Cancel

Open app

Search

Frantoni's Pizza

3.6 (172 reviews)
ModeratePizza, Italian
Open 11:00 am - 9:00 pm

Order Frantoni's Pizza Takeout or Delivery

Frantoni's Pizza Photos

Business Info

FRANTONI'S PIZZA ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?
Moderate noise
Casual
Good for groups
Good for kids

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Frantoni's Pizza

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Margherita Pizza
Angela L.

My friends ordered from Frantoni's for his birthday. The delivery person came right on time and was very friendly. They ordered two pizzas (one margherita and one sausage with mushrooms) and a variety of dishes. One was penne with meat sauce, linguine with clam sauce, and chicken francese. The pizzas were pretty good. They are not as crispy as I would like but there was a good amount of cheese and toppings. The chicken francese was a little bland and maybe needed more salt. The penne with meat sauce was a little sweet for my taste. The best was the linguine with clam sauce. There were plenty of clams including fresh clams. The linguine was very flavorful and well seasoned. I enjoyed it.

Lemon chicken pizza and rice ball
Sheila M.

Came into the store to get a quick bite for lunch. The store is very clean. It was not so crowded on a Thurs lunch time. The lemon chicken pizza. It was very good. I did see some garlic pieces, but I wished they had put a little bit more lemon sauce. I also ordered the rice ball. The rice ball rice was very undercooked. The inside of the ball ball was very crunchy and very bland. I shared the rice ball with my coworkers, and they agreed with me. I definitely get the lemon chicken again.

a pizza in a box
Lourdes M.

We replaced our caterer for this year office party. We do not have regrets for having them. The review is for their catering service: The delivery is on point. The pricing is reasonable. The variety of their pizza is plenty. Our first time to include in our gathering a salad pizza. It sounds healthy but obviously people prefer the other stuff. Grandma pizza is the favorite. I love their veggie pizza. I even took home a slice to share with my hubby. The side dish of garlic bread and fresh salad are absolutely good. We would definitely use them again for our future gathering.

Melinda S.

Always my go to place for a quick bite doing errands. Service is quick for takeout! Ingredients are super fresh. Makes you want more!

a box of pizza
Cindy U.

Frantoni's Pizzeria & Ristorante 66 Hillside Ave. Williston Park, NY 11596 5 STARS ALL THE WAY I LOVE YOU BENNY- Handsome w/great hair. $10 off any large. Got a promo code a couple days ago. Decided on the way back from my dentist appt today in Manhattan where I was told I need a root canal. Getting it in 2 weeks. It's time to pig out while I can. I called and spoke to a lovely fella Benny telling him I'm heading back from Manhattan and will call when I get closer. 1 - Order 1/2 pepperoni 1/2 sausage Walked in. All smiles from staff. How pleasant they all were. Nice cozy space. Floor to ceiling windows so lots of light coming in making it spacious and airy. Clean and nice space all around. Not a stuffy feeling at all. Now the pizza. OMG. The pizza is LARGE. Needed both hands hold it and used my leg to widen the door open. Lol. The smell of the pizza in the car was amazing. OMG. SMH. Now heading home. My tummy is rumbling. Told hubby to pull over at UPS. FIRST TIME HAVE I EVER EATEN REAL FOOD IN THE CAR. Hubby parks the car. Hands me a napkin and opens the box. SMH. OMG. Doing the happy dance on my seat. First bite. Hmm. Hmmm Hmm. Yep there was a few moans. Licking my lips for the juicy tasty tomato sauce, pepperoni oil and tasty sliced sausage. This was DELICIOUS DELICIOUS DELICIOUS. ABSOLUTE PERFECTION. Pepperoni a little crispy on the edges, flavourful sliced well seasoned sausage and golden brown mozzarella cheese. Tomato sauce was the perfect amount and great flavour. The crust was crispy and chewy in the right spots. Burnt, crispy, chewy crust and the bottom the same as well. YUMMMMMMM. Hubby and I had a slice each. Only couple minutes away from our house so will finish them at home. Oh Yeah. I'm saving 2 slices for MY breakfast tmrw. Hubby knows hands off. Or else. THANK YOU BENNY. SEE YOU SOON.

