The other day, we found a menu at our front door for Fishtown Pizza so we decided to try it for delivery last night. We called and ordered from them directly as we have had the WORST experience with Grub Hub, time after time. When I called and placed the order, the girl repeated it to me but it was pretty clear thru the call that she was either doing something else or talking to someone else while she was taking my order. It was really no biggie until we got our order. The order did arrive on time but when we took it upstairs and opened up the bag, I noticed that the mushroom cheesesteak that I ordered was actually a chicken cheesesteak. Normally, I wouldn't have minded nor would have called back but I was realllyyyyyy having a craving for a cheesesteak. I immediately closed up the container and called. The woman who took my call, verified that it was put into the system as a mushroom chicken cheesesteak and asked me to please hold onto it and she would send the correct sandwich out. About 25 minutes later, the correct sandwich showed up. I handed the driver the incorrect sandwich and he told me to keep it and handed me back $1 (I guess for the difference in price or the mess up) I tried to give it back to him but he wouldn't accept. Now to the food ... the mozzarella fries with added bacon were really good and they did give you a decent amount to share. My boyfriend's cheesesteak hoagie was enjoyable for him and when I got my cheesesteak, it was pretty good, too. It wasn't very greasy, had a significant amount of meat, and the bread was very fresh. I wouldn't give it a 5 star for overall taste a quality, more like a 4, however, I am giving a 5 star rating for the customer service. I also have to say, I ate half of the incorrect sandwich for breakfast today (chicken cheesesteak) and it was good. It was made with real chicken chunks, not that shredded crap, again, a decent amount of protein and very fresh bread. read more

The delivery was quick and hot, so I'm just judging this place on the taste of the pizza. Overall, not really impressed by the sauce (slightly too sweet), the crust (floppy and dry), but the cheese covered the pizza well. The pizza didn't really have anything notable about it, so I probably wouldn't order that again. The fries had ham-like bacon the day that I ordered, with wayy too much swiss and cheddar cheese so they tasted kind of out of sorts. I've heard that there are better pieces of pizza here, but the fries and pepperoni pizza were not my favorite. read more

Fishtown Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Philadelphia, Pennsylvania

Great food, wings and pizza are awesome. Quick with delivery and never any issues with my order.

Awesome Food Awesome People. They Give Good Portions Also. I Recommend A Try For Anyone

They are good and quick! I've ordered here a few times. Good inexpensive pizza. They do ground beef and onions so my coworkers were real pleased. They also deliver to parties in a park. read more

Unfortunately the food has really gone downhill. I've been a customer for 15 years. Lately the food has arrived overcooked, under seasoned, orders incorrect and taking an hour to get. Tonight I specified to omit two allergens from my husband's gyro platter. They were included in abundance. When I spoke with the store, I was told my request wasn't heard (despite the fact I repeated it twice) and they could do nothing. No replacement offered, no partial refund. I ended up giving my spouse half my food. He's a diabetic with specific needs in addition to certain food allergies. When I asked to speak to the manager, I was told they were unavailable. I'm done with this business. read more

They make a good cheesesteak. They also have a bench and an outlet so you can sit and charge your phone or whatever. They also gave my friend salt when she asked for it, even though she brought her own food. The people are cool and it's a very chill vibe. read more

I'm giving this place two stars because the family who owns this place is nice and service was good. But the Grandmother made my hoagie with NO GLOVES !!! In post Covid world that is a big food safety problem read more

The pizza was sub par. I've been trying to find good pizza in the area and it is so so so hard to do. However, the service was beyond friendly. I would go there again maybe and try something like a salad or a non pizza item. But I would have to look elsewhere for pizza. Maybe a hoagie or cheesesteak but definitely not a pizza. read more

I ordered a pizza from here after getting home from a wedding. I was also very drunk when I ordered it. It was still terrible and just not a good pizza. However, the delivery was super fast and the guy was friendly. Fast delivery when drunk earns you 2 stars, even if the pizza was bad. read more

