I've been going to Gallagher's pizza since it 1st opened. Throughout the years, moving from the West side to Suamico location or beyond, their food has been the same, delicious, consistently "traditional" to their inception food we've always loved. Not only that, but where other places have increased prices, I can still order my favorite: cheese ravioli in marinara sauce, for $10.99. They have the BEST mozzarella sticks!! Garlic bread? Chef's kiss! My daughter loves their chicken fettuccine alfredo. It's her go to. Their sauce, delicious! I always ask for more. I also love they have had the same promo going on since time began. read more

Ordered 4 lunches yesterday to go and they were all perfectly prepared and piping hot not to mention delicious as always! Pick up always easy and staff is friendly! read more

Food was sub par. Went there on a Saturday. Not a lot of folks, later in the PM. "Chef" from the back was making himself a mixed drink with an isolated bottle of rum close to the drink prep area. Not a well-run establishment from what we saw. read more

What an awesome addition to the Howard/Suamico area! Large selection on the menu, good drinks & great service! Definitely will be back!

Got take out while in town for an overnight stay. Hot, cheesy, and delicious. Ready for pick up quickly, even with 5 pizzas!

Bad service won't be coming back here. Family of 5 ate here last week 7/2023 Friday evening for the cod and shrimp buffet 20 minutes before close. (5-8) The worker said that we could continue to eat after 8 and they'd leave everything out, they just wouldn't bring anymore food out after 8. The whole time we were eating they didn't bring more food out which was slightly annoying but fine whatever, but like 5 minutes after a worker came up and told us they needed to close the buffet because kitchen workers wanted to go home. At this point we're annoyed and upset because we would not have done the buffet if we had known they'd be shutting it down. When she told us this hubs was bringing one of the kids up already so they grabbed their plates and then when they sat down the workers were already shutting down the buffet. So they didn't even check with us to see if we were done grabbing what we wanted. 25 minutes seems like enough time to eat and fill up but getting two kids and a newborn settled and was hardly enough time for me and my husband to get our fill. Took forever to get service after that too, we wanted a refill on one drink and our server didn't come by until she asked if we wanted our check. She seemed to only be interacting and doing stuff for the guy at the bar. A separate occasion we ordered a taco pizza and wasn't too impressed, very salty and didn't taste very taco-ey. read more

Awesome place for buffet fast and friendly. Love all the wing ding except the boneless ones . Close to home .

Have had the lunch buffet twice. It's just alright. Not bad for what you pay. Service is great on the other hand. Food is just okay. Wings at the buffet are a must. read more

Hey Guys, you nailed it tonight and exceeded my expectations. I was holed up in the hotel next door for work and saw your place when I arrived. I wasn't familiar with the area and didn't feel like going out. I called up and order a sausage classic. From the time I called until it was delivered to my hotel door was 17 minutes. The pizza, was super, great, fantastic! I had to give it 5 minutes to cool down is was so hot. I'm a pizza guy and the pizza looked really good, and tasted even better! Hats off to you and your staff, from the gal who took my order, your delivery person and your cooks. You surprised me and was very impressed! Great job! read more

I ordered a delivery to come to my parents' house in Suamico when I was home visiting. There was a mix-up and the address they had was wrong, so my order ended up getting fulfilled at the DePere location and sent to a hotel out there! Once they realized what happened, people from both locations--in Howard and DePere--called to apologize and to make sure everything was cleared up so I would get my order. They prepared a new order for me really quickly and even gave me a discount to apologize. Super nice and friendly service and they worked hard to clear up an honest mistake. We received very tasty pizza and fish fry after that! Would highly recommend. read more

