We had heard that the pizza here was good for quite a while. We finally made it and it was a great experience! The service was very friendly and the pizza was delicious. I really like the thin crust and you get to watch them toss it around. The toppings and sauce were very good as well. I'm glad we finally got there and will definitely be back! read more

Right around the corner from my son's apartment. Super quick and easy to order and one of the friendliest receptionist at a pizza joint I've met! She could give classes to others. When you go- make sure you order and watch the magic as they hand make their pizza with style read more

See all

What a great pie! We decide to stop in today, which is our first time ever being here although we have had their pizza with friends at home. We were warmly greeted and could see that we would order at the counter and have a seat. I went ahead and took a seat. Then my wife ordered for us then came over to join me. Within a short amount of time they brought our salads and garlic knots over. The garlic knots were very warm and fresh plus there was a side of pizza sauce to dip them in. Let me tell you they are delicious. The salads were a good size portion and their Italian dressing should never be passed up. It is probably one of the best that I have ever had. We had barely finished our salads. When our pizza came out. I asked for my usual/go to which is pepperoni and sausage on one half that my wife ordered for me. She had her ham and bacon on the other half. With that dreaded pineapple that I don't think belongs on pizza, but she loves it. Everything was so good and the pizza had that perfect crust that you would expect for thin New York style. Everything was delicious and I'm sure we will be back many times. read more

Fratelli's Pizzeria - Pepperoni and sausage pizza. - Pizza Near Me - West Chester, Ohio

Pizza is always delicious! Reminds us of the pizza we love on the east coast. Meatballs and garlic knots are also always on our order!

Very good pizza, although it was a bit burnt on the bottom. Overall though it was excellent. We also got the garlic knots and those were very good. The atmosphere was good except it is often very hot in there during the summer. The service was very good but they don't always have the right hours posted. Overall very good pizza place and we will be back read more

First pizza west of the Mississippi I can say is the closest to NY style pizza and therefore receives a 5. They understand 3 inches of Cheese does not make a great pizza! The crust and sauce is number 1, then cheese. The crust was thin, crisp and well done on the bottom. The sausage was sliced the same way as Bruno's one of the top 100 found in New Jersey. Sauce was great albeit not as good as mine e.g. could use more oregano but still better than most. Yes, the assembly line pizza with conveyer belt is the thing heading west but this seems to be an oven (did not go in) heated to 600-700 F. Nice job! read more

Fratelli's Pizzeria - Half sausage pizza - Pizza Near Me - West Chester, Ohio

First time here overall really good. Food/Drink: Pizza by the pie ONLY! Pretty good Artisan style pizza. Toppings really were lacking I wanted more. Full modern pizza style menu, appetizers, entrees, pizza, soups, salads, and desserts. Pizza: Needed not more one more ouch of crunch literally perfect, left me wanting more toppings though. Very flavorful, great taste, nice bite, size was adequate with a salad or another item. Sauce wasn't too bad not to sweet, not to bitter, I did want a bit more garlic . Dinning Area: Pretty large, open, area. Plenty of seating! Prices: very fair prices. Personal Buffalo chicken pie, side garden salad with a grilled chicken breast, and fountain special for $15! Parking: Plenty of space, shared strip mall lot. Bathrooms: Bathrooms were clean and adequate size. Atmosphere: During the weekend dinner rush, it was a pretty busy but not crazy. I ordered and got my food extremely timely. Staff/Attendants: Staff overall was young, and attentive. Nice girls, brought everything out, and exchanged pleasantries when in left. Great experience...if I lived closer by I'd go again! 7.5/10 read more

See all

Amazing New York Pizza! The best in the area. We added fresh garlic to our supreme and it couldn't have been better.

Great NY style pizza, but no delivery option, which is fine. Still very good pizza and friendly staff.

