UPDATE (3/19/19): Ali B (owner) messaged me in response to my initial review; he asked me to return for a dine-in lunch where he "guaranteed my time and experience will be much better than last time." So, I went back today with a friend; I paid for his chicken pita combo since Ali insisted that my repeat meal (chicken shawarma, falafel and drink) was complimentary! Thanks man.
Female cashier was friendly and helped my coworker decide. Food was prepared accurately, fresh and in 5 minutes. The chicken pita ($9) was mammoth and tasted good; fries were cooked to the perfect golden brown texture. Since I'm not a hummus fanatic (like my wife and youngest daughter), I should have requested it be put in a container and not directly under the entire bed of lettuce. Still, I enjoyed the hefty portion. Falafel plating presented nicely, served heat hot and tasted pretty good; we both liked the flavorful red sauce served with it that packed a nice kick of heat!
That said, we both agreed Mr Shawarma still holds bragging rights for falafel, sauce variety/innovation, and the novelty of selecting your preferred amount of choice toppings while seeing the meal take shape in front of you. Still, I think 5Bs may have the slight edge in price, rounding out the visit at a solid 4/5, easily bumped from a 3.75/5 because of the reassurance provided by the owner's message and follow-up gesture; it shows he cares about his customers and their experiences which only means this place will likely continue to improve! Thanks Ali B!
I'll be curious to try the pizza they're going to start offering beginning early next month (April 2019).
FIRST VISIT (3/4/19): Mediterranean fast food spot, next to Verizon store on Colley and 21st St, with subtle New York City touches and Halal food practices ("permissible" by Islamic law, no pork). There's a small, shared lot outside and 2 distinct indoor spaces: dining room and order counter/kitchen. A bit odd but bright and clean with simple contemporary decor: light gray walls, dark gray vinyl/leather seats, and NYC art (glass wall etchings, clock and canvas prints all depicting city staples - maps, scapes, landmarks). Seating exists at 6 four-top tables (paper towels on each) and a few high chairs floating around, too.
On order approach, I personally enjoyed the spinning Shawarma wheel (of fortune) in plain sight (a la NYC). Employee greeted me and offered some suggestions. As a Mr Shawarma faithful, I told him it was my first visit and that he had a tall task of converting me, especially since Avi (Mr. S) makes the best falafel around. He didn't budge when I hinted at a FREElafel sample, so I bought a chicken shawarma salad and small falafel side (4 pc) for $16.70 - high price point for typical drunk undergraduate street food, which can also be said for a recent price increase at Mr Sharma's but I like supporting community minded business owners!
Wall menu salad price was $8.95 but rang up for $9.95, as on the print menu. Also, when asked by the cashier and chef 1, I requested spicy sauce on the side. At prep, Chef 2 asked me
if I wanted spicy sauce. Neither are deal breakers, just indicative of 2 process kinks that could improve. Ultimately waited 10 minutes from payment to food delivery in an otherwise empty restaurant.
Salad looked and smelled good but amounted to a 3.5/5. A healthy amount of chicken (yay) with cilantro BUT unwelcome heaping hummus hills hu (better word play attempt is there somewhere) beneath iceberg lettuce, a quartered unripe tomato slice, and 3 pickle slices. It presented NOTHING like the example pic on the menu (blanched baby kale, red cabbage, cucumbers, etc). Falafel? It was OVER...priced and cooked. Not terrible but NO threat to Mr Shawarma's, IMHO. read more