pizza, but gonna stick to picking it up from know on And checking it before I leave now! read more

I read Jenn M.'s review and took it to heart. I have to say,Jenn lied to us. Geneo's is even better than she describes. A longtime staple for our softball team, somehow Geneo's drifted from us as the neighborhood changed and we moved to different parts of the city. I always assumed that is was sold, like most older places were, and then bastardized by the new owners. When I ordered this past week, I was pleasantly delighted.This is the pizza that Chicago was filled with in the 70's and the 80's. Incredible. Great toppings (plenty of choices), excellent crust, and sauce.....yum. If it is possible, it is even better than I remembered. Pizza that is made EXACTLY as you order, decent prices, and great delivery.While it may not be an epiphany, this is certainly a reliable,go-to pizza joint. In my top 3 neighborhood places for sure. read more

Haven't been here in over 20 years...for the size of the party pizza (20 inch) and the price...it's still a great deal...very thin crust...sausage is pretty good...sauce is semi-sweet...good local pizza...spoke with a worker who says it's the same original recipe but not sure it it's the original owners read more

Geneo's Pizza - Couldn't find a clear photo of the menu...hope this helps - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Best pizza in Chicago. Have been ordering from here my whole life and nothing comes close to it. Prices are fair for the quality of the food. Don't hesitate to come in. read more

In search of the best non meat pizza during this Lenten season. Could not find a menu anywhere online for this place. The only thing I found was a blurry picture that you can't read on yelp. Ordered a half cheese and half green pepper and onion. Found the cheese side to be better tasting then the onion and green pepper. Not sure if it was because the veggies are out of season here in Chicago. Definitely will try some of their meat pizzas from here after Lent. read more

I've been ordering from this place for awhile and sometimes it's been great sometimes decent but recently annoying. I'm not sure why I have to call to tell them to make sure my goddamn order is RIGHT just for it to come WRONG. Not only that, but the drivers? Are you kidding? Asking for tip and if it's low then you get an attitude? Lmao ok read more

Awesomest pizza near MDW. Next time I'm working nearby, I'm getting more. I went to Giordano's on the same trip, and it wasn't nearly as good. I had a deep dish with spinach, tomatoes and chicken. Now deep dish isn't my first choice, but I was with someone from California who had never had Chicago pizza, so there really was no choice. Still, it was pretty awesome. Next time I'll order with extra sauce. For me what makes Chicago pizza so much better than what I get in most other cities is the crust. That nice crunch it has right out of the oven someone how can't reproduced in my hometown Detroit. Unfortunately there is no seating at Geneo's so this means eating in the car, an unwieldy but tasty proposition with a deep dish pizza. read more

This place is pretty awesome!! Fast delivery and really great food!! Check out their barbecue chicken pizza, it's my fave!!

I literally am IN LOVE with Geneos!!! We order here everytime for our church events and also for home. It is THEE best pizza joint in Gage Park! If they sold pizza by the slice I would prolly never leave their establishment! No joke! Only thing I would change about it is make it a sit in joint (how would you do that, i'm not sure) it would definitely be BOOMING! All the thumbs up Geneos! read more

Geneo's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Liked the pizza but delivery took more then what they said. And the pizza was kinda cold. And its not cool when the delivery guy ask you for tip. read more

Food is great, but yesterday my food was delivered by a tall man with glasses that insisted I gave a tip on the credit card slip. When I didn't give one he gave the slip back and replied I don't need your tip. I am seriously now seeking a new restaurant. Any ideas? Sincerely Disappointed! read more

Best pizza you can get in the Chicago lawn area...dare I say Chicago in general? Yea I'd say so! SOOO good and great prices! I love them!

