Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Fire Island Tap

    3.0 (2 reviews)

    Fire Island Tap Photos

    FIRE ISLAND TAP ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Fire Island Tap

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    6 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Fire Island Tap

    Flora's Wine Bar & Restaurant - Gnocchi Truffle

    Flora's Wine Bar & Restaurant

    4.6(18 reviews)
    28.9 mi

    Great service, great menu selection for both food and drinks. Great atmosphere…read more Fish was over-cooked I so wanted to give this place five stars. The fried artichokes were fantastic. The meatball appetizer was cool. Our drinks were amazing. That said my brother got the halibut. I got the red snapper special. They need to learn how to cook fish both were incredibly overcooked and the weight staffed and come over to check on us and we are honestly in a rush to head back to a concert so we just ate it and gave a decent tip and there was really no time to really tell them what was going on in terms of the cookery of the fish, but hopefully they see this and slap their cook around a little bit. Let them know that they need to take the fish off a little bit sooner. Can't wait to go back and try it again though and hopefully they'll know how to cook fish by then. But I'll probably end up getting a pizza or something I'm

    Food: 4/5 - I came here with my bf's family and we got about 5 pasta dishes and a cauliflower…read morepizza. All of their fresh pastas are very yummy but the biggest standout was the truffle gnocchi. I ordered many truffle pastas in NY and across Italy and this was the best Ive had by far. We ahead with this restaurant to host a bridal shower and everything was lovely. I had the baked Branzino the second time I visited and it was tasted fresh but lacked flavor. Great cocktails and extensive wine list! Service: 5/5 - friendly staff that are fast and efficient. Ambiance: 5/5 - I love it! It's dark inside during the day but has lovely wall art even on the ceilings. Warm lighting everywhere and feels very intimate and romantic.

    Photos
    Flora's Wine Bar & Restaurant
    Flora's Wine Bar & Restaurant - Paccheri Rosa pasta dish

    Paccheri Rosa pasta dish

    Flora's Wine Bar & Restaurant

    See all

    The Sandbar - Pretzel

    The Sandbar

    3.0(62 reviews)
    2.6 mi
    •$$

    We were looking for a chill spot with live music during our day trip to Fire Island, and Sandbar…read moredelivered exactly what we wanted! Laid-back, lively, and totally unique. The minute we walked in, we felt transported to a Key West-inspired oasis. The vibe at Sandbar is everything you want in a beach bar ... veteran watering hole energy, live music playing, and a crowd that's having the best time. If you're into quirky décor, you'll love the hundreds of colorful flip flops hanging from the ceiling, each one signed by past patrons. It's fun to look up and read what previous visitors have written. There are even surfboards and nautical treasures everywhere, making the spot truly one-of-a-kind. We came especially for the famous Rocket Fuel ... if you've never had one, you're missing out! Rocket Fuel is a frozen, creamy concoction featuring pina colada mix, amaretto, and rum (usually topped with a float of 151). It's the quintessential Ocean Beach drink: frosty, sweet, a little indulgent, and just strong enough to get you in island mode without derailing your afternoon! We grabbed our Rocket Fuels, settled in, and enjoyed the vibes. The live music was awesome and kept the energy up with beachy classics and crowd favorites. Even in the afternoon, Sandbar was buzzing but never felt overcrowded or hectic. From friendly bartenders and great drinks, I look forward to returning here for a fun evening with my friends.

    Why did he force my friends to go into an out of service bathroom?? Extremely disrespectful and…read moreinvaded the private space of people going to the bathroom. He also open the door of someone actively going to the bathroom. Not acceptable and this is not ok. I hope this restaurant takes accountability for this...

    Photos
    The Sandbar
    The Sandbar
    The Sandbar

    See all

    Fire Island Tap - wine_bars - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...