Overpriced slightly better than okay burgers. Seriously if I have to spend $50 for a mediocre double burger, fries and shake... actually, no. I take that back. If I'm spending $50 on burgers, fries and shakes? I'm going to Shake Shack and getting change. How does this place get the rep it does? read more

Very nice place, clean and neat. I was pleasantly surprised. The food was so delicious. Compact, humble teamwork over there, preparing tasty food for hungry New Yorkers. And they are doing that with a lot of passion, professionalism, and skills. They definitely deserve each $ they make. And a raise as well! For both manager and staff. They know what they are doing. My bacon cheeseburger was out of this world, juicy, meaty, rich, succulent...mmmmhhhh!! Fries...McDonald's should learn from them! Sodas from the fountain, free refill. Fast service, my burger was ready in 5 minutes. Clean restrooms, considering the bustling neighborhood. A few steps from the Church of Jonh Divine. read more

See all

Food is pretty great for fast food. I wouldn't compare it to a nice sit down place but for convenience it does the job. The food I got was a little cheeseburger with lettuce, mayo, bbq, grilled onion, and jalapeños. When you get quite a few condiments the burgers get a bit messy, but that's understandable with the amount of stuff I put in it. Along with the burger I got little Cajun fries and a milkshake to share. I prefer the Cajun the fries over the regular, however I do wish they were more crispy. The milkshake was vanilla and it tasted great. It wasn't too sweet and it was just the right consistency for a milkshake. The service was fast for the food, but the pickup ate gets quite crowded and you kind of have to push around to grab your food. They also forgot the shake at first so I had to go back through the crowd ask for it. I was there during dinner time so I'm pretty sure that's why it was quite busy. But other than crowding the people working we're nice and had no problem getting me the shake when I said it was missing. I would definitely go back again. read more

See all

Yes, I'm 7 months late..April 2021. Parking is very limited, your best bet is to double park and have someone wait in the car. Outside is very sketchy. You have people hanging out in front of the restaurant which is next to a Chipotle. Food was great! Maybe because I was extra starving. Lol. Ordered a well done bacon cheeseburger with Mayo & lettuce. Fries were good as long as they come fresh out the fryer. read more

See all

It was pretty good all around. It didn't take long to order and the staff were nice. Once we ordered it did take a little bit to get all the food, but it was dinner time so it's understandable. It can be hard to grab your order when they call it because people tend to crowd the pick up counter. When we got our food it was warm and fresh. I ordered a little hamburger, plain and it was well-cooked. I also got a little fry Cajun style and it was pretty good. They included lots of seasoning, but it wasn't my favorite. I think I prefer the regular fries. The vanilla milkshake was great, but it came out about 7 minutes after the rest of the food. Would eat there again. read more

See all

I ordered large fries for $8.39 with the expectation that they will give me the 'Five Guys Portion' of fries. But nope. Just a cup-full of fries. No more fries in the paper bag. Who charges $8.39 for this amount of fries? Really Five Guys? Please make this right. read more

Five Guys - Burgers Near Me - New York, New York

Disappointed! We order from them at least once a month. I hate that I have to go through a delivery service but it is what it is. I ordered a Little Bacon Burger and forgot to get the cheese. So once we got the order I went to add the cheese and the hamburger patty had a huge chunk out of it. and you can tell that it was cooked that way because the area was seared on the edges where the rest of the patty would have been so technically I got 3/4 of a patty. It is already super expensive with delivery let alone trying to get something fixed. VERY DISAPPOINTED!!! read more

Five Guys - WHERE'S THE BEEF? - Burgers Near Me - New York, New York

I never thought that I would give a Five Guys locations a low rating. But there is a first time for everything. I ordered from this location after finding it on UberEats. I was craving their burgers, which I had on the regular back home in California. I ordered a hamburger, with my usual toppings. Simple enough, I didn't think the folks here would mess it up. But I was wrong. The topping where not what I ordered, and the burger was cold and stale. It looked like it's been sitting under a heat lamp for a day or two. The Five Guys locations in California are legit, at least the ones I went to on the regular. But this locations gives Five Guys a bad name. Come on, people, get it together! read more

Just had a little burger. Came out quick, as ordered with a crispy edge to boot!. It's not Shake Shack but it doesn't have to be. It's a very good burger built your way. This Columbia Un. location is consistently good. read more

Very greasy burgers and fries. Hot dogs are more typical. Decent for a quick bite, but may be a bit heavy.