We ordered takeout, and the food traveled ok. 1. Garlic knots with cheese - great flavors, had we eaten there, I think the texture would have been better. (4/5 ) 2. New York style - this was pretty good it needed to be reheated, but that's expected of this style. Once reheated, it was pretty tasty slightly on the oily side. (4/5 ) 3. Steak hoagie - overall great flavors. However, the bun was a little soggy from the travel. I suspect if we had eaten as soon as prepared, it would have been better. (4/5 ) Overall, it's a great pizza place we will be ordering again for the New York style pizza. read more

See all

Definitely the best New York Style pizza around,..hands down but their customer service and their attention to detail is unmatched! Me and my wife had yet another pleasant experience dining here and after receiving our already most delicious ever pizza, we were told we would receive yet another same size/ingredient pizza for free because our original pizza wasn't shaped right! I mean come on man!I'm a Fat Guy, do you really think I care what the best pizza in the Tri-State is shaped like! But thank you very much Fratellis because you care and we appreciate that and I would recommend you to anybody that will listen and not because you gave us a free pizza but because it's actually the best tasting pizza! But more importantly because you care! 5 read more

I ordered the large Hawaiian pizza to go. The service was polite and quick. The pizza though, was over cooked both by taste and by the fact that the crust did not bend - literally like a piece of cardboard. The toppings were also somewhat limited on the pizza. read more

Best Pizza in Cincinnati The sauce is what makes it special. Crust is chewy like I like and a sprinkling of pepper is great. Get a large cheese and you will love it. read more

Caught wind that there was pretty good New York style pizza near my work so my doubts got the best of me. Had to try it to believe it. I got the Craiger/New Yorker. The meatball on the craiger was , perfectly seasoned. Veggies on the Nee Yorker were crisp not soggy. I can't say this is the best New York style I've had but for Ohio, idk where you'll find a better NY 'Za. read more

Fratelli's Pizzeria - Craiger/New Yorker - Pizza Near Me - West Chester, Ohio

I'm from Brooklyn, NY, and know something about pizza. Fratelli's has some of the best NY style pizza outside of the Big Apple. Excellent! A real gem. read more

moved from New York in 99, always searching for a non-chain pizzeria that serves it by the slice. Stumbled on this place while in the area. Food was great. Will come back again!! Accidentally dropped one of my slices on the ground and the owner made me a new personal pizza. read more

Great pizza, great price, and a wonderful and friendly family staff. I passed many pizza places just to get to this one.

Really enjoyed the pizza! Great service as well!! Prices were reasonable and numerous beers on tap! read more

Fratelli's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - West Chester, Ohio

The pizza was tasty, but the real star of the show has to be their other dishes. My boyfriend and I also got a baked ziti dinner with our pizza and was great! We definitely want to come back soon to try more of their dishes like the calzones! read more

Fratelli's Pizzeria - Baked Ziti Dinner - Pizza Near Me - West Chester, Ohio

See all

Great New York Style pizza. Every pie we have had has been consistently great. The service is good, but they do get busy on Friday and Saturday nights. We have been ordering through their website lately to take home. The web site is a little "klunky", it needs some pictures to help make the various specialty pizza's clearer. We drive from Sharonville to West Chester to pick it up. It is worth the drive. read more

I was very impressed with this small business pizzeria. I got a calzone with extra cheese, broccoli, and onions. It was only 8 bucks after their cash discount. I appreciate great food at a great value. The calzone smelled amazing in the car on the 5 minute drive home and it didn't disappoint! read more

Favorite NY style pizza in the area. Pizzas are big and the price is right. Friendly service

Good pizza and good garlic knots. The ingredients are fresh and the pizza is made with love!

My favorite pizza. Pro tip: ask for your pie to be cooked one extra minute, perfection.

Best pizza in the west Chester are. Run by a very friendly family and the service is always excellent! Always a fantastic experience!

Fratelli's is the best NY style pizza in the Greater Cincinnati area! Family-owned business with friendly staff. Great sauce recipe and homemade meatballs for subs. Definitely recommend! read more

I am rating takeout service only here. I called in a take out order for two large pizzas, picked them up piping hot and drove and immediately bit into that cheesy goodness...and I have to say FINALLY after 8 years I have found a pizza slice that remotely resembles a real New York pie. Mmmmm. It was exactly what I wanted. Too bad they don't deliver to my area because I would be here way too often. The pizza dough is nice and thin, and there is a perfect sauce to toppings ratio that creates that chewy yet saucy cheesy bite with just a bit of grease dripping off that I expect out of a good slice of pizza. BEST pizza that I have had in the Greater Cincinnati area. Definitely will be ordering from here again. Would also recommend the eggplant parm! read more

Fratelli's Pizzeria - New York pizza and make your own with pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - West Chester, Ohio

See all

We were very satisfied with our recent visit to Fratelli's. The customer service was on point and the food was excellent! The sandwich, salad and pizza were generous portions and taste made us all plan on a return trip. read more

