I started to write my review and had to go back and read all the reviews because I was shocked they didn't have five stars. Yes the place is small, yes they have rules when ordering, but this is an experience. I have had many wood fired pizza from all over and this was the best I've ever had. This isn't your local pizza joint you bring the kids to this place is when you are going out with your significant other to enjoy a great meal. read more

Forage Pizza - Margarita pie - Pizza Near Me - Forestburgh, New York

See all

The best pizza we have ever ate!. We come to Inn at St Josephs Lake every year with my wife for a few days and order every evening something new at the Farage. Never were disappointed with service, or food they served. Highly recommended to try read more

Wouldn't take a large pizza order so they lost out on a $500 sale. When I tried to place the order I was told "the owner doesn't like to do large orders!" read more

Had a few various slices: Sopressatta, funghi, bacon and maple syrup (very sweet), and plain. All were just ok, tops done nicely bottom is wet and floppy. Pies are about 12" also. So dont thing its a huge pie. Need 4 pies to equate to one normal pie. So be prepared to pay about 60-80 bucks to feed what would be a normal pizzeria pie. The white bean dip was very good as were the spicy olives. The places sits about 7 people at the counter and a few at the table. but pretty cramped. There is outdoor seating but that doesn't work in the winter. Talk to the owner but can't really get a straight answer from talking about the oven and the ingredients. read more

Forage Pizza - Front - Pizza Near Me - Forestburgh, New York

This will be my second visit to this fabulous pizza spot. We sat inside, it was early, took seats at the bar. Brought our own beer and wine. This time, I struck up conversation with the owner and chef. Learned about his heritage, background, and passion. Any haters for this pizza? just stop, it is perfect with every bite. Hot out of a wood fired oven with fresh ingredients. I love when someone takes what they love and makes a beautiful product, in the middle of nowhere, that you have to seek, because it is THAT GOOD. Who cares on how the pizza travels, eat there, don't expect alterations, that is what makes it unique. Be adventurous, be real, but don't down this place because it doesn't fit your lifestyle, EAT GOOD FOOD and LOVE IT. Cheers to this place, keep it going. read more

Apparently some folks in our society can't follow rules. They have expressed this by posting negative reviews and giving 1 Star reviews to a 5 Star establishment. I know I know you we treated badly or you were hung up on, yada yada yada. You are not savvy enough to read the rules and abide by them. You seem to be above following the rule in general and are put off when you are called out. I stand by my recommendation of "this place is the best pizza in the county" and probably far beyond. So try try try to just read and obey and possibly you will have as good as an experience as i myself have had along with hundreds more. LAUREN's (Winter so far) POP UP BISCUIT BREAKFAST If you are a breakfast person like me, you find and sharing great places. So just as my reviews of Forage Pizza in Forestburgh NY the fine folks there have done it again. Lauren the "Biscuit Queen" has decided to share her love of cooking and her famous Biscuits with the community. Posted below is the menu and I promise you shan't be disappointed. Start with the basic w/butter, homemade jam of the weekend, bacon and cheese, sausage and cheese you get the picture ..... Read the menu! The biscuits are light and fluffy whatever you put between them and the coffee is superb. I highly recommend you stop by on the weekend (check out their schedule) and give it a try. Whatever you have on them you will not be disappointed! read more

Forage Pizza - Biscuit Breakfast menu - Pizza Near Me - Forestburgh, New York

We come far and wide for this amazing pizza when in Upstate NY. We're from NYC and this is better than any pizza in the city. The apps and vibe outside are also stellar. This is a special place, highly recommend read more

Incredibly rude and fire safety hazard, no thanks. Man who appears to be owner scoffed at us when we decided to order to go instead of sitting down in the tight seating area. He screamed "only 4 pizzas to go and no splitting the checks!" We never asked about splitting checks...and there were at least 15 people inside. Pizza looks good but better pizza and service elsewhere. read more

Easily the best pizza I've had outside of NYC. It's very simple, read the rules. They won't do orders to go. They won't lower the volume of their music. They may get a little *fresh* with their customers. Your reward is an absolutely amazing pizza with fresh ingredients, lovingly prepared, and served piping hot. I'm not normally a white pizza guy, but the Funghi was outstanding. If you don't mind some spice, the red pizza Diavola is also incredible. Pizza's change whenever they feel like (seasonally), so check their Instagram, or just read the menu when you get there. It's worth it, no matter where in the Catskills you're coming from. read more

I had the foraged greens pizza and might be one of the best pizzas I've ever had in my life. Very small inside so hard to eat there but delicious! read more

Had the Anchovies. Had the mortadella pizza. Damn good. They play great beats, outdoor area super chill. Will be back for sure read more

Forage Pizza - Mortadella Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Forestburgh, New York