I've got to give this one five stars. I cannot count the number of times this placed has saved me from starving while working my job on the south side. Pizza is delicious, service is good, fast delivery, they usually bring a free bottle of pop for me too! So I get a large 2 topping delivered, w/ pop for ~ $15. Highly recommended!! read more

The worst place I've ever ordered from! I ordered for delivery and even that process was a nightmare, I can't imagine actually going to the place. Charlotte (the woman taking our order) was very rude to us and made a simple large pizza order excruciating. The pizza took over an hour and when it actually arrived the order was wrong. We had to wait another hour for them to actually send us the right pizza and we live down the street! Charlotte then was extremely rude to me when I called about getting the wrong pizza. I don't understand why they keep her taking the orders when she clearly can't do her job right and she has the WORST customer service skills. When we actually got the right pizza it was bland and not even worth the hassle. Save your time and money, and order from somewhere else. I hope Geneo's does themselves a favor and gets someone else to take orders. read more

Really good pizza. And reasonably priced. They always give u a two liter of pop when u get a pizza. Last time, we ordered two big pizzas and got two two liters. I got extra two liters on my back porch cuz we don't even drink the pop most times! read more

On a much earlier visit I made the mistake of bringing my prejudices with me. First off, I can eat a TON of pizza. If it's great, I can eat a few tons. They have to wheel barrow me out of the best pizza joints, and happily so. Problem was, I was thinking in terms of New Orleans, California, East Coast, etc. and these were geographically and volumetric-ally off by major margins. Order staff looked at me and my diminutive female guest and advised a small. I brushed her off like the rhino to the fly and ordered the large (congratulating myself for the moderation I showed by not ordering the extra large). A large came and I plowed gustily into my first slice, pausing 2/3 through as I realized it was only slice #1 and I was already suffering jaw fatigue. This tore a serious chunk out of my appetite all by itself. Meanwhile, the pizza was great - tasty, piquant, rich, thick, joyous, incredibly filling and so on. I approached slice number two with more caution, but not enough. The last half of slice #2 had more pain than joy and I had to stop eating like it was pizza. Further ingestion was clearly going to be a matter of pacing and pride rather than the ravenous devastation I was used to when the flavor and mood struck. By the time the third slice became a possibility I was sweating like a Saudi Prince and asking myself whether I had (gasp!) made a horrible error in judgment. I had. My twiggy guest had eaten almost half of one slice and I managed only a few bites into #3 before giving up and leaving a good 4 pieces untouched. I'm not sure whether the server's grin was an "I told you so" or a "Good, now we can feed homeless people all over the Midwest for another week" but whatever it was, she was right. Moral of the story: Order with caution read more

I love this place! It's so yummy. The pizza is delicious I usually get a large for me and my brother and it feeds us just fine, we also get a pop with it. Who wouldn't enjoy a free pop with the purchase of a pizza? When I get together with my friends we order a party pizza and it feeds around 6-7 people but we also get an order of wings as well which I have to say are realllyyyy good. We do have to wait a little for delivery but we have never gotten cold food. It's quicker to just pick it up but it's up to you if you want to get it delivered it might take a while longer or if you want it ASAP then you're better off picking it up. read more

Ordered for the first time from here yesterday. Got it for pick up, the gentleman at the register was friendly. Sausage and pepperoni pizza is superb. I'll be going for more soon! read more

Been ordering from here for as long as I could remember! I live in Texas now and wish I could open one up over here to continue the Chicago Tradition! Every time I go Visit I make sure my family has a pizza ready for me once I get home! Same delivery guy since I was young too! Great guy! My entire family orders from here! Love this pizza! read more

Geneo's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Well, I hate to give a bad review but this pizza did not live up to the reviews I read! The thin crust was very doughy and the pizza was dry. No flavor at all except in the sausage... which the sausage was delicious and fresh. I couldn't even taste the cheese because of the crust. I really felt bad for my hubby because he was coming off a fast. He wanted Dominos and I said NO let us get some "real" pizza. Needless to say should've got the Dominos because one thing they have is the buttery garlic flavor. We may try this place again. I just read a tip to order extra thin with extra sauce, that may work out better for us. The price was reasonable. read more