We found this local pizza place to be mostly average - didn't blow us away, but was decent pizza and a short walk from our hotel. The atmosphere is fun with counter service, and many gourmet pizza options. The personal sized pizzas are just the right amount. My husband got the barbecue chicken pizza and I got the white pizza. read more

This place has good pizza and it's even better when you can eat it outside in the weather is fine.

What a great restaurant!! The food, drinks and service were top notch! We felt welcome and had such a great night singing with the live music! read more

Oh my god! Best pizza ever. I'm a vegan and to find a place like this while traveling is a real treat. Vegan cheese meatless sausage. Sooooo good. Lots of vegan pasta options too. read more

After a full day of driving, we checked into a hotel but we were hungry. Fortunately for us this place was within walking distance. We decided to try pizza and ordered personal pizzas. My pizza was a simple cheese and pepperoni. The pizza is oven fired and ready to consume within ten minutes. The crust was good as well as the toppings. I would definitely eat here again. read more

We arrived in lumberton for the night in route to florida. We were hungry for a lite dinner and Your Pie was directly across the driveway from our hotel, Marriott Spring Hill Suites. Seemed easy enough, we asked if they would deliver and they said to the hotel lobby. So we ordered a 10" pie with a variety of meats and veggies on it along with a chopped salad. We received a call from downstairs to say it was there within 15 minutes. Easy enough! The pie was nice and hot. Unfortunately they did not include plates or enough plastic wear for two people. Considering we are in a hotel you would think they would. We were given one fork. The pie was delicious and hot. The chopped caprese salad was just ok, it really wasn't chopped, pieces were still pretty large, especially the lettuce and cheese, tomatoes were really all that had been chopped. We would recommend this place if you need a quick dinner while staying nearby. read more

Great pizza and best beer selection in Lumberton. Always very clean, and special events like live music and trivia on certain days.

For those passing through Lumberton your choices are limited. This fast casual place is clean and the pies, with choice of crust types, were decent. Friendly service, comfortable and satisfying. read more

I was in from out of town and staying at the hotel in the same parking lot. I was excited to order some pizza and tried calling repeatedly. I could never get an answer so I ordered on-line and paid. Within 5 minutes, I got a call from the restaurant that they could not fulfill my order. At that time, I canceled the order and was told I would be getting a refund. I did receive a partial refund but not the full amount. I have tried to call repeatedly across numerous days and can never get an answer. I have left messages asking for a call back and that has not brought me any closer to a resolution either. Since I have zero ability to review their food, I can only rate off the service. If I could give lower than a 1, I would. I understand that staffing can be challenging but I have called at "off-times" and simply asked for a call back at their convenience. And still no response. read more

Pizza was okay. Like being able to pick toppings. Saw sign offering keto friendly crust made from cheese and cauliflower. Nothing saying it was 4.50 upcharge. No one said anything about that until pizza made and paying for it. That means $14.49 for a pizza that is personal size. Also one employee had came up to get a cup of gelato and stood over the pizza toppings while eating. Probably not going back. read more

OMG , this pizza is a slice of heaven!!! Fresh toppings, gooey cheese, and all baked to perfection! I will be going back! read more

Your Pie Pizza - The Lineage & the Southern Heat...YUMMY!!! - Pizza Near Me - Lumberton, North Carolina

See all

Great concept but I've been here twice and cleanliness does not appear to be a priority. Been to Blaze and Pi Craft in various locations and the energy from the staff is better at those places. NY vs NC not sure if that matters but the NY experiences have been the better. Personality of the staff can set the experience. Beers are great just confusing on where you order a beer ... the unmanned bar or the pizza line? Again we'll intended poorly executed in my opinion. read more

I Love The Pizza here For me it's one of the best in town so far and The Gelato Scoops are Refreshing

Great spot with really good pizza!!! The food and drinks were top notch as was the service! They had live music which made the experience even better. We loved it and can't wait to come back...so good! read more

I recently went to your pie, and ordered the pizza below. They allowed me to mix two of the sauces which made this pizza absolutely delicious. It was made just the way I pictured it. It comes out piping hot! It was a thin crust pizza with the right amount of toppings for myself. When we arrived the line was out the door but they got everyone in at a pretty fast pace. I also had the salted caramel gelato which was a good blend of sweetness and creaminess. Looking forward to going back soon! read more

Your Pie Pizza - Custom made-pesto/Alfredo sauce, onion, spinach, bell pepper, fresh garlic, two types of cheese, jalapeños pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Lumberton, North Carolina

Staff nice but pizza was burnt was not as when I haved purchased before. The pizza started to have a funny taste to it made us all sick.

The pie tasted good but was cold. We ordered a ceaser salad and there was no dressing on the salad. We had the order for delivery, to a hotel right across the driveway. No napkins or plastic silverware were delivered, so we had to go back down to the hotel lobby for those items. read more

This spot is serving meals that are out of this world! They are top notch on customer service and they got us our food out right when we sat down! I highly recommend the cheese pizza if you usually get cheese pizza at other restaurants. The cheese sticks are on point aswell! read more

Very first responder friendly can't beat the hero discount. A little slow to clean tables but nothing else to complain about... and if I did it wouldn't change anything lol read more

Your Pie Pizza - Italian sausage, shredded mozzarella and Basel - Pizza Near Me - Lumberton, North Carolina

Excellent food! Great service! Will definitely eat there again! I highly recommend the BBQ chicken pizza!

