Now that Panera Bread is closed within Mayfair Mall. They're serving breakfast Prices are outrageous for almost everything on the menu Plus side "free peanuts" if you really want to call it "free peanuts" Will I patronize this establishment again??? Most likely not based on the pricing read more

See all

I like the food here but not for the high price. We ordered 2 "Little" Cheeseburgers (which means a single patty) at $9.19 ea, 1 Little Fry for 5.19, and two small/regular cokes for 2.99 each. All of this came to $32. That is just too high a price for me when I can get the same cheeseburger meal for two elsewhere for under $15. Having said this, I did like the flavor of the burger, and the fries are tasty but not crispy. I understand this is their style, which has good taste, but they are too greasy for me. There are salted peanuts for you to grab while you wait for your order, and these are yummy. The location is in Mayfair Mall, with an outside entrance which is nice. There are several tables of different sizes and the young man at the counter was very friendly and nice. read more

Five Guys - This cost 32.00 - Fast Food Near Me - Wauwatosa, Wisconsin

Food is always delicious and hot. Service is quick and the ambiance is what you'd think any burger joint would be. My Fiance and I go there a few times a month. read more

Five Guys NEVER disappoints!!The best burgers, generous portions of fries seasoned to perfection and AWESOME staff to boot ! It is always worth the money! read more

As I started to think my cheeseburger from Five Guys for the $8 I thought it's getting long in the tooth from when they first opened. Today burgers are very popular and lots of choices are available today and you can get a really good burger or a craft burger for around the same money or a little more and some come with frys. Since I was at the mall it was convenient to just stop over with out seeking out one of those really good burgers places. The cheeseburger is good for fast food convenience and it's cooked fresh to order. My cheeseburger was topped with ketchup, raw onion, lettuce, tomato and pickles to keep it simple. The toppings were fresh and the bun was soft with the fresh cooked beef and I liked how the toppings are chilled and the beef is warm. I will probably have another cheeseburger In the future from here but I will have many from other places before that because all the choices that exist today. read more

See all

The best cheeseburgers in the country. They are simply the best. Tonight I tried the Cajun fries and they are pretty good. Ordering small (regular) fries and small Cajun fries worked out very well! I've been ordering FG for delivery, and it's a shame that milkshakes are not in the menu. read more

The food at 5 guys is great! I have been here a few times and it's always consistent. It is a little pricy but quality cost money and nothing is frozen, all fresh beef and fresh fries! They don't even have freezers. I would definitely recommend staying away from the shakes though it was not good! read more

2 hamburgers, 2 small (more than I could eat) fries, just water to drink = $28.18. That's 2 hamburgers = $18.18 2 fries = $8.38 tax $1.62 It's not that the burgers are bad. Pretty good meat, done well. And the fries are OK too. But not $30 worth for a burger and fries lunch. I gave it a 3 not only because of the pricing but the music was so annoying I couldn't wait to get out of there. Also I could not understand the order taker, after a couple tries I just guessed at his responses. Maybe just me, maybe the mask, maybe a bit of training on how to speak or emote through a mask. Not going back. As someone else said (John B), you can get some great burgers elsewhere. read more

There is just something about a five guys burger that is so, so very good. The ratios are spot on with each and every bite having the perfect combination of flavors, which for me comes from double patty, cheese, ketchup, mustard and fried onions. Knock the chains all you want there's a reason they're everywhere, it's the consistent, excellent burger they serve... read more

Any other Five Guys I would give 4 stars because I feel like the food is delicious and worth what you're paying for. This Five Guys gets 5 stars because of all of that, but mostly because of the employees. So this review is simply about the service, since I feel like the food is the same across all locations and definitely of a higher quality than most fast food burger joints. We live nearby and probably go to this location once or twice a month. I have yet to have a poor experience interacting with the staff. We go all different times and all different days and every single time the staff is polite, helpful, talkative, and seem to genuinely care about your experience that day. There are always plenty of employees and they are all itching to help you. A manager or supervisor has always asked me while we were eating in the restaurant if everything was as we had ordered and if it tasted alright. Occasionally they've also asked if they could get us anything and would drop off napkins or condiments. There's always been at least one employee in the dining area constantly cleaning and asking customers if they could dispose of their garbage for them. I would go to this Five Guys for the food as it's excellent as always. I will SPECIFICALLY seek out THIS Five Guys because of the staff and the pleasant experience I've always had there. Keep up the good work guys! read more

The bacon cheeseburger was pretty good. They do give a TON of fries, so you'll never feel as if you don't have enough!!! I'll go back, because the CS was excellent and like I stated the burger was good. Not the best I've ever tasted. Don't pass this place up if you've never been there, because each of our likes and dislikes are different!!!! read more

