I had dinner at Your Pie Pizza in Lumberton, NC as it was in the same parking lot as I was staying. The restaurant has both inside and outside seating for dining in but you can order carry out too. When you enter, the menu is on the wall and then you order and pay. I went with the white pizza as I couldn't find where the available toppings were listed. The pizza is available as 7 inch, 10 inch or 14 inch. Besides pizza, you can get salads or pastas. I got the upgrade and got a side salad and drink added to my pizza price. The side salads are already made in the case and the fountain beverages are self serve. There are more options in the cooler and craft beers are available at the bar. The pizza is thin and very good. I liked that it was cooked in a brick oven and came out fairly quickly. I did see the gelato when paying so I got the raspberry and strawberry sorbet after finishing my dinner. It was softer than I expected but tasted fine. Service was friendly but I would have liked some guidance with ordering and where the fountain and forks were located. read more

See all

While in the area for lunch we chose to dine here. It was a pretty quiet nice pizza place. I ordered a build your own veggie pizza and wings. The pizzas came out within a reasonable time. The wings came out later but unfortunately were not fried as the description stated. They were rather fatty and wiggly. I sent them back and it appears they were placed in the brick oven. After receiving them back and it did not help I had to request a refund. The manager was not willing to refund as she stated she can not refund because I did not like them. I then had to point out the description posted and then she did the refund. If going for pizza only I would recommend. But the manager also would be better with a little customer service and friendly attitude. read more

See all

In the same parking lot as the SpringHill Suites Hotel, a very convenient restaurant. Italian food, such as pizzas, sandwiches, pasta dishes, salads, wings and ice cream. The service was great. One can preorder through their website, but the website is not perfect and makes it difficult to find the exact location to place the order. We ordered take out. The pasta dish was quite good and a tad spicy. The pizza crust was cracker thin, but not bad. The wings were good. They seem fairly new, but claim they've been there for 7 yrs. You can dine inside or take to go. They make it all right in front of you. We found them very affordable. It's worth checking out. read more

Very conveniently located just off 95 in Lumberton, adjacent to the Springhill Suites parking lot. This is a chain, (very similar to MOD pizza up north,) where you choose your own size pizza and then add your sauce, cheese, and toppings to your liking. Pizza has a very thin crust, and was tasty. Also important to note, that beer and wine are available! Service is pretty fast, employees were friendly, and they have inside seating or patio seating. Restaurant and bathrooms were clean. read more

The pizza was hot and delicious. The service was friendly and the restaurant was clean. Very convenient to 95 exit. Great place to stop.

We had the #1 Supreme pizza. It was a 14" on a very thin crust and a greek side salad. I washed it down with 2 Red Oak Lagers on draft. First off, finding a decent pizza off the highway with a good ambiance and decent draft beer selection is almost impossible but we lucked out with this place. The service was excellent and I would say that the pricing was fair all things considered. The only real negative was the salads which were small and were mostly lettuce. So, if you are heading up or down interstate 95 and want to get decent pizza for 2, you will be glad you did. read more

Stopped here on the way to FL. First time visiting a Your Pie Pizza and it didnt disappoint. They have other things besides pizza like wings, salads and ice cream. The hubs ordered a pepperoni pizza and I ordered a greek salad. The pizza is a thin crust pizza. The Greek salad on the menu doesn't include meat but you have the option of adding a meat. My protein of choice was chicken. Both meals were delicious. The cost for our meals and drinks was $29.93. The atmosphere is casual. The staff were really friendly and the restaurant was clean. We would definitely stop in again if in the area. read more

See all

Nice clean casual stop right off of 95. We had a cheese pizza and a sandwich (sort of like a calzone but open on the edges). Both were really good and we're from NY so we definitely know a good pizza. Prices were very reasonable and we enjoyed everything very much. Definitely a nice change from the usual fast meal while you're traveling. read more

Your Pie Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lumberton, North Carolina