This place has one bad rating from someone who ADMITS they never even tried the food in the review. World doesn't revolve around you Karen, don't be so petty and punitive. Moving on...this is likely the BEST pizza place I have ever eaten. I've been to Prince St, Lombardi's, Patsy's, Joe's, Lee's Tavern, Emmy Squared, Roberta's and on and on and on. DO NOT skip this pie. Wait for it, call a third time, prepare ahead of time. WHATEVER, this is destination worthy food from a punk rock master of the craft. Anthony admits that he doesn't follow the rules for a traditional Neapolitan-style pie, but he understands them enough to break them the right way. The crust has structure, chew, and a little crispiness to it all while being super tender. And as far as the toppings go, his pies are pricey, but I don't understand how he makes a profit with the quality and generosity of his portions. Funghi was insane, LOADED with quality mushrooms without a crimini/button in sight. Finally, SUPER inviting folks. They admittedly don't seem like they are interested in just pandering to people expecting that Domino's customer experience. They are hanging out, enjoying their lives and running the business that they WANT to run, not the one ol' 1-Star Karen up in the reviews THINKS they should run. If you get it, you'll get it. And you'll get it FAST, because these pies cook up, reportedly in just 90 seconds. My family and I were all shocked at how quickly our order came out. Just make sure that you AT THE VERY LEAST try a bite of one slice at the many picnic tables they have set up against the woodsy backdrop before heading out. The pie is at its absolute best right out of the oven. In summation, ignore the Karen and check this place out while you still can. The hype is coming. read more

Forage Pizza - Nona dora, funghi and dido ante pies. Amazing range of flavors between these three...all delicious. - Pizza Near Me - Forestburgh, New York

Fantastic pizza -- rustic, crisp, covered with the basic -or- more interesting toppings

I'm not exaggerating when I say this is the best fungi pizza I've ever had. And I'm a native New Yorker pushing 50. And we had it in winter with local organic mushrooms. In spring they will use foraged ones. We ate it so quickly I forgot to take a photo of it. But here are the house rules. And yes, you should eat the pizza THERE and not do take out or it will loose it's splendidness. The music is loud but fortunately it's great music. If you don't like it, you suck. read more

Forage Pizza - a man holding a pizza - Pizza Near Me - Forestburgh, New York

See all

WOW...WOW...WOW!! Great pizza, friendly staff, very relaxed vibe! Can't wait to return. read more

Really great pizza! Generous salad portions. I enjoyed the creative combos like BLT pizza, but the classic margherita was really my fave by far. Just so well done! Would def go back. Nice outdoor picnic table seating too. read more

Since it opened during the beginning of the pandemic, it has been terrific. And interesting friendly crowd...some come 30 miles to eat here. Fresh, tasty and nothing bland, beats pizza within 50 miles....don't close up your box if doing takeout, Anton will not like it! Neither will the pizza. read more

Like most of the other reviews, this is a standout restaurant. The pizza is excellent, fairly priced for what you get, and the service is friendly and fun. We had the Burratta appetizer and the Fungi and Dido Ante pizzas, and really enjoyed them. The Burrata came with their sliced foccacia on the side which was equally delicious. I look forward to coming back next time we're in the area. read more

Forage Pizza - Fungi, Dido Ante, and Burrata - Pizza Near Me - Forestburgh, New York

Love there Pizza, fresh vibrant ingredients and made with passion. Great local friendly vibe, small inside but plenty of seating outside in the summer. read more

Was finally able to try this place. I knew it would be good, but not this good. Killer funghi pizza and the smoked trout with focaccia was insane. read more

See all

Amazing pizza. Went with 10 people so got to try about 5 different pies all of them were outrageously delicious. Can't wait to go back!

I am hesitant to tell you what I think about Anthony's pizza. The next time I go, you may end up ordering and consuming the last dough available. That would really suck for me. Especially if I make a special trip up from Manhattan just for his 4 cheese pizza. Or, really any one of his out of this world pizzas on truly the most delicious crust ever. And, dare I say, I'm a bit of a pizza aficionado. Yeah, I don't I'm gonna tell you how I feel about the pizza. read more

Schopenhaur once said "only fools eat right away what's in front of them". (don't google just trust me) Then call me a fool. It's more like For-nah-ge pizza, even though they say they forage and they don't mean raccoons raiding your dumpster, but They seem suspicious and untrustworthy. But strike me dead if I had a better brick oven pizzas anywhere in the world! Especially the fungi pizza. I don't care what dumpster they 'foraged' from. I will eat it whole as soon as it comes out of their dome shaped brick fired oven. This is how Schopenhaur would've want his pizza too if he was still alive. *no pictures because I was busy eating. read more

Really top-notch pizza in a not-so-obvious place. We sat on the stools and chatted with the owner and cook, and they were delightful. The crust was wonderfully thin, and my funghi pizza was delicious. Definitely recommend. read more

One star is more than they deserve. Terrible, rude customer service. "Read the rules" before you can order, which are obnoxious. These wanna be "hipsters" really aren't as cool as they think they are. POOR service with a bad attitude. A $ 16 salad that was a small cup of grass. Literally. So-so pizza that took an hour with no apology from the "chef" , who contiunued to behave in a rude manner. Dirty surroundings. Loud music and a large dog on a rope barking as you as you try to choke down their terrible food. read more

