highly upset i ordered an Italian sub and added turkey with American cheese and I don't understand how it became just a turkey with a half of slice of cheese!!! beyond disappointed... I also order a crispy chicken Caesar salad wrap with extra dressing on the side and they decided to make a grilled chicken Caesar salad wrap and not send the extra dressing!!! everyth about my order was incorrect! I sat on the phone for 7 minutes trying to place the order and couldn't eat because I didnt get what I asked for or what I paid for! yall need to do better read more

We ordered through DoorDash and got our order in good time. The Buffalo chicken pizza is AMAZING. The Philly cheesesteak pizza is good. Their crust is on the slightly undercooked side. Mozzerella sticks and Cesar salad was pretty good. Would order again, definitely didn't have a bad experience like other reviewers did. read more

Five Star Pizza - Signature Buffalo Chicken Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brockton, Massachusetts

See all

Totally worth the wait on a Saturday night. Veggie calzone, spicy fries, and Ceaser salad were fresh and flavorful. Will definitely order again! read more

Paying 20$ just to deliver my pizza i don't want to pay an extra 20$ I just want my pizza delivered not pay 20$

I ordered via Slice app for this Five star pizza place. Thought being named Five Start couldn't go wrong. I worked late so i ordered and had it delivered to my family before i got home. I was surprised how burnt and terrible everything came out. We ordered 2 types of cheese pizzas and cookies. ALL were burnt should not have been served. I called Slice 3 times to investigate why this would be sent and got no response. Of course, I couldn't call five star because they were closed. So, my family at like 1 piece of burnt food because they were hungry and we threw the test awasy. There goes $54 worth of food and delivery. I would NOT recommend this place read more

Five Star Pizza - two slices of pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Brockton, Massachusetts

If you're in the area and you want some great pizza, this small local joint is great! The quality of their food and service are always consistent. The owners remember you when you come in frequently and are really polite and nice. They often have special deals, like a free 2 liter soda with a large pizza or a free 20oz soda with a large sub. Can't beat free! I'm not a fan of their buffalo chicken, which doesn't taste as spicy and hot as their levels of spiciness claim (nuclear!). but they have really good French fries and I also enjoy their meatball sub! Lastly, this place won't completely empty your wallet! read more

HORRIBLE!!! Disgusting food and bad customer service. Ordered wings and 2 pizzas and the order was $50. Figured the food must be good for the price. Food came an hour and a half later. Wings smelled like pure FISH. Couldnt eat it. Called to get a refund and got hung up on, even though i offered to bring the food back uneaten and never got helped by a manager or anyone. Dont eat here, such a waste of &$. LITERAL TRASH . read more

The Signature Buffalo Chicken pizza is the best! It is pretty spicy, so beware if you don't like jalapeños. The pizza is so good I have never tried any of the other items on the menu. read more

I placed an order online through GrubHub for Five Star Pizza. The estimated delivery time was 45 to 55 minutes. Over an hour after the order was placed I logged on to check the status of the order. The updated delivery estimate was over an hour past the original given time. I called the store to check the status of my order. I was informed that I would have to call GrubHub to cancel the order. When I told the associate at the store that I was going to post a review all he said is "okay thank you I understand" and then hung up on me. Terrible customer service and not willing to help a customer in any way shape or form. read more

Worst experience EVER. Spent over $75 on take out. Never received it. Or an apology, reason to come back, nothing. Scratch that. I got a bad attitude, told me it wasn't their problem and to call the company they use. Granted, it was delivered by a third party, but if that was my company I'd make sure the costumes were satisfied and received the items they paid for. And if they didn't, of give them a free app or reason to consider using us again! I'll never even speak of them never mind eat their food. read more

I didn't even get a chance to taste the food. I tried to set up an order and they were having a conversation while I was waiting on the phone. I then asked what kind of ginger ale do they have either schweppes or Canada dry and couldn't give me a solid answer. He went to go "check" for two minutes and came by and said he doesn't know if it is schweppes or Canada Dry. read more

Takes FOREVER to get food every time I order. Have ordered about 10 times, food has NEVER been ready when I get there. I have been in the dining room for 40 minutes right now after arriving 20 minutes after ordering. Unacceptable read more

I've been to pizza places all over Brockton and this one is superb. Just the right combination of sauce, fresh cheese and toppings. They deliver within 20-25 minutes too which is pretty quick in this industry. read more

One of the guys I work with brought some leftover pizza in as his son is friends with the owners son. Well he brought in their buffalo chicken pizza and it was amazing. About 2 weeks later we order a pepperoni and a buffalo chicken pizza. While my 2 kids chowder the pepperoni my wife, brother in law, and myself ate the other. Both of them agreed with me that hands down that is the best buffalo chicken pizza we have ever had. Awesome food and highly recommended. read more

Went for pick up order for the kids and a small steak & cheese for myself... As usual the food was delicious and fresh... I made the mistake of getting an order of not so good chicken fingers next door at Nagoya.... Won't make that mistake twice... Stick with what works - 5 star is the best in town! read more

Some of the best pizza in Brockton! I'd give it 5 stars, but I think the prices are too high.

The reason this place gets two stars is because of their jumbo wing dings which ended up being the only thing we ate for dinner. First time trying this place. We ordered a large pepperoni pizza and a small bbq chcken with mushroom and olives. I took 3 bites of my pizza and just like that it was over, worst pizza i've ever had, the sauce was just awful. My husband and son got no sauce on their pepperoni, every time they took a bite the cheese would just peel right off or fall off the pizza. Really? It was almost comical. Our search will conitnue for real hand tossed pizza and great sauce. read more

The entire chicken wing dinner smelled like fish. I didn't appreciate the way he tried to tell me that I was making it up. I just wanted another plate or a refund as long as it was accomadated. Disgusting. read more

Waited an hour and 10 min for a delivery I placed at 5:15 when I was told 45-50 min. Food was ok but the steak tips were put on top of my fries which made them a bit soft. The wait was ridiculous considering they are right down the street. Won't order from them again. read more

$11 minimum delivery charge!!! I'll pass. I ordered a medium philly steak n cheese sub they told me I ordered a medium pizza... Never again

When I lived in Whitman that was my go to spot. Their buffalo chicken pizza is the best around and can't be beat. The also make a very, very good veggie pizza. If there was one thing I were to stay away from it would be the buffalo finger sub - not a fan of that. They make outstanding pizza and anytime I am in the Whitman area I make sure to stop in. read more

Use to be great, but it's average now. Prices are kinda high for the quality of food.

I love five starr Pizza in Brockton. The owners are friendly, they always remember your name. The prices are not so bad either. My faviort Pizza their is The Bufflo Supreme pizza. It is made with Bufflo sauce, bufflo ckn, blue cheese (which I dont like, but I LOVE it on here) Celery and jalapenos. (I personaly dont like Jalepenos, so I always order it with out them, but my husband loves them, so he always gets them with it) This is the best place to get your specilty pizza. I personaly love Cape Cod Cafe Cheese pizza, so I actualy have not even tried Five starr cheese pizza. read more

Pizza is good chicken is ok but there very unprofessional make sure you get menus and don't ask them any questions more then once they get bitchy. read more