Small place that can get super busy. Every time I've gone for dinner the food has been amazing. I went once in the beginning of the day and it wasn't as good. Maybe a different chef? Maybe a fluke of a meal? Not sure. But any other time it has been AMAZING!! Pro tip- do NOT fill up on the amazing chips and salsa. (It happens to the best of us.) Margaritas are amazing! There are so many flavors to choose from. Pomegranate is my fav but why not call an Uber and try them all. Chicken chimichangas are my favorite there. The Mexican salad is also on point. read more

See all

I think the food here is pretty special. Its not a huge menu and nothing is fancy, but everything is pretty tasty and prices are fair. They have really good grilled chicken. I am a fan of their chicken fajitas, guacamole, and grande burrito with beef. They also have great lime margaritas cause they are not too sweet as long as you don't add flavoring. read more

Fiesta Mexicana - Mexican Near Me - Brewster, New York

See all

First off, the prices are extremely reasonable! $11 for a frozen margarita, yes, please. The combo meal that included three different samples of Mexican dishes (enchiladas, burrito, quesadilla, etc) for $15.95! You just can't beat that in 2025. The food was delicious and fresh, nothing extravagant, but solid good Mexican. I took one star off for the bathroom. It was not very clean, and needs a face lift. Also, the service was very minimal, they did not refill waters or check in on us throughout the evening. Very basic and non personal. I would go back if I want decent Mexican food on a budget. read more

I attended a party here. This place is a solid four star. Margaritas were great, sangria was fantastic. Guacamole was excellent and chicken fajitas were fresh and delicious. Service with a smile of course, very efficient and really nice people. The shrimp special in the salsa Verde was excellent, lots of hints of cilantro and Tastee tomatillo. The ceviche was excellent, the shrimp were cold and crisp with mango and onion and other veggies. Just delicious. I will definitely be back to try out some other cocktails and fabulous food. read more

See all

Really bad. Tap water tasted horrible. Chips were good. Dip and guac was really bad. I ordered simple chicken rice and beans. Horrible. The marg was pretty good. But it could have been better. Waste of time and money. read more

Great food excellent service would definitely reccommend Did not drink but from the looks of people around us the drinks were plentiful and seemed enjoyable read more

TERRIBLE. TERRIBLE. TERRIBLE!! Terrible food. Terrible service. Terrible all around. Took forever. I wasted my money.

Good prices and good food. We had a coupon for a meal for four and were eating leftovers for days.

Friendly staff and atmosphere,excellent service ,tasty food ,generous portions and reasonably priced my family eats there once a week

If you're looking for some solid margaritas, then this is a great spot. Their guacamole is made fresh and is SO good. I will say their meals have gone downhill over the past 1-2 years. Not sure if there is a new chef, but it definitely doesn't compare to years prior. The interior is pretty outdated and could stand an upgrade. Can be very loud depending on the day/time (as can any restaurant). Bar is sizable and the bartender has a strong & appreciated pour! read more

Always fresh food and great!!! Drinks live the people and the atmosphere... wonderful customer service I've been going here since 1999 love the place and the people the food and the drinks!!! read more

I could make better Spanish rice from a box. Tacos were soggy. Chicken in enchiladas were so bland. Bland bland bland

We've been eating at Fiesta for many years. More than 35 counting their first restaurant in the village of Brewster. The food is always good and the service is first rate. Prices are very reasonable and you do get a lot for your money. Very family friendly. You will not be disappointed. If you are looking for a more upscale experience try their other restaurant, Las Mañanitas, with outside (open air and enclosed) dining and a huge fireplace to take away any chill in the air. read more

Great authentic food, guacamole made at table and one one the best recipes we've eaten, great atmosphere, for families!!!!

I came here with a friend during my time off and ordered a beef dish with rice and beans. The service was great and quick, the food was delicious and the atmosphere of the restaurant was great. The decorations were beautiful, and they had great music playing. I wish I dined in but overall the experience was great and I would come here again whenever I'm craving Mexican food. I look forward to my next visit. read more

See all

In a strip mall with plenty of parking. The interior gives off a stereotypical Mexican restaurant vibe. The tables were clean but the floor could definitely use a sweep. The servers were nice but the service was painfully slow. It took 40 minutes to get our food and the restaurant only had 3 other occupied tables. To start you get complimentary chips and salsa, as you should at any proper Mexican restaurant. The chips were warm and fresh; the salsa was smokey, tangy, smooth, and delicious. The sangria was huge and very tasty. We got the salmon, and the skirt steak over rice. The salmon was very dry and came with no sauce. The skirt steak was well seasoned but undercooked. The Mexican rice was overcooked and mushy, but the refried beans were decent. The red sauce that came with the steak added much needed flavor to the dish. Had we come here for just drinks and chips with salsa, Fiesta Mexicana would have earned a 4 star review. I was not impressed with the entrees and do not feel compelled to return. Las Mañanitas, also in Brewster, is slightly more expensive but blows Fiesta Mexicana out of the water. read more

We love eating here- good service, strong margaritas, nice portions. Never had a bad experience.

