Always honest and genuine about fixing your car. Used them many times over the years.

Doing work on my car without my au thorization and catching them. Quality was very poor. Jammed up my steering wheel, telescope and my turn signal then called me a liar twice on something I didn't do. If I do it I own it! Anyway, 3/4 of my car bill is labor and 1/4 over inflated parts, cars finally put back together but I can't pick up during the M-F 9am-5pm hours and closed weekends. So l told them to leave the car out and I would pick up but when I turned on car I had to shut down fast and get it towed out of there fast. It's like someone purposely played with the motor. I never let any shop know I have more mechanics skills than most there workers, they still think women are dumb. They loosened and flipped my alt belt, loosened and chewed up teeth on my lower two belts, damaged my new paint job. I never had a chance to put the corvette emblem back on...It's been at their shop for so many, many, months. Please, customers beware. I am sending pics. read more

See all

Mark, the new owner has continued right where Feldman left off. They did a great job and go the extra mile. They replaced the water pump on my Porsche 911 with no issue. Highly recommend them for your foreign or domestic car service needs. read more

Needed high pressure fuel pump, new motor mounts, new timing kit, and water pump. Received a fair quote quickly with no BS. Feldman got OEM and upgraded parts quickly and did all necessary work, on time. Communication from Mike was excellent; the phone was answered quickly and politely each time I called. It is clear these guys care about their business reputation. Given the challenges that came with this particular job, the team at Feldman was communicative, honest and efficient. I highly recommend Feldman Auto Repair! read more

This is a great shop. Why? Because they are incredibly honest. One of my cars is 20 years old and I tend to do a lot of the work on it myself. When I need service that goes beyond my skill or tools, these are the guys I go to. Several times, I had issues where a less reputable mechanic would have taken advantage of the situation to do extra work or sell extra unneeded parts. Not these guys. As an example, I recently had some AC issues and took my car in to get the AC checked out. It wasn't blowing very cold. I thought I needed new o-rings or had a leak in the compressor since the hoses all looked good. It's an old car, so they could have easily found all sorts of parts that needed to be replaced. But the parts were actually fine and after checking everything out and not finding any leaks, they recharged my system and told me to keep an eye on it. They did everything right too, using dye and a sensor to check for leaks. I paid a small bill for the recharge work instead of the big bill some mechanics would have charged to replace stuff that wasn't broken and and my AC is still blowing cold a few weeks later. So very reputable shop here and my go-to mechanic. read more

I will be using Feldman for all my auto repair! Very responsive and friendly people. When I arrived to the business I had second thoughts about leaving my car. The lot is very crowded. But do not worry about first impressions. This place is honest and will take care of your car. read more

This is an awesome shop! The owner is awesome, the mechanics are awesome, the pricing is awesome, the service was awesome and I couldn't be happier with the results! Couldn't ask for a better experience. Thanks!! read more

Extremely satisfied! My Subaru Outback developed problems where the sensors were reading inconsistent values with lost engine power and the transmission slipping. They took the time and diagnosed the problem to a single source which resolved all of the symptoms at a very reasonable cost. The car runs beautifully. I must add they certainly had the opportunity to replace several sensors, try other potential solutions and cost me an arm and a leg: Instead they were very honest in their diagnosis as well as the actual repair and, bonus, it did not break the bank. I highly recommend these guys! read more

It's always an amazement when you experience something so humorous and infuriating at the same time. When you give a business your trust, there's an unspoken expectation... value my business. Don't break my trust. Don't lose your integrity Feldman's had my trust but they didn't honor it nor value it. Thus they threw away their integrity. Feldman had my car for 2 weeks to fix an issue. The day I finally pick it up, the issue isn't fixed. Gary's response? "Oh we didn't "FIX the problem.. we just got it running again. We didn't know you wanted us to "fix it" fix it". I'm sorry... can you repeat that Gary? You didn't know we wanted you to fix it fix it? You honestly think we just wanted you to "get it running?" Like temporarily? So the car will just once again randomly die on the highway or in the middle of a busy road? Is that what you would want for your wife's car? Or your car for that matter? Cuz that's really scary.. very unsafe. Shame on you for allowing me to pick up my car, pay you 600.00 and allow me to drive a car that was unsafe. Thanks for "getting it running" so I could drive it off your lot to a truly honest and reliable mechanic. read more

Awesome shop with good mechanics! They are honest with excellent communication=Mike! They have earned my business and I will always bring my vehicles to this shop. read more

Just moved down to St Augustine from Jersey and wanted to find an auto repair shop I could go to a trust. Found Feldman Auto Repair online and wanted to try them out based on reviews and ratings. Was not disappointed. Went in for a 44 point inspection along with full synthetic oil change. Extremely fair pricing, top tier quality, and honest work. Didn't want to get price gouged by some commercial shop. Will definitely be going to Feldman's for all my auto repairs. read more

