Alright, here is the skinny on Andy's... If you want the…read morepizza to be AMAZING, not just good, you MUST order it "saucy" and with onions. Don't like onions? You'll like these ones. Unless you are straight up allergic to onions, they must be one of the toppings on your pizza. You can also count on Andy to deliver great wings, subs, and fried snacky bits. This is a dinner only, mostly takeout establishment. It's run by genuinely nice people who work to treat customers and community right. Definitely worth a visit.

I drive by this place once every couple weeks, and never even noticed it until a few weeks ago,…read moresince it's a small place, unassuming place, kind of off to the side and in the cut. Figured I'd stop in quick and grab a slice. Welp...they don't have slices! So instead I opted for a small meatball sub. Since Andy's doesn't have medium subs, only small and large, the "small" is actually more like a medium. It was fairly tasty and hit the spot. Pricing for their pizzas and subs is essentially on par with most local places that you'd find in Rochester or Buffalo. Hopefully I can stop in again to try more of their menu, although be aware that they are only open on evenings and not for lunch!

Best Pontillo's Pizza! Great wings. We go weekly. Local, friendly and close to home.read more

Pontillo's in Churchville is awesome! The staff is very friendly, the pizza is very well made, and…read morethe prices are fair and accurate to the website, unlike most other pizza places including other Pontillo's. It's easy to see they are honest and putting out quality to earn repeat business. They do not skimp on the toppings or any other part of the pie. It's worth the longer drive for the much higher quality experience.

I ordered a sweet sauce large cheese pepperoni and onion pizza! This was hands down one of the best…read morepizzas I've ever had! The service was amazing and it looks like they are doing some cosmetic changes inside the restaurant. The pi's was only $23! Dude that's an amazing price!! My new go too place for pizza!!

Stopped in for lunch with a friend and was a very enjoyable dine-in experience! a little busy…read morearound lunch hour! staff and customers were very pleasant! pizza with sweet sauce was excellent!!! even bought a couple jars of their sweet sauce to take home!!! highly recommend!!!

This was the place to go when I was growing up and it was known as Pontillo's. My God, it was…read moreblessed by the pizza gods. We returned home last week for a visit and agreed to meet our cousins here. It is said that the pizza holds true to the Pontillo's recipe and cooking time, etc. We ordered 2 large pies, both covered with pepperoni and assorted vegetables. Our sad thoughts driving back to the hotel were in agreement: the sauce and cheese were tasteless, the vegetables had no taste and were mostly uncooked, and the dough was soft and chewy. That made us wonder about the flour and other ingredients being used. Tasted cheap. That's not the quality pizza we remembered and used to brag about in pizza arguments. If you're from Batavia, let me know the best pizza joint in town. If you say this place I'll respect that. Maybe it was an off day?

First time here and Buffalo in general. Saw boxes of their pizza in our place of work that's why we…read morecame here. If locals order from thsi place and see them enjoy the food, we thought it might be good. Plenty of parking and on a Wednesday, very busy compared to other restaurants we have seen in the area. The server was bubbly and kept on checking on us. I enjoyed the pizza

Stopped by here for the first time on on my way to an event in Buffalo with some friends. We had…read moreheard good things and definitely weren't disappointed. Great prices Great selection Darts Plenty of seating and TV's to enjoy a game and drink with friends Conveniently attached to a pizzeria We honestly had a GREAT time. It's a comfortable local place with some great views out the back bay window of Tonawanda creek that are definitely worth the visit to enjoy while downing a few ice cold beers.

We go by Jim's saloon when running errands in Batavia. Stopped in on a Saturday, good crowd, great…read moreprices. Had a beer and the kind bartender said they had fifty can't wings Wednesday and Saturday. She said we could order any amount we want. Placed an order for 10 wings. She said they would do any number of sauces we wanted. Tried the sweet hot and the garlic parmesan hot. Some of the best wings we ever had, give Jim's a try for great wings!

Great breakfast sandwiches and fish fries! They are a hidden gem! We love getting food from here…read more You can't go wrong with fish fries, breakfast pizza, sandwich's, pizza, and wings!

First time sitting on the pizzeria side. They seem to be sitting a lot over here tonight…read more Service was good. Ravioli were delicious. It's a lot quieter on this side lol

This is my favorite pizza in Batavia. After living here for a few years, this was my go-to spot. We…read morewere back in town for the day hanging out and decided we needed to get some pizza before we went home. We ended up getting a few things which were all delicious. We got a large cheese and pep pizza, some wings, fried mozzarella, and some fried dough bites for dessert. The pizza here has been great and the service is always pretty quick. They have two sides of the restaurant with takeout on one, and dining on the other. The dining room is gorgeous and has such a great vibe to it. It feels upscale, yet cozy. If you're in Batavia and need a pizza, Main Street is the place to go.

Amazing amazing pizza on a regular day and I gotta say taco pizza awesome you got it down girl…read moreamazing. Keep making that magic God bless.

We got some pepperoncini pizza and 12 each of BBQ and medium wings to take out. All the food was…read moregood, but their buffalo wing sauce was a little thin. The BBQ wings were fine. The round pizza was cut into squares, so be aware if you don't like that. The crust is also quite thick around the edges, but it was properly baked and not burned. There was a special which included a 2 liter of pop. The service at the counter was prompt and friendly. In addition they opened at 11am on Sunday, which is not always the case.

Great pizza and a really great prices. Lots of options are many, many overwhelming. Wings were…read moregood. A bit salty but solid. Hole in the wall place

I grew up in the 60s on Rosewood Terrace, close to where Nino's is on Culver Rd. I remember getting…read morepizza there in the 70s when Nino was running the place. I moved to Texas in '82 and only got back to Rochester a few years ago. I didn't realize Nino's was still in business till just recently. I stopped in there tonight and ordered an extra large Sicilian pie. Nino's son Jimmy is running it now. The place is a liite different inside but the pizza is as good as I remember...that marinara sauce is still the same, flavorful and slightly sweet, loaded with mozzarella and a very generous amount of fresh toppings, all at a very reasonable price. I've traveled the world since I've been gone, even to Italy, and I don't remember pizza better than this. I'm glad they are still around. If you're looking for a great Sicilian pie, look no farther then Nino's... Molto bene!

Stopped on a cross-country drive in Batavia and found this lively, delicious spot! So much more…read morethan pizza! Delicious menu, cocktails looked great but we had a long drive ahead. Maybe next time. Great service, lovely patio on a perfect summer evening!

My husband and I were craving veal Parm so we stopped in on a Friday around 4. All I can say is…read morenothing was as good as I expected from a boring little salad in a weird tilted bowl to fishy tasting lobster bisque. This stuffed peppers were decent but the vegetable itself was tasteless. The veal, which must have come from a teenaged cow was just short of nasty. Mine was folded over so only partailly breaded and looked like it had been put through a cuber! I had heard good things about this place but we won't be back.