Pizza was fine- we got this for take out and I think if we had eaten it more immediately probably would have been been great when freshly made. The garlic knots garlic flavoring all went to the bottom of the container and could've been stronger. Enjoyed the mozzarella sticks and sauce. The Hawaiian pizza was yummy and New Yorker was a nice combo of toppings. All items could've just had a bit more flavor. Still a pizza option I would consider if I'm in the area. read more

See all

if you haven't tried Fratellis you are missing the best pizza place in sw Ohio. pizza is great and the meatballs are amazing! locally owned great staff! Brian H read more

I was in town for business and looking for something quick and easy to take back to my hotel. I saw Fratelli's on Yelp and decided to give it a try. I am so glad that I did because their pizza was DELICIOUS and the closest thing I've had to NY pizza without being in NY. I got a medium 1/2 cheese and 1/2 pepperoni. It was a huge portion and could have easily fed 2-3 people. You should give them a try if you are looking for a delicious, NY style pizza! read more

This Pizzaria was recommended by a co worker. I drive by it every day and though we would try. Pizza's funny, you like what you grow up with and every other pizza isn't as good. Anyway the pizza was very good. It was a thinner New York style crust. They advertise it that was and it was spot on. I'm a thicker crust guy so although this was very good I'll stick to my local favorite "Raymond's" read more

Was in Cincy for a large soccer tourney and had lunch here due to solid Yelp reviews. The pictures people had posted on Yelp looked like the type if pizza I prefer. New York style on the thinner side. Order a large half cheese and half pepperoni and it did NOT disappointed. Excellent crust, sauce and cheese.. probably one of the best pizzas I have ever had. Definitely top two. Would give them 4 and 1/2 stars, but cant so I land on four. I will never give a perfect five star score because there might be something better somewhere. I haven't encountered it yet however. Do not pass this place up. Truly excellent pizza. read more

Fratelli's Pizzeria - Our pie - Pizza Near Me - West Chester, Ohio

We have been going here for years and tonight may have been the last time. The pizza here used to be top notch NY style pizza that you can't get anywhere else in this city. The Craiger was something I used to crave. We moved farther away so only go on rare occasions now so that kinda sucks. The last time we went the crust had gone down hill. No longer had a crisp and they had lost some luster. Maybe an off night, so didn't bother me too much. Tonight we were in the area so figured we would give it a shot. We walk in at 7:39 and immediately are told they close at 8 tonight so the dining room is closed but still available for take out. I used to work in restaurants so I know if you close at 8, anyone who walks in prior to 8 is welcome. Kitchen staff usually isn't too pleased with late walk ins but nonetheless you're getting served. Not tonight. I have heard grumbling that over the last few years there is new ownership/management and the food/service has gone downhill. I think tonight it was proven. read more

My favorite pizza in town. It's a great, simple, good slice of NY Style pizza. Not too greasy. We've eaten in and it's worth it because the it's fantastic right out of the oven. read more

Good pizza. Crust is thin, but hey...I like it that way. Nice staff. Support a local business!

This is dry & burnt! Whomever took it out of the oven knew it & put it in the box anyway. It's disgusting & unhealthy. read more

See all

Hmm, what to say about this pizza: 1. Did not grow up with NY style pizza per se, so maybe I didn't know what I was getting myself into? 2. Have only dined on the pizza once. (carry-out) 3. Not worth the money. So, when you're feeling low, and want to be lazy, what do you do? Pick up a pizza. But, this pizza make make you feel even worse. The pizza looks and tastes sad. Incredibly salty. Shared a medium with my husband, the crust was almost too tough to chew. Did I mention salty? Pro Tip: you get a discount if you pay in cash! $$$ Also, they have a dine-in/sit-down restaurant part. Just finished dining on this pizza, and my tummy isn't very happy with me. Oy. read more

Came for a couple of pepperoni slices during lunch time. Very good New York style pizza. Slices big enough that folding is recommended. Crust has a nice balance of crisp and NY style chew. Sauce is simple and tasty, not overly seasoned. One of the few true NY style pizzerias in Cincy. read more

Fratelli's Pizzeria - Pepperoni pizza slice - Pizza Near Me - West Chester, Ohio

When I read the (few) negative reviews I just laugh I grew up in the Bronx, and my wife in Brooklyn We thank Gawd for Fratellis a good NYC pie I think it is far and away the best Pizza in Cinci - and despite what one reviewer said, the pie is delicious the next day - even cold Full disclosure- I am extra biased because it is one of the few places in Cinci where you can get a pie with anchovies read more