It is always a pleasant surprise to come across a service (or product) provider that is capable, honest, dependable, collaborative, and still very fairly priced. We have taken our vehicles to Feldman Auto for several years, because we know that we can fully trust Mike and his team, just as they proved yet again today when a mechanical issue cropped up. Whenever a neighbor, friend, or acquaintance asks us if we know of an honest and competent vehicle repair facility, it's our pleasure to highly recommend Feldman Auto Repair. Terry G read more

They were wonderful!! I'm thankful for the effort to make the repairs executed in a very timely manner with an incredible price

My car had previously been worked by Feldman so when I had a problem I took it there and after 3 days of waiting I called and was told they had not looked at it yet. He said that I didn't have an appointment. He was too busy. When I asked for my keys back he seem surprised and asked if I wanted him to repair my car. I said no give me my car. I took it elsewhere and got a report the next day read more

Service was amazing and fast. Looked all issues that I had brought up. Friendly, honest and reasonablypriced. Will definitely be back

Absolutely fantastic! About six months ago I bought a 2010 minicooper from a mini dealer in Jacksonville. The dealer did not tell me that the one thing that the various on-board computers don't check for is engine oil level. Of course, neither did the dealer. So, one day while driving, I hear a clunk, the engine light comes on and the engine seizes. I had the car towed to Feldman. I was told there was a little less than one quart of oil in the crankcase and the engine most likely had thrown a rod. Feldman installed a new engine (long block) and, of course, a new clutch plate/bearing. The work was professional, done on a timely basis, and was very reasonable ---- compared to what it would have cost had I taken the car back to the dealer. Feldman also test drove the car for about 50 miles to make sure that everything was done properly and that all the systems work. What more can anyone ask for!! If you have a problem with your car, you won't go,wrong by having Feldman do the work! read more

Very knowledgeable, professional team. They repaired my car in a timely manner. I drove all the way from Jacksonville to get quality service and it paid off. read more

Nice nice owner who has always dropped everything to help me in a pinch with my Mercedes and my daughter's dog of a Mazda!

Overall I am happy with the services provided by Feldman auto repair, however I'm a little disappointed this morning. I dropped off my car yesterday to have a dead battery replaced, and when they called later in the afternoon to tell me the work was completed I let them know I would be by to pick it up in the morning. They let me know they were open from 8-12, and when I showed up at 11:30 to get my car the entire place was closed. Not only were they closed when they verbally told me they would be open, but they left my car unlocked. This would be understandable if they were to have left my keys in the car as well for me to still get it, but the keys were no where to be found. I'm not impressed by the decision to close early when they knew a customer was coming to retrieve their car. read more

Service was great, they were quick and inexpensive! Mike explained exactly what was needed and why. I will definitely use again!

I've had my BMW 650i in that shop several times. Every visit they have 100% exceeded my expectations, time of repair, friendly, great communication, fair estimates they stick to, etc, etc. They also on a couple of occasions recommended less expensive options to repair than I thought were doable. They have my trust 100%, and I always recommend them. Craig Sanford - St Augustine read more

Ok. Car won't start. Call Feldman Auto, made Gary listen to what happened when I tried to start. "Battery" Gary says, Me I'm like are you sure!! Gary is clear that his Crystal Ball may not be working today and that over the phone isn't that reliable a diagnostic tool! Ha Ha. Of course it was the battery. Shout out to Triple A for getting to me in less than 2 hours. Jumped my car And I went right to Feldman Auto where a replacement Battery was provided at a very reasonable cost. Yup Feldman Auto the only place to go for honest and speedy service. read more

I was promised a call explaining and quoting a particular problem. I was called and told my car was ready and I owed $230.56. Fine. I went down to pick it up and when I got in the car the same warning light was on. They said NO PROBLEM, we'll reset it. 45 minutes later the tech guy clearly having trouble "resetting" it went into office and then theytold me I had another, larger problem. They said it didn't show before but now IT was the problem. They clearly are not fully trained to work on foreign cars. Besides that, after the technician (and I use that term loosely) pulled and tugged on every wire under the hood when I left I had no AIR CONDITIONING! Of course that too must be my fault because my wife refused to drive my car down there be cause it was too cold. And finally there is grease on the carpets, steering wheel, elbow console, passenger side carpets and both door jams. Just a total TECH SLOB. Nice work Feldman!! read more