Living in the past Let me start by saying I really do like Five Guys. It's been some time since I've been here, but they offer up a great burger. That said, the place is decorated with signage that is dated years back. Your burger was great in 2008, but how does it compare today? For a chain burger, it's far better than the others. But today there are many local offerings which I'd rather devour. For lunch I spent just under $15 for a double cheeseburger, "small" fry and a soda. In hindsight, my belly would have been overjoyed to devour $15 in AJ Bombers or Merriment Social brgr. Customer service was great - the wait for my burger was not too long, the staff looked like they were happy to be flipping burgers and it was super clean. read more

It's ok. Not my favorite. Burgers are good, but a bit overpriced in my opinion. A burger, fries and soda will run about $18. If you like lots of toppings, then this is your place, you can get a variety of toppings for no extra charge. They're also generous with their fries because of "the dump": you'll get a cup of fries and then an equal amount of loose fries in the bag that come close to the container size. The fries have the skin on, and they must make them from scratch, because you'll find bags of potatoes near the register. They generously salt them, and when they come out crispy they're good. When they come out limp, not so much. They also have large bins filled with complimentary peanuts in the shell. Something to snack on while you wait for your order. Cool right? Not when they're stale and chewy. Gross. If you've never been, it's worth checking out. read more

Great food and great service. Definitely coming back to eat here again! Recommend to anyone who loves a great burger, fries and a shack!

Carried out some burgers and Cajun fries the other day. First time here. The Cajun fries were super spicy, almost too spicy (I love spicy food). Since we had takeout, they were a little soggy by the time we got home. A soon in the air fryer crisped them up. Portion sizes of the fries were crazy. Ordered the large size to share between two people. Bad idea. There were way too many fries for just two people. Seriously, order the smallest fries. Next time I know better. The burgers come with two patties and almost unlimited free toppings. One burger gave me two full meals. I had the bowl because they do not offer gluten free buns, just a lettuce wrap or the bowl. The burgers were cooked medium well. The meat was juicy and seasoned well. The toppings were very generous. Five Guys would get four stars if they offered gluten free buns and decreased the spice level of their Cajun fries. If I'm in the area, I'd stop again. read more

Remember a few years back when the world was creaming it's collective pants over Five Guys? The hype has died down, but you can relive the fun by visiting any Five Guys location which will be plastered with glowing reviews from such media stalwarts as the Wake Forest Gazette extolling the delights of the "Best Burger of 2009". Seriously, its probably time to update some of those signs. Anyway, for a chain burger Five Guys is pretty tasty. There's only a few things on the menu (hot dogs, grilled cheese and the burgers) so were ordered burgers and fries - because the name isn't Five Guys Grilled Cheese. I like that you can customize your toppings and that everything is made to order. The people that work at this location were actually pleasant and friendly, a rarity in fast food. My burger? Definitely above average in quality and decently priced at about $6.50 for a 1/2lb burger (burgers are two smaller patties though the menu doesn't really tell you that). Fries? Ehhhh...I'm in the camp that thinks Five Guys fries aren't anything special. They do give you WAY more than you need - a regular easily serves 2 people. They've also got one of those nifty soda machines from the future where you can make all types of different and disgusting drink combos if you so choose. Overall - Five Guys is pretty good for a chain burger place. But you shouldn't really eat here all that often because you'll die. The end. read more

Had my first five guys experience yesterday at the oak Creek location. I have to say I was a little underwhelmed the burger was fine fries were pretty good good selection of drinks but in my opinion the prices were a little bit high and just not that impressive. The staff were anything but engaging. If someone I was with said let's go there I'd be okay to do so but I would not choose to go again. read more

I ordered a milkshake and i was number seven, it took more than twenty minutes for it to come because the person making it would wait until there was no line. I feel as though I was not valued, even when the number of customers went down. I am very disappointed." read more

So disappointed in the burger that they sent over to my house and they claimed that they were doing the same as they always did it was terrible the burger was small the fries I could hardly there were hardly any there I had to throw it out there was so greasy they are a 15 minute ride from my place to the to the to the Mayfair mall where the five guys is and I think they're taking advantage of people in the in the virus right now I think they're cheating I'm giving them less food for more money and like I said I had to throw mine out in the garbage read more

Nothing to brag about , it's a yuppy thing. Way overpriced , I WOULD NOT WANT TO WORK THERE , THE GUY ON THE GRILL KEPT RUNNING HIS MOUTH NON STOP AND JOKING AROUND. Also , it's not like they give you extra fries to be nice , it's because the fries you order come in a dixie cup. There are a ton of other places you can eat for half the price they charge. read more

