Your Pie Pizza

Good Pub food, good polite service Clean and attractive…read moreambiance Plenty of street parking.

1st time in Lumberton and stopped for lunch. What a pleasant surprise! This place is a treasure-…read morebar, wine bar, small bites & more. An eclectic atmosphere with pottery, jewelry, and paintings all by local artists. Annette, the owner decided to do this in her retirement. If you're passing through and Lumberton is on the way it's worth the stop.

Seat at the bar!

Blue cheese Burger and salad

See all

Adelio's Restaurant

4.2(126 reviews)

3.7 mi

We like to have the calzones from this site. They have a great selection of Italian items. Great…read moretakeout and Great Service.

Food was good however the Parmesan cheese on the table was molded. On the table next to us was…read moremolded as well. They stated someone forgot to put it away the night before. My husband had to ask that his meal be remade since he sprinkled the cheese on his plate. Finally the owner brought out fresh on a plate.

Dining area, bar in the background

Shrimp Bruschetta

See all

Main dining area

Alberto’s Greek Food

5.0(5 reviews)

3.8 mi

Never disappointed whenever I've had their food. Very generous portions that are tasty. Had both…read morethe lamb gyro and the lamb Greek salad which has become my favorite. They are friendly and very customer oriented. Service is very quick.

Everything was delicious! Spotted this food truck while leaving the library. I decided to come…read moreback to this area a few days later to try it out. Worth revisiting again! Gyro was stuffed with lamb and a good side of fries. Grape leaves were so good and came with tzatziki sauce. Quite Affordable for much food. Big plus!

New Food Truck located downtown

American Cheeseburger with fries special. Great grade of Hamburger meat.

See all

Lunch Special Chicken. Also includes pita bread.

Pier 41 Seafood

4.2(171 reviews)

2.8 mi

What an awesome place to visit, large parking and huge dining area. Service was quick and constant,…read morehushpuppies and drinks from the start. Very large menu but we couldn't resist the seafood! Shrimp was perfect calabash style, oysters and fish cooked just right. Servings were very big and the prices were very fair! Had much more to list but the truth is it was all 5 star comments from everyone. Our server was incredible, always pleasant and kept our glasses full. Saturday afternoon, busy but not too bad. Visit Pier 41 with confidence, it doesn't disappoint!

Dined here this past weekend with some family and everyone loved their food! Our server was super…read moreaccommodating and so attentive. We all ordered various seafood dishes including fried oysters, scallops, flounder, shrimp, and deviled crab. All of the seafood was fresh and served piping hot. The baked potato was cooked perfectly as well as the fries. The hush puppies here are some of the best I've had in NC, crispy and delicious! We arrived shortly after opening on Sunday and it didn't take long for the restaurant to fill up yet our service never suffered. We will definitely be back the next time we're in town.

See all

Arnolds-Good Times Great Food

4.0(162 reviews)

2.0 mi

Received a recommendation from the hotel to visit this local restaurant, and it definitely lived up…read moreto expectations. My husband is a wing connoisseur, and he ordered the 10-piece naked wings in buffalo sauce, and I decided to try the frogs leg. Both were excellent appetizers, and we ordered the Philly cheesesteak with sweet potato fries, and a shrimp quesadilla. Hubby loved his cheesesteak, and I can honestly say that the shrimp quesadilla was the best one I've ever had. We noticed lots of families eating and the waiter we had was terrific. We would definitely stop again if in the area. Only thing missing is Yuengling beer on tap - only got one in a bottle.

