We stopped in on a quiet Saturday afternoon, and everything was amazing--the food, service, beer, and atmosphere. The TVs are positioned throughout the restaurant, so there's really good viewing from the seating areas, which is always a plus. I definitely need to come back soon, just to see if this small brewery/restaurant with such tasty beer can impress me a second time. But for now... yes, yes, YES! Next time, we may try the outdoor seating. If the second visit is anything like the first, I think we've found another place worth coming back to! read more

Pass by here a lot and had no clue this little brewery existed! Food was typical bar food -- fries, wings, pizza, salads, burgers, etc. We got the smash burger, fries, gochujang wings and summer salad. I was more than satisfied with our spread. The seasoning on the fries was perfection. Unfortunately, no pics of the food. The beers were delish! Had several options on tap and decided on a flight of Gose. Belgian Tripel, Belgian Blonde w raspberry, and the Swarzbier -- visually, absolutely gorgeous...and they tasted exceptional as well. That swarzbier was full of body and flavor with a hint of sweetness. If you like stouts or Dunkels, give this a try. Such a great recommendation from the bartender. Tip: you order from the bar and find a table. There's not a host to seat you. There's also a keg of water for self serve agua. The only downside--super loud inside. It was fine for us. There are outdoor, no frills picnic tables if you don't like the noise. But don't let it stop you, give them a try! read more

First Love Brewing - Flight - Brewpubs Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

Good beer brewed here. There is a variety for any preference. Nice clean modern interior with wood picnic tables outside in the shade of a huge tree. Pleasant and fast service... they offer tastes as any good brewery should. They have food cooked to order and it looked good, although I had just one beer. Definitely a good brewery with excellent brews. read more

See all

First visit and I only tried two beers here: Cardinal Truth and Joy. Both fell flat on flavor IMO, yet both beers were hyper-carbonated to the point it almost lightly burned the palate. I couldn't finish the two 5 oz samples that I purchased. Atmosphere is clean yet a bit barren; we thought it felt like a cafeteria. read more

First Love Brewing - Beer menu - Brewpubs Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

See all

Great little brewery and equally delicious food. Cute atmosphere, friendly and helpful service, and nice beer selection. read more

See all

6/7/25. Just stopped in a pizza, salad and wings. All were good! AND we have lunch for tomorrow. read more

See all

Came at the recommendation of an acquaintance who claimed they serve best pizza in FB. We were greeted enthusiastically when we approached the bar where you order. The wine list is inadequate but the beer list is fantastic. The Margherita Pizza was disappointing. The outer crust was delicious but the inner crust was paper thin and limp. Hardly any mozzarella. It was a late Sunday afternoon so perhaps the pizza chef was off. We will give it another chance. read more

First Love Brewing - Our pizza. - Brewpubs Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

Revisited this place on this trip, and it's still amazing! Service, food, and cleanliness were all top notch! read more

First Love Brewing - Fries - Brewpubs Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

First Love Brewing is an adorable brewery that is located right around the corner from the Amelia Schoolhouse Inn. It was the perfect spot to get great service and grab a quick flight. Their pizzas looked amazing and we'll definitely be back to try their food menu next time! read more

First Love Brewing - First Love Brewing - Brewpubs Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

See all

We loved the wings. Cute atmosphere but super hard to find seating when it's busy. The bill was a bit high. We expect that for Fernandina but don't think we should be paying the same amount for food and drinks at a brewery as we would be paying at a sit down restaurant with nice cocktails. read more

First Love Brewing - Asian wings - Brewpubs Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

A fun micro brewery stop in Fernandina Beach if you're on the island. Up to 20 beers brewed on site with new ones rotating in often. This night I got a blood orange 8% IPA and a coconut stout - both were unique and quite tasty. There is food here as well with great pizzas, sandwiches, and finger foods that match well with the beers. Places to sit both inside and out. It is a popular place and can get quite crowded. Noise levels can be high inside. Come and try all the beers - the staff is helpful and will give you tastes until you find what you like! read more

Stopped by on a Saturday afternoon with a group of women. We were easily able to find parking right outside the brewery and they were plenty of seats inside. Loved that they have a lot of home brews to choose from. I want to say it seemed like at least 15. I tried two of their IPAs and the coconut stout. Loved all 3. We also wanted a little snacky and tried the truffle fries and zucchini fries. Crushed them both. I'd give the truffle fries an 8/10 and zucchini fries a 9/10. Zucchini fries were super crispy and well seasoned plus came with a delicious curry aioli. The pizzas looked amazing too. Definitely recommend stopping in. read more

Been here many times with my wife...and others. First Love has the best burgers and pizza in town. The atmosphere is great and service is awesome. I highly recommend it!! Bill Mc. read more

