I have to say that I LOVE Fratello's pizza. We actually ordered it by mistake, mixing it up with another similarly named pizza place. Their thin crust is one of the few pizzas that reminds me of the pizza place of my childhood in Altamonte Springs. This is now our GO-TO pizza place. I have not tried the hand tossed yet as I love the thin crust soo much. read more

Fratello's Pizza is in a strip mall located on the corner of Forsyth and Aloma. I prefer their wings over their pizza. Fratello's Pizza offers good service and possesses an ambiance that you would expect from a national chain of pizza. It is next door to a bar, so I am sure they get a decent amount of business from there. read more

Fratello's Pizza - a slice of pizza in the window - Pizza Near Me - Winter Park, Florida

The pizza here is amazing! You can tell that a lot of personal love goes into each pizza. If you sit at the small table they have inside, you can see that each ingredient is measured, carefully placed, and consistent each and every time. It shows in each pizza with the reliability of flavor in each bite and quality of each pizza that the owner delivers. The staff is exceptionally friendly, willing to joke with you, and more than happy to explain the science of food to make such a phenomenal, enjoyable meal. I cannot recommend this place enough!! read more

The jumbo slice is worth it. The cajun wings were super soggy so was not a good experience. Didn't actually taste cajun either. read more

Fratello's Pizza - Jumbo slice with Buffalo chicken and jalapeño. Chicken is diced so tiny - Pizza Near Me - Winter Park, Florida

See all

A hidden gem indeed. Gerald and his staff are extremely friendly and he is a master of his craft. You won't find a better pizza in this area. 5 stars! Add a side of garlic oil and hot wings to your order, you won't be disappointed. read more

Very original, INCREDIBLE pizza, and super friendly staff. Do not miss out on this spot!!

I absolutely love Fratelli's restaurant in downtown Orlando. I go there at least once a week for lunch since they're conveniently located right across the street from where I work! My favorite dish there is the Stuffed Shells. (Pictured here in my review). The staff are great, the service is fantastic, and the price is very reasonable. Get the pizza too! It's DELICIOUS! read more

Fratello's Pizza - Stuffed Shells! - Pizza Near Me - Winter Park, Florida

Pizza took 1 hour 15 minutes to be delivered despite the order site saying 30-45 minutes delivery time. I.called after an hour and was told my pizza was late getting into the oven. I accepted that excuse and waited. When it arrived I grabbed a slice and was so disappointed. The pizza wasn't hot. How can one rate a pizza that at best tastes like it sat under a warmer for 30 minutes waiting for an available driver to finally deliver it. For 25 dollars, I could have got 2 pizzas from Diminoes. They at least would have been hot. read more

Had the worse encounter with the Manager of this locación.. Wings were over cooked and dry..refused to exchange them and was very rude.Their service has truly went down hill..I advise to stay clear of this place.. read more

Fratello's Pizza - Cajón Wings - Pizza Near Me - Winter Park, Florida

Hidden gem, I made a yelp account just to post this as this place is criminally underrated. I've been trying to find this place as my co worker was gate keeping and they don't have their name on the box. Best pizza in town by far, so good you can eat it cold, and they have good prices read more

Fratello's isn't just a pizza place, it's an American joy to have especially in this day and age where everywhere you go you're expected to pay 15 dollars or more for a meal. Not only is the pizza truly excellent but I was talked out of getting their 12" pizza one topping (#9) for their go to (#1) which was one large slice that was not only way cheaper but was more than enough for me as someone who can eat a lot. They chose to talk me out of spending more money on them when they could have just let me do what I originally wanted and had been just as content. They're truly a spot that is for the people. Everyone in there was sweet and kind and very welcoming and I hadn't been satisfied by pizza like that in quite a while and love when I stumble upon smaller places like these. Anyone giving this place less than 5 stars is an insufferable human being and shouldn't be allowed to review anything let alone give an opinion on food. I truly hope this place never goes away and that I can come back for more as someone who tours for a living and loves playing the venue next door!! read more