Not being from the area we basically flipped a coin while choosing a restaurant for dinner, there's…read morenothing like ordering and eating the daily special while listening to some head banging tunes from Nirvana and Metallica at a volume that drowns out the staff - but we got through it which is more than I can say for the meal. Our server Annie was outstanding, very friendly and attentive if I were just reviewing the service this would be a five star review the only thing she miss was she charged me a credit card fee even though I paid cash, unfortunately the kitchen staff isn't doing this restaurant any favors the frozen from a box preparations give even old greasy bar food a good name. We started with the fried chicken skin appetizer which are delicious if you've ever had them prepared fresh by a chef instead of previously frozen from a short order cook with little to no training, they were horrible if I had only one request it would be to remove these from the menu. After going back and forth we both decided to order the Thursday Night Special - a fried Katfish fillet, fried pop-corn shrimp, fries and plenty of grease with a side of pre-portioned coleslaw - I have no words for this mess I think the cook dumped everything straight from the fryer to the plate without letting the old grease drain back into the fryer. I may be a little harsh on the kitchen but they have issues and if any of them noticed we ate very little of anything plated here and passed on the slaw. Fortunately we were just passing through so we don't have to return here or blame it on "they were just having a bad day" I could of spent my dough on losing lottery tickets and would have been happier, the food here gets a do not recommend...

Upstairs view

See all

Panera Bread

3.0(68 reviews)

0.4 mi

Good morning I had stop by couple days from visit Myrtle beach ,sc and the cashier Stenajah told me…read moreI can call her najah she was very nice and very sweet and the dishwasher lady kina was very nice take my dishes away from the table and nice to other customers and she was very patient with wait on other with there dishes and who ever made the salad for me was very good and I heard it was someone with a j but im not sure and also it was very clean and I look forward to visit again

Great food options for a good price. Great service. Clean establishment. Friendly ambiance.read more

Hearty Fireside Chili & Rustic Baked Potato Soup

Kickin' Grilled Cheese & Creamy Tomato Soup Value Duet

See all

New Sandwiches

Haleigh’s Diner

4.5(30 reviews)

0.5 mi

Fantastic food, service, and owner…read more I stopped by Lumberton to get a glazed croissant from Cakes and Pastries. To my disappointment, they were closed until New Years. Oh no! When I stumbled upon the perfect 5 stars hovering over this place, I knew I just had to check it out. I am so glad that I did. You walk in and are greeted by an open kitchen, red and black decor, and a wall pasted with numerous family memorabilia. Haleigh, as it turns out, is the owner Mike's granddaughter. If you see Mike, he'll treat you like an old friend. Man, the life he has lived! I ordered the BLT with some tater tots. Sorry folks, healthy options are scarce to find here! This is, after all, a diner. The BLT came out in about 8 minutes, and it was a beauty. Cooked on Texas toast with clearly fresh ingredients, the BLT was sensational. The tots, alongside the house sauce, were an inspired addition to the BLT meal. The owner swears that everything is FRESH and HOMEMADE. These are novel concepts for many diners nowadays. This will become a regular stop on I-95. The exit is 22 in N.C. Come to Haleigh's Diner for some truly next-level food and service at a LOCAL and FAMILY-RUN business.

We were headed down 95 and this was a great spot to stop for a quick lunch that wasn't a fast food…read morechain. The service was friendly and the food came out fast. The menu isn't huge, but they had a decent variety, and the prices were super reasonable. I went with their Zach burger with fries and was not disappointing. My friend ordered their homemade chicken salad and she really enjoyed it as well. Overall a great a solid spot for a quick, affordable lunch, with friendly service.

Sandwiches

Chocolate banana swirl bread

See all

Drink station

Fox's Pizza Den - Lumberton

3.8(4 reviews)

1.9 mi

Amazing! You can tell they use fresh, quality ingredients. I love how crispy the pepperoni was I…read moream particular with my pizza and really loved theirs! The salad was also yum and the homemade ranch. A plus- service was also great! Everyone was nice and very helpful. Go try it. Do it.

We tried out the new Fox's Pizza Den in Lumberton. We went with the hope of finding our new…read morefavorite pizza spot. We were greeted by smiling faces upon entry and were given menus. We ordered 2 16" pizzas, one Deluxe and one Deluxe Meat. As you can see in the photo the toppings were not skimpy and the crust was not burnt. That's where the good ends. The topping were not fresh but either out of a can or previously frozen. This pizza is in the same category as any other pizza chain restaurant. This Fox will continue the quest to find a decent pizza spot in Lumberton.

See all

Thai Chili

4.3(134 reviews)

2.8 mi

Yummy! Tons of menu options, including $9.99 lunch weekday special…read more Tofu noodle soup was good. The drunken noodles also super good. A happy pit stop on a long drive! Seat yourself, server comes to you, pay at the counter after. There is a parking lot.

