If it means anything, I was born and raised in NYC, pizza capital of the universe...so, anyway, I like pizza!!! I also own a pizza restaurant in Michigan which we joked about with the cook for all of the obvious reasons. I LOVED this pizza and would like to replicate it in my own place. I think it was the sauce that set it apart. It is a 10 in my book. If they threw a price of oak in that oven I think it would be a 12!!! Waitress and cook were friendly and attentive. Don't care about the price cause it was well worth it ( but the price was good:) Thanks for a great experience on our trek from Florida back to Michigan!!! U guys rock!!!! read more

Pros: The pizza was good. Cons: service and wait time. We ordered our pizza at 5:52. They told us 40 min. We got there in 45 min. It wasn't ready. I was told 'seven minutes' and then after 15 more minutes, I asked if they were making our pizzas now. (Because I could see them looking chaotic and making our pizzas based on the toppings). Only then was I told, "yes. Something happened. They were made but they think someone took them. They were making them right away and they would be just a few more minutes." The pizzas were ready at 7:16. In that time, only one server asked me if I would like a drink while I waited. Once they were finished, they were each opened for me by the cook to make sure that they all looked good. I appreciated that. No communication and we paid full price and I left a cash tip. I've been here before and service is always lacking a bit and unorganized but this visit was crazy. read more

The pizza was fantastic. Service not so much. It took 10 mins for anyone to come to our table and no one came to give us our check. We were sitting for 30 mins after finishing our pizza. We had to go find someone to pay our bill. We'll be back but I hope the service is better. read more

Fire & Stone Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Chillicothe, Ohio

Great great Pizza and love the groove ! Service was awesome! Even though place was completely full! Highly recommend!

New to Chillicothe, this was our first pizza date in town. Love that it's on Paint street; such a cute downtown area. Friday evening, so it was pleasantly bustling. The ambiance was warm and vibrant. We had a draft beer and a glass of red wine to start, and got the Godfather pizza. The pizza was very good; crispy crust and the hot honey added a nice kick and interesting twist. Service was efficient- could be exceptional with a little more attention to detail (like wiping the table from the previous diners before taking a drink order). Everyone was busy, so it wasn't a big deal! I would have preferred a bottled wine over boxed wine, but if it works well, it works. Definitely would return after checking out the other offerings in town! read more

excellent pizza and beer. waitress was great. very relaxed . restaurant had a very relaxed atmosphere .

The pepperoni roll was fantastic. Ranch dressing was good a tad dilly. The pizza was amazing!!! Service was not amazing they ordered Diet Coke and the syrup was out so we asked for another one and she said that they would go have the syrup change out downstairs. They never actually brought out the replacement drinks and it took two hours so that the service is definitely lacking for such a small venue you would think that 3 to 4 waitresses would be more than enough however apparently that wasn't for them we would definitely go back, but I would hope that the service would improve. And match how good the food was. read more

Fire & Stone Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Chillicothe, Ohio

Visited Fire and Stone for the first time today. Wow! It definitely won't be our last time there! We ordered The DeGarmo, a meat-lover's specialty pizza, that was cooked to perfection in the coal-fired oven. We sat at the bar and enjoyed a cold pitcher of very fresh draft beer while our pizza was prepared. We boxed up a third of our pie to take home, but we ended up opening the box and finishing it off before we got up from our seats at the bar. I'm sure it would have tasted great leftover, but it was never going to taste as good as it did fresh out of the oven. We're already planning our next trip back read more

See all

Looked for some new pizza place to try so we headed to Chillicothe to give it a try. Service was good but food did take a while. We had two pizzas and a salad. The salad was just a salad nothing great but nothing bad. The pizzas on the other hand were amazing. Crispy thin crust with just the right amount of sauce and the fresh toppings made for two wonderful pies. read more

Fire & Stone Pizzeria - The Works - Pizza Near Me - Chillicothe, Ohio

See all

My husband and I ate here for dinner last night. Even though Fire and Stone is located in my home town, it had been a few years since we ate here. We both had a house salad. It was very fresh and large in portion. They make their own ranch salad and it was delicious. They should consider bottling it for sale! I would buy it. We also ordered a DeGarmo pizza. Also very delicious. The waiter was attentive and friendly. Next time I won't wait so long to come here for dinner! read more

Fire & Stone Pizzeria - DeGarmo 10 inch pizza - Pizza Near Me - Chillicothe, Ohio