I ordered delivery and got my food delivered in a decent time, but opened the bag and was given the completely wrong order. Called the restaurant and they put me on hold for over 20 minutes, called back no answer. Worst costumer service! read more

I came down to this location a few days ago and it was legit. Service was A1 from the cashier, (tall, thick, white boy) on down. Coke freestyle machines appear to be in service. I got all the toppings I asked for, fries straight from the oil piping hot. Got home and my food was still warm. Seating capacity has resumed at 35%, so folk were inside eating. They were good to me. read more

Five Guys - Burgers Near Me - New York, New York

See all

I usually take a delivery order with a pinch of salt, but five guys near Columbia always delivers. Granted, it's 2 blocks away so even delivery is pretty quick, but I digress. No frills, quality ingredients, and a friendly staff for the days you do stop into the brick and mortar. They also NEVER skimp on the fries. They always fill the bag regardless of location, but I always feel like I'm getting even a little more than the typical portion here. My wife and I can split a small and still feel like it was almost too much. Again, if you're ordering from 30 blocks away, sure. This might not travel well in the dead of winter. That said, it's a great fast food option in a neighborhood with only so many fast food burger options. read more

Gave me the worst food poisoning... couldn't even keep liquids down... projectile vomiting all afternoon

Thanks, Five Guys, for twice screwing up my takeout orders! One order had an item missing and the other order had an extra product charged.

I literally have nothing negative to say about this place. The staff is always very friendly and efficient. The restaurant is always clean and even when it's packed, I've never had an unpleasant wait. Now for the food -- this is one of my favorites, second to Shake Shack. The burgers are perfectly cooked, not too raw, not too well done. I always load my burger with plenty of toppings and they always get it right. The fries are equally as perfect. Whether I get them regular or Cajun, they never let me down. Note: I always get the small fry because they dump an extra scoop in the bag which adds up to a medium. The prices are kind of steep, but the fry trick saves you a bit. If you love a great, juicy burger and a pleasant atmosphere, definitely stop by this Five Guys location. They won't let you down. read more

Five Guys - Burgers Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Since they opt out of reviews (for obvious reasons) on Grubhub, here I am. This place is a disaster. Items were missing from my order and the burger was a mess. Delivery guy ran away down my hall yelling back at meet that I'm wrong and everything is in the bag. Nope. When I called the restaurant, manager said the system shows everything was delivered. nope again. So essentially I was called a liar, twice. The burger looked like the toppings were thrown on from across the room and then they played catch with it. Absolutely disgusting. Don't order from here. read more

Five Guys should not partner up with Uber for deliveries. They stole our food with no regard for the customer.

I've been coming to this Five Guys location for years. I loooove their burgers and the fact that you can customize them and add all kinds of toppings. They always give a ton of fries so I never get anything bigger than the small size. The location is pretty big with plenty of seating and its wheelchair accessible. It's always in order and very clean. I like that you can eat as many peanuts as you want while you're there, they're pretty good. There's also a little section where you can leave love notes/recommendations for the restaurant. Id say its a little on the pricey side but worth it. read more

See all

Ate here and then had bad diarrhea that lasted all night! You might think "Well, that's a you problem," but the fact I'm seeing so many other reviews on here that also describe unsanitary experiences and rude/inconsiderate staff, I think my concern about the food is justified. read more

I have never had five guys so I wanted to try it out when it moved into my neighborhood. The difference between the "Little" and the regular burger is the patties. The "little" comes with one patty and the regular comes with two. I got the "little" as that is usually how many patties I eat. I also had the cajun fries which are the same price as the regular fries but come with seasoning. The price is comparable to Shake Shack so not the cheapest but moderately priced. The two patties is more expensive than one obviously and you will pay for it. Total price for two people was about $20 sharing the fries and the drink. I ordered the "little" hamburger and added mushrooms, lettuce, tomatoe and mustard, ketchup. I forgot the pickles! The burger tasted good but the bun wasnt as toasted as I would like and got soaggy quickly. I like that you can add the toppings you would like though. The fries were good with the seasoning but could use more crunch. Overall I enjoyed my burger but this is not my favorite burger place in New York. Will come back if I am around and in the mood though. Place is popular with all though and are usually busy but plenty of seating to be had. Not a place you go to for ambiance but for convenience and a burger. read more