Ok....it's official that is our favorite local NY style pizza. The quality is consistent and this little hole in the wall not only has the best pizza but the best deals ($3 XL Slice). Must try pizza for locals and visitors alike. read more

Fratello's Pizza - XL single slice ($3) what!!! - Pizza Near Me - Winter Park, Florida

See all

I have not had their pizza...BUT, let me tell you about their wings and their Greek salad. So so so good! We went to an event at The Haven right next door, so we popped in to Fratello's to grab some dinner. Me being Keto (trying rather) opted to get wings and a salad (this is the second time that we have done this) and each time their wings have been on point. We get the medium garlic wings, and a large Greek salad. Last night we bought for 4 people and they had a 24 wing special for about $20. Their Greek small is about $5 and the large salad is $7-$8. Anyways- their wings are cooked to perfection with just the right amount of seasonings and their salads are PACKED and full of flavor (yes I know some people cant imagine salad with flavor). This will be our go to place when we are in the area! read more

The pizza is great I have let nine of my Nabors try this and it's the only place they now order. Price are still great the cheese has recently changed still great and less grease. The wings are also just as good, and my favorite is the burgers they are to die for best I have ever tasted and I travel a lot. Now the deserts price are good I think best deal is the apple wrap it's big the price is well worth it you'll not be disappointed I promise. read more

Fratello's Pizza - the front of the restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Winter Park, Florida

Mediocre at best. The person cutting my pizza had just walked-in, did not wear a mask, and did not wash their hands. I will not be returning. read more

Our favorite pizza spot.. pretty quick and awesome staff... reliable product and good for the price... overall I'm really happy with this place, been going here for years, don't plan on stopping anytime soon read more

This location is the only one that I recommend. The owner is super nice and the pizza dough and toppings are fresh. I love this hole in the wall pizza spot and it is definately a must try if you are in the area for lunch. Our favorite pizza we order is the bacon, onion and tomato but the dough and crust is what won us over! read more

I have ordered from them four times now..first order it was pick up, we live 3 mins away and got home to have a cold pizza but it was very good and the salad was giant! The wings were horrible so don't ever get them! Second order was better with a nice hot pizza and the meatball sub was perfect!! Yum The third order was the same..we were very happy to find a great pizza place.. NOW..urgggg our Fourth order ..pick up as always... Large pizza with onions xtra cheese pepperoni mushrooms... No xtra cheese minimal pepperoni and three of the slices had GIANT air bubbles...so nothing on them. I called them and spoke with the manager..he said it happens and that on this pizza "he knew about it but still let it go out the door like that"! He did offer a pizza if we did a delivery..but We declined. He didn't apologize.. We don't want to buy from establishments that let not up to par food go out the door! The pizzas are not cheap but neither are we. Can't buy us back! Bad management!!! read more

Fratello's Pizza - The manager knew about these giant air pockets and still let it slide! Would you pay $20.00 for this? - Pizza Near Me - Winter Park, Florida

Some of the worst pizza I've had. Flavorless, undercooked and low quality. Nothing like New York pizza and I'd say it's even worse then chain pizza. Very disappointed, avoid at all costs. read more

Great independent chain. First night I flew into FLA I found this place with the help of yelp. GREAT Pizza, they use Grande Cheese which makes all the difference. Back on day 3 to try their Gyros, hope its good the person after me ordered a couple as well. read more

Fratello's Pizza - Menu & pictures - Pizza Near Me - Winter Park, Florida

See all

Fratellos catered our department meeting, and it was a hit. We ordered 15 pizzas, 6 orders or garlic knots and three large salads for a group of 40. It was plenty of food, very affordable and delicious! They delivered it and were so helpful getting the food to our conference room. If you go here, you must order the garlic knots. read more

I wouldn't know if they have good pizza or not - was going to order tonight but the phone just RANG AND RANG AND RANG, tried calling more than once - maybe if they answered the phone so I could order, I would be posting a good rating. Hire someone to answer the phone so you don' lose sales - NY Pizza Baby got your sale tonight. read more