After a bike day up in the Fernandina Beach area, we needed some beer and pizza. Hubby suggested First Love Brewing and I was all in on that idea! We ordered a couple flights and enjoyed them outside while sitting at one of the patio tables. The daisy honey blonde was my favorite. Close second was a beacon of light, a very tasty milk stout. Hubby's favorite was the cardinal truth IPA. We went inside to order food and grabbed a table since it was getting chilly outside. We ordered huli huli wings and a hot honey pizza. The wings came out pretty quick. They were sensational! We both loved these wings. Crispy, sweet, savory, tangy. A unique flavor for sure. The blue cheese was on point as well. Our pizza arrived shortly after the wings. Hot, crispy and delicious! The crust was perfection! Pepperoni cups were yummy. There was a perfect balance between heat and sweet. We both loved it. It was also just the right size to share without taking home a bunch of leftovers. Highly recommend! We will most definitely be back very soon! read more

See all

Always delicious. Nice owners. Smash Burger is the best in town. Outdoor seating available.

Our table rated the following foods Beers are excellent but smaller pour Wings amazing Salads just OK but need some help. Burger just ok Zucchini fries amazing Will come again and get the things we liked. read more

Ordered take out to watch a football game while on vacay. The wings (hula hula and gochujang) and the zucchini fries were some of the best we've had! The staff were so friendly. Thank you! read more

First Love Brewing is a good brewery if you are in the Fernandina Beach, Florida area and looking for a cool brewery with a cool overall ambiance, good drinks and friendly and professional service. Overall, it was definitely a positive experience and I would recommend a visit here. read more

Amazing hidden foodie paradise in the middle of a brewery. We loved everything, kind service, delicious food and a great variety of beer with knowledgeable beer tenders to help. read more

A simple beer and pizza joint - bummed they were out of wings when we visited. However, the truffle fries were an awesome surprise. About 10 different beers on tap (no true IPAs) but a decent variety to choose from. We may stop by again when we're in the area to give them another try! read more

First Love Brewing - truffle fries - the best part! - Brewpubs Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

Locally owned. Wonderful pizza with unique flavor combos. Pro tip: if the pie(s) have the same base (marinara, alfredo, pesto, etc) you can get two flavors of pizza in one! Great for people who are undecided between two pies. Salads are great. Must visit if you're in the area for a casual bite and brew. read more

We were staying at a B&B across the street and after a day of travel this cute little brewery was perfect. The place was hopping and all the inside tables were full but we grabbed a picnic table outside where the weather was perfect. I ordered at the bar and they gave me a number sign to put on the table for the food server to find me. We had Huli Hulu wings which were delicious. Crunchy with a sweet Hawaiian style BBQ sauce. We also had a Momma Maria pizza. It is medium in size but perfect to share with the wings. It had meatball pieces and ricotta on it. It was also very good. We had a flight of 4 mini beers and relaxed. All in all, a very good brewery with lots of locals and tourists alike. read more

First Love Brewing - A flight with the beautiful tree in the background - Brewpubs Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

Piping hot pizza paired perfectly with ice cold beer. Quick service at the counter. We chose to eat outside at a picnic table under the enormous oak tree in the parking lot. Cabinet with games and cards was a fun touch. Great spot for Sunday afternoon lunch. read more

First Love Brewing - Piping hot cheese pizza. Oh so cheesy! - Brewpubs Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

See all

Delicious pizza along with a great variety of craft beers and get the house fries-they are delicious!! Easy walk from downtown, they were very busy, but had no problem getting a seat, food, and ice cold beer. Will definitely be back next time we are in the area! #exporeandtravelwiththekirklands read more

See all

oh my gosh! it wasn't quite right the first time, but they went over & beyond to make it right! crispy, delicious pizza!! and hello...Prost!! This beer ma ma made me happy!! Flavorful but not bitter! can't wait to return! read more

Cool little spot, but prkg is a little tight/awkward in the lot and they only had one person taking orders/pouring w/a long line, so the wait was ridic. But, she did her best and was so nice (I think her name was Beth?). They might have been short-staffed, but not sure. Absolutely loved the beer flight board and that it resembled Amelia Island; that was really cool! The beers were hit or miss for me, but there weren't any of the four that I downright disliked. They had pizza as well, w/some interesting pies on the menu, but I didn't have enough time to stay long enough to wait; plus it looked like they were backlogged on that front as well. Ambiance was nice, but they could use a few more barstools at the bar and definitely need to section off an actual line area, because a couple of guys just straight up walked up to the counter and ordered while we were all waiting in line and nobody said anything! I was about to after the second one...but thankfully the lady taking the orders told him she'd help him once she took care of the people at the counter and the rest of us in line. read more

