It's not often I give a 1 star but the only reason this place gets any stars from me is due to the buffalo chicken pizza being so dang on good. I completely understand this is a family ran business but the hours of operation on Yelp and Google are not correct/have not been updated so on a Sunday I wanted to grab pizza and they ran out. We drove there from our weekend rental after seeing reviews of call-in orders not being accepted. It's a mess and if you don't live in this town there would be no way of knowing when it's last call for pizza. And for those reading this be sure to order pizzas by 4pm on Sundays to make sure they actually have pizzas available. We dined in on a Friday evening because it was the only open space dining spot in town and luckily we got our pizza within the hour (we were abruptly told the pizza would be a long wait before we were greeted) and since we had no place to be we grabbed some beers and waited. Our waitress was very nice and being that she was the only one serving I had sympathy for her but the guy making the pizza which I assume is the owner is frankly not nice. Maybe he needs to hire someone to work the front so he can focus on making the pizza's. read more

See all

Had the Margerita pizza, worth the 46 minute drive. Real brick oven pizza, fresh mozzarella. Excellent tomato sauce fresh basil, crust crisp and perfectly cooked.. Home made meatballs, as good as nonas 4 good sized, perfect meatballs served with fresh ricotta and basil. Under $11, amazing. Only open on weekends during summer. I hope weather holds up will be back next week. Top line food at crazy low prices read more

Ordered a veggie pizza. So Tasty! Crust was perfectly done, fresh veggies from their hydroponic greenhouse across the street! Nice size 14" pizza. Sat outside on a perfect summer day. Staff/owner(a) very friendly and helpful! read more

See all

Awesome pizza and service! Great location. Fresh ingredients and perfectly made. Love this place!!!

Really good outdoor pizzeria serving solid pies. Wood fired, brick oven, thin crust. Good service!

On our way to the Hawk's Nest look-outs, we came upon this place when we were looking for food. It's in a cute, quaint little town. The ambiance was great, the spot was decked out in Halloween decor and honestly felt like you were just hanging out in someone's backyard (in the best way possible). The server was hilarious and made the experience so much better. Now for the good stuff: the pizza. WOW. What a pleasant surprise. We had 3 pizzas: pesto, buffalo, and four cheese with pepperoni and onion. All of them were amazing, but the buffalo chicken pizza was top friggin tier (and I don't even like buffalo sauce that much). We washed it all done with some Boylan creme soda which was equally delish. Would love to go back if we ever find ourselves in the area. Definitely recommend. read more

What am amazing place! We ordered the pesto pizza which was soooo delicious. And Frank is the best waiter ever! Do come in all and enjoy a pie. This is coming from a foodie and a pizza snob. read more

Outstanding pizza. Simple, fresh, piping hot right out of the oven. We love this place.

Amazing pizza without the angry hipster attitude. Yes they have pepperoni. Yes you can make substitutions. Yes they have a beautiful outdoor space with real chairs (who wants to sit at a park bench?). The service is a little slow because they have limited oven space but nothing crazy'. The sausage is a must. Great pizza minus the pretentious. read more

Corner Piazza - Sausage pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Eldred, New York

Best pizza. My family and I crave this pizza and we travel from Long to get the four cheese right out of the oven. All the pizza is great as well but that's our favorite. read more

Corner Piazza - Four cheese Brick oven Pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Eldred, New York

Just recently moved into the area and finally tried this place. All I can say is PHENOMENAL! My boyfriend and I got a white and margherita brick over pizzas to try. From the fresh ingredients to the flavor I was just blown away! And It was the perfect night to come try this place as it is sit outside. If you are ever passing through town I highly recommend to stop and visit! You will not be disappointed!! I will definitely be coming back to try the other pizzas they offer! read more

Corner Piazza - White Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Eldred, New York

See all

Delicious pizza. Fresh ingredients, small oven so ot takes some time for your order to arrive.

Pizza was so yummy and the brothers are funny, highly recommend checking out this place! The patio is inviting too.

The pizza and restaurant are very good quality, however the staff were not very pleasant and seemed rude this Sunday evening.

This place is awesome! It is all outdoors, so they aren't open year-round. The wood-fired pizzas are incredible and the service is great! We had the owner's brother wait on us, and he was so nice! Definitely check this place out! read more

Amazing place, amazing service, exceptional pizza and meatballs! Don't miss it! Worth a trip!