I've always heard good things about this chain, and finally gave it a try with a fellow Californian. Was hesitant at first because the reviews are so poor, but yelp isn't always the most reliable thing. Had no clue what the difference was between a regular and a little, but we both went for the little cheeseburger with everything and shared a regular fries. The little was more than enough for me... I was expecting sliders, but it actually seemed like a regular sized burger. You get all the toppings for free, which is pretty cool. As reviews said, the portion of fries is huge, and you better believe it. We didn't even finish half of the fries because we were too full. Fries are okay, not crispy or crunchy...more on the thick side. Our total was a little over $15, which is hella expensive for 2 burgers and fries. I'm still adjusting to New York prices, but geez. read more

Five Guys - Little cheeseburger - Burgers Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Almost every night I'm with my friends we end up back at this Five Guys. The staff is so personable talking to you the entire time or cracking jokes as if you were in the back with them. They never mess up your order and always make it taste so so great. Their double bacon cheeseburger paired with a peanut butter milkshake is to die for. And they are more than generous with the fries. I will continue to come here as long as I'm around the area. read more

Five Guys - Burgers Near Me - New York, New York

Whatever drugs they're feeding the staff members here, they should sell them on the market to all restaurants. I've been here many more than I have checked in, and I have never been disappointed. The staff has always been very upbeat and friendly. The food is naturally fresh and awesome given how the restaurant is supposed to work. If I could say one thing to improve, I would just say to keep the drinks dispenser full of syrup more often. read more

Five Guys - Burgers Near Me - New York, New York

I had such a good experience her today for lunch. Maybe it's because all the students are gone and the staff are just that much happier - but I was greeted with a warm smile and my colleague and I's food was ready in no time flat. I had a double cheese burger and I couldn't have been happier. Top that off with a peanut butter shake - I was basically eating my feelings and my feeling was joy my friends ... Feeling. Joy. First time in this joint but having lived in DC for 5 years this franchise has lived up to 5 guys reputation. Definitely worth returning again to dive deep into grease and deliciousness. Also it was one of the cleanest 5 guys I've ever been to. I mean usually you see hansel and grettle style peanut drippings all over the place - but someone came out to sweep every 10 minutes it seemed. Top marks! read more

Five Guys - I want you in my life forever ... #neverletyougo - Burgers Near Me - New York, New York

Loved it. There r always times when I crave for some calorieslettuce wrap is refreshing and feel less guilty lol

This is one of those places I complain about yet go to over and over. Their damn too-convenient location to my apartment gets me every time. Plus, they are open later than chiplote and subway. I find their food expensive for a take out kinda joint. For the same price I could eat at Deluxe or that other hamburger place whose name I forgot - and just get take out there. But, I am lazy and the location is close to my apartment, when my lazy ass doesn't want to walk a few more blocks to a diner. But, my biggest gripe is that for the same price, I could get a take-out burger at an actual diner. Plus, it takes a long time. The wait isn't that long, but for a take out place, I find sometimes it's just...long. I'd expect that kinda of wait at a restaurant, but I don't eat at 5 guys for ambiance. But damn, it is good. And I grabbed a burger there last night. read more

Pretty bad, the people who work there are rude and cooks are untrained. I'll let the picture speak for itself. Keep in mind this was like $13. I asked for lettuce and mushroom. No mushroom and 1 piece of lettuce. Disgusting. read more

Five Guys - Little Hamburger - Burgers Near Me - New York, New York

Ordered two burgers and a large fry. Took them an hour to deliver cold burgers and did not include the fries. Subpar, do not plan on ordering again. read more