Delicious pizza - rude obnoxious staff. From the minute we walked in they seemed annoyed with us. I understand no special orders what I do not understand is nasty attitudes towards customers. If you like verbal abuse then this is the place for you read more

Amazing real Italian Pizza. Wood fired, Italian Pizza Oven. Stopped in at the last minute. Needed food. Great decision. Honestly, Forage Pizza is the real thing. read more

See all

We can not remember having better pizza! Thin crust, homemade sauce. The Marinara was good for the vegans. Soppressata and Margaret's pizzas were excellent. My wife can't handle garlic, so none of the appetizer dips would work, but the owner threw in one with trout dip on the house. Excellent. They just opened, so there may be some growing pains. They had run out of sausage by 5 PM on Sunday. Napkins where from a big roll. read more

Forage Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Forestburgh, New York

Delicious pizza but psychotic staff. If they make a mistake on your order, it's your fault. If they make a mistake on the check, it's also your fault! Don't even attempt to ask for an explanation of the check. You will be verbally abused and sorry you ever asked. Buyer beware.... carefully look over your check. There's some new kind of math being used there wherein food and beverages totaling $102 end up costing $141! That's a lot of tax, even for the state of NY! Our protestations regarding the final total were met with scorn and ridicule. One of the employees even gave us the middle finger as they yelled at us to get out! ( Hello middle school!) If you don't mind overpaying for your meal and being verbally accosted for questioning same, this is the place for you! read more

Seriously amazing food, atmosphere, everything. We drive 45min each way and it's 100% worth the trip

Great little roadside pizza place Pizza so good, thin crust, excellent toppings Outdoor seating BYOB or run across the road to the general store Can't wait to go back and try the salads read more

What a great menu. Limited and wonderfully so! We ordered the Funghi. It needed more time in the oven in our opinion. It didn't look like the crust in the photos - there was no color or crunch to our crust. We will be back to try the Foraged Greens. read more

Superb quality individual pizzas! Big-city quality--this place could be in Brooklyn, it's so good. We live in the area, and never dared to dream that we could get this kind of quality in rural Sullivan County. We ordered several take-out pies ahead of time for a party--however, the shop is run on a small scale, so probably dropping in to eat is the best bet. The fungi topping is the best! Tastes like real wild mushrooms. They also sell cool-looking T-shirts, just in case you want to show off your insider panache. read more

Some of the best pizza I have ever had, and that includes some of the most well-known pizzas in Naples and NYC. Perfectly crispy crust; flavorful, locally sourced ingredients; and well-balanced flavors. Salad was also excellent. Highly recommend if you are in the area! read more

Amazing thin crust pizza. The white pizza with burrata and pizza with sausage are to die for. Ingredients are very fresh

I've driven past this place almost every other day for over a year and noticed that it's super popular for outdoor dining during the summer. So I finally decided to pop in one afternoon for a last minute dinner, and this little hole in the wall blew me away. Service is nice, staff are great. Prices are decent. Definitely recommend for a quick bite for lunch or dinner ! read more

It's upsetting to me to have to give a two star review to a restaurant that has some really amazing food. The reason for my two stars is mostly based on service. For starters, you are not aloud to order take out. When I asked to take a pizza to go, they literally said no. I assume it was due to the fact of they think it was jeopardize their pizza quality, so it is what it is. I'm of the mindset that if I'm paying 20+ dollars for a pizza, if I want to take it to go, it shouldn't be a problem. However, this was only a minor gripe of mine, and if this was the only issue I had, the rating would be much higher. What was worse was the fact that I was instantly met with hostility walking in to the restaurant. I went here with a group of four people, and we were all shocked at how we were spoken to. I don't really understand why, but again, it is what it is. The biggest icing on the cake was when we were being served, the man who seemed to be the owner, or maybe the manager of the restaurant came up to us and decided it would be wise to speak in a mocking Asian Accent asking about sushi that they had. I was personally shocked because I don't think he realized that someone in my group was of Asian descent, so it was insanely disrespectful. It took him a solid minute of awkwardness to read that we weren't okay with it. The whole situation is really upsetting because the food really was delicious. It's a shame that it was ruined by pretentious workers because honestly if they were even a touch nicer, and not blatantly racist, this pizza place would've been the best one I've gone to in years. The food was really great, but it was completely ruined by the experience. read more

Might be some of the best pizza I've ever had. Crazy delish. Thanks for opening up in Forestburgh, we'll keep coming back!

Forage Pizza is amazing! We had the smoked trout dip and the fughi pizza. The smoked trout dip with focaccio was delicious and the perfect starter. The funghi pizza was among the best we have ever had anywhere. Everyone is so friendly and welcoming. We can't wait to come back and try more, but it will be tough not to keep ordering the funghi one! read more

Best pizza I have ever eaten, owners are extremely passionate about what they do. But don't try to ask for something special or change the menu in any way, they wont, nevertheless if I could have any one pizza for the rest of my life it would be the Margerita read more