Two of the hardest things we can do are buy a car, and then find a reliable trustworthy shop when somthing goes wrong. As a local i have teied a few places for one of my older trucks and Gary an mike here at feldman are by far leaps and bounds above the rest. Great guys doing what they love to do all while taking care of there customers. They honest , fast and on piont with diagnosis. Do not go to those chains when u can go to a local biz doing it the right way !!! Thanks guys keep up the great work ! read more

These guys are amazing, while on vacation we started having major AC problems. Took our truck in to see what they could do if anything, not only did they fix it the very next day they did it for a very fair price..very honest company, wish we lived closer they would be our mechanics for all our vehicles read more

Thank you Gary and Mike for being honest to a person who is just passing through. I was on vacation with my family and we drove from NY to South Florida, with a stop in St. Augustine. I had some car trouble and Feldman Auto fixed it fast and got is back on the road to continue our trip. Once again thank you. read more

Very professional and friendly family business. I went there for what I thought was a big problem, and the owner fixed it in a minute a said have a great day! I highly recommend this company. read more

If it's Integrity that you seek, Feldman can't be beat. Dr. Van S. Cogley

I have used Gary for years and could not give higher marks, I wish there were 10 stars to give. Recently brought my car in and basically told them the water pump was broken and needed to be replaced. Received a call about 2 hours later saying it was only a hose and I could come pick it up. You think that would be the same story if I brought my car to a dealership? Yeah, me either.... One of many stories. Honest, hard working, friendly, and reliable. Thanks for everything guys... read more

Needed a minor repair (headlight bulb) when visiting area and found Feldman on Yelp. Their service was very good - fast response with a fair price. Would definitely use again. read more

Great Customer Service and Exceptional Value. Easy to work with and very pro...Thanks Guys, Kenny

I am the owner and operator of HAIRPORT of St Augustine and I depend on my car for transportation . Feldman Auto repair was there for me with fast and dependable work. I can trust that they will be fast, thorough and give me a good price. They even drove me to my business and picked me up. Afterwards. I will continue to be a fan of Feldman Auto Repair read more

Miserable experience with a transmission replacement that they recommended... failing within a few weeks of the installation. Thereafter; they claimed that I should have expected no better from a 'junk' transmission--which was the first time they had used that description. Stories changed, excuses were issued and they did nothing to make good on it. Was REALLY surprised at their reaction and the abysmal way they did business, even after doing a small amount of business previously. Spent the same amount of money (to replace their replacement) with a 'name' transmission repair company that offered me an extensive warranty and offered a VERY poor opinion of the condition of the transmission they installed. Will NEVER do business with this company again and recommended extreme caution working with them on anything serious. They seem to be fine for oil changes and the like but this experience was THE most miserable (and costly) car repair misadventure I've ever dealt with. read more

I found myself a new mechanic! The most important thing I look for in a car mechanic is honesty. My 07 Nissan Pathfinder broke down and was towed to Feldman Auto Repair. Feldman was recommended to me by a friend who swears by this place and I didn't want to get ripped off like I have been at other places. Mike (the owner) gave me a quick diagnosis- and unfortunately it wasn't good. My transmission was shot and it was going to be an expensive repair. He gave me options- one of which was to get a used, remanufactured transmission and save money, but he warned me that it was risky. What really impressed me was that he basically talked me out of spending thousands to fix the car and recommended that I cut my losses and trade it in. The cost of the replacing the transmission was almost as much as the value of my vehicle and it would have been stupid to dump that kind of money into it. I appreciated his honesty because he probably could have talked me in to spending the money at Feldman to fix it. Mike's recommendation cost him some business, but I will be coming back knowing that he's a mechanic that I can trust. On a side note- I liked the vibe of his shop. A few customers came while I was there and I watched how he and the other mechanics interacted with them. They were very friendly and personable- way different than going to a chain place like Goodyear or Tires Plus where you wait forever to talk to somebody and it takes forever for them to call you to let you know what's going on. I have another old car that needs some work (oil leaks) and I'll be bringing it in to Feldman in the near future. I'll write another review that speaks to the quality of their work. read more

Very nice people. I came to to them because i saw they have good reviews. My car kept shutting off when i would come to a complete stop so I brought it to them & they hooked up the computer to me car & then they told me it was my oxygen sensor. So i came back so they could fix it. They replaced it along with some spark plugs, later on that day I went to the gas station & filled my car up & i go to leave the gas station & my car shut off again so immediately i called them to tell them & they told me to come back. I planned on going back but then 2 days after that incident, I had to get gas again on my way to work & once again i go to leave & my car won't start at all. Tried to start it at least 10 times, had to call a tow company, was late to work. I called a friend who knows cars & he told me that they had ripped me off because clearly my car has a fuel problem. So it's been a week without having a car & i am very disappointed that auto part stores take advantage of people who have no idea about cars. read more