Pros: It's in a mall; You can grub up on your way to foot locker. It's a pretty good fast food burger. They don't nickle and dime you for add ons and condiments. They have crayons so you can write immature things about friends and hang naughty drawings on the wall. Cons: It's in a mall. Unless you need to go to foot locker, it's horribly inconvenient. I have never received great service here. One time it took 30 minutes to get my food. Thats ridiculous.They might not nickle and dime on add ons, but thats only because you've already paid $7-8 for the burger. In conclusion: They sell hamburgers. Sometimes it's convenient. Immature drawings. read more

When it comes to burgers and fries, make no mistake, Five Guys Burgers and Fries is solid. Chain or not, in any city's Best Burger competition, they deserve at least an honorable mention. I particularly like the way the patty is seared, offering a little outer caramelization, which just may be Five Guys' secret. But if not that, the light, sesame-seeded bun is certainly a contributor. If the best burgers have one thing in common, it's a bun that doesn't compete with the burger. But as delicious as I find the sandwich, this is one of the few reviews that I've penned where value plays a role in my rating. Thirty minutes before writing this review, I dined at Five Guys. My regular cheeseburger, regular fry and regular soft drink was two cents short of $14. I left $1 in the tip jar and my investment is $15!! Now one thing Five Guys doesn't do is make you feel ripped off--they do give you free peanuts and even a "regular" fry is more fries than one person can eat. HOWEVER, there are places in The Mil where you can get a burger of similar quality and a few less fries for seven bucks. At these few places, you can even add a beer to your meal and come out spending under $13. Perhaps it's because Five Guys was founded out East where everything is more expensive. I'm glad they brought their acclaimed burgers to Midwest--they are all that and a bag of, well... peanuts--but at fifteen bones a pop, Five Guys will be only an occasional treat for this one guy. read more

F eeling hungry after creating a wedding registry at C&B, I headed to Five Guys with my fiance. V egetables? No. I wanted Dayum Dayum DAYYYYUM good burgers. E veryone should try their free peanuts; they are salty though, just like the fries. G ood golly Ms. Molly - my favorite invention, the Coke Freestyle machine is in this U nusually small, but clean and organized restaurant space. Y es the employees were courteous, friendly, and polite. S adly, slightly overpriced as usual. read more

FIVE GUYS gets FIVE STARS Okay so, I've had Five Guys previously, and was satisfied, but after going there on pretty decently busy Tuesday, I'm blown away! First thing noticed upon walking into the restaurant was how clean it was, and as i said before, it was pretty busy. Second thing noticed is the tiny simple little menu, this is good. Laid out in black and white (and red ;), even if you are not sure what you want, you should be able to decide very quickly, choose something to put between your buns, choose condiments, fries? Drink? Yes, please! This is great given the complications we are faced with day by day. As me and my lovely companion were standing in an ever growing queue, i couldn't help but notice how friendly the young lady at the counter was. This is very nice because, when the hell was the last time you walked into a fast food restaurant and something that caught your eye was how nice and happy the employees were? Having pride in ones work is not something that usually goes hand in hand with fast food, or even full-service restaurants for that matter, this was a breath of fresh air to say the least. As we were helped by the aforementioned bright young gal, we shared a couple laughs and were not rushed, but helped in a fast and efficient manner. Working in a kitchen is hard when its busy, and its even harder being so nice and friendly to every single customer, but that's exactly what we received and exactly what we observed as given to every patron. After a five minute wait we received out boatload of fries, Cajun style, cooked to perfection, a bacon cheeseburger and a hot dog. Fries, obviously freshly cut, as noted by the 20 or so bags of potatoes sitting on a rack in the lobby, perfectly cooked and seasoned. Love that they fill the bottom of the bag, generous portions are hard to come across nowadays. The burger, a little one, can hardly be called little. Every ingredient freshly cut and placed on a fresh juicy burger patty, bursting with flavor. The hot dog, ordered Chicago style, with the same fresh ingredients, was sliced in half like id never seen before. It was like they made a burger out of a hot dog, it was awesome! The only thing i don't like about this place is that its so far away! Ive been to the one on Oakland several times and it comes nowhere near comparison to this little gem of a burger place! I shall come back here often and bask in the burger glory! KEEP UP THE GOOD WORK GUYS AND GIRLS! read more

Great burger! The Small burger would have been sufficient though, only one patty. The French fries were excellent and fresh!