See all

Wow, I'm a fan! My parents and gf came here for a light dinner after a long day exploring the area. At first impression, the restaurant seemed a bit messy with dirty plates on the outside tables and some on the inside -- but then I noticed they could be short on help for the Saturday evening with Ross County fair going on. We were greeted promptly with a friendly smile and felt welcomed. The menu had a good list of pizzas and a build it yourself option as well. Other options included soups, salads, and sandwiches too. Since we weren't too hungry, we ordered the Chillicothe Cobb salad and the 14' Forager pizza and added their fennel sausage too. The salad was a basic cobb salad but their pizza was on point! The crust was crispy (though personally I would like it just a tad crispier... but maybe that's just me), the ratio of white sauce to ingredients had a good balance and complimented one another well. Overall everything was consumed and we were happy. Service-wise, the two ladies were friendly, though a bit rushed/hands tied. I feel like they could use one extra set of hands, but as I mentioned earlier, they could be short that shift or not expecting a lot of business. More people came in as we were leaving, so that's great to see they are doing well! I'll be back to try more of their options and will update my review when I do! read more

Fire & Stone Pizzeria - The Forager with added fennel sausage - Pizza Near Me - Chillicothe, Ohio

This was our first time eating here. We ordered a Cobb salad which was good but not amazing and I think $9.00 was very pricey for the type and amount we were served. Now that being said the pizza was phenomenal. The crust was perfect!!! We were waited on very quickly and had are pizzas within 20 min of ordering. We had the chicken bacon and ranch also a pepperoni pizza. That ranch dressing is the best it's house made and delicious. Will definitely avoid salad next time but there pizza will keep us coming back!!! read more

See all

Food was good but the dough on the pizza seemed a little off. I also didn't see the health violations on the reviews until we already ordered. Service was fine. I didn't realize that servers could wear open toed shoes. read more

The food here is decent...especially for Chiilicothe. Not an amazing value, however, as I find it to be a little pricey for thin crust pizza. They only have one high chair, which is annoying and weird, because it was being used when I was here and my kid had to sit in her stroller. The owner called my daughter a boy repeatedly even though she had a bow in her hair! Lol The owner is unfriendly and acts inconvenienced when people come in. She was our waitress one day and you'd have thought that refills were a huge request. The ambiance is confusing-not a sports bar, not really serious sit-down food. The service is ok. read more

Today we have been out checking the south eastern side of Ohio. We stopped in today and enjoyed a DeGarmo along with a make your own pizza with today's special Meatballs. Highly recommend trying Fire & Stone Pizza. read more

Lousy service. Probably would do a lot more business if they wouldn't put you on hold and forget then not answer when you call back . Had this happen several times . Shame . Good pizza lousy service. read more

We had a large group come to Fire and Stone. They were very accommodating and the pizza was terrific!

Enjoyed the crust and toppings- caramelized onion and mushrooms. Basic beer selection and friendly service.

The pizza was fantastic. We were traveling through the area and decided to try it. The service was great.

My daughter and I go there on a regular basis. Best crust in Chillicothe, i find it hard to believe but fire stone makes a difference. A little lite on the toppings at times but still good pizza. Place is lively and staff is friendly. read more

See all

Had a fabulous meal here tonight. First time customer. The crust on their pizza is the greatest! Great flavored pizza, as well. And wonderful salads and great service, too! We'll be back! read more

See all

Fire & Stone is an awesome pizzeria in downtown Chillicothe. We had read some reviews, an decided to give it go. It turned out to be the type of pizza my wife and like best, stone baked thin crust. The menu has many pizza options, featured was lots of topping choices sure to suit anyone's palate. All fresh and high quality toppings generously applied to what will be tasty stone baked pie. The cheese they use is an in house blend of 3 cheeses that is out of this world. They also have some adult beverages here too. Hard to beat this place for pizza. read more

No complaints here from this out of towner. A friend and I were on our way to Indiana and found ourselves hungry around Chillicothe, so I got on the Yelp-tubes and the overwhelming response was that this was the place to spend your food dollars in this town. The restaurant itself is in a little slice of old-time downtown Americana. Established old buildings, plenty of street parking around. You walk in and the space is long and narrow with a good amount of tables and bar space. We decided to split a meat lovers pizza, and it was fantastic. Really great crust. Love that wood fired taste that you can't get with electric ovens. The amount of toppings were generous, and for the two of us, a 14" pizza left us really full. I'm not sure I'll find myself in Chillicothe again, but if I do, I'll make this a definite potential stop. read more

If you like stone fired pizza then you'll love this. Yummy. Crispy. Good service, nice atmosphere, excellent food.