Tried to order a pizza over the phone and was told I had to be there to order it so I drove there and tried to order a pizza at the counter. The rude pizza maker asked me if I was there to pick up. I said " no, I would like to order a pizza". He said sorry, can't order a pizza, Pizza is table service only. This is the only pizza place in town where you can't buy a pizza!! Won't go back...ever read more

Being from the Bronx, I was used to having my pick of delicious pizza from a number of different pizzerias. After moving to the country, I was disappointed in the lack of amazing pizza. I mean, the pizza upstate is ok, but nothing to get excited about. Until my husband and I came across this spot. The Corner Piazza beats any pizza joint back in the old neighborhood (sorry Patricia's!). The margherita & pesto pies are absolutely delicious, while my husband loves the garbage pie. Only downside? Getting a craving in the middle of the winter when they're closed! read more

We stumble upon this neat little place late last summer looking for a place to eat with outside seating.(we love sitting outside in the summer) Friendly staff, cool little bar and pizza to die for!! A must try!! We will be back! read more

My new favorite place to eat on a nice weekend day. Great ambiance and fantastic wood fired pizza. Super friendly service. I LOVE this place! read more

Corner Piazza - Awesome outdoor stone fired pizza, ice cold beer and ice cream desserts! - Pizza Near Me - Eldred, New York

We were passing through town and almost didn't stop, but turned around when we saw the Corner Piazza - how could we pass it up?! Brilliant concept and tasty pizza. They also had a delicious meatball appetizer. We would absolutely stop here again and hope we have the opportunity to in the future! read more

Delicious fresh pizza. Fresh ingredients. Soft and crispy dough. It's just delicious and really sweet owners/staff. read more

Corner Piazza - Pizza Near Me - Eldred, New York

See all

This is a hidden Gem In Eldred New York. Located on the four corner intersection in Eldred is the Corner Piazza. This is an Outdoor Pizza Patio with a Wood Fired Brick Oven. There are several patio style tables with umbrellas as well several stools at the bar facing the Brick Oven and a flat screen TV. There is music piped onto the patio for your enjoyment at a nice level volume. This outdoor patio is only open Friday , Saturday and Sunday. The patio also closes at 8:00pm. One of the owners Lou took care of us and served us as well as made the most delicious pizzas with fresh ingredients. Lou pumped out 4 fantastic pizzas while engaging us in conversation about his establishment. It turns out Lou is very community oriented with several charitable organizations. Lou made us feel welcome and we thoroughly enjoyed our dinning experience. Lou finished the meal with the recommended Tiramisu which was creamy, fresh and tasty. Lou's Brother Frank stopped over who operates the liquor store across the street and was also very friendly and helpful. This place is a must stop when in the area. read more

See all

RUDE!!! OBNOXIOUS!! I would never return here again! The owner was extremely rude to my wife and 3 children when asked very simple questions. And to boot the pizza tastes like wet cardboard! Not even worth the one star. read more

Sit around an outdoor bar with a brick pizza oven and enjoy the fresh country air and great pizza

Great place to have a quick meal with excellent wood fired custom made Pizza's, generous salads and COLD BEERS. I have to go back and try their desserts......ran outa time on this trip! read more

This place is Awesome!! We love their wood fired pizza..and I my self am not a big pzza person..my husband is..but I love there's.. And so does he..great people..great outdoor place to eat..just all around good..and these people do alot for the surrounding communities.... At Christmas time they put on a great thing for the children....thumbs up to these guy's.!!! God bless! read more

Delicious pizza, fresh ingredients, and nice outdoor seating area. Also a great meatball appetizer. When you finish your meal, you can get fantastic ice cream across the street at their little shop (same owners). The only downside is that this place can get busy in the evening, and since all pizzas are made to order, there can be a long wait for the food. It's still totally worth it, though -- and if you're really hungry, just order the meatballs to last you till your pizza is ready. read more

Amazing! It's rare to find an authentic, quality wood fired brick oven pizza joint that tops their pizza with fresh basil from the garden and sources their wood specifically for their oven and what they are cooking. What's even more rare is finding this in a tiny town on a corner in upstate NY. If you are anywhere within 30 miles of this joint stop in and grab yourself a fresh Garbage pie or their newer, and equally amazing, Buffalo Chicken pie. read more

Great little pizza spot. Not far from home, so we rode the bikes up. That's an awesome ride anyway (Hawks Nest). GREAT atmosphere. With music playing and sun shining it just makes a good mood even better. Then the food comes....so good. Everything tastes fresh, delicious, and perfect. Staff is kind, helpful, and friendly. We will DEFINITELY go back. read more

Incredible pizza in a lovely setting! Every ingredient is fresh and delicious! We had the margherita pizza and it was exceptional! Highly recommended!! Will be back! read more

Delicious, great little spot that makes addictive pizza; if you're driving through from out of town, this spot is a must stop!

This pizza is among the best I've ever had! Fresh ingredients cooked to perfection in their wood fired brick oven. You can't go wrong with a margarita pie but then again they're all good. This is an awesome place run by great people, you will not be disappointed. Tell em' Margarita Man sent you;) By the way, It's only 25 minutes from Bethel Woods, incorporate it into your concert trip. read more

i have eaten here several times and each time its better then before...ive had the veggie,the margherita,the pesto and the garbage,plus the homemade tiramisu ,i cant say which my favorite is because they are all good! the staff is wonderful,friendly, full of suggestions ,fresh ingredients,fresh air,worth the 70 or so miles round trip !!! read more