Cancel

Open app

Search

Your Pie Pizza

4.1 (88 reviews)
Closed • 11:00 am - 9:00 pm

About Your Pie Pizza

Loading...

Read the full summary in the app

Order Your Pie Pizza Takeout or Delivery

Your Pie Pizza Photos

Business Info

YOUR PIE PIZZA ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?
Casual
Trendy
Outdoor seating
Dogs allowed

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Your Pie Pizza

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Nice clean casual stop right off of 95. We had a cheese pizza and a sandwich (sort of like a calzone but open on the edges). Both were really good and we're from NY so we definitely know a good pizza. Prices were very reasonable and we enjoyed everything very much. Definitely a nice change from the usual fast meal while you're traveling.

Dodie H.

Stopped here on the way to FL. First time visiting a Your Pie Pizza and it didnt disappoint. They have other things besides pizza like wings, salads and ice cream. The hubs ordered a pepperoni pizza and I ordered a greek salad. The pizza is a thin crust pizza. The Greek salad on the menu doesn't include meat but you have the option of adding a meat. My protein of choice was chicken. Both meals were delicious. The cost for our meals and drinks was $29.93. The atmosphere is casual. The staff were really friendly and the restaurant was clean. We would definitely stop in again if in the area.

Here is my receipt
Marti H.

After driving all day I did not want to get back in my car. I read RAVE reviews about this place so I thought I would place an order for delivery. Through their website I ordered a personal pizza, Greek side salad and Dr Pepper. ($19 + $5 delivery fee + $5 tip) When checking out it said my order will be delivered by DoorDash. I received a text that said my order would arrive by 8:28 (I am 1/2 mile away) It arrived at 8:50. I was handed an EMPTY cup, a wilted Cesar salad without dressing, and a pizza. I showed the receipt that said Dr Pepper, and also Greek salad. He just looked at me, and shrugged his shoulders. I get up to my room, open the pizza box and it is a cold pizza with burnt crust. I am beyond disappointed in every way. I tried to call the restaurant but was put on hold, I sent an email. We will see how this gets

Honey hot wings

If you want some good wings these are the best in Lumberton. The honey hot wings are WONDERFUL. I have not had good wings in lumberton so far until now.

Takaiya G.

Just stopping in. We had a 7 in pizza which wasn't bad, just we got it thin and it was super thin. The service was petty fast. The ambiance is quiet. If you in the area, come on by.

Audra H.

First time at this restaurant, I walked in and stood in front of two people behind the counter for what seemed to be 5 min. I asked them if this is where I order and the guy in the NY hat jumped at me saying he had other pizzas to make before mine. Finally an employee on the new shift asked me if he could help me. He was really nice and took my order and explained the menu. When I got to the register to pay I ordered my drink and my nice guy that took my order for a phone call and he said he had to take it. Another guy helped me pay. My drink was never brought to me so when my pizza was delivered I asked for my drink. He proceeded to tell another girl that was sweeping the floor. It took her a couple of min. To get around to bring me my drink. I guess sweeping the floor was more important. The pizza is good too bad the service sucks. I will be staying at the hotel behind for quite a while and this pizza place will not get my business.

Build your own pie w/pesto pepperoni and mushroom
Kriss D.

Stopped into grab some lunch with a friend! The pizza was great! I got the build your own with pesto, pepperoni and mushroom. The salads were a little sad with very little lettuce for the price but overall the experience was great!

Menu
Ward D.

A Great place for a real pizza designed by you and cooked right there. According to Wikipedia this restaurant chain "... is an American fast-casual pizza concept, that was started in Athens, Georgia in 2008 by Drew French, and operates as a restaurant franchise with 70 locations across 19 states. Your Pie has customizable 10-inch pizzas, pasta bowls, and salads. The restaurant uses brick ovens to cook their pizzas.[1] Gelato (Italian ice cream), craft beer, and wine are also available." This particular site is located right off the main street. It is very nice inside. It has a polished concrete floor with a clean look and lots of 2-person tables The menu is displayed on the wall next to the counter where you place your order. The neat thing is you get to watch them make your pizza and put it in the oven. And the pizza they made for me was excellent. It came out in about 5-7 minutes. There is an eating area inside and an outside patio. I highly recommend this place to fellow travelers hungry for pizza in the Lumberton area. The price for a single 14-inch pie was $18 which may be a little high but for the price, service, and taste, I thought it was well worth it.

