Was driving through town recently and wanted a quick late afternoon snack…read more This place was exactly what I hoped it would be. The guy working the counter was friendly and welcoming. He still had a few slices left from lunch, so I grabbed one of those. It was excellent New York style thin crust. Perfect for an afternoon snack. Bathroom was clean, parking was easy, food was good, and the pizza chef was a cool dude. There's a few booths for seating indoors and, at least in the summer, two tables outside. I'll gladly stop here next time I'm in town and need a bite.

Great pizza , their "weird" sauce is really good. Always positive and friendly, definitely…read morerecommend trying a slice

Pizza was excellent! Owner was friendly and helpful,…read moreWould definitely recommend! I like that you could order different toppings on each half

I got their wings to go, they were good but I wish there was a little bit more sauce and they…read morecould've been a little bit crispier but other than that they were good. The restaurant is kind of small but they have seating, it was also a little chilly in there.

Good pizza, wings are usually good . Delivery available. They have a tendency to give attitude…read morewhich isn't necessary but the foods not bad

Very good food, always get the job done. It's the best pizza in the area. I drive 45 minutes just…read moreto get the pizza because I am very devoted to the flavor and the amazing crust. I hope more people will visit and see how great of a pizza shop they are!!

Yes Yes Yes, we love and can't say enough good things about this place. If you haven't taken the…read moreshort drive out to Cato and had this Pizza well you're definitely missing out. The first time I stopped here was on a Fluke, I was looking for a quick bite while working and all it took Was one time and I was hooked. I've gone several times now and I've never been disappointed,We've tried Cheese, pepperoni, chicken wing and Garlic pizza and all have been great. We've also had their wings they make them fresh and crispy. Large pepperoni and 20 wings $32.00 I've had the same in Mattydale for close to $47.00... Staff is super friendly, Food is great and the price are very fair. Take the drive you won't be disappointed...

I decided on a small cheese pizza and chargrilled wings with their "Jenny" sauce on the side. The…read morepizza was very good, there was a good amount of cheese and the sauce was tasty. I don't care for a thick crust (and this wasn't thick at all), but it was so thin that I actually wished it had a little more dough. It was very nicely cooked and I did enjoy it. The wings were chargrilled perfectly, and were very juicy inside. The Jenny sauce was okay, I found it was a bit lacking in flavor, for my taste. I'd definitely get the wings again and try a different sauce. It was very busy and the service was great. I'm looking forward to my next visit and trying one of their specialty pizzas!

Never been disappointed. Great pizza, Dirty Wings are the BEST!!! Garlic, feta, tomato pizza is…read moreour favorite. Service is always great. Everyone is very friendly.

Great slice of garlic, feta, tomato pizza already done and oven heated to perfection. Cold sub was…read morefresh and excellent. Very friendly staff. Winner, winner!

Needed a quick slice so stopped here. Inside of this place isn't very appealing. The pizza though…read moreis really good. The plain cheese was great. No flop and cooked to perfection. Nice sauce and cheese ratio. The Sicilian was average but not bad. It looks burnt in the picture but I like it that way. They had tons of flavors of pizza ready for their lunch rush. If you are in the area, try this place.

A charming mom & pop kind of place, with delicious pizza to feed a crowd! The kids are picky about…read moretheir pizza and asked for extra slices, gobbling them up. Our baby niece was overjoyed to gnaw on the crust, and cried whenever she ran out. The dough was pillowy soft, the crust was crispy, and it wasn't too greasy. If you're looking for a great local pizza place in Auburn, Amelia's is your place!

This review is for "Locals on the Lake" upstairs from "The Pizza Stop", same building restaurant…read morebar upstairs, takeout pizza downstairs. I'm telling you, the owner loves his business as the quality has not darkened in years... That is rare. So we ordered one of the new menu items (Chicken Parm, char broiled (bc my wife says I have to be healthy) and the meat lovers pizza with ricotta. AMAZING! We can't go there without ordering fresh pizza bc that is nirvana. The Chicken Parm did not need breading! Crusty and juicy, these people know what they are doing! And they make a lot of sauces there, the one with the Chicken Parm, was a perfect compliment to the HOMEMADE pasta and chicken. Drinks were generous and reasonable. Great service! Ya know what, I shouldn't be sharing this gem... Okay pay no attention!

Best pizza we've had since Lombardi's in NYC. Oven baked BUT it had the smokiness of a coal fired…read moreoven. Service was excellent. Laid back feel of a small American lake town.

Brand new pizza joint in Phelps. I just had a slice of pepperoni for lunch and it was delicious…read more They sport a thin New York style crust. Service ran smoothly for a new place that was pretty busy for lunch. They have indoor and outdoor seating as well as a separate arcade room with several different games.

In town and had to stop by. I am so glad we did. I was in the mood from some good wings and boy…read moredid this place deliver. These wings are life changing.