Everything topping no extra charge, yes please!! Worth every penny for the quality burger you are getting. Not to mention how generous they are with the fries that taste like heaven. Always a go to when I'm in the mood for a quality burger read more

Love five guys!! #1 burger spot when I'm craving a burger. I love that you can add as many toppings as you want and it's all part of the nice price. The service is always so fun and friendly at this location and the free peanuts and extra fries is something you can't beat read more

See all

Word of advice if ordering for takeout check your order fully before leaving. Open each wrapper and look. I ordered a bacon burger but it came with no bacon. My son's burger came without his favorite mushrooms and pickles. I called the store who offered to remake the order but I live ten minutes away to have to go back and forth. The fries at least were correct and the order was ready at the time I wanted it Place was clean. Even though I was craving five guys for days it will be awhile before I go back. Again check everything before you leave read more

Just under $60! for three little bacon cheeseburgers and one double plus two fries and medium drinks. It was "ok" but not worth it. I couldn't eat enough peanuts to make it worth it. read more

Five Guys - Burgers Near Me - Merrick, New York

I do not visit this Five Guys in Merrick, very often but the times I came to eat were at night the place was very clean and the food was just as I ordered it and the fries were excellent. First class customer service. I would give 90% of the credit to a lady worker (black t-shirt) who seems to be in charge, but this week we went at lunch time and it was a disaster. This worker seemed to be arriving or taking something from a black truck (black t-shirt). We entered almost at the same time. We did not see him wash his hands and with a very strong smell of tobacco and sweat, the food was poorly cooked and not to mention the terrible fries. read more

Food is so overpriced and food takes so long too come out when we are the only people here, 26.15 for a burger shake and fries is the biggest scam ever . Way too overpriced for mediocrity read more

Prices to high They tru to rip you off order a regular burger and you get a double??? I had a bug in the lettuce yes they took it back and refunded my money but it took 10 minutes and no apology whatsoever , then I counted my money and they short changed me Pit stop for take out burgers if you don't want Wendy's or Burger King read more

Usually have a good experience. This time, not so much. I brought my daughter in after picking her up at school. We ordered fries (how could you not), a burger for me and grilled cheese for her. The food takes a little while which I don't mind since the cook it to order. The fries were great. The burger was good hut, my fault for not realizing, I was given and charged for an extra burger. The bad part comes while waiting. The staff was talking while working which is not an issue. They should enjoy being at work. The language was the issue. One of the woman, who was working the grill and fries, was cursing. Not just once, because I have been known to drop the occasional f-bomb, but multiple times while we waited. My 8 y/o heard because I saw her eyes go wide. I didn't mention it to her or to the staff because I didn't want to make a big deal in front of my daughter. Again, I don't mind the talking but cursing isn't appropriate when there are customers around. read more

Five Guys - Burgers Near Me - Merrick, New York

I was on Long Island and hungry. I've always liked 5 Guys burgers even though they've gotten more expensive post-Covid. My burger was fine. Not terrific but fine. My order of little fries almost fell out of the bag, I received so many. But, EIGHTEEN DOLLARS AND CHANGE for a burger, fries and soft drink? No. There are far too many places, not fast food joints, with better burgers for less money. read more

This place is like every five guys I've been too. It's fine. I'm not sure why, but I feel they used to be a little better and the prices were lower, but they are fine. You go in and order the burger how you want it with a lot of sauce and topping options. They make it fresh and wrap it up. The fries are usually overflowing the container in the bag, but they seem to have reigned that in a little. The large shakes are what a medium shake used to be, but most places have gone that way. The staff was friendly and following all the safety procedures they should. The wait was a little, but that is expected. If I wanted five guys, this is an average one and close to where I live. I will probably be there again for those reasons. read more