Chicken soup
Brendan R.

Very disappointed because this place used to have very good food. No idea why but the quality has really declined. Chicken marsala is like steamed chicken in broth. Asked for paper plates and utensils.- didn't get either. Very bland food

The three slices in question!

See all

12 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

9 years ago

Business owner information

Photo of Mike M.

Mike M.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 years ago

Business owner information

Photo of Mike M.

Mike M.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 years ago

I went there with my students. We ordered 8 pies. The service was great and the pies were delicious.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

9 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of S B.
1
24
0

11 years ago

Business owner information

Photo of Mike M.

Mike M.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 years ago

Business owner information

Photo of Mike M.

Mike M.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

15 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

16 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

9 years ago

favorite local pizzeria. regular slice, grandma slice, and marinated eggplant slice are all excellent

Business owner information

Photo of Mike M.

Mike M.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Page 5 of 5

Ask the Community - Frantoni's Pizza

What time do they close? Do they have waitress service?

Does the vodka sauce (like if I order a grandma pie with vodka sauce instead of marinara) have meat in it?

Their vodka sauce has prosciutto and onions in it and it's in the sauce that is used on the pizza with rigatoni a la vodka and it is the sauce used for their pasta dish, so I would definitely say yes.

Is there waiter service if you dine in?

Yes

Don’t See Your Question? Ask Away!

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Pizza 31,725 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Riella's Homestyle - Bread

Riella's Homestyle

4.1(268 reviews)
2.6 mi
$$

Great place to eat out or for a quick specialty slice…read more My go to for a slice with anything on it

First and foremost I've been reading the reviews and what is so consistent are the complaints about…read morethe portions and prices which is what I'm going to address exactly. First of all, I come in with a clipp coupon which is an incredible thing I highly suggest for everybody to look into the deals are incredible and the whole idea is to bring in brand-new customers which is what I was, this was my first time there a couple of weeks ago. I was really excited to try out this place, but yes, as many of the reviews say it's just a Pizzeria with some tables thrown inside. So it's not a fine dining restaurant by any chance but boy I can tell you from looking at the size of the menu and the outrageous prices you would have thought it was a five star restaurant!!! Seriously, many of the appetisers are in the $30 range, which is ridiculous- So when I walked in to pay the server who I assume is a waitress, maybe more, was named Maria and I see that she's been mentioned many times in the reviews so she's probably a regular there--- she seemed visibly disappointed and annoyed when I told her I have a clipp Certificate, to let people know who are not familiar. It's extremely similar to Groupon but much much better and much cheaper -- again the idea is to bring a new people although you can use it every time you go there which I have been told by people in the advertising business that the business owners actually hate this sort of thing because they actually lose money they're just taking a chance on bringing a new customers and introducing them to the business which could be beneficial in a long run So that was a turn off. Then I was told that I most likely wouldn't be able to use it because it's for Dine in only , however the one good thing is that somebody who apparently was the owner came over and told her basically to knock it off and stop worrying about that stuff and he said not a problem this time so I can say he was extremely nice and pleasant to speak with And that was nice of him to do that for me that one time if I do go back there at least I know moving forward that it's for dine in only and not takeaway- But the primary complaint here is I couldn't believe that my Dish was $37 and I was excited to try it out only to open it and find SEVEN Shrimp !!!! I mean they gotta be kidding me!! this dish is the shrimp or Renata of course you can see the thing that cost nothing which is pasta was packed to the brim.... Extremely disappointing, I was also purveying the pizzas and asking the prices and the prices were also a little bit ridiculous for a slice ... stuff look pretty good and the food tasted good but you gotta be kidding me for almost $40. I only got seven shrimp????? This is just another one of those restaurants that get over on the people... sad .

