Caveat #1: Freshdirect is literally a lifesaver for me because I don't have a car up here in Westchester and it's not socially appropriate to ask other busy medical students to drive you to the grocery store.
Caveat #2: I have minimal arm strength and carrying 5+ lbs of groceries tires me out and makes me super cranky. Freshdirect delivers to my third-floor walkup. Score!
If there were a Trader Joe's or H-Mart on campus, would I be using FreshDirect? Definitely not. Since most people don't live within walking distance of one anyway, FreshDirect really wins for its incredible convenience, great customer service, farm-fresh, locally-sourced and good-quality meats & veggies, and awesome discounts and giveaways.
Is FreshDirect cheap? No, definitely not. If prices comes above all else, FreshDirect is not for you. If you're environment-conscious, quality-seeking, budget-conscious and flexible, however, you can make FreshDirect work. I've seen four heads of broccoli go for $4, cut-up whole chicken parts for $1/lb, two bunches of kale for $4 and great quality salmon for $6.99/lb. The FreshDirect brand actually offers pretty great quality and relatively low prices; my roommate was stunned by the quality of milk that I bought for her - "I've never had milk taste so good! I'm addicted to this milk [insert emoji with hearts for eyes]." (I'm not a milk drinker so I don't really know what she means, but she adores it. And she "spoils" herself by getting FreshDirect milk. I think that speaks to how good it is).
The other day, I asked my friend to get me skinless, boneless chicken thighs from Trader Joe's, thinking that they'd be cheaper. It turns out that they were $4/lb at TJ and $3.19/lb on FreshDirect (sale). Oops. So sometimes FreshDirect is actually cheaper! Crazy, huh?
They've done random giveaways in the past; I'm not sure how they work. This whole month, though, they've been doing giveaways every few days and they've been really great so far. I've gotten to try chobani flip yogurt, matcha love green tea, kale banana pineapple popsicles, quark - and more. :O
FreshDirect also supplies non-food household items - paper towels, lightbulbs, laundry detergent, etc. The 1-day shipping is amazing because it's even faster than Amazon Prime (and often cheaper, too). Definitely has been a lifesaver when I ran out of toilet paper. :x
Customer service is super responsive and really great (aka refunds, no questions asked). When my eggs broke a few times, they credited me immediately. The other day, I was surprised that my pre-sliced ribs ($12) were actually not pre-sliced - not a big deal, but I wanted to know what was up with the slicing because I'd rather not order non-sliced meat in the future. I emailed them and they promptly credited me.
Overall, I have zero complaints against FreshDirect. I have never had a messed up order and all of my food has been excellent quality (no spoilage or rottenness). The $30 minimum forces me to compile a grocery list for a week at a time, and the time that it sits in the cart allows me to reevaluate whether or not I really want those items. I find that I don't buy random things as often, and I've had much less food waste than I had in the past. I've ordered from FreshDirect over 30 times in the past 7 months and I'm really happy with my experience so far. I would definitely recommend it to anyone in grad school (or really, anyone with a busy schedule). There's no crazy check-out time, no wandering around all over a store looking for your groceries and price-comparison is a cinch with "sort by price." read more