Walked in and walked right out. Lol sorry ain't no burger worth $12 except for a Gordon Ramsey burger for $20-$30. 5 guys lunch would have costed like $30 for a cheeseburger, fries and a soda. I guarantee I make better burgers and so do most home cooks. Save your money and go someplace else. First time and def the last time ever stepping into a 5guys burger spot. I'm sure there good but extremely overpriced, and not worth it one bit. New York needs an In and Out burger place. read more

Burgers very average. Fries are good just another overpriced and over rated place, it takes very little to get people in Bellmore or Merrick excited, we really have very mediocre restaurants. read more

Just sent this feedback to Five Guys Corporate: "We've been huge fans of FG's for years. Ordered online yesterday and headed right over to the store since the ETA was 9 minutes. Got there and was told the order would be about 5 more minutes. I then watched as my order was assembled, then left to sit for approximately 5 minutes, unwrapped, while the first worker on the line - and apparently the MOD - continued to stack up orders behind it that the staff clearly was having trouble filling, rather than completing the orders on the line. Finally, my order was wrapped, by the grill guy who clearly was frustrated as well, then sat a few minutes more until the first line worker took bacon from the fryer, unwrapped my order, added bacon, then rewrapped it. it then sat for a couple more minutes. Finally, I told the worker packing the orders that I wasn't happy with the order sitting out for 10 minutes. He went to the first line worker, the apparent MOD, who shouted across the kitchen something I couldn't hear. When I motioned to my ear, she came over and told me, rudely, that she had to wait for the bacon and that the order was fine. I said that sitting open for 10 minutes wasn't fine to me, to which she replied that the table was heated, as if that would add the juice back to my burgers. I told her that didn't make it any better and she barked "What do you want, a refund???". I told her to pack the order and I'll take it up with corporate, so here I am. If this was my first visit to Five Guys it would likely have been my last. And I don't know that I'll return to that location, as there are not only other FGs within a short drive, but ample other options like Shake Shack, Smash Burger, and a whole lot of local burger joints. I don't need to be treated rudely and told that my food sitting open on the pass for upwards of 10 minutes is OK. It is not, and we had tepid, dry burgers for dinner, with the outlandish price of $50, PLUS my $5 TIP. Not happy at all. Will be copying this to Yelp shortly" So there you go. read more

While I usually love five guys my experience has turned me off. I ordered through Uber eats.. when my order arrived cold, I anticipated that (a delivery service) but not only cold half my order was NOT in the bag!! I called to complain (Uber does refund you) because my meal was a bag of fries, well the manager said sorry Uber will refund you, it's the drivers fault... what??? Maybe you should change how you serve delivery service customers... PERHAPS PUT CUSTOMER NAME ON BAG SO YOU CANT BLAME THE DRIVER (said driver grabbed wrong bag) Won't eat there again!! read more

It was alright, I was hungry and made a stop-simple. The burger did not blow me away, I did not see what the big deal was. Good: -The burger was very filling -They are generous with their toppings -For a busy story, they get the orders out in a decent amount of time Bad: -The burger while filling, wasn't flavorful to me -Cajun fries tasted like potatoes dipped in Lawry's Seasoned Salt -Ordering a regular tasting burger & salty fries for $15 was disappointing to me -Cleanliness, I know it's busy but they need to wipe the tables down every so after the customer makes a mess of the place with the peanut shells and such read more

I'm giving him them the benefit of the doubt with the 4th star. So often, I wish yelp allowed half stars, because this should be 3.5 star review. Burger was tasty, a definite step beyond any fast food joint. The fries were also head and shoulders above your average diner's. That said, $15 for a burger, small fries and a small drink is pretty steep. The free peanuts are nice, but not a game changer. Newer chain burger joints are popping up constantly, offering a wider array of burgers, sides and beverages. As I said before, 5 Guys gets the benefit of an extra 1/2 star due to being the impetus for the recent explosion in the quality chain-burger joints. read more

Five Guys - Almost $15 for burger, fries and drink?  It's good, but not that good. - Burgers Near Me - Merrick, New York