Great Thai food! I especially enjoy their noodle dishes and their Thai curries. They also have…read moregreat lunch specials. For great food and friendly service, this is one of the best local places.

Drunken noodles with chicken

Vegetarian Pad See Ew with Tofu

See all

Vegetarian (vegan) Yellow Curry with tofu

Ruby Tuesday

3.1(75 reviews)

0.6 mi

Really fresh salad bar and the grilled salmon entree is really good! This is my third day in a row…read morehere and I shall be back again.

My fiancé and I both ordered the burger. I got a bacon cheeseburger and I received it with no bacon…read moreand barely any fries. They brought some more bacon out when I was almost done eating but it was cold to the touch. I would definitely not recommend them. We also both got the salad bar but the lady that was cleaning it was rude when I asked for a refill of ranch that was completely empty. Our waitress was friendly. It is however nicely decorated for a nice date night.

Bar

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

3 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Carrie S.

7 years ago

Stopped for a late lunch while traveling on I-95. Was an easy stop from the interstate and good healthy choices for all. We had two pizzas, a panini and a salad and the options worked for everyone. It was great to have a vegan cheese option. Staff was lovely and food was good. We will be back. read more

Nicole R.

3 years ago

The pizzas are DELICIOUS. I wish they had more locations throughout the county/state. The restaurant is nice and clean, I appreciate that they offer outdoor seating. read more

T T.

4 years ago

absolutely worse pizza ever..... don't waste your money. Manager rude also

Your Pie Pizza - pizza - Updated October 2026

Browse Nearby

BEST of Lumberton, North Carolina Restaurants near Your Pie Pizza

BEST of Lumberton, North Carolina Coffee near Your Pie Pizza

BEST of Lumberton, North Carolina Things to Do near Your Pie Pizza

BEST of Lumberton, North Carolina Desserts near Your Pie Pizza

BEST of Lumberton, North Carolina Parking near Your Pie Pizza

BEST of Lumberton, North Carolina Breakfast near Your Pie Pizza

BEST of Lumberton, North Carolina Dinner near Your Pie Pizza

BEST of Lumberton, North Carolina Burgers near Your Pie Pizza

BEST of Lumberton, North Carolina Shopping near Your Pie Pizza

BEST of Lumberton, North Carolina Movie Theatre near Your Pie Pizza

Best of Lumberton

Things to do in Lumberton

Browse Brands

Brands by name

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed Your Pie Pizza also viewed

Tuscany NY Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria

4.6

(19 reviews)

This is the best pizza in Lumberton. I ordered online for delivery and was definitely not…read moredisappointed. You can tell it is made with quality ingredients

Pizza was really good. The dough was fluffy but cooked well. Definitely a hole in the wall location…read morebut was a great find and would definitely recommend.

Bravo Pleasant Pizza

3.6

(58 reviews)

Four stars? I'd give them five if I had personally been here but four will have to do based on what…read moreI have experienced so far. I currently reside in Japan, and was looking for a good pizza place for my sister and brother-in-law to enjoy a slice and have a beer together as a little gift. First thing I did was make a phone call to figure out what their menu pricing is and a very friendly woman answered the phone and told me what specials they have, about how much pizza cost on average, and told me about their beer options. Even from another country she provided all of the information and took care of my needs, all the while, was extremely friendly. All the information I was given matched up with exactly what I was looking for and more, since this place is much nicer on the inside than your average pizza place. My sister and brother-in-law went there last night for dinner and had a fantastic time together. They took photos of the food and beer to share their excitement and cannot stop raving about how delicious everything was. I cannot thank Bravo Pleasant Pizza enough for their excellent service and for providing exactly what I was hoping for, for my family.

One of my favorite restaurants in town for over 15 years! My absolute favorite is the pepper…read moresteak sub, which I highly recommend. The House Special Pizza is my 2nd favorite if I shall ever switch up. I love the sausage. No wait at 11 am and not bad to eat alone if you're not in a crowd. Only once I've had an inconsistency in my sub. Owner was hard to reach but later he apologized and made things better in his own way. He has shown more compassion for customers when mistakes happen not just regulars he's seen over the years. This spot is a town favorite. Highly recommend. Nice atmosphere with tons of Greek Decor collected by owner Yannis throughout the years.

