Amazing food and Amazing service!! The deep dish all meat was delicious! And the cannolis were perfect!! Fatboy Approved!! read more

See all

Had lunch with a friend here today. Its great location on the downtown square and narrow deep room reminds me of a great OLD pizza joint in Chicago. The lady who was taking care of us provided excellent service and has a wonderful accent and back-story. The food was fabulous. I had the daily special of a personal thin crust pizza with sausage and mushrooms. My friend had an Italian beef sandwich with fries. She took half of it home. Both of us ordered a deep dish supreme pizza to take home for dinner. This is the 2nd time I've dined here and will definitely be back. It's such a comfortable and friendly place! read more

Mugsy's Hideout - Small deep dish supreme pizza - Pizza Near Me - Murray, Kentucky

The food was great the service was on point, we had a deep dish cheese, 2 different appetizers all were amazing! Definitely be back! read more

Mugsy's Hideout - Deep dish cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Murray, Kentucky

Have heard this place talked about visiting from out of town, so got around to going. Liked the size of the place. The menu is pretty varied with a lot of different categories for a local restaurant. All of our food tasted good, between me, my brother, his wife, my niece and nephew. Good waitress. read more

See all

2nd time all I can say is wish everyone could taste this fantastic food. 1 30 minute drive one way. Wish it was closer. Found another person who drives up there who works in Bemis area she lives in Paris, TN. Had Gyro sandwich (with fries included they don't cheat on the food enough to share) we had a Combo Sandwich (again fries included outstanding), then one time a large everything pan pizza. Well we brought the whole pizza home to eat as well as freeze for the next few weeks so much it reheated excellently. 2nd time we got a thin small with our splitting a Gyro with the fries and our thin small ground beef (meatball) was outstanding. Still got a box to go home with and have the next few days. Go there you won't be disappointed. read more

See all

Excellent deep dish pizza, friendly owner, casual/fun atmosphere. We drove an hour to get there.

Stopped in last Saturday for lunch. Loved the old building. Supper nice people. The food was delicious. We had Philly cheese steak and calzone. Both were hot and delicious. The service was very friendly and pretty fast considering how busy they were. read more

Mugsy's Hideout - Philly Cheese Steak - Pizza Near Me - Murray, Kentucky

See all

Had a chance to eat dinner at Mugsy's in Murray KY this past weekend and what a great time !! Very casual atmosphere the service was very good as well. And the Pizza was excellent we had the Chicago pizza supreme and a thin crust pepperoni. Both were delicious. The Chicago pizza probably the best Chicago style pizza I have had outside of Chicago. Full of onions mushrooms pepperoni and sausage lots of cheese and topped with great sauce. The thin crust nice and crispy. Plenty of street parking. If you find yourself in Murray and like Chicago pizza it is a must read more

See all

Pizza was soooo good. The leftovers we warmed up at home were even good. Our waitress was very friendly and kept up with my husband's beer refills. He drinks them fast lol. We have recommended Mugsy's to friends and will definitely be going back. read more

Mugsy's Hideout - a pepperoni pizza on a table - Pizza Near Me - Murray, Kentucky

The atmosphere was comfortable, the servers were great. But the food was not very good. The sauce on the spaghetti, and other pasta dishes we got had a spicy, red sauce. It just didn't taste good. Not spicy in a good way. It was a tangy, burn your tongue. Almost like hot unsweetened ketchup. We didn't care for it. Fun to try a new place..but it wasn't a home run for us. Probably won't go back. read more

The meat lovers pizza is amazing. Mugsy's is a must every time I'm in town. The deep dish is some of the best I've ever had too.

Love the toasted ravioli!! Great marinara sauce too! We had a pan pizza and it was so good. Terrific authentic pizza!! Our server was very helpful and friendly! They have daily specials!! Highly recommend! read more

Good food, good menu. Service was great and server was super friendly. Will definitely be back when in town.

We had pizza. It was very good! We actually ordered two different crusts and enjoyed both. Service was excellent. Nice ambiance. Enjoyed the outing. read more

Very Good!' Service was good, again the food was outstanding!!! I On the car it says iPhone speech listen for device response. Exit and bologna. It says exit. On the car it says iPhone speech. Listen for device response. Exit in bologna. It says exit on the car. The iPhone speak with supervisor. That is weird. That iPhones me know. I mean I've never. H read more

Wonderful service and even better food. We frequently visit and will continue to be customers of this establishment.

Of course when we don't know quite where we are, googling "food near me" works. Was looking for a southern BBQ joint but it was closed. Sometimes those things just work out! Good service, good food! read more

Mugsy's Hideout - 14" Thin crust meat lovers - Pizza Near Me - Murray, Kentucky

My girl friend and I are from Chicago. Mugsy's has the best Chicago style deep dish pizza in Chicago! We brought friends with us who are from Pittsburgh PA and never had deep dish pizza. They too thought is was FANTISIC! read more

I love their food, it's amazing and the employees are so nice!!! Nice atmosphere and great food for a good price and big portions!

Outstanding food and friendly staff. The deep dish pizza pie is incredible. Give them a try if you're in Murray.