The Nat on Cauliflower Keto Crust

See all

6 years ago

When I visited on Wednesday Liz was very rude, however Rachel was amazing!

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Jon G.
16
8
1

6 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Bob R.
0
10
0

7 years ago

Business owner information

Photo of Kevin F.

Kevin F.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 1

6 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

7 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

7 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

7 years ago

The food is great! The cauliflower crust is to die for. Atmosphere is amazing, and Kevin and Ashton make it all worth it!!

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

7 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Page 3 of 3

Ask the Community - Your Pie Pizza

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Pizza 152 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Arnolds-Good Times Great Food

Arnolds-Good Times Great Food

4.0(162 reviews)
2.0 mi
•$

Received a recommendation from the hotel to visit this local restaurant, and it definitely lived up…read moreto expectations. My husband is a wing connoisseur, and he ordered the 10-piece naked wings in buffalo sauce, and I decided to try the frogs leg. Both were excellent appetizers, and we ordered the Philly cheesesteak with sweet potato fries, and a shrimp quesadilla. Hubby loved his cheesesteak, and I can honestly say that the shrimp quesadilla was the best one I've ever had. We noticed lots of families eating and the waiter we had was terrific. We would definitely stop again if in the area. Only thing missing is Yuengling beer on tap - only got one in a bottle.

Immediately get a table, waitress came up and took our drink orders and didn't come back for…read more10mins. My husband asked about our drinks and she wanted to know if we wanted an appetizer. Same question she asked when she got our drink order. She then served two more tables before getting our drinks. Finally we got our drinks ! Time for the food. Told her what we wanted ( simple order) told her I wanted plain grill chicken. Nothing on it. Had to get up for us to get refills waitress continued to walk back and avoid our table. When the food finally came it made chicken was covered in onions. I waited for our waitress to ask for a knife, my husband finally flagged another waitress down and asked for one. She didn't get me one either. I finally had to get up again and go to the front to ask for a knife where I was told they had to wash one. Finally got a knife. Cut open my chicken and the thick portion was pink. Needless to say I didn't eat it. BTW there were empty tables everywhere. They weren't busy at all. I could understand about some of this if they were. She was literally tending to 4 tables. No excuse for pink chicken.

Photos
Arnolds-Good Times Great Food - Upstairs view

Upstairs view

Arnolds-Good Times Great Food
Arnolds-Good Times Great Food

See all

Haleigh’s Diner - Entrées

Haleigh’s Diner

4.5(30 reviews)
0.5 mi

Fantastic food, service, and owner…read more I stopped by Lumberton to get a glazed croissant from Cakes and Pastries. To my disappointment, they were closed until New Years. Oh no! When I stumbled upon the perfect 5 stars hovering over this place, I knew I just had to check it out. I am so glad that I did. You walk in and are greeted by an open kitchen, red and black decor, and a wall pasted with numerous family memorabilia. Haleigh, as it turns out, is the owner Mike's granddaughter. If you see Mike, he'll treat you like an old friend. Man, the life he has lived! I ordered the BLT with some tater tots. Sorry folks, healthy options are scarce to find here! This is, after all, a diner. The BLT came out in about 8 minutes, and it was a beauty. Cooked on Texas toast with clearly fresh ingredients, the BLT was sensational. The tots, alongside the house sauce, were an inspired addition to the BLT meal. The owner swears that everything is FRESH and HOMEMADE. These are novel concepts for many diners nowadays. This will become a regular stop on I-95. The exit is 22 in N.C. Come to Haleigh's Diner for some truly next-level food and service at a LOCAL and FAMILY-RUN business.

We were headed down 95 and this was a great spot to stop for a quick lunch that wasn't a fast food…read morechain. The service was friendly and the food came out fast. The menu isn't huge, but they had a decent variety, and the prices were super reasonable. I went with their Zach burger with fries and was not disappointing. My friend ordered their homemade chicken salad and she really enjoyed it as well. Overall a great a solid spot for a quick, affordable lunch, with friendly service.

Photos
Haleigh’s Diner - Sandwiches

Sandwiches

Haleigh’s Diner - Chocolate banana swirl bread

Chocolate banana swirl bread

Haleigh’s Diner - Drink station

See all

Drink station

Your Pie Pizza - pizza - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...