Fox's Pizza Den - Lumberton

3.8

(4 reviews)

Thomas' Pizza & Subs

3.7

(31 reviews)

I eat here often, and think they have the best subs in town! I love their super, italian, or turkey…read moresub! They have great salads and the friend chicken is AMAZING!!!

Very disappointing experience. I walked in right at 8:00 PM to be seated, even though the…read morerestaurant doesn't close until 9:00 PM. I stood at the front for several minutes while the employees just watched me without saying anything. Finally, someone asked if I was planning to sit down and eat, and when I said yes, I was told they had already closed the dining room for the night. If you're open until 9:00 PM, customers should be able to expect service before closing. Being ignored and then turned away an entire hour before closing was extremely unprofessional and disappointing.

Arnolds-Good Times Great Food

4.0

(162 reviews)

Red's Smoked & Smashed

4.7

(18 reviews)

Absolutely the best burger I've had in a long time. A…read morefriend was recommending this yesterday and I tried it this morning 2006 August 5th. I will be back over and over I can't imagine getting a burger from anywhere else. Not even comparable to fast food joints or even steakhouse burgers. Very well done.

I was looking forward to eating some bbq here but was sadly disappointed. We went on a Friday night…read morearound 7pm and the place was empty. There was s few pickup orders while we were there. The place was simple and clean. We went to the counter and asked to see a menu. Surprising but they only have one bbq pork sandwich on the whole menu. So I asked if the cook made it himself and was it smoked bbq. We were honestly told he used to smoke ot but no longer does. We saw a few crockpots in the kitchen and decided not to eat there. My suggestion would be to remove the smoked from the name as it's hugely misleading if you don't smoke your own pork and only have 1 bbq sandwich on the menu.

Giorgio's Restaurant and Pizza

3.8

(76 reviews)

Good Pub food, good polite service Clean and attractive…read moreambiance Plenty of parking. Good music selection

Came here on a Saturday night, and it would have been a 20-minute wait, but there was seating…read moreoutside. It was a perfect night to eat in the open air, unless you're downwind from a lady standing near the entrance smoking a cigarette , which we were, unfortunately. After we got our drinks, we waited at least 30 minutes to get our food, but we appreciated the update from one of the servers. We never did get the waters we asked for, but our pizza and chicken Gorgonzola were excellent...even on the wobbly table from which we ate! Our server was working her tail off, because according to another server, they were short three people. This place is a staple in Etown, and it will most likely be around for a long to come.

Jersey Mike's Subs

3.4

(22 reviews)

Always fresh and amazing food. Staff is always friendly and the store is always clean.read more

I spent $30 dollars on two subs and had to use the magnifier app on my phone to find the meat…read more PATHETIC also ordered Mikes way add pickles and banana peppers, but they could not be bothered to even get that right. Sadly, just another time of lousy service. Hadn't ordered here in months because they couldn't get order right. Wanted them to finally succeed, but alas failure is the main item on their menu.

Adelio's Express

3.8

(8 reviews)

Nice little gem tucked into a mall off the beaten path. We were looking for a light lunch salad,…read moreand gave this place a try. We ordered the Greek salad with gyro meat, a gyro "all the way", and a cheese burger "all the way" which came with fries. The salad wash fresh and plentiful with all the typical Greek ingredients. The gyro meat was warm, tasty and plentiful. The salad had a LOT of Greek salad dressing on it, so you might want to ask for it on the side. The gyro was huge with a thick layer of sliced meat at the bottom and a bunch of toppings. The pita was warm and it all meshed together very well. It's one of the best I've had in a while. The Cheeseburger had cheese, chili, chopped onions, pickles, ketchup, and mustard and was tasty. The fries were hot and seasoned. Everything seemed fresh and was prepared in front of us. We would stop there again if we are passing though.

smallest cheesesteak I've ever had, then 80 cents for a small cup of ranch. I would not recommend…read moreeating here

The Peddler Steakhouse

3.7

(100 reviews)