Seriously.... I have a weakness for Five Guys.... It is such unhealthy food but it just tastes SOOO GOOOOD!!!! The staff at this Five Guys location is extremely efficient and friendly. I came on a Saturday evening and the place was packed, my order took about 7 minutes to be prepared and it was cooked and prepared to perfection!! Juicy double patty burger with lettuce, tomato, cheese, bacon and ketchup.... it's the meal that you should feel guilty about but just can't because it was that good! I wouldn't recommend you come here on a weekly basis (your waistline and heart probably wouldn't recommend it either) but if you have a cheat day and want to indulge in a juicy burger and some really good fries, then make a stop at Five Guys! read more

Five Guys - Oh baby... - Burgers Near Me - New York, New York

NOTE: THIS IS ABOUT DELIVERY NOT PICK-UP Delivered me a COLD burger. Doesn't't reheat well. I know it's mainly the delivery services fault but they obviously made it well before the driver arrived because the burger was stone cold when I got it. Just plain gross and won't be ordering delivery again. read more

A good experience and delicious burger. Everyone loves digging at the fries at the bottom of the bag. Well they do the favor of dumping a whole bunch down there in addition to the fries that you ordered. Something about them that is really good, perhaps that they are double fried. Not to long ago they added milkshakes to round out the meal. You can also get creative with the options, for example by adding a burger to the grilled cheese and get a Patty melt. And while you wait, snack on the free Peanuts. read more

Walked here to find out their Flex dollars machine didn't work. Ordered anyway. Burgers were not even mediocre. And are way too expensive for fast food. Don't go here. read more

All the ratings are for the Cajun fries. The burgers are good too. A meal is totally affordable. Come here to treat your cravings. read more

So overpriced it's a joke. Two single patty burgers and a hot dog for almost $20? Ridiculous. It's at least $5 less for the same order at Shake Shack and the quality is better. read more

Just received my order, what I wanted most was a banana milkshake and of course it was missing !!!!! I called Five Guys did not get an apology. They just told me that I have to call Grub-hub, which I did. Grub hub said they will reimburse me. But the point is get the order correct. read more

This place is really good! The burgers are reasonably priced ($6.49 for a small cheeseburger) and fresh. The service was fast, friendly, and consistent. Tldr; good fast food in Morningside Heights read more

FIVE GUYS you got one job! Only one! Make Burgers and Fries. I mean it is in your name after all. Friday night at 10:18pm. "Hello Ma-am, just to let you know we're out of burgers" "You're out of burgers???" "And fries" "AND FRIES, but you are called 'burgers and fries'" "I'm very sorry but we can make you a hotdog or a grilled cheese" "You are very lucky that I love hotdogs!" ---- Besides calling me Ma-ma (I'm no ma-am) the service was friendly and fast, and I'm always a fan of the burgers (when they have them) and now I'm a fan of the hotdogs. read more

Oh my freaking gosh, this place is so delicious. I felt like a super hero fat kid. This place reminds me of In-N-Out Burger, but possibly better. Only thing that needs improvement are the shakes. Cajun fries were on point and the burger oh gosh the burger. Super moist, cheese melted on perfectly, bun toasted just right. I wouldn't change one damn thing on how they create their burgers. If you grew up to or are a parent/aunt/uncle,etc and watched Sponge Bob, it's like crusty crab burgers. You immediately fall in love after your first bite. Yes, it is true. This location is clean, busy, has friendly staff, and makes your order quick- which is great. read more

Whoa! DIdn't know this was here. Pleasant surprise on a lovely spring day. Let's get down to it. - Truly delicious burgers....meat of some super fancy, and I'm guessing--super happy--cows (could sad cows produce such excellent-tasting beef? -- methinks NOT) - The fries are good (cajun fries simply have some fancy dust strewn about -- no batter like Popeyes).....and..they load your bag full..I'm a big eater and I couldn't finish a small - They have Coke Zero on the fountain and free refills - score! - Simple, no fuss menu -- similar feel to In-N-Out and Shake Shack My Yelp rating could be higher..... - Fifteen mother freaking bucks for a burger, fries and drink - 25 minutes (I timed it) wait at 2pm on a Wed (after you order.....waiting for your food). Yum, but only affordable now and again. read more