can't believe people still eat here. It is the bucolic setting & that's it...!!! Certainly NOT the food. Ate at another Mex restaurant & other customers & I were talking about the food at Las Mananitas. They were from NY as I was. A question came up: WHERE DID THESE PEOPLE GET THE MONEY TO OPEN LAS MANANITAS....& expand on Fiesta Mexicana???!!!! CARTELS...??? That's what people are saying. read more

We found tasty food, a nice ambiance that's not as crazy/noisy as Las Mananitas, and super large platters at pre-Covid prices. You can't go wrong. We were surprised no not see sangria on the menu though. read more

Placed take out order at 6:45 and received food 1 hour later than estimated delivery (8:30 pm). Guacamole was dark brown and watery. read more

Fiesta Mexicana - Guacamole - Mexican Near Me - Brewster, New York

I love this place! Me and my bf go here often the food is always on point. I usually get the taco salad with shrimp and this time he got the chicken chimichangas. I get the prickly pear margarita and he gets the Cadillac margarita. We always order the table side guacamole and their homemade tortilla chips are always warm and crunchy and the salsa is tasty! Never a disappointment! read more

Good drinks. Bad paella. Could use the lobster tail for a doorstop. Gross. Should have stuck with the regular menu which has been pretty good in the past! read more

I came for the guacamole and a drink I had a whole order of guacamole all by myself unbelievable how great the guacamole is here.

Sweet Jesus this place was loud. The guacamole was good, but being ignored by four different waiters as they sat at empty tables in the dining room playing on their phones was beyond frustrating. Probably a pass moving forward. Which is a shame because the food is ok. However, the volume level and poor service kind of ruin the experience. read more

This is definitely my top restaurant for Mexican-American food! Everything about this restaurant is delicious. I've ordered numerous plates from here, and they never disappoint. read more

Great spot. It was packed but efficient. Food was excellent. Service was too. We were glad we picked it for a family birthday meal

Have to update this review because I decided to give this local restaurant another chance. We arrived on a very busy Saturday night and were seated pretty quickly. I ordered a combination dinner and I have to say, it was very good. The food was fresh, flavorful, and had the right amount of spice. Best salsa around! The service was incredible. Out waiter kept our salsa bowl full. No need to ask for extra. He was in it! Prices are average and not expensive. My only complaint is that they charge for refills on soda which I think is very gauche and a tacky way to bump up the bill. Overall, positive experience! read more

Don't come here! The food didn't taste fresh at all. We also saw a cockroach on the wall. It's unsanitary to eat here. I will not be coming back read more

I heard bad things about Mexican food in New York from a friend that visited recently. So I was curious to try it myself, being a Mexican. First positive sign is that everyone behind the counter was Mexican, or at least some type of Hispanic. Our waiter though, didn't appear to be too excited about work today. In fact, his responses were either short, or rudely abrupt. I had to run out between drinks and ordering food, so I didn't get to analyze him further. But I don't think his attitude got any worse. I ordered the enchiladas suizas, which on the menu is the green sauce/chicken option. The rice and beans were meh but that's how important feel about rice and beans. I did, however, appreciate the carrots in the rice to mix it up a but. What I didn't appreciate was the seeming shortcut taken when making my food. Typically, the sour cream is put on the enchilada after its heated. The sour cream appeared to have been on the food when it was heated. So it was a bit thick, and even changed the taste of it. The green sauce was on the sour side, but I've had green sauce with no taste before. I'll take sour over tasteless any day. A decent outing nevertheless. In this area it's probably the best it gets. My only gripe was the lack of horchata as a drink option. Oh well...... Imabigdeal@yelp.com read more

Fiesta Mexicana - Enchiladas suizas - Mexican Near Me - Brewster, New York

See all

Delicious, affordable, clean, professional and friendly staff. Plenty of parking. Don't let the idea of going to dinner in a strip mall turn you away! read more

I am not one to write reviews but want to give these guys credit. If you need catering for an event definitely give them a call. They catered a 2 day event for us for 50 people. The food was amazing and fresh. The service was excellent. And the prices were very reasonable. Their staff was helpful and worked with our budget. Everyone loved the food and our event was a huge success. I would give them 10 stars if I could. We will definitely continue to use them in the future. read more

This place was fantastic! Service was speedy, food was delicious, and it was child friendly. It is spacious and colorful without being over the top. Nicely sized bar with seating for 10-12 people. We had the chicken tacos, beef burrito, the chicken soup, fresh made guacamole and hot homemade tortilla chips! I think the owners of Las Mananitas own this restaurant too so you definitely can expect the best! read more