Second time here within a month and the fries taste great but if I'm paying for a large they need to be large. They have looked like a small size. I've been to a few five guys and i noticed a big difference the times I've been here. The first time my husband went back in to say should they look this small. The guy said no not at all and topped it up. The second time he knew to check while inside and asked. The lady said that's how we do it .ummm you may want to tell all the other five guys!! Sort out the fries please. read more

Ordered through Uber eats. I ordered a burger with lettuce as the bread and it's completely Soggy they put way too much sauce. The entire bag was covered it in and when it was brought inside it got all over my coworker.. Don't recommend ordering out.. read more

This milkshake didn't bring the boys to the yard. Burger made my heart stop so that's cool. Looking forward to that doctor bill. Not bad.

Just are at five guys. Two burgers with soda and small fries $30 bucks and not worth 30 bucks! They forgot the onions on both burgers I will never eat at another five guys again read more

Just went here and apparently when you order a regular burger it means double patty and with cheese , the person that took my order also asked what size fries I wanted , I told her medium and then they didn't give me my fries and they tell me that they did not charge me for them , that's not even the point the point is that I ordered something and the messed up the order and then don't even give me the fries that I ordered. Never going here again , awful customer service awful service all together. read more

After hearing about this franchise and seeing them around, I have one word to describe my experience - DISAPPOINTMENT OK, the burgers are tasty and you can get it with whatever you want on them, the Cajun fries were somewhat tasty and you get huge portions (of fries) but the burgers are freakin TINY and OVERRRR PRICED!!!!! When I was done ordering for 2 adults and 3 children, I didn't expect to be paying almost $60! It might have been ok if the burgers were huge but I'm a man with an appetite. My kids are far from big but they have a decent appetite also. After dropping that kind of loot, I shouldn't want or need another burger. My coworker suggested I try the place out and he's lucky it was a weekend, because if it had been the next day when I next saw him...WHOOOOWEEE, I wouldda been fired! read more

My day off so after getting my hooves and nails done i headed here for a quick Lunch/Dinner on my way home. I also stopped at Bagel Boss to spend my paycheck on a roll and piece of cake BUT thats another story. It was clean and guy took my order. I got my soda and ate my meal in peace. Guy next to me went thru 5 buckets of peanuts..Good for you George Washington Carver. As you can see by my picture they listen to your requests lol. It was good my fat ass is nice and full and im already in bed watching Better Call Saul. Good monday indeed. read more

Five Guys - They take light mustard seriously lol - Burgers Near Me - Merrick, New York

The burgers are great. The fries are pretty good. The prices... the prices kind of suck. Tonight was our second trip there and we ordered 3 "little cheeseburgers," 2 regular fries, 3 regular drinks, and it came to $27 with tax. That seems like a lot. For that much money you can get a whole lot more food at All-American Burger. Bottom line - great burgers, not great value. read more

Just like any other Five Guys...huge, fresh burgers, seemingly unlimited (and free!) toppings, delicious fries, and peanuts (also free!). The fries come in immense proportions, with a regular easily able to feed two adults, or 1/2 of a Rex Ryan. Get 'em cajun style, which is basically with Lawry's Seasoned Salt but so good. I love that I can get grilled onions on my burgers there, which are made to order, and the cheese is actually melted on the patties. That's right, patties. Two patties to a single burger here. Free peanuts, although I'm not sure why they have them, is awesome too. It just works. All of it just work. I want to meet the five guys, and I want to thank them for their magnificent contribution to American society. God bless the USA. read more

Greasy food that can clog your arteries, doesn't taste well and is priced too high. I couldn't believe it. If you go to this place you will be breathing trans fats. Not exaggerating: the floor was slippery because so much oil is fried here that it ends up like a thin layer on every surface. I can only imagine what that could do to our insides. read more