See all

After driving all day I did not want to get back in my car. I read RAVE reviews about this place so I thought I would place an order for delivery. Through their website I ordered a personal pizza, Greek side salad and Dr Pepper. ($19 + $5 delivery fee + $5 tip) When checking out it said my order will be delivered by DoorDash. I received a text that said my order would arrive by 8:28 (I am 1/2 mile away) It arrived at 8:50. I was handed an EMPTY cup, a wilted Cesar salad without dressing, and a pizza. I showed the receipt that said Dr Pepper, and also Greek salad. He just looked at me, and shrugged his shoulders. I get up to my room, open the pizza box and it is a cold pizza with burnt crust. I am beyond disappointed in every way. I tried to call the restaurant but was put on hold, I sent an email. We will see how this gets read more

Your Pie Pizza - Here is my receipt - Pizza Near Me - Lumberton, North Carolina

See all

If you want some good wings these are the best in Lumberton. The honey hot wings are WONDERFUL. I have not had good wings in lumberton so far until now. read more

Your Pie Pizza - Honey hot wings - Pizza Near Me - Lumberton, North Carolina

The worst pizza that I've ever had. Thin as paper and so soggy that it fell apart. No flavor. Awful and too expensive. The salad was fresh, so 2 stars for that. read more

They have a lot of options for toppings. Wings ain't bad either. Have not tried the gelato yet

1st time there as we are staying in the adjoining property hotel Lemon ricotta pizza and chicken pesto pizza (for my wife and me) both outstanding cooked exactly as requested Staff very personable, helpful and professional Highly recommend read more

Hey! You can create your own pizza by choosing the crust, sauce; and toppings! Better yet, that's why it's called YOUR Pie. Another huge thing is the staff is welcoming and warm. Also, there's draft beverages for the adults. Why not stop of I95 for a quick and affordable bite. read more

Nice relaxed atmosphere. Very clean pizzeria . This is like a Subway for pizza . Pick your size and they build it to your taste. Also had a Greek salad which was very fresh . Nice change . Plus the staff was very nice and helpful . read more

I want to love this place instead I feel it's just OK. Just a bit of background - I grew up in CT which is truly the pizza capital of the US. It has more nationally recognized pizza joints than anywhere in the USA. My standards are very high and I travel a lot so not an amateur eater... So on the overall review: Staff: 2.0 They seem disinterested Atmosphere: 3.5 Nice place but lacks any intimacy Pizza Pie: 4.0 - Very good pie with fresh ingredients and I like the thin crust with a bit of char, not quite New Haven style but very good. Other offerings: Come on folks individual salads premade in very small plastic containers for $3.70??? Gelato - Nice but also over priced. Good selection of drafts at $7-8 ...but come on! This is not a high end bar Price: Not crazy expensive but over-priced given the offerings and atmosphere and given the location (Lumberton - not exactly a hot spot). A large Pizza is $22. I can buy a similar pie in Orlando for about $19-20 and that is a heavy tourist area. Overall great concept with good pies but it falls short in many areas. I guess it's a successful chain but it will have to do better to get me back in. read more

Just stopping in. We had a 7 in pizza which wasn't bad, just we got it thin and it was super thin. The service was petty fast. The ambiance is quiet. If you in the area, come on by. read more

Your Pie Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lumberton, North Carolina

Great food for a great price. Buddy and I stopped in and have a keto pizza. Was great.

First time at this restaurant, I walked in and stood in front of two people behind the counter for what seemed to be 5 min. I asked them if this is where I order and the guy in the NY hat jumped at me saying he had other pizzas to make before mine. Finally an employee on the new shift asked me if he could help me. He was really nice and took my order and explained the menu. When I got to the register to pay I ordered my drink and my nice guy that took my order for a phone call and he said he had to take it. Another guy helped me pay. My drink was never brought to me so when my pizza was delivered I asked for my drink. He proceeded to tell another girl that was sweeping the floor. It took her a couple of min. To get around to bring me my drink. I guess sweeping the floor was more important. The pizza is good too bad the service sucks. I will be staying at the hotel behind for quite a while and this pizza place will not get my business. read more

Your Pie Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lumberton, North Carolina