The pizza here is pretty good. I gave 3 stars because they have an XL cheese pizza special for $7.99 but they don't promote it. I ordered a large and paid almost $12 when the XL would've been $8. Should be something they tell their customers. Overall it's decent. read more

Fratello's allowed us to go through the entire order process, we gave our credit card information, and then it happened. This "business" called us back, refused to deliver to our address because the Owner said they couldn't....... no good reason, just "because". When pressed, we were told because we were outside of the delivery area. Even though they had delivered to our neighbors right down the street. Do NOT eat at this establishment. They do not appreciate their customers nor does the Owner understand how to run a business. read more

For over 20 years this has been THE pizza place on the East Side. Delivery or pick up. They offer great food. The owner is there to make sure the product is up to snuff. Wings, pizza, calzones and more! And you get a free pizza after 10 magnets. read more

I just moved to Winter Park from Philadelphia PA and tonight I decided to hunt for my new regular pizza place. I decided to give this place a try based on google reviews and the proximity to my apartment since I was getting it delivered. The wait time was normal so no complaints there and the delivery girl was charming. However, the bottom of the box was soaked through with grease. I ordered a margarita pizza and all it was was a white pizza with sliced tomatoes on top. I ordered a medium sized pizza and a 2L of cherry coke. My bill came to 20.00$ and I consider that quite pricey for one person to eat dinner. All in all, my hunt continues! read more

Our son who lives locally and is in the food industry recommended this pizza spot while we were in Winter Park for a longer than expected hospital stay. We didn't realize it was strictly take out but after we got past that we so enjoyed the pizza. We tried a regular cheese XL for the same price as med that night and the margherita pizza which I loved. It had fresh ingredients and just the right amount of garlic. Their crust is fairly thin which I enjoy but I did see some deep dish styles pizzas being made also. I enjoyed watching the guy making the pizza and throwing the dough. I also had a small house salad which was huge and really good including the Kens Golden Italian in a package even tho I don't normally like packaged dressing. Nothing but good things to say about the food we enjoyed here. read more

Totally bummed about my customer experience. I ordered delivery. My girlfriend can't eat tomato and i specifically asked for there to be no tomato sauce and to replace it with pesto. I explained the need twice. Yeah, order came wrong. When I called I was told they would look to see who took the order wrong. There was no apology or offer to fix problem. I asked if that was all he had to say to me and he said yes then hung up the phone. Bummer customer service. Pizza is good though, girlfriend hungry...not good. Update... received a call, the chick who delivered the pizza called and apologized. That was nice. Would have been cool if the manager would have done that instead of one of the employees. Ah, right and she offered to fix the problem the next time I order. read more

After living on this side of town for many years, I FINALLY tried Fratello's pizza. And boy am I glad that I did. The pizza was ordered for pick-up, the time frame they gave me was accurate, the pizza was delicious - I give any pizza two thumbs up if it can be consumed without having to use two hands - and the service was great. I also ordered a Stromboli for lunch the next day, and I was the envy of the lunch table. It was the perfect amount of cheese and toppings. Four stars for Fratello's! read more

Over the 4 years I've lived in Orlando, I've gone through quite a few pizza places. Some most of them forgettable, some of them are not for good and bad reasons. I came across Fratello's after I got fed up with paying Domino's prices. I really do like Dominos' pizza, but I just can't justify the price. Fratello's has great pizza at a really affordable price. Their 16" cheese costs about as much as Dominos' 10" if I recall. Their website also doesn't mention it but, as I remember, they don't have a delivery fee for orders of $10+ which is partly why Domino's is so expensive. This may have since changed. They have wings which, in my opinion, are some of the best in the area as well. Their desserts are great but, a little pricey, and I'm yet to try the burgers, but I surely will one day. If you're looking for an awesome pizza at an affordable price, I'd give Fratello's a try. You won't regret it. read more