I loved this place before I was vegetarian, now, not so much. The last handful of times I've been here haven't been great experiences. Maybe it's because I go here for lunch, but with the place being slower you would think the service would be more attentive. Let me start by saying I will never get guacamole anywhere else. The one reason I keep coming back here is for the delicious guacamole they make right in front of you. They're known for their outrageous sized margaritas as well, so apps and drinks here are always a fun time. However, the food I've been able to order since going vegetarian has been limited, and I keep getting sick from the options. There's currently three items under Vegetarian on the lunch menu, one option is fried- which most vegetarians avoid for fear of getting sick from oil tainted with animal products. So that leaves me with two options, or of course I can eat the quesadillas from the app menu. The dishes come with rice and beans, and I can't tell which it is, but every time I eat the sides I get sick. I know refried beans are traditionally made with animal lard, so I assumed the ones that came with the vegetarian dishes were made different. But I'm starting to think that maybe they are not. Between the fried option and the beans, I don't think Fiesta fully understands what Vegetarian is. My last four times eating here have all been during lunch hours, but slower business should NOT mean slower service. On one occasion, we were seated without menus and tried to flag down a waiter a few minutes later. We figured he'd just forgotten but when he came over he asked if we were ready to order without looking down to realize we never even got menus. On another day, we sat down to a table set up with napkins clearly full of lint. We ended up trading napkins with the empty table next to us since our waiter had already disappeared. For my most recent lunch here, we switched it up to the bar to avoid bad lunchtime table service. All was well until I took my leftovers home- half a burrito, half of the rice serving and half of my beans- to later find all that was packed up for me was the burrito half without either side! It's so disappointing that service is so bad around lunch times, because the place has a friendly look and the owner is nice. The menu could improve and judging by other reviews I'm not the only vegetarian that thinks this. Again, here for the guacamole. But I hope to start coming back for more than just guac and margs. read more

Authentic Mexican food. Sister restaurant to another local restaurant, Las Manañitas.

Better prices and more authentic compared to Las Mananitas down the road...would have never guessed. This place is tuck away in a shopping center. We arrived between lunch and dinner and got to pick where we sat since the restaurant was so empty. The service was great, maybe due to the lack of customers in the place. We ordered guacamole which was made right next to our table; they asked if we wanted it "spicy" and we said yes however I did not taste any spice whatsoever. The chips were great and the salsa was decent however had the consistency of tomato soup. The margaritas were amazing! We got the large frozen ones and they had about 10 flavors to choose from; well made with a good balance of alcohol and flavor. The beef chimichanga was flavorful and had a good amount of spice to it; I believe the app came with 5-6 pieces. The worst part of the meal was when my plate came out and in the refried beans....WAS A BLACK HAIR. It was sitting right on top so I have no idea how this was not noticed by the kitchen staff, since I noticed it before my plate hit the table in front of me. The waiter was quick to bring the plate back to the kitchen and rectify the mistake. I ended up getting a combination plate with a cheese quesadilla, beef chimichanga, and a chicken enchilada. The quesadilla was just a small round flour tortilla loaded with cheese; not your typical triangle shaped quesadilla. I was disappointed because my beef chimichanga did not taste like the app. The beef was dry and had no flavor. Overall, it was an average meal. I loved the margaritas and the chips. I would probably come back if I'm in the area however probably couldn't order the combination plate again. read more

Great food and service. Clean, comfortable seating and accommodating staff. Prices are reasonable.

Yikes, over 60.00 with tip and we received two meal with nothign more thatn frozen vegatables. We waited to tell the server who did not come for over 20 minutes, so we ate what we had. Not an appoligy or anything. I ordered a veritarian Burito with cheese and beans. How can they forget when there is only three items in the order, plus it on the menu. The waitress did go into the kitchen and tell the staff but not even a "oh I'm sorry "and let me take off the cost of the beans and cheese and not make you pay for something you did not receive. We have eaten here many times but something has changed. Someone told us they opened a new restaurant and now this is kind of like a hang out bar with Natchos. Seems like they are right. What a shame, it was a nice place. read more

Prepare your taste buds to hop the border this place is the real deal. As soon as you walk in you get an eye full of the detailed wall murals that really sets the fiesta mexicana mood. They have table side service for fresh guac and if your lucky the live mariachi band will be there to serenade and add to the fiesta in your mouth! Try anything it's all muy bueno... Grab your muchachos and check this place out. read more

See all

Came here as a recommendation from a friend. Had the guacamole for the app, I enjoyed a beer, while my wife had a margarita. Everything was excellent. Beer was ice cold, margarita was on the money and the guacamole was excellent. On to the entree...... I ordered the shrimp fajita and my wife ordered the steak fajita. Everything was seasoned perfectly and tasted fresh. The service here is also excellent, with the waitstaff attending to your needs, but not in an overwhelming way. Overall, I would definitely recommend to anyone considering all the above. The only reason I didn't give 5 star is because I would like to come here again before I truly give it 5 stars. Enjoy..... Ok. Just had the flan and it was also excellent. Changed my mind. Five stars to you. Thanks to the staff here and thanks for a great date with the wife. read more

Fiesta Mexicana - Shrimp fajita is AWESOME!! - Mexican Near Me - Brewster, New York

See all

The food is "OK." I got the sample platter. The Quesadia was bland. The Chimichangas were cold and soggy. The Nachos were also cold and soggy. The guacamole was very good and the chips were as well. The restaurant was filled with smoke from the kitchen. The bar area is very small, and they only have one TV. The service was very good however. Probably won't be back. read more