Photos
Riella's Homestyle
Riella's Homestyle - Garlic knots

Garlic knots

Riella's Homestyle - Friendly welcome

See all

Friendly welcome

Molto Bene - Loved the Chicken Parm

Molto Bene

4.0(138 reviews)
4.5 mi
$$

Came here to finish up restaurant week and couldn't be any happier. I mentioned to my friend \who…read morelives in Merrick that we were coming here and she told me that it was her families "goto" for Italian food. It was a snap to get here from the Meadowbrook Parkway and they have a very convenient parking lot right on the side of the building. We came into a very comfortable venue, took our seats and was joined by our waiter immediately after sitting down. Loved the fact that there was really nice music in the background. I am so tired of hearing loud techno while trying to enjoy my meal. We started with some delicious toasted bread (I should have known better) and ordered shortly thereafter, (We had already reviewed menu at home.) Our dinner consisted of: Appetizers: - Mussels in a garlic / white wine sauce - Mozzarella caprese Main Entreès - Shrimp Scampi with linguine - Chicken Cutlet Parm with linguine - Chocolate Cake - Italian Cheesecake Everything was wonderful. My wife loved the caprese while I thought the mussels were amongst the best I ever had. (Best were in Bruges, Belgium) The Chicken Parm was thin, crispy on the outside with tender meat and the Shrimp was fresh and tasty. All this was followed by wonderful desserts with hot coffee. There were enough items on the menu to make me want to come back. On another note... I was a little surprised to see another Yelp review from a fellow Elite member which was not so favorable. Not sure how you can go from one extreme to the other but sorry to read that the experience was not as good as mine. KUDOs to the Team at Molto Bene.

Place is crazy small and very tight. Expect your chair to get bumped into several times. The…read moreportions are not huge. For Italian, you want huge portions. The service was ok. Seemed the owner was helping a lot. Overall, 3 starts. Not bad by any means and not great either

Photos
Molto Bene - Great Venue

Great Venue

Molto Bene - Pollo Milanese

Pollo Milanese

Molto Bene - Delicious Mussels

See all

Delicious Mussels

Borrelli's - Stuffed Mushrooms & Baked Clams

Borrelli's

3.4(316 reviews)
0.7 mi
$$

My sister in law suggested this great website called Goldbelly. I looked at it and thought well…read morethis is pricey. She told me to try the pizza from NY even though they come in a pack of 3 or 4--I can't recall as I ate them all but one. Still unsure, I called the place. It is Borrelli's in New York, and I spoke to them. I asked all about this order place and the manager got on the phone. He was so nice and told me that Goldbelly is the way to go and they don't ship thought anyone else. He also explained that it will be just the same as if I walked in if made according to their clear directions that come in the box. It is all flash frozen the minute it cools and then shipped. Well, he was right. This is the best NY pizza I have ever had and I love NY and go there often. Just follow the directions to the letter, it is easy. They are not huge pizzas, they serve 1 or 2. I looked up this place and it sure looks cute and just an adorable pizza place. I will go there soon.

Now, we did not go to NY to get Pizza. We had it delivered flash frozen from this great website…read morecalled, Goldbelly. Look them up, they have the best food and all delivered to your door, flash frozen and great. I have seen photos of Borrelli's and it is cute and looks so comfortable. I think they might even have a counter. As to the pizza, we ordered 4 to be delivered to LA. You have to order 4 and it is pricy, but spend a little more and free shipping you will get. Our pizzas came when promised, all still packed in ice and all sealed when fresh. You just heat them up, follow the directions exactly. This is the best NY pizza we have ever had and we have been to NY, but we did not know about this place. The crust is perfect, thin with such flavor. The sauce and cheese combination they use is the best. We are in heaven and have ordered more. They can stay in the frig up to 3 days and in the freezer no longer than 3 months. I wish I had some now. So perfect.

Photos
Borrelli's - Bar

Bar

Borrelli's - Tomatoe and mozzarella salad (BANGING)

Tomatoe and mozzarella salad (BANGING)

Borrelli's

See all

Frantoni's Pizza - pizza - Updated May 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...