Best Tuna Melt I've ever had (besides some I've made myself). Clearly made with love. Worth the…read moredrive from anywhere.

A Hidden Gem! A quaint historic building filled with…read moredelectable delights and friendly customer service. Very well thought out grocery and etc. The meal choices from the deli showcase are creative and all the items I've tried have been delicious. BEST PIZZA EVER!!! Give the Milanville General Store a try. You will not be disappointed!

Actually pizza not bad for being in the boonies Will be…read moreback when lunch in the boonies is needed

I gotta admit this is some of the better pizza I've had. He makes it just how I like it - thin and…read morecrispy, not too much cheese or sauce. You're probably not going to find better pizza in Sullivan county. It's just a standard take out pizza joint, but there are a few tables and a bar for dining in. 10/10

Nice little spot with great Irish vibes, especially with St. Paddy's Day around the corner. The…read moreatmosphere feels festive and welcoming, and the pizza smells absolutely amazing as soon as you walk in. Definitely a fun place to grab a bite and soak in the pre-St. Patrick's Day spirit!

Way overpriced, for the smallest portions! It was tasty but…read moreway overpriced . 3 small pieces of veal and small bowl of pasta was $39!!!! Soup and salad are now add ons with a charge . Sorry won't be returning

Stopped in for takeout and had a great experience! The pizza was delicious -- fresh, hot, and full…read moreof flavor. While we waited, we grabbed a couple of drinks and they were excellent. The staff was friendly and the atmosphere made the short wait really enjoyable. Definitely coming back!

I got here to grab a to-go pie based on the quoted 15-minute pickup time, and I arrived within that…read morewindow. However, by the time I got home 8 mins later, the pizza was completely cold--not even warm--which was unexpected given the timing. The pizza itself was average across the board: the crust, toppings, and sauce were all just okay. It was edible, but nothing stood out in terms of quality or flavor. The space appears family-friendly, with both indoor and outdoor seating, and a casual fire pit area. It also looked like there's a fairly full bar available.

Local gem - service is friendly and reliable, and food is always excellent. Pizza, eggplant and…read morechicken parm, shrimp oreganata are some favorites. Kids love the spaghetti. So glad to have them in town!

The best pizza in the Catskills is located at Michaelangelo's!…read more Was in the mood for pizza while on a short getaway. We found Michaelangelo's, certainly glad we did. The food is outstanding. We ordered a cheese pie, half regular, other half extra cheese. The quality of the ingredients is very high quality, and fresh. The sauce, cheese, and dough were very good. The prices are great. Service is very nice, friendly, atmosphere is very nice, clean, and a lovely place to sit, and dine. Even the bathrooms are spotless. Highly recommend you add this gem on your list of restaurants to visit.

It's not often I give a 1 star but the only reason this place gets any stars from me is due to the…read morebuffalo chicken pizza being so dang on good. I completely understand this is a family ran business but the hours of operation on Yelp and Google are not correct/have not been updated so on a Sunday I wanted to grab pizza and they ran out. We drove there from our weekend rental after seeing reviews of call-in orders not being accepted. It's a mess and if you don't live in this town there would be no way of knowing when it's last call for pizza. And for those reading this be sure to order pizzas by 4pm on Sundays to make sure they actually have pizzas available. We dined in on a Friday evening because it was the only open space dining spot in town and luckily we got our pizza within the hour (we were abruptly told the pizza would be a long wait before we were greeted) and since we had no place to be we grabbed some beers and waited. Our waitress was very nice and being that she was the only one serving I had sympathy for her but the guy making the pizza which I assume is the owner is frankly not nice. Maybe he needs to hire someone to work the front so he can focus on making the pizza's.

Awesome pizza and service! Great location. Fresh ingredients and perfectly made. Love this place!!!read more

Always tasty and dependable, usually on time when called ahead. I'm a fan of the Asian dishes on…read morethe menu, like the ramen, which is a little undersized for the price (and smaller than a real ramen restaurant) but still delicious, and by virtue of being the only ramen in Sullivan County, it's the best here. They have just recently expanded into a larger section of the building, with more seating, but I suspect most people, like myself, take their orders to go. A hidden gem in the county (it *is* in the middle of nowhere) but, even though I live 2 minutes from their sister location in Kauneonga Lake, this location has the superior menu.

Good food, good prices, and good variety. Definitely will continue to order & pick up here.read more

The food is SO good. I come from NYC so they have some high expectations to live up to in terms of…read morepizza, and they exceeded them. Such a great place to stop by on the lake. Also plenty of vegan options-- one of the only places over here like that! Pizza is also totally customizable which is awesome. Just wish they were open full year!

Friendly staff, charming owner and the best pizza I've eaten in years! The view of the lake was…read morebeautiful but it was a bit too chilly to sit outside. My family can't wait to go back to eat there again. Also I owned a house in Swan Lake across from the Stevensville Lake Hotel! What a coincidence!

I started to write my review and had to go back and read all the reviews because I was shocked they…read moredidn't have five stars. Yes the place is small, yes they have rules when ordering, but this is an experience. I have had many wood fired pizza from all over and this was the best I've ever had. This isn't your local pizza joint you bring the kids to this place is when you are going out with your significant other to enjoy a great meal.

The best pizza we have ever ate!. We come to Inn at St Josephs Lake every year with my wife for a…read morefew days and order every evening something new at the Farage. Never were disappointed with service, or food they served. Highly recommended to try

This has turned into a mainstay for my husband and I. We frequent this restaurant about 2X per…read moremonth. I have eaten everything on their menu and recommend it all except the bacon. But my husband loves the bacon and orders it all the time so it's not like it's bad... just not for me. April makes the best drinks! And my favorite there is the manhattan. They mist it with a little Laphroig single malt scotch. Delicious. Don't hesitate to try this place; you won't regret it.

Chohecton Fire Station was such a great find! The hummus and cheese board were absolutely awesome…read more-- fresh, flavorful, and beautifully put together. Everything tasted high quality and paired perfectly together. The vibes were on point too. Great atmosphere, relaxed but lively, and the music really set the mood without overpowering conversation. It's the kind of place you want to hang out in for a while.