Came here on a Saturday night, and it would have been a 20-minute wait, but there was seating…read moreoutside. It was a perfect night to eat in the open air, unless you're downwind from a lady standing near the entrance smoking a cigarette , which we were, unfortunately. After we got our drinks, we waited at least 30 minutes to get our food, but we appreciated the update from one of the servers. We never did get the waters we asked for, but our pizza and chicken Gorgonzola were excellent...even on the wobbly table from which we ate! Our server was working her tail off, because according to another server, they were short three people. This place is a staple in Etown, and it will most likely be around for a long to come.

We had an excellent dining experience on Christmas Eve at Giorgios! Our service was amazing and the…read morefood was delicious with generous portions. Definitely worth the visit!

Isaac and his team took great care of us and our crew from "A Caring Heart" from Wilmington NC. We…read morewent to Wallace mid May and the folks of the park let us use a picnic shelter (shout out to Jason!) Isaac delivered plenty of pizza for us all! He was amazing and the world is so small because through conversation we realized he knew a boss of mine from Fairmont NC that I worked for in 2009! Food was superb! And it's always great to connect with good people! Thank you Isaac! April Richardson and Crew A caring Heart

Place was amazing! dropped in here for a quick dinner and was instantly greeted with a warm and…read morewelcoming atmosphere. The waitress, who's name was Paige, was so personable with amazing recommendations, appreciated honesty, and humor. Food was so good -everyone enjoyed what they had. We met the owner, Isaac, and his wife, Tia, and they were just wonderful people with such amazing hospitality. 10/10 recommend & would absolutely come back if we have the chance!

I frequently head to Sugar Hill Pizzeria on Sunday evenings when I have work in Kinston. I always…read moreorder the same thing, a supreme pizza, so I can't speak for all of the other things on their menu. But I've enjoyed delicious pizza each time I've visited. The staff is friendly and helpful.

Grabbed a few pizzas plus steak and cheese to go while in town for the weekend. Food was delicious…read moreand customer service was outstanding...love Southern hospitality!!

The food and service is fantastic!! They are fast in completing our orders, and it's our go to for…read morea pizza night. We love Fat Daddy's!

Seriously best pizza around and they have a GF! Wish GF was…read morea large but we make it work. Finally becoming "regulars", always place an order and then we just get there in time to just sit and eat and enjoy! They only have beers for the alcohol menu. Bring quarters for the kiddos!

It's terrible....., that other country seafood and desert restaurants can't cook like these chefs…read more Darn good eating. These young ladies work hard and smile all the time. Oh, and thanks for playing good Christian music.

Always delicious food on the buffet. Plenty of choices and stuff are always bringing out more…read more Wait staff is very friendly and helpful. Seating is tight at times and little noisy but that's because the food is always fresh , hot and delicious. Highly recommend

All the employees were pleasant and helpful. My family and I didn't like the flavor of the pizza…read more The cheese pizza was the most palatable. It could just be that we are new to NC and where we're from we were used to something different. We ordered some assorted slices as well and 2 of 4 were burnt on the bottom. Edit: I know it's a far stretch here, but have you considered that fact that Yelp asks days later if you'd still like to leave a review so I thought why not..now I have the owner scratching his head and finding it suspicious that someone could possibly have not been thrilled by his pizza. It was a review from a day you were very much open, Friday. I still think that any and everyone should give it a try if they are so inclined. I'm also thrilled that so many people have enjoyed it. As a business owner, your immediate response to a review should not be to attack the reviewer. This interaction has left a much worse taste in my mouth than the burnt pizza.

As a native New Yorker from THE Island this place is spot on!!!…read moreGreat authentic pizza, REALLY!

The pizza was hot and delicious. The service was friendly and the restaurant was clean. Very…read moreconvenient to 95 exit. Great place to stop.

I had dinner at Your Pie Pizza in Lumberton, NC as it was in the same parking lot as I was staying…read more The restaurant has both inside and outside seating for dining in but you can order carry out too. When you enter, the menu is on the wall and then you order and pay. I went with the white pizza as I couldn't find where the available toppings were listed. The pizza is available as 7 inch, 10 inch or 14 inch. Besides pizza, you can get salads or pastas. I got the upgrade and got a side salad and drink added to my pizza price. The side salads are already made in the case and the fountain beverages are self serve. There are more options in the cooler and craft beers are available at the bar. The pizza is thin and very good. I liked that it was cooked in a brick oven and came out fairly quickly. I did see the gelato when paying so I got the raspberry and strawberry sorbet after finishing my dinner. It was softer than I expected but tasted fine. Service was friendly but I would have liked some guidance with ordering and where the fountain and forks were located.

Divine food, for sure it's the best pizza I've ever had, hands down. Very friendly staff, always…read morewelcoming. They never fail to deliver, literally.. no pun intended. If you haven't gone yet, what are you waiting for?

We were in town recently for a sporting event and decided to pick up a pizza after. I called ahead…read moreat like 5 p.m. and was told there was at least an hour wait. I mean, it was a Saturday - so - okay, but 5 p.m. is so early to be on that kind of wait already! We ordered a medium pie and the garlic knots. Even coming in after the hour wait, our order still wasn't ready and we waited for probably another 15-20 in the restaurant before it was done. At this point, I'm expecting this pizza must be better than anything else I've ever tasted. Unfortunately, not so much. The pizza was huge - I give it that. A medium was more like a large/extra large at other places. It's not the best NY style pizza I've ever had, but it wasn't the worst. The garlic knots were interesting -- VERY heavy on the butter/garlic topping stuff - so much so it cakes the bottom of the pan. I can see why that would appeal to a lot of folks, but for me and my kids, we found it to sort of just make the knots soggy and mushy instead of that nice balance of dough crisp bread and flavor. Overall, probably on the 3 1/2 star scale for me with the wait/service issues and mostly average flavor.

I've ordered from Cugino Forno twice now and both times have been great. The pizza is delicious,…read moreand the salads are fresh and flavorful--I usually get the blueberry salad, but even the one I got by accident was just as good! There was a mix-up with DoorDash picking up the wrong order, but when I called, the manager handled it immediately. He was kind, apologetic, and truly cared about making it right. That level of service really stood out and turned a Mix-Up Into a 5-Star Experience Mistakes happen, but they went above and beyond. I'll definitely be ordering again!

You no longer have to travel to Brooklyn to get authentic NYC style pizza. It's right here in ILM…read more Friendly staff and outrageously great pizza (yes, and salad too).