There is nothing better than finding a local dining diamond. I am a huge sucker for small town, old downtown revival type restaurants. There are so many of these type towns in Ohio with old buildings and entrepreneurs who take a chance and create something unique are winners in my book. Found Fire and Stone on Yelp...a beautiful evening drive over with the windows open in the Challenger; parked right out front in old downtown. Sat at the bar/counter and ordered up a Fat Tire. High ceilings, big windows, narrow profile...prototypical downtown design. Love it! They have a fired pizza oven and after reading reviews knew this was thin crust (yes). It sits in the back and you can see from the counter. Ordered a salad and the DeGarmo pie. The salad wasn't anything to write home about (called Just the Basics) and it was fine. The pizza was terrific however...thin and crispy crust with a generous amount of toppings. Next time i would try something more traditional (mozzarella, basil, etc.) but it was very good. I would have liked the crust to be just a tad more crispy. What a great local place for pizza...next time I'm in town on business I will be stopping back. Really really enjoyed this place. read more

See all

I walk by this place all the time and never had food here until today. The space is nice and the pizza was good. I'm not a big fan of thin crust pizza though. The Degarmo had a whole bunch of meat. read more

Fire & Stone Pizzeria - Degarmo 14 inch - Pizza Near Me - Chillicothe, Ohio

Shawn is too busy getting out of work than worrying what is being served under his name! Closed more often than not! Hope Shawn enjoys his compulsive time "off" read more

Delicious pizza with great crust and flavor, the people were friendly and the atmosphere was very pleasant; I would definitely recommend this place! read more

Friendly staff and great food makes this one of the best places in town. Enjoy one of their salads along with a thin crust pizza and draft beer. read more

Fire & Stone Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Chillicothe, Ohio

If you are used to top quality food, remember you are in rural Ohio and lower your expectations. That said, this is the best food I have found in Chillicothe. Pros: ingredients are fresh and of good quality, the space is cozy, inviting, clean, subdued comfy lighting, three nice beers on tap (not counting Bud Lite), wait staff is friendly. Cons: they advertise as 'wood fired pizza' but I don't think it's a very hot fire. Crust was kind of soft and rubbery, not at all the lovely bubbly, chewy, crispy-scorched crust that come from strong risen dough and a red hot fire. The crust was indestinguishable from pre-made store bought. It had no rise. I sat at the bar and had a Fat Tire draft and the Forager pizza with Canadian bacon added. While I missed having amazing crust, everything else was great. Best food I've had in rural Ohio ever. read more

This place has went downhill fast. We came in tonight and ordered salads and a pizza. It's been 40 minutes and NO SALAD AND NO PIZZA. GET employees to work to make salads or train the servers. If you have 1 hour to wait for salad the come here. Otherwise go somewhere else. Can't wait for a new pizza place to open. We will not be back. *we come in 3x a week and we no longer will. Pizza update. We ordered a cheese pizza pep and extra cheese. They forgot the pep and then cooked it and just put it on top. Terrible. read more

Best pizza in town! White sauce is my fave!! Never disappoints! Now with door dash I can even have it delivered:) great atmosphere too!

Two kinda of pizza, pepperoni and "the works", were both very good. But first we had two kinds of salad, green and Greek, and both were very fresh, with housemade dressings that were delicious. We will definitely go back again! read more

Fairly good pizza with good toppings. The crust was a bit doughy as it could have baked a bit longer. A few beers on tap and the addition of wines in the near future according to the bartender. Blue moon,Fat tire ale,Portsmouth Pilsner, and bud light on tap. Mid afternoon, not very busy yielded a quick turnaround on the pizza. Certainly worth a try, but hopefully they will add more topping options and increase the bake time. read more

See all

The Forager with chicken was delicious; Best pizza I've had since 5th street Pub. If your passing through Chillicothe, it's a must stop read more

See all

A welcome surprise. Forager pizza with salad combo and house-made Greek dressing hit the spot. Thin crust, great cheese and mushrooms and greens in the perfect ratio. Got this for take-out and washed it down with a good bottle of red and the Stanley Cup semi finals. I'd call this a great night. read more

Reading good reviews and hearing the same from Chillicothe friends, my wife and I picked up Washington CH friends for what we anticipated would be great pizza. We called prior to leaving, no answer, and left a message. We called a second time on our drive. No answer. Upon arrival, a handwritten sign on the door announced that due to a lack of help, they were closed. However, some people were inside eating and the oven obviously going! Round trip of over 60 miles could have been avoided with a call back or a message on the answering machine. read more

It has been years since i ate here because the last time was not a good thing. I will say pizza was better this time but way over priced. I dont mind paying it though for something special but it really wasnt. Biggest issue was time. I paid for 1 hour and 20 minutes on the parking meter and ran out of time. All weordered was a pepperoni pizza and a ceasar salad. We were the 3rd table in the room so not busy. So if you go dont be in a hurry. read more

Their pizza is good when they actually have dough or toppings! Twice on separate occasions I have called trying to get pizza and the first time they had no dough!! Second time they said they were out of pepperoni and pineapple! So disappointing!! read more

Some of the best pizza in chilli town. The marinara sauce is probably my favorite part along with the crispy crust. It's a smaller area but it's worth it being tight in there or having to wait. Great place for a social lunch with friends and a date night out. Calzones are really amazing as well. read more