See all

Stopped into grab some lunch with a friend! The pizza was great! I got the build your own with pesto, pepperoni and mushroom. The salads were a little sad with very little lettuce for the price but overall the experience was great! read more

Your Pie Pizza - Build your own pie w/pesto pepperoni and mushroom - Pizza Near Me - Lumberton, North Carolina

See all

A Great place for a real pizza designed by you and cooked right there. According to Wikipedia this restaurant chain "... is an American fast-casual pizza concept, that was started in Athens, Georgia in 2008 by Drew French, and operates as a restaurant franchise with 70 locations across 19 states. Your Pie has customizable 10-inch pizzas, pasta bowls, and salads. The restaurant uses brick ovens to cook their pizzas.[1] Gelato (Italian ice cream), craft beer, and wine are also available." This particular site is located right off the main street. It is very nice inside. It has a polished concrete floor with a clean look and lots of 2-person tables The menu is displayed on the wall next to the counter where you place your order. The neat thing is you get to watch them make your pizza and put it in the oven. And the pizza they made for me was excellent. It came out in about 5-7 minutes. There is an eating area inside and an outside patio. I highly recommend this place to fellow travelers hungry for pizza in the Lumberton area. The price for a single 14-inch pie was $18 which may be a little high but for the price, service, and taste, I thought it was well worth it. read more

See all

Delicious We ordered #1 pizza and a Greek salad. I would highly recommend this plave read more

We tried to stop at a local diner but it was carry out only and they wouldn't even let customers use the restrooms. I saw Your Pie Lumberton was near by and it offers nutritious and delicious options customizable for each family member. It's a Win-Win when the staff is phenomenal, helpful, kind, and offers great recommendations! What a nice and welcoming respite during our drive from South Carolina. Thank you and we'll stop again if we have the opportunity. read more

Your Pie Pizza - The Nat on Cauliflower Keto Crust - Pizza Near Me - Lumberton, North Carolina

Five stars, glad this was right there, literally in the parking lot! was recommended and did not disappoint! Great service and fresh ingredients. easy concept, you pick the kind of dough, the toppings an they cook it, viola! some cheaper pies for more basic cooks, aka, cheese, or veggie, or meat, but they can do a bunch of different kinds. also gelato! and kids meals. watch from their patio while 95 traffic moves no where and thank yourself with pizza! read more

Dope little spot with reasonable prices.. staff has always been nice they seem to be getting ready to build this area up so could be a great location. The pizza is always bussing try the sun dried tomatoes yummmm read more

Can you believe this? I ordered a pizza with sausages on it. This is what I got! I just left there - waiting to have a piece of my pizza and when I got home - I had to ask myself - what did I order? It was ridiculous. This is my 3rd time there and my second negative review. I guess I better start looking for another pizza place. read more

Your Pie Pizza - A pizza with hardly any Italian sausage - Pizza Near Me - Lumberton, North Carolina

Good pizza takes time. Glad to have this franchise open up in Lumberton! Update 3/20: Your Pie up and running full steam ahead. The New Cauliflower crust is a game changer for the taste buds however does come with a significant up charge. The draft beer selection is being finessed regularly based on customer preferences. Wine Specials on Weds and Trivia nights make this an appealing place. Overall impressed by this well oiled machine. Takeaway: Overall a great place to come with friends and family to grab a personal pizza or two and enjoy a craft beer on tap or vino. Best to enjoy Your Pie on site rather than to go. Deep Dive: Came in on a Sunday evening for dinner. Establishment is wide with sufficient seating in addition to a nice outdoor option. You immediately stand in line on the left side of the building where you start building your pizza/salad/etc.. Choose white wheat or gluteal free bases. This place has only been open 2-3 weeks and it seems staff is still finessing efficiency and work flow (hope this improves with time). You then pick your sauce base and toppings. Next the pie goes into a flame oven that is open for viewing. You pay at the counter and are given a table # and your meal will be delivered to your table. Good pizza takes time so don't expect fast food delivery. Grab one of the great options for craft brews or wines. Draft options were well chosen. The pizzas have thin flaky crispy crusts that illicit a delectable crunch with each bite. Perfect temperature to devour promptly upon delivery. I do appreciate that Your Pie has options for the dairy and gluten intolerant. They have vegan cheese that mimics the real stuff. They have a variety of meat and vege toppings that you can load up on. I believe the perfect amount of food is 1.5 pizzas. So bring a and make it family style. Gelato! read more

