What an absolute delight!…read more We walked in on a Saturday night without reservations & were immediately sat. They were so cool about it. Before I talk about the food let me tell you about the ambiance. Classy, clean, cool - am I in NYC or Murray, KY?! And the music selection surprised me at every turn. Nick Drake? Yes, please! For starters, it was happy hour & wine was $7 a glass. The cab was delicious. A perfect selection, poured fresh table-side. The starter kale salad with fresh fennel bulb was a testament to the goodness of God's creation. I crave that salad daily. House-made pasta - need I say more? The chicken in my mushroom pasta dish was house-roasted, you could taste it! And the mushrooms were so fresh and fragrant- the way mushrooms should be eaten. The red/sauce sausage pasta my daughter got was just the right amount of spicy. The next day I mixed our two pasta leftovers together & that was a real treat! For dessert we had the flourless chocolate torte which was the perfect ending to the perfect meal. I'm already planning my next meal when I visit Murray next weekend! Oh, also! They used Oneida Michelangelo silverware - the fancy stuff my parents used at home growing up. So that was special

Excellent food and great service. We loved the Caesar Salad! Alfredo with fresh Turkey Tail and…read moreOyster mushrooms atop Chicken...Amazingly tasty.

The service was quick! The server was very helpful. It is a nice big space so you don't feel packed…read morein. We absolutely loved the food! We had cheese sticks, a cheese pizza and another specialty pizza. All was fantastic' I can't wait to go back!

Without a doubt my favorite pizza in the world. I travel.... A lot. NYC, Chicago, all over the USA…read moreand I've eaten pizza at many acclaimed pizza places in numerous little Italy areas, nothing tops Pagliais. The quality and freshness of the ingredients is amazing and put all together, it's perfect.

Amazing food and Amazing service!!…read more The deep dish all meat was delicious! And the cannolis were perfect!! Fatboy Approved!!

Had lunch with a friend here today. Its great location on the downtown square and narrow deep room…read morereminds me of a great OLD pizza joint in Chicago. The lady who was taking care of us provided excellent service and has a wonderful accent and back-story. The food was fabulous. I had the daily special of a personal thin crust pizza with sausage and mushrooms. My friend had an Italian beef sandwich with fries. She took half of it home. Both of us ordered a deep dish supreme pizza to take home for dinner. This is the 2nd time I've dined here and will definitely be back. It's such a comfortable and friendly place!

It's over, this place is just not the same without Matt running it with his vibrancy, warmth and…read moregenuine care for customer satisfaction. The environment is like a tomb and the quality of the food is awful, all while charging a higher price. They're serving small, dried out overdone pieces of pizza for more money than ever. They're really skimping on the ingredients in the calzones and I think they've changed the dough and the dressing for the salad (for the worse). You can upgrade the physical interior of a building but without the food quality and ambiance, it's meaningless. Very Sad after all these years of great food, service and warmth. We gave them a few chances but we're done, it's over.

Pizza here is really damn good, service here was great and very welcoming. Inside was super nice…read moreand generally seemed like a clean place. Not too much to say since this place does all it wants to do pretty well. Never had an issue ordering out from here either. Overall, good service with good food. Place you don't go wrong with in Murray

I am working in town and stopped in at the suggestion of a friend…read more The place was almost empty. Maybe 6 of us total in the bar area and probably about that same amount in the dining area. I sat at the bar and had a couple beers. For appetizers, I asked the bartender what she liked the best. Based on her recommendations, I ordered the Pub Pretzels with Beer Cheese along with the Buffalo Ranch Chicken Dip with Tortilla Chips and Celery. Typical bar food. The Pub Pretzels and Beer Cheese looked and tasted like Auntie Anne's brand. Not bad. The Buffalo Ranch Chicken Dip was served in a disposable container. It was good, but, very mild, not spicy at all. Could have used more heat. They have an area for live music. I'm sure this place is packed when school is in session. It is next to campus. Several TV's to watch sports.

The service was great. Pizza crust wasn't impressive but the toppings were fresh and the were…read moregenerous with the toppings.

The pizza used to be great.. but the last three times we got a pizza to go... the crust was only…read moreabout half-cooked and they have definitely changed the pizza sauce to something entirely different. The employees act unaware of any changes, but several customers were confirming our suspicions. Not that we needed them to, the different taste is obvious, it can't be missed. Also, the buffet is no longer all-day as it had been for many years at this location. Now, lunch buffet goes to 2pm and dinner buffet runs from 4pm to close. It doesn't matter though, we can't handle the nasty taste of the new pizza sauce.

Went 40 minutes before closing, they did inform us they weren't going to put anything new out as…read morethe oven was turned off for the night when we got in. We decided to eat anyways. Food wasn't super fresh, the salad bar was actually the best part about it. They had a very big variety for their salad bar. None of it seemed sus. 5 of us ate for $35 (4 of them had the senior discount) Great value for the price, I intend to go back sometime, just not right before they close. I also saw people with some game ticket things, it looked like there was a game room on the other side but didn't have time to check it out.

We went to Mister B's yesterday, 2/16 around noon to eat lunch. There were multiple servers…read morestanding around doing nothing. There were not many customers, and we asked to sit outdoors with our puppy. We were told the porch was closed and that we could not be served. I have worked in many restaurants myself over the years and I have never turned away a client. We obviously could not sit indoors with our puppy. It was not cold, the sun was out and I found it rude and will not be going back.

Delicious pizza and wings, slow service. We ordered to go so not sure how the restaurant was. Would…read morerecommend the pizza and wings for sure!

Mistakenly gave two cups instead of two bowls of soup. Sweetest man helped us out and fixed it…read more Absolutely wonderful staff!!

Food is great but for a small little town with low income, they need to adjust their prices if they…read morewant to stay in business here!

Ordered a small pizza with Canadian Bacon, Black Olives and Onions. Pizza was decent. I wish the…read moreonions were baked a little more, but not a big deal. They use Door Dash for their deliveries. Pizza was delivered in less than 30 minutes. I would order from them again when I'm in Murray Kentucky. I'd give them a grade of B+

Food from here is usually above avergae I would say but quality is very dependent at times on…read morecertain factors like time. Stuffed crust is always good, rarely ever had issues with orders revolving that. New York style I could debate, the burned the hell out of the cheese last time I got one that it was near black and flaking off the dough. It stays in my rotation of pizza chains, no where near my favorite.