We have had dinner at this restaurant-outdoors- 3 times. Food was fresh . We were very disappointed to see some of the employees with sloppy masks. I did mention to the 1 gal that she is supposed to cover her nose. Her response was that it always falls -NOT ACCEPTABLE! Get a proper mask that FITS properly. Sloppy management if the employees!!! Next gal was putting the pizza boxes together, breathing and talking over them while wearing her mask as a CHIN STRAP. Again, NOT ACCEPTABLE!!!! Again, sloppy management! All the other employees were properly masked but obviously ignored the obvious POORLY masked coworkers.we are in the midst of a pandemic that is only growing worse. These teens need to adjust to customer safety to keep this restaurant open safely! read more

This YourPie location is a great place to kick back and enjoy a piping hot made-to-order fresh ingredient pizza and a cold beverage with your family or friends. Features a spacious outdoor patio with 2 big screen tv's and plenty of seating providing a fun spot to watch a game or enjoy listening to one of the local music acts this restaurant often features on Thursdays. The owner/manager of this YourPie (Kevin) actively interacts with his patrons and is very responsive to their comments and suggestions. I highly recommend! read more

Delicious pizza, fresh ingredients, lots of choices! I got both a white and a red pizza, wife and I split each. Both were perfectly cooked, and very tasty! The staff were all very nice, good beer. Selection and lots of TV's! Good outdoor seating area for the spring too. Will definitely be back!! read more

Great new place in Lumberton. Good pizza and good beer selection! Would highly recommend to people. Staff is very nice and helpful!

Now I've only been once but about to head back there for a pie and beer. But first time we all had a pie and it was very good. And the pie maker was not scared to put in meat on the pie. Can't give 5 stars till I've been there a few more times but will be updating this soon. read more

While staying at the Springhill suites next-door my husband and I picked up two pizzas that were prepared quickly and tasted great. Side salad were good too. read more

This pizza was mediocre. The bbq was the worst bbq I've ever had. Never coming here again. If you do choose to come, get the marinara.

Great pizza. And very friendly and attentive staff. We're already planning to come back when we pass through on our way home from Florida next year. One suggestion: better signage-- we had a hard time finding it from Fayetteville Rd. Tip: it shares a parking lot with the new Springs Hill Suites off Fayetteville Rd. So, go, pick your crust and toppings, and wait for a bit (not long) while enjoying a craft beer, wine, or soft drink and then eat the best pizza you've had for a long time. read more

Amazing pizza!!! Staff was very accommodating and pleasant. It is right next to the Springhill Suites.

Super clean (restaurant and bathrooms), super nice staff, and the pizzas..... omg, the pizzas were so fresh and delicious!! My husband had a lineage, and I had a vegan pizza that I built. We each loved our pizzas! Oh and lots of great outdoor seating. I highly recommend this restaurant! read more

Came in yesterday to order some pizza and I seen the staff ( multiple employees)was drinking alcohol at the bar , like it was totally fine the dough was so hard i had to stand in the line for 5 minutes wouldn't recommend coming here read more

The food was amazing!!!! I did a vegan version of the Ischia pizza (I did a build your own but used vegan cheese). IT WAS SO GOOD! It measures up pretty well against other fast food pizza places. read more

Fun place! There is a large selection of craft draft beer and the pizza is delicious. The staff is very friendly and accomodating. Highly recommended. read more

Great prices, yummy food, and the manager is awesome!!! A must go when visiting the lumberton area!

Here's the good! The pizza was amazing - fresh ingredients and priced just right. We thought it was going to perfect - live music and then........I would have given "Your Pie" five stars if they hadn't forgotten to make my husband's pie and then when we had to reorder his pizza and order my son's it took over 40 minutes just to order and even when it was finished I had to tell the workers it was finished. The manager just said"Sorry, it was very busy and chotic." Honestly, that was true but not an excuse to leave numerous people without their dinner and waiting a second time to order and wait again. We don't live here but I am hoping that this location gets more workers and trains them ( knowing what goes on vertain pies, having enough pizza markers for orders taken and finding a system to make sure people get what they ordered.) Locals should try this not on a Friday night - it's probably better when not so busy - ask the manager. read more

The is a fantastic place!! The best individual pizza made in a fire oven. Fresh ingredients as well as an assortment of toppings. A must try for you. read more

Great spot we found on the way home from the beach! We were craving pizza and found on Yelp!! Yay Yelp didn't disappoint once again!! Great selection of craft beer and the pizza is made to order and put in the oven right in front of you!! Sooo delicious- southern heat was my favorite of their classics! read more

Placed an online order. Says it would be ready in 40 minutes. Arrived about 10 minutes early and waited. It took a little longer than originally stated. Pizza was good, cheese sticks were a bit too dark on the bottoms and you could taste it. Biggest disappointment was that we ordered the family pack which was suppose to come with 4 brownies but instead we had 2 extra cheese pizzas when we got back to our room and no brownies. Definitely double check your pick up orders before leaving. read more

The food is awesome. The staff is friendly. Butter pecan gelato was yummy! Will definitely be back!!

Wow. This place is legit. Not only is the store In Itself a nice setup the pizza is amazing. We got the keto pizza with cauliflower crust, it was great. Awesome flavors, honestly this place crushers blaze pizza by a mile. read more