See all

Mmmmm. Stopped by on my way home from Myrtle. Not far off 95. Brand new establishment and online ordering! I got a vegan pizza and the hub got pepperoni/green pepper. Fresh ingredients, hot delicious pizza and the box is just sooo cute! This place is gonna do well! Gluten free crust & vegan cheese ??!!! Winning!! And it's under $10! For a personal 6 slice pizza! Can y'all please expand to Maryland and open a store by my mailbox,, on my lawn please Jesus!!:) read more

Your Pie Pizza - Vegan cheese. Mushroom.onion.basil - Pizza Near Me - Lumberton, North Carolina

So I'm back, laughing at some of my clever little jokes to make my reviews interesting and I see I never updated. As an elite Yelper, it is my duty to keep current...even if I still wear skinny jeans and not bootcut. I digress. The last time I was here was late July/early August. I'm glad I didn't update my review then because it's kinda taken me a long time to move past the experience. So it goes like this and I'm reporting from a managerial point of view: I see 1 person prepping the pizza dough (check). I see 3-4 people on the line where they build the pizza (check). I see 1-2 people staging the pizzas as they come out of the oven and ensuring their delivery to the dining area (check). I see 1 new person working the register and I've been in line for a least 10 minutes. They call that a "bottleneck" and this poor newby was drowning. No one moved over to help, no one expedited the drink orders to help keep her at the register instead of doing both. The people on the line can't take any more orders because the line isn't moving. I see pizzas come out of the oven, sit on the staging area...sitting, sitting. Those are gonna be real cold! (no check here, just a needle dropping off the record and making the most horrific sound). I notice people at the tables mumbling that their order is taking a long time to come out. You see the telltale signs something is askew: cranking necks/standing up and looking around for an employee, pointing at the order with a huge question mark expression. Then I saw the next thing happen, people just kind of took it. Like, shrug...I won't say anything. Meanwhile, my fellow pizza connoisseurs in line are doing "big eyes" which means, wtf... All of this inaction probably got us into this current situation, you know. It's not polite to not speak up when something is wrong, yet southerners throw shade with their "bless your heart" shenanigans. I'm a speak up, cause I'm from the north where pizzas were born and this injustice must be addressed. (Joking and not joking) So I say something to an employee, "Excuse me." I am ignored and I say, "Excuse me! Could someone open the other register? I can see my pizza has been out of the oven for a while and I don't want to pay for cold pizza." This was met with blank stare and no response. So I repeat this process again and I am told the person at the register is new and needs to learn. Yes, she was correct. Yet, you're supposed to support new people and make sure they don't get too overwhelmed and quit. So, this person seems to be the supervisor and she just takes over on the register for the new person. Not really the solution I was looking for nor does it support her adage about "needing to learn". I wanted to walk out, just leave the pizza and go elsewhere. However, the draw of the gelato is too strong for my young daughter and rather than adding a meltdown to the situation, I silently told myself this was the last time I'd set foot in this location. No apology was offered, the service was curt after I asked for them to address the backup. Nope. Not. Gonna. Do.It.Again. read more

This time around has been the absolute best! The summer crave fave is a MUST HAVE not try I gotta keep having this peach pizza omg! I enjoy the options of the family deals they have. I'm glad to see this establishment looks like it's here to stay, YAY! It actually seems to be a huge hang out area. The pizzas are personally sized but I love that, it pairs great with wine. Everything about the pizza is fresh and the brick oven tops it off. I haven't tried the paninis. The deserts are good from the brownies to the sorbet. read more