This is the first time I've actually been an a 5 Guys , though not the first time I have eaten from one. Silly me, I didn't know about the free peanuts till I read the previous reviews. Next time I will know better. This was the first time for my wife and child who both thoroughly enjoyed themselves. I thought the food was consist ant with my earlier experiences. The only negative I have is the fact that there is no children's menu. My three year old actually did a pretty good job on her grilled cheese sandwich. The size of the french fries was surprisingly large for the price. We each had our own sandwich and all left with happy tummies. read more

Solid burger. Solid fries. Meal will run you about 15 bucks. Everything fresh and made to order. Huge fries, free drink refills. Pleasant staff, clean restaurant. I wouldnt expect anything less in the heart of Merrick. read more

I ordered a bacon cheeseburger and a cajun fry to go. Once I arrived home with my order I sadly discovered there was no bacon on my burger :(. I called and an assistant manager said next time I come in they would give me a free sandwich with my order if I brought my receipt in. One month later I came to collect and they hooked me up with a free bacon burger and sm fry! 5 stars for cleanliness, excellent customer service and delicious food. read more

Haven't been to 5 Guys in a while and was craving a nice juicy burger dripping with grease. This place is clean and the service was fast. They have quite a variety of fixins' to customize your burger and make it your own. If you're going to order french fries, keep in mind they overstuff the bag so I suggest splitting a small to reduce grease intake by a tad. read more

Five Guys consistently is one of the best burgers I have had, and this is my "go to" Five Guys franchise when I am in the mood for a burger. I regularly get the same toppings which are delicious and am generally very happy with the cajun fries, and while they are good, I would like them to be a bit more crispy. Much like a lot of things these days, the price is a bit higher than I would like, but on the flip side, the ingredients are very fresh and you have to pay a premium for such quality. The only thing that might make the burgers slightly better is if they had a guacamole (preferably my wifes recipe), to top the burger with. read more

Food is ok...better than most fast food offerings, but I'm the middle of the pack when compared to other upper level burger chains such as burger fi and shake shack. The quality is there, but a few things annoy me... 1) I know they are popular but I do NOT like the freestyle coke soda machines. You taste the remnants of every other flavor that you didn't order and the soda flavor is always off. Go back to a regular coke dispenser please. 2) You can't order buns without seeds. To be fair, this chain will provide 2 bun bottoms, but there are always areas that are either peppered or pounded with stowaway cling on seeds that leave each side of the bun bottom mangled when you flick or pull them off. Again not a problem at fi or shake shack. 3) I am not a prude, but the music is too loud. I should not have to strain to hear if my order is ready over a loud tune that I don't want to hear. Fix this five guys and you'll have five stars. read more

Friendly staff and my food was prepared quickly,The location was very clean. The burger was tasteless,limitited menu. First & last time here.Expected better from other reviews read more

Five guys is on my rotation for burgers and fries. The fries are great and the portion size is huge. Their fries are so good I eat them plain. I normally get a double burger with grilled onions, grilled mushrooms, lettuce, pickles, jalapeños peppers,ketchup, tomato, hot sauce and American cheese. Sometimes I wash it down with a vanilla milkshake. The meal price is much more than Micky D's but worth it. read more

Normally have a great experience here. They must have recently changed managers and I had a terrible interaction with her. She needs to be retrained on how to speak properly and professionally. Will NOT be giving this location anymore business and will be telling all my friends to do the same. read more

Awesome burgers and fries! They know how to keep their customers happy! The best deal all around! Wish they were in midtown by my office!

Just a little to Expensive for what u get a cheeseburger and shake were 14$ and I left hungry

The manager here is very nasty. She was very rude of the phone for no apparent reason. She seems to be really mad with life. I don't understand. All I wanted to do was place an order and she was just straight up nasty. Thats no way to run a business. read more

Five Stars for Five Guys! They have revolutionized the cheeseburger and the dining experience. The online order system is smooth and reliable. There is nothing bad to say about Five Guys read more

your experience here is very dependent upon WHO is taking your order and WHO is calling your number. the ones MAKING the stuff don't care, so the product is usually the same stuff. if you are having trouble at the counter when TRYING to order, just walk out. It gets WORSE! read more