Good burger, juicy and not dried out. Better than decent fries. Non-descript sesame seeded bun. One regular cheeseburger, one little cheeseburger, regular size fries (a whole lot of them), and a regular size beverage $23. Took forever to get the food and it was a quiet Sunday afternoon. Too much goofing around by the teenage/young 20s staff. read more

Not sure how this tiny overpriced burger thinks it could compete with Kopp's or Sobleman's

I first read about Five Guys several years ago in GQ, where they noted the franchise as the fastest growing burger chain. I've stopped in for their delectable double patty burgers several times in various locations. For a big chain, they're probably as good as you'll get. There's nothing overly special about the place other than that all burgers are cooked to order, and the myriad amount of toppings you can add. Note: avoid the lettuce (This reviewer enjoys bacon, tomato, grilled onions, and pickles with a dash of A-1) and build at your own risk - the burgers fall apart the more you add. I should note the fries are pretty tasty -- add the Cajun seasoning if you're looking for a blood pressure spike. Overall, I'd rather nosh on Sobelman's, AJ Bombers, or Kopps (among the many other Milwaukee options) but in a fix Five Guys will do. read more

In the year 79 C.E. Mt. Vesuvius erupted, covering the Roman city of Pompeii in 20 ft. of ash. A similar catastrophe occurred when I asked for ketchup and mustard on my Five Guys cheeseburger. Just as the eruption disrupted centuries of Roman art and culture, this ungodly amount of condiment on my burger was a grave distraction from what is normally excellent quality beef and fresh ingredients. I certainly retain my trust in Five Guys' burger flipping ability, but for the love of God, do NOT let these psychos touch a ketchup bottle. read more

ive been to multiple five guy resturants and the one located on mayfair knocked them out of the park! this burger smacked! the cajun fries were perfectly crisp. i brought a egg for them to fry and put on my burger and they actually did. service was amazing and the managers were likable and friendly. my favorite employee was liam. read more

My boyfriend and I drove to Milwaukee for Summerfest this week, and neither of us have had Five Guys before. We decided to stop and grab food at this location before leaving. The staff was extremely friendly! Really enjoyed the staff at this location, they set an example of a vibe all restaurants should project. I know they purposely give you bag fries at this chain, but it seems like they hooked it up for us especially. The burger was amazing, delicious and fresh. We didn't know that the normal burgers are a double, so the "little" version definitely would've been enough with a medium fry!! It ended up being a little expensive, but if you're smart and know the portions you can get out of there full and satisfied at a decent price. Everything is truly made to order, so the fries were the best I've ever had! All I can say is I'm glad they don't have one in Waterloo, Iowa because I'd be their number one customer! read more

Five Guys - Huge amount of fries - Fast Food Near Me - Wauwatosa, Wisconsin

Great!! Workers are always friendly! The manager was at the register with a new employee and we were all just making small talk. I mentioned that my daughter had just received a scholarship to Marquette University and when I handed my card to pay, the boss gave it back to me, and said it was on the house! Total surprise, made our day!! Food is GREAT too!!! Thanks Five Guys, best customer service in town! read more

Its ok but over priced for a burger. I didn't really think it was the greatest. It was good though and much better then McDonalds. I think its their fries that are the best. read more

Workers consistently changing gloves, this is what I pay attention to most. Every time they handled a new topping or patty, they switched gloves. Satisfied with their attentiveness, keep it up, that doesn't happen everywhere and people notice! read more

Been coming to Five Guys since they started in DC and experience have always been very good. This time I had great service! After placing my standard order I was looking up Five Guys Secret Menu and found the Patty Melt option. One employee said they do it, and another asked if I wanted to change my order. Of course... Very cool in the moment reaction to a customer desire! read more

Wow that was good. Disclosure, I'm not really a burger guy. But I thought the hamburger here was delicious. I really liked it.

I purposely avoid Five Guys because I know once I eat their burger I'm going to want another one like everyday for the next 2 weeks. They have the best fast food burger in my opinion. I can't exactly pinpoint what makes them so good - they just are. The fries are nothin special - I don't even order them when I eat here. If you do order them, beware - you can split the regular size between a couple people easily. read more

Went to 5 Guys in Mayfair, ordered a couple burgers and a large fries ($5.00). We got our order and there was a small amount of fries in the normally overflowing cup and no extra sack dump. I thought that they may be cutting corners and eliminating the sack dump but decided to watch the fries guy to see if he was making the dump.. I watched him bag a couple orders with small fries and he did the extra dump that made them famous.. We were going to leave a little mad and my wife said I should mention it to the clerk. I did and the manager who was standing next to her went into panic, apologized and set me up for a free meal, diffusing any bad feelings I was going to leave with..excellent customer care... read more

Huge fan of 5 guys. They are consistently the best $8 burger you can buy. they are freshly made and the fries are even good. The meal is extremely filling and for $10 I can't think of a better meal. read more

All the hype I heard right before this place came to Mayfair, was for nothing. The burgers were ok, but the fries were terrible, they were greasy, soggy and under cooked. The choice of toppings is good, and also dictates price, which isn't terrible, but in my opinion not completely worth it. read more