Best pizza in fishtown in my opinion!! The slices taste different then the actual pies... and my family is obsessed with the slices!!! the chicken cheesesteaks are not made with that frozen meat it's fresh chicken and it's soooo yummy!! When u order it they put it in a nice container not wrapped in foil and paper to get soggy!! Also the chicken fingers here are amazingggggg taste like breaded chicken breast! And the salads are huge also yummy!! The delivery is so fast .. I just love everything about this place!!! read more

For pizza, this wouldn't be my first choice. For cheese steaks and hoagies, it's up there on my list of favorites. Friday night, I ordered a turkey & cheese hoagie with lettuce, sweet peppers, pickles and mayo, a side of macaroni salad and small order of curly cheese fries. I accidentally ate the cheese fries and had to leave the hoagie in the fridge to enjoy later. The hoagie, which was Saturday's lunch, was loaded with turkey and cheese. I had to scoop off the lettuce because it had started to brown, as well as the sweet peppers which had begun to lose their flavor. The pickles however, were delicious! Fishtown pizza delivers their cheese steaks, hoagies and French fries in Styrofoam containers. I have never received a non-pizza order that was banged up or smashed. The hot items stay hot and the cold items stay chilled. The delivery guys have always been polite, and I've never questioned, "Geez, is the food here yet? When did we order?" read more

Pizza? Get the bacon cheesesteak wrap with provolone. And the people there are nice. read more

Moved to NoLibs a few months ago and STILL looking for our go-to pizza place! Tried Fishtown Pizza last night and were not super impressed. Pizza was OK definitely doughy, though they didn't skimp on the toppings and the sauce was good. My roommates wrap was super cheesy some might think that is a good thing but she wasn't too happy with it. The hoagies did look good, and were huge, these got a thumbs up, lots of the toppings requested and stuffed. They really are generous with the portions at least. Fries were soggy - a big disappointment for me! Not the worst in the area, but still not our favorite... read more

This pizza sucks but it didn't kill me and it's close to my apartment, that's how I came up with two stars The pizza is definitely "thicker and doughier" as the other review mentioned. I'd call it spongy and I find a lot of pizza in Philadelphia to have it is freaking horrible. Granted I'm from NY originally so my standard might be higher. I got a veggie and plain back in February and I'd have to be in quite the pinch to order from there again. I haven't had their heros, yes heros, not hoagies, again I'm from NY, so I can't speak to their quality or lack thereof. This is the only pizza shop in Fishtown that I've tried since moving here last November so maybe there are better ones, but I'd rather take the trip to Rustica, it's just not worth the risk. read more

Wings are the best I've tasted in the area and pizza is good all types...I used to work at 5th n spring garden ordered there all the time...the chicken finger platters are good the salads are good they used to be bigger but they down sized....they raised the prices recently ...my job made them big bucks ...never disappointed at this places...love the jumbo wings and blue cheese so addictive...I know good food...you will feel great read more

I always order from this place. Never disappointing and always fresh! It's by far my favorite pizza in the city! Their StromboliS are amazing too! read more

Fishtown Pizza - a piece of bread in a box - Pizza Near Me - Philadelphia, Pennsylvania

alright this place needs an updated review. I go here pretty often because it's nearby my place and the quality of food is always consistent. It's easily the friendliest of the local pizza haunts that Girard Ave has to offer, and most generous in terms of portions and things like that. The pizza here is Greek-style and the option to order a personal size pie is cheap and great to share with a friend. I really like the breaded chicken breasts that are... most likely not frozen or at least don't taste frozen. Anyway this place has gotten a few negative reviews and I go here often enough to say it's worth it. read more

I know longer believe "there's no such thing as bad pizza" ... If you don't believe me, give it a go, but I would save the calories and the $ for something more worthwhile read more