First off, this food is highly over rated. It's like a family owned WI thing where everyone supports this restaurant because it's family and farmers unite in beer, and extremely subpar pizza. I get it. But if you think you are about to get some sort of amazing, delicious, must have pizza, please do not waste your time or hard earned money. The crust, dry. The sauce, spicy, but flavorless (I know, what does that mean ... I wish I could explain better), the cheese, wet/greasy and pulls off in one bite. Next, the staff. It's getting hard to accept that we can't find good workers. Find the right people and do a better job of training them and grooming them. Having staff that act entitled and full of attitude does not sit well with me or any normal human being. I hate to say this, but spare the disappointment, save money, and grab a Little Caesar's or any chain pizza as it will be a guaranteed a 10 out of 10 in comparison. read more

Great take out. I called in my order for a medium pepperoni classic on thin crust. The wait was 20 min so I headed there from the fishing hole. I was ahead of schedule so I stopped at Festivals bakery for cookies for the kids. The pizza was hot!! It was delicious too. read more

Totally delicious Great delivery and great people Some things you can tell that frozen I'm not doing a bad review I think they could use some approvements I'm not telling them what to do read more

One of the nicer gallagher's in town (prob because it is new). I wish the had the buffet more than just mondays. I would recommend that. Salad, rotating pizzas, wings, pasta, soups, etc. A full line up (not just pizza) for $10 read more

All in all really good food as always just like there other locations, the new location is very nice inside BUT the phone rings constantly & becomes very obnoxious, I'm not sure if the ringer is all the way up but that's all you hear when eating here. Lastly the service is good but it's a bit messy yet which I can understand due to it just opening up. read more

The pizza has gone way downhill. Ordered a pan and garlic cheese bread. The pizza had cut up super spicy sausage when I ordered plain old Italian sausage, the crust was swimming in a wet greasy slurry which made it soggy and gross, the cheese was not melted all the way. Would have been better with a frozen cardboard pizza from the grocery store. Give this place a hard pass in the future. read more

1st time @ any Gallaghers. We visited Lineville Rd tonight. Waiter Travis did an excellent job, was courteous and on his game. He gets a "very well done" note here. We had the classic 14", thin crust. Pizza was fine, just not our cup of tea as we are so used to our fav in GB we have been a fan of for 4 decades so yes we are already branded on our fav and we were just too tired to drive in to town tonight. Noticed many customers enjoying your pizza though while we were there dining so you have a great product obviously and repeat business. We compliment Gallaghers on the fine decorating and cleanliness and ambience. btw, I loved the creamsickle colored floor in the mens washroom. Never walked on one like that before. We hope you folks do well here in Howard/Suamico. Good location and lottsa parking. Notice you deliver now so I bet you will be doing a lot of that too! We'll be back for cocktails on a snowy night as the bar looked so warm and inviting and your staff all were wearing smiles! read more

The only thing more disappointing than our pizza from Gallagher's this evening was the reaction from the manager, Travis, when I called to let them know the pizza wasn't up to Gallagher's standards.... correction, their prior standards. We ordered an 18" with 3 toppings and paid $27.16. The toppings were sparse all over but my complaint is that there were NO toppings within 2-3" of the edge all around. Several slices literally had zero toppings on them. When I called the restaurant, Travis answered. I was calm and feel I was quite professional, this is just a pizza, no reason to get upset. Travis made me repeat myself multiple times because he "didn't understand the problem". The problem is that I paid for an 18" pizza but received the ingredients for a much smaller one, Travis. He did not care. Eventually he mumbled "Uh, yeah, I'm sorry about that". Unless this restaurant gets some management training for their kitchen and personnel, don't waste your money. read more

As an update to our previous review, we ordered from the Suamico Gallagher's Pizza for a crew working at our house today. It was perfect. The customer service was outstanding, they went above and beyond, taking our order even before they were technically open, the pizza was incredibly delicious, hot and perfectly made. All we can say is way to go Staff at Suamico, you have knocked it out of the park and once again proven that Gallagher's is the BEST! Thank you so much. read more

Tried Gallagher's for the first time! Loved our pizza! The waiter was excellent. all in all a good experience