See all

This was such a solid place to grab lunch and a beer. These guys make their own hand-crafted beer and artisan-style pizzas. I was visiting family in Fernandina Beach and read good things about this place. First Love Brewing is centrally located on Amelia Island. Their establishment is nice and spacious with tables surrounded by the fermenters. There is a nice laid-back community vibe here that immediately draws you in and makes you feel welcome. First Love has around twenty rotating beers on tap. Off to the side is a chalk board menu that lists all of their beers and percentages. In addition to good beer, they made great pizza and wings. They have some regular pizza favorites like margarita, white, and supreme on their menu. They also do some specialty pizzas. I went with the Honey Hot Pizza and a beer flight on my first visit here. The pizza is seriously as good as everyone says it is. That Honey Hot had a nice kick to it too. First Love Brewing makes really good beer. I mixed up my flight and got an ale, stout, and a lager so I could have a bit of a variety. You can't go wrong with First Love Brewing if you are in the Fernandina Beach area. The staff is super friendly and great at educating you on their beers. Great place for kids too! read more

See all

First time here. Service was fantastic. Smash burgers were a big hit. Cooked perfectly and very tasty. Everyone loved the fries. Wings were very good. Spicy wasn't over the top hot. Not a beer drinker but the light beers were good. They don't have ice so forget asking for ice water. They have a keg tap if you want water. read more

First Love Brewing - Wings - Brewpubs Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

See all

Friendly and knowledgeable staff. Delicious food. Huli huli wings and zucchini fries with curry ranch sauce was total YUM! The whole menu looked fabulous. Local craft beer was good as well. Had the Ruby. Will do a flight next time to try others. read more

Local pizza and beer - all delicious. Location is just outside of the downtown area with plenty of parking.

The food is absolutely amazing. The best pizza rated very high as they use fresh ingredients and zero zero flour from Italy. It is our Friday night date night. Great brewery with amazing beers as well ........ The wait staff is amazing as well. They are very courteous and helpful and smile. It is obvious that they love working here. read more

I would have taken pictures, but the kid had the phone, you know how it is. We had the Hawaiian pizza, zucchini fries, and regular fries. The curry sauce and aioli were so good! But nothing could touch that Hawaiian pizza. Happy tears and sweet dreams. The food was delicious. Exactly how pizza should be. read more

Had some beers. Beers were good. They have a good variety in brews. Also got a flight and there are quite a bit of winners here. Didn't order any food but very nice place they got there. Was quite busy even being a Sunday night. read more

I went to culinary school with one of the owners Kevin. I finally stopped in and ate with my bf and loved it. Great customer service food came out very fast! Truffle fries were addictive and we couldn't stop eating them. Huli pizza was perfect balance of sweet and spicy. Gochujang wings were a little spicy and perfectly cooked. Bit of a drive for us but would for sure come again. Kevin and Jessie are a great pair and dedicated resturaunt owners. Kevin went to culinary school to better their business and learn more about it and it paid off! read more

See all

Awesome beer selection and pizza was great. Loved the one with meatballs on it. Will go back the next time we go to the island.

Beer is great. Pizza is ok --very salty, light on toppings, too much crust. Wings are decent. Zucchini fries are ok. Fries are ok. Ceaser is ok (grilled chicken looked weird). You have to get your own water out of a keg that requires two hands to use which means you touch the same handle and spigot thing that literally every other customer who needs water touched with both their hands. Sailing on picnic tables outside are fine if it's not too hot. Inside is loud, but there's games for kids to play at the tables. read more

I LOVE First Love! I've tried most every pizza place on and around Amelia Island/ Fernandina Beach... Also, I'm from Joisey so that's what I rate against. I think this place has great beer, great wings and great pizza. Inside is fun brewery style, the people working are excellent!!! I have enjoyed their wings in several occasions as well as their pizza, and it ranks as high as #1 on my list in the area- head and shoulders- a totally different league above Arte's pizza. I much prefer to sit outside at the picnic tables because it does get pretty loud inside. Dont worry- if you do sit outside the waitstaff will still bring your food to you when it's done. read more

Excellent pizza - great crust & cool names of unique pies. Was probably 10-12 beers on tap and a good selection. It is counter service and then brought to your table. Also has a cool selection of games & puzzles to keep you occupied. I'll be back! read more

Solid place to grab a beer. ...and a bite if you want pizza, sandwich or other stuff while you enjoy their beers. Nice high-top tables to sit with friends while you have a drink. Simple, but clean interior designs. Beers are made on site, so pop in and sample one of their craft brews. First Love is located in a strip mall, so parking was ample. read more

See all

Very good, if not the best Neapolitan pizza in the area. The underlying crust is thin and crispy while the edges are crispy and chewy. We tried the Huli, Supreme and the Momma Marie. All but the last were excellent, the Huli a little unusual, but the last had too much water in the ingredients and the crust just dissolved. We also tried the Buffalo and Korean wings - they allowed us to order both flavors in a single order. Both had good flavor and our server said they were fresh wings, I guess not frozen, but for $14 for 8 wings, kind of expensive. With two beers, one wing and 3 pizzas it was over $90, but, other than the wings, about what is expected for this quality of pizza. I would stay away from any pizza if watery toppings, vegetables, ricotta etc. the crust can't sustain them. read more