Worst pizza store in the world food is always burn 99.9% of the time if I could post the picture of the food I just got this abortion of a chicken finger I would read more

Fishtown Pizza - Overly cooked chicken fingers falling apart and barbecue sauce everywhere's that's what you call customer service - Pizza Near Me - Philadelphia, Pennsylvania

Excellent food! Best wings I've had in Philly! I ordered the 12 piece buffalo wings, and it lasted me 3 meals... Huge wings. Their gyro platter is also very good! Comes with fries and coleslaw. Next time I'll ask them not to toast my pita bread though, I would rather have it plain. I love this place. The delivery is very fast too. read more

Fishtown Pizza - Buffalo wings!!! Amazing! Huge wings, and very flavorful! - Pizza Near Me - Philadelphia, Pennsylvania

See all

I ordered delivery, greasy pizza, extremely expensive. I would say if it's the only thing open, I MIGHT go there again. It's definitely a last resort for me. I will say, I've only had their pizza, so I'd be more likely to try their sandwiches. Update: Owners or affiliates attempting to leave nasty comments because their pizza is trash. Personal attacks and gross pizza. Too bad I can't give them 0 stars. Stay classy boys. read more

Nothing gourmet about this place. Just good, cheap pizza that I crave sometimes. Buffalo chicken cheesesteak is pretty good too.

Very good Greek-style pizza! Took a shot because I am not a Santucci's fan and the Art of Pizza blows. This is my new favorite pizza joint! Yay! If you like thin crust, go elsewhere. This is greek-style (thicker crust, but not deep dish). read more

I really love this place. It isn't pretty and the people can be a little quiet but they really are sweet and always friendly and while its Greek style pizza, it's delicious. They're my go to pizza place for take-out. I've never had a bad thing. read more

Love fishtown wraps and the people who run it

First time ordering Pizza from here while visiting my son . Pizza is extremely greasy which means cheap cheese. Dough is so hard. Had to pick the cheese off the pizza and throw the rest away because it was to hard to chew.20 bucks for an extra large with extra cheese plus delivery. What a waste of money . Beware of horrible pizza here read more

They should change the name to Fishtown Sandwiches and Wings. I say that because the pizza is ok but the Oven Grinders and Wings are awesome. The employees are very nice and the delivery is always on time. read more

The pizza isn't worth the box it comes in. The wings are on point. I like my chicken and in the last week me and the delivery guy have become good friends. Seriously though, great wings. I'll update this as I feel out the rest of the menu. read more

The lady on the phone was so rude I had to cancel my order. She made it seem like I was bothering her by calling in the order. Very unprofessional, I would not go here. Try Pizza Brain instead. Those dudes know how to treat a customer. read more

We have been getting food delivered from Fishtown Pizza for many years (on average 2x per month) and have enjoyed the food, until recently. My husband usually gets the chicken wings, and LOVES them. Tonight he got the wings again and was happy. About a month ago we ordered pizza THIN AND CRISPY. It was NOT crispy at all, but soggy. And tonight I ordered a BLT with CRISPY bacon, and the bacon was NOT CRISPY at all and looked and tasted like it didn't even touch the heat. I had to put it in the toaster over myself to cook it! Disappointing. Not sure what's going on with them, but we will be trying new places to call for delivery. read more

Fishtown Pizza supports its local school, Penn Treaty School, so you should support Fishtown Pizza!!! :) Friends of Penn Treaty School (FoPT) is grateful for Fishtown Pizza's donation of a door prize to the Penn Treaty Staff Appreciation Breakfast. read more

i lived in port richmond for years had all differnt pizzas my daughter moved to fishtown, we ordered from fistown pizza, was the best pizza i have ever had, its banging, the crust is too die for the cheese delicious, the sauce goes great, when people critisize the pizza, ya"ll got some smoked out taste buds. i live in s. philly now, but will still only eat fishtown pizza.......christine deegan read more