Cancel

Open app

Search

Fresh Donut

4.1 (48 reviews)
Closed • 6:00 am - 1:00 pm

Order Fresh Donut Takeout or Delivery

Fresh Donut Photos

FRESH DONUT ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Fresh Donut

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Breakfast burrito
Brendan H.

Been here twice. I liked the tiny little breakfast burrito and a long John donut I got, and I also actually really liked the coffee I had on my first trip. The second time when I asked for a coffee they said that they are not serving coffee anymore at all. When I asked why, it was because someone said to them that it wasn't very good. So now they don't serve coffee at all at a donut shop??? When I'm ordering a donut at 7 AM, what drink do you think I want? Coffee! Even if it is very bad. Still give me the drink that I so require. Also gave me the wrong type of burrito, no big deal on that. Figure it out. When you do I will likely bump you to 5 stars. 6/22 Coffee is back. Tastes the same.

Donut Hole
Keenan T.

Most bakeries aren't able to do much for you in the last half hour before closing. This was a different experience. Large flaky donuts and a cinnamon roll were easy to get ahold of and were still warm when I got to the car. The donut holes were a perfect bite sized treat as well.

Selection of donuts at 6:30 on a Friday morning.
Brian F.

First time I came here was on a Saturday at 8am. The case was near empty of donuts, and there were 5 people in line. So I turned around and walked out as I saw no reason to wait to get no donuts. Second time was in a Friday at 6:30am. There was already a person ordering, and another person came in shortly after me. But most importantly, this time, there were plenty of donuts. Ordered a half dozen. The donuts were good, but their variety was lacking. Hopefully they can grow to a point where they don't run out of donuts in the morning, and have a wider variety of donuts.

Fresh outta the kitchen donut holes!!  (6/13/2021)
Gwen W.

7:11 Sunday morning - they open @ 5 AM, and there was 4 guests in line in front of me when I walked in. The owner was poppin out donuts as fast as possible, I will give them credit - you can only supply as fast as the donut making machine can cook em. I love the fact they open @ 5 AM every day. Supply is hit or miss based on how busy they are, obviously. To share with family I got a chocolate long John, 2 glazed, an apple fritter, one of their chocolate croissants for my mother, and 2 dozen fresh outta the back donut holes. Good holes - soft yet chewy, two thumbs up! Same for the tray of warm glazed (fresh outta the kitchen); yeast batter was cooked perfectly, and the glaze wasn't overtly sugarfied (a big personal turnoff!). I did take a bite of the Apple fritter, and it was actually quite good. A solid cinnamon , hints of apple, flavor. Crispy around a few of the edge spots, soft and chewy throughout, which made it perfect based on my personal criteria. I'll definitely keep this one on rotation (along with the holes) for future stops here. I did see their wrapped breakfast burritos in the casing, but no one got one during my time in the store. I'd like to take a peak under the wrapper, hopefully they're tasty - I don't really care about the "presentation", as breakfast is breakfast; as long as they're tasty, that's all that matters. I'm glad to see another breakfast option added to Pickerington, and one that's NOT a chain - that in of itself is worth several stars.

Small long John donuts
Godfather ..

This was my first time trying this place and it will be my last. I stopped in around 10:00AM to pick up something for a quick breakfast. They open at 6 and in 4 hours, they were sold out of just about everything in their display case. For a donut place they hardly had any donuts. All they had was a few sheet pans of mostly empty pans of donuts. When I asked the girl behind the counter if that was all they had, she said yes. I ended up getting some breakfast burritos for us to try and 2 rather small long John donuts. The breakfast burritos were not warm so we had to microwave them when I got home. They tasted just ok & not bad. Honestly we could have and have made bigger breakfast burritos at home. The donuts tasted just ok. The chocolate icing on top flaked off and made a mess. I'm not sure why their icing flaked off into pieces. Overall, I'll say don't waste your time trying this place out. What a big disappointment it was. A so called donut shop that's only open until 3:00pm that didn't hardly have a big selection of donuts available to choose from, isn't my idea of a donut shop. People do eat donuts after 3:00pm. I'm not sure this new place will last long with it being the way it was with hardly any donuts to choose from.

Great selection
Jacob S.

Stopped in around 7am on Tuesday morning, they had a great selection of baked goods. They also offer croissant sandwiches, and breakfast burritos. On this particular morning, I got a ham and cheese burrito and a cream filled long john and strawberry stick. I ate the burrito, it had great flavor and was filling, very reasonable prices. I gave the other two confections away. the feedback was great! fresh, fluffy dough, they even threw in donut holes for free! Overall, very impressed! I will be a repeat customer!

Long Johns

See all

Photo of Kim W.
69
4
1

4 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

5 years ago

Delicious!! We have tried this donut shop twice now and will keep going back. So happy to have such a great donut shop in Pickerington.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

5 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Tina B.
21
12
0

5 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

5 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

5 years ago

Great service and great food, fresh and tasty donuts and breakfast sandwich. We will definitely be return costumers.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of M S.
0
8
2

5 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

5 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Page 2 of 2

Ask the Community - Fresh Donut

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Donuts 490 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Porters Coffee House and Bakery - Fresh croissant with sausage, egg and cheese.  Yum

Porters Coffee House and Bakery

4.4(127 reviews)
2.1 mi
•$$

We were in the area and looking for a new coffee shop to try out. This popped up as suggested and…read morethe location was close. The building is awesome. It's an old house and the inside is super cute. The actual coffee shop is in the garage so they open the garage door cuz it was a gorgeous day outside. The pastries all looked delicious. The ham and cheese quiche was so good. I asked if they had any sugar free syrups. They had vanilla and caramel so I had them add both to an iced latte. It was really good. My husband opted for one of the house drinks, called the White House. It was delicious as well. Wanted to try the breakfast bagels but they were all out since it was later in the afternoon. Once they are gone they are gone for the day. The quiche was delicious though. We will just have to try other things next time. The cinnamon roll was awesome too! We will be back.

Decided to give them another try and I left so disappointed. The customer service was not the best…read more They weren't super busy when I got there - just steady flow of customers coming in and out. I did have to wait to place my order but it wasn't too bad. The cashier was not warm whatsoever. I ordered two drinks and two pastries, scones to be exact. My drinks took a little over 10 minutes to be ready (which was not bad given how busy they were) but I still hadn't received my pastries. What was frustrating was that people who ordered after me HEATED pastries had already gotten their orders yet I hadn't received mines that just needed to be bagged? I kindly told the cashier I was still waiting for my scones and I could tell she had clearly forgotten about them. She shortly gave them to me with no apology for the delay or anything. When I got home, one of the scones I had ordered was the wrong flavor. They were also extremely dry. If you're in a rush, be mindful that the pour over coffee takes a little longer to make. I am completely dissatisfied with the service today. I might give their other location a try but this one is a no for me.

Photos
Porters Coffee House and Bakery
Porters Coffee House and Bakery - Egg, cheese and bacon on a jalapeño cheddar bagel

Egg, cheese and bacon on a jalapeño cheddar bagel

Porters Coffee House and Bakery

See all

Fresh Donut - donuts - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...