Called to get specials on pizza and wings. When pizza arrived it was cold, not what we ordered and had approximately 7 pieces of sausage on it. I called immediately and was transferred to "GERALD"! Apparently, he was the owner. He was very argumentative with me and clearly didn't appreciate "us" his over 8 year customer. Not only, did he over charge us for the pizza, he actually acted like he was doing us a favor when he said he would credit our account. He didn't even ask us to remake our pizza. I can tell you - when ordering your pizza or wings - don't ask them about the specials. They overcharge certain customers and don't offer the same deals. They are worse than a used car dealership. Better off ordering from NY Pizza - much more reputable!!! read more

Love love LOVE this place! Must get their white pizza with extra tomatoes & extra ricotta... It is amazing! Even if you order anything else you have to get their garlic knots.... Also amazing. Never had bad service either. read more

Got a big sopranos pizza was so doughy that I could only eat the cheese and pepperoni

This place is unbelievable. They have by far the best pizzas in town they even have an olive oil crust. You have to try their wings and their specials sometimes they even have a boneless pork barbecue sandwich which is unbelievable. This place is a must for any resident of central Florida. I saw the post about the owner being unfriendly which I find to be so totally wrong Gerald is one the nicest people along with his family. We been going there for years because of his awesome service and talent. read more

Unbelievably upset by what I just received. First of all I want to start by saying the pizza they use to make 7-9 month ago was unreal. Since then they have continually gotten worse. Tonight just broke the straw for me. I paid $30 for 2 large pizzas and what I got was close to the level of little ceasers pizza. There was way to much cheese, the pizza was floppy "when it use to have a great crisp" and there was to much marinara. I can't believe they could say this was okay to send to someone for $30!! read more

Fratello's has some of the BEST pizza in Winter Park! They're always are fast with their delivery. The taste and quality are very much like NY style pizza. I recently ordered several pizzas for an event, and everyone kept asking me where I got the pizza. I'm ordering more tonight! read more

Best pizza,garlic knots around.... Pizza can be had in traditional hand tossed or extra thick crust... always a special going on here... won't break your budget,, Btw, they have slices available during the week if your in the area..The menu will blow you away with the spread of choices... burgers to wraps,calzones to pizzas, sandwiches, salads, etc.. On the corner of Forsyth and Aloma Ave. My favorite spot read more

Their gyros are surprisingly good....it's all carryout so you save tipping and delivery time if you're inclined to drive yourself....lots of veggies, nice pita and decent meat....very filling....pizza is great....it's a tiny place but don't let the appearance from the outside deter you from trying this gem of a place....friendly, helpful and efficient, this is my favorite pizza joint....l read more

I've been living in Florida since August, 2015 and I have to say, that by far this is the best pizza that have ever had in Florida. Reminds me of New York City Pizza where I used to live. Quick but quality service read more

Unprofessional, discourteous , and immature. These are the three words that best describe fratello's customer service . Three weeks ago, I had an incorrect order, and called to make a complaint. A woman who took my order, then again answered my call back. The woman hung up the phone,after I informed them that the order she took was incorrect. I said To the woman "you must have not been listening clearly to me, because I was very slow and coherent making my order." She didn't like this , and she hung up on me. I called again and made a complaint to the manager , who offered food compensation, I refused and said the issue wasn't the pizza any longer. A simple apology , and a "we will do right next time," would have been fine , but now, I'm being mistreated by the staff. I asked them to please do something about the employee and said goodbye. (Know that I only was expecting discipline or a write up, not a termination) Now this is where the issue becomes a true example of Fratello's immaturity ... I called just a few moments ago, willing to give them another try, and I was blown off. First I called and a man answered the phone , he said I was breaking up, I said I'll call back. When I called back the same woman I had an issue with 3 weeks ago then answered . I said can I please speak with the man I was just talking to and she replied, your breaking up... Now, the fact I was breaking up once is understandable, but twice , and that she was the person to pick up after I immediately called back....tells me everything . Fratello's is full of childish behavior, and rude employees. Order at your own risk. read more