See all

I love to Create-My-Own salads and pizzas. The ranch dressing is on point! My first order was the Lineage and it didn't have garlic and I thought it was the most boring pizza. I doubted this place and came back months later. I found that any and ever pizza comes out excellent when I add Garlic from the menu selection. The restaurant app makes order easy and seamless. I earn my points quickly for something great. My meal is always ready upon arrival. I've only tried the gelato once. I had key lime and it was super sweet but can't beat the price for something extra at the end of a meal. Besides the first visit, I ordered the Hot Honey pepperoni pizza the first time and they only put 3 toppings on it out of the default 5/6 toppings it's suppose to have. I reported it to the manager, he consulted his team members, and made me a valued customer. I really like this style of restaurant. read more

See all

Their food is the best!!! Great service as always! The outside patio is everything you're looking for with TVs and live bands.

I got the delicious cheesy bread and some yummy gelato! Great price for wonderful food and the service was spot on.

What a great new addition to my hometown. We needed a new place to meet a friend, have a glass of wine, try out a craft beer, watch a game, and build your own individual pizza! As soon aS I walked in I was greeted and met by Kevin the GM. He mentioned the new cauliflower crust everyone was raving about so I decided to give it a try. It was on point! I love all the choices of sauces, veggies and meats! Gabby was very patient as I wanted a mic of everything but then wanted it on only parts of my pizza. As I was at the end I saw the gelato, wow!!!! Katlyn checked me out with a smile and she was extremely pleasant. I like the variety of food offerings, if you are not up for a pizza you can order a chopped salad. Thank you "Your Pie" for coming to our community and making a presence! I'm going to now call you "My Pie"! read more

See all

Just picked up my 2 pizzas ordered - first of all I had to call twice and the phone rang and rang and rang - I ordered my 2 pizzas and went to pick them up. I walked in and there was only one family of 3 ordering and I waiting in the pick up line. I had been there for a few minutes when I started the timer on my phone. 6 minutes and 31 seconds (and I had been there at least a couple of minutes before I started my timer) was even acknowledged. 3 people were working - I was never more than 3 feet away from one of the employees and not one even said "I'll be right with you"! This is then3rd time I have had an issue with this place. I let the first 2 go because I don't like to give reviews unless they are good - but 3rd strike and you're out! I have been in the service business for decades and I am an "over tipper" - I did not leave one red cent. I work too hard to give my money to people who do not deserve it. There are 4 other pizza places up the street. They just gained new customers because I won't go back and I'll tell 2 people - And they will tell two people and so I. And so on. Too bad cuz the pizza is good. Oh well!!!! read more

The pizza was pretty good, we have tried it 4 times now. The staff is friendly and accommodating.

Travel from the DC area to FL multiple times a year. Stay in Lumberton on the drive back. A restaurant nightmare Until we found this place! Pizza is to order and comes out quickly. Thin crust and really tastes fresh. Salads are pre done in a case. They're ok. Lots and lots of beer and wine selections. Decent prices. The staff is friendly enough; seem to care about getting it right. Tough to figure out the pricing from the boards. We'll definitely come again. Forget the steakhouses with the 2.5 stars. You all should come here instead! read more

Best beer selection in this area! Pizza is good and they are not shy on the toppings. I mainly go there for the beer though. read more

Your Pie Pizza - Sycamore Juciness IPA - Pizza Near Me - Lumberton, North Carolina

We were l passing through and this restaurant seemed to have good reviews. We pulled up. I got out to check it out while my family stayed in the car. There seemed to be a couple and a family waiting outside and a few cop cars. As I got out, the couple was let in. I asked the family what was going on. They said the employees put a sign on the door that they were closing until 9pm because they were short staffed. The family counted nine employees inside that the could see. There were just few people at the tables. They said the couple was let in because they were only drinking and not eating. A cop knocked on the door and an employee opened the locked door only for the police officer. I asked the family what was up with police presence. They said the police were patrons. I asked if the pizza was hood and they said yes. Needless to say, we were disappointed. Our family of 6 was in the car and we were hungry. We made the wrong stop. We couldn't wait around for more than a half hour to see if we would be served. We are driving from VA to FL. read more

This place has good pizza and it's even better when you can eat it outside in the weather is fine.