Great pizza! I'm the guy that as soon as I move somewhere I start looking for the mom and pop pizza place that is above and beyond the chain pizza places. This place has awesome Chicago Style deep dish pizza. read more

Had some great pizza at Mugsy's! Kiddo had spaghetti and it was tasty! Wife had the Chicago beef and it was on point! Great service too. Will definitely return!!! read more

See all

Cute little hole on the wall downtown. Some advice, if you want a legit Chicago style pizza call and order it 30 minutes before you get there. We had it and I absolutely recommend it. One slice is plenty for almost anyone. Pizza was thicc! read more

delicious omg. everything is very very good !!! pizza is also very very good cold the next morning, pretty sure it didn't survive twelve hours in our house read more

Pizza was very greasy. We got the pan crust and had a large amount of grease on the pizza. The building is nothing fancy, but the service was great. Everyone was very friendly read more

Traveling through and found this hideaway on Yelp. Gotta say the pizza was excellent. Love the small, family feel and the service was outstanding. Positives: 1. Non-Smoking, 2. Delicious Pizza (Chicago style deep dish and thin crust), 3. Super clean, 4. TV w/ ESPN Negatives: none. read more

Hard working service. Very much local a local place. Fun, busy and wide open seating. I was solo so I didn't get a pizza. Went with the "Special" which was a ribeye sandwich with grilled onions and steamed vegs. Was standard but tasty. read more

See all

I couldn't decide what to try. I was with a big party and service was so efficient. I had the Italian Beef Sandwich, it was perfectly authentic, tasted better than the famous restaurants in Chicago. Portion sizes were more than enough with leftovers (so you get to enjoy it twice). My party shared Gyro and Italian Sausage with me. We had ravioli and the sauce was to die for. The owners are so personable and you can tell they care about the people that visit their restaurant. Can't wait to be in Murray again to try something different! read more

Family owned. I think the owners are probably in the witness relocation program (just kidding). The point I'm trying to make is that this joint is legit! Son of chicago teamsters Mugsy's crafts authentic deep dish chicago style pizza deep in the heart of Kentucky. We ordered the deep dish meat pizza it was amazing. It is much more than a pizza joint it was incredible to see people interacting across tables involved in the discourse of the day. Here at Mugsy's it really is about more than Pizza it's about community! read more

Really good pizza, great atmosphere, awesome service. Really enjoyed the baked ravioli as well. All around solid pizza restaurant.

Some of the food looked good however being from Chicago we ordered a deep dish pizza. It had lots of cheese and very little tomatoes and sausage. It was a 10" served on a 16" pizza plate so the cheese had melted all over the place. Needed way more sausage and tomatoes and a lot less cheese and served in the deep dish pan. The only other thing was the place was very very noisy. The service was very good. read more

Love this place! Amazing pizza and always great service. Me and my family go here every time they come to town to visit. They also have good salads with fresh ingredients. One of the other reviews said too noisy. This has never been a problem when I've visited and I have been there over 10 times. Again this place has delicious pizza and you should definitely try it out! read more

Stopped in while in town for work. This little place is tucked in downtown Murray...if that's what you want to call it. Haha Service was great and server was knowledgeable of the menu. The BBQ chicken pizza was by far the best BBQ chicken pizza I've ever had. Chicken was fresh grilled and seasoned perfectly. The bbq sauce was light and sweet and the bacon added the perfect amount of saltiness. If I ever make it back, I will be sure to try the pan pizza. This is an authentic Chicago style pizza joint. I was hesitant to get it because I wasn't too hungry, but I'm going to be sure to go in on an empty stomach. -1 star for not having much of a beer selection. read more

Overall good food. Dining area leaves a lot to be desired as it's dated and not well kept but the food is good and the service has always been friendly. read more

The food is great. The service is good, but during peak hours, they feel understaffed. Prices are decent. They are closed on Mondays, which makes you want it on Mondays, lol. I do enjoy early or late lunches here. read more

Back visiting mom and came back here for an annual dinner. Still amazingly great food and service. It is always nice to see a company continuously taking pride in their food and not compromise ingredients to save a buck. read more

If your looking for a great steak or even a gyro sandwich stop here !! Good food good portions great service read more

See all

Stopped by with 6 others folks nothing here invited me back!!!! Let's break it down!!!! #1 service ,SUCKS #2 menu ,their were more things marked off then what they had to offer #3 salad , Romain not fresh by the time I got rid of the brown crap their was nothing else to eat!!! #4 pizza, excellent, it's the best I've had in Murray!! This restaurant has potential the owners need to hire a food manager to manage the restaurant as well as them, no excuse for being out of product, I've been in the food service business for over 30 years nothing hurts a restaurant more then not having product and the o-well attitude . Remember owners you provide a service and you need customers to pay your bills if you don't or can't provide the service customers will find a place that can!!!!!! read more

I just ate at Mugsy's Hideout for the first time in a while. (I have been on a diet.) Mugsy's was always one of the best pizza places ever, but they have taken pizza to a whole new level! We had the 12-inch pan pizza. The crust and cheese were incredible as were the sauce and toppings. I have enjoyed all the big name pizza places in Chicago and I am no stranger to New York pizza (thus, the need for the diet) and this was absolutely the best pizza I have ever had!!! Mugsy's is located on Murray's town square, which is quaint, and across from the court house. You can usually park in front of the establishment. Most of the people who go there are locals, because the Murray State University college students seem to focus on the places near the main north-south drag (HWY 641/12th Street) rather than venturing into the downtown area. Alcoholic beverages are available, but it isn't a bar and people go there mostly for the food. read more

Great Chicago pizza! They even had Leinenkugel's on tap. It felt like I was back home. Great staff and plenty of seating. I will definitely be back! read more