Farrell's is a staple on Davis Islands, and anytime I drop in to TeBella for a matcha or tea after a morning workout, I always drop by Farrell's afterward for a bagel or a sandwich. By noon on weekdays, the bagels are always nearly gone but you still have a couple to choose from, but on weekends, they are long gone before lunch. On those days, I order their delicious egg salad sandwich on rye, and you get a choice of side. I've had their pasta salad and it's delicious, but this time I just opted for chips. And always a pickle spear! Farrell's is also well known as an ice cream shop. Though I've never tried their ice cream, while I sit in to dine, I watch many parents come through with their kiddos, grabbing a scoop or two. The interior is very lunch diner-esque. Nothing flashy or special, just comfy, easy seating to enjoy your lunch. And a friendly team happy to help. If you're a Miami Hurricanes fan, you'll love it here, as it's filled with memorabilia and orange everywhere you look. read more

Farrell's On the Island - Egg salad sandwich on rye bread - Sandwiches Near Me - Tampa, Florida

See all

Came in for a late lunch Saturday while a friend and I were in town and realized we hadn't eaten yet at 4pm. We were worried they were actually about to close down, but the workers cleaning out the bagel case assured us that the rest of the kitchen was still operating as normal. I got the Greek salad, and my friend got a veggie-less Philly cheese steak. I loved the Greek salad, and I was glad the dressing was on the side because I prefer a smaller amount of dressing than most. Jenn's Philly was exactly the way she asked, and it was delicious- she ate every bit. The interior was very similar to a typical New York deli, except with Miami football instead of Yankee gear, which made me laugh a little. The ice cream seemed to be a popular item for them- several people came in to get ice cream while we ate and talked. Overall, it seemed pretty great, but we'll be back eventually! read more

Amazing ice cream! Lots of flavors to choose from and different ones you don't see just anywhere. Before the ice cream, we had breakfast sandwiches. I thought they were not that good. I would definitely not order one again. Also, the service was not very good. The ambiance is long tables. You seat yourself and pay upfront before you eat. It was very expensive. It cost $70 for three people. I think maybe it is a tourist spot. I thought it would be different. read more

Came in with my friend to get bagels for her son. The place smelled of bagels, made me hungry even though I just ate lol. Walked up and ordered. They toasted and sliced the bagels and put the cream cheese on the side as asked. It was rather expensive for 4 bagels at $13 total. They also serve Yoders ice cream!! I'll have to come back. read more

A great stop on David Island. We wanted to get some ice cream and we definitely found the right spot. They offer Lots of delicious it's hard to make up your mind but my kids were set on cotton candy and Gator tracks. Both were super yummy with little flavor bites inside in each . Definitely will be stopping in for lunch because the food here smells amazing!! read more

See all

Fresh ingredients, made to order, and yummy selection of ice cream flavors. Nice owner. I endorse this independent business.

This a great spot on Davis Islands for a quick meal at an inexpensive price. It's a very casual place with quick service and good food. It's situated on the quaint block of Davis Islands Village with several other restaurants and shops. I had the bacon, egg, and cheese on a bagel. It was good, but the amount of eggs and bacon inside the sandwich was minimal. The hash browns are great. I would definitely try their food again. read more

Farrell's On the Island - Inside - Sandwiches Near Me - Tampa, Florida

See all

Great food! Got a Bacon Egg and cheese and was shocked at how good it was. The cashier was a nice guy and joked around while making the food. Would highly recommend if you want a breakfast sandwich. Only downside is the decor, the restaurant is crowded with Miami Dolphins memorabilia. This is Tampa, put some Bucs stuff up! read more

Wonderful service and food! Not from here, so glad we found this one. Light lunch - and they offer ice cream!

Nice "All about the U" Miami Hurricane sports deli and ice cream shoppe. Kindof a strange combo, but it worked for me and my family. They have inside and outside seating and are very pet friendly. They even have a fresh baked pup cookie for sale. The staff was very friendly and the service was quick. We ordered at the counter from the menu posted on the wall behind the counter. All of the items were clearly described, and the guy behind the counter explained all additional options. GET THE FRIES! Small upchage, but they reminded me of the days of hot fries at the Bashore Little League ball fields a block away, as a kid. We tried a few different sandwiches, and we were all thrilled what what we ate. My Miami Cuban Sandwich was delicious even though it was not on Cuban Bread, and it did not have pickles in it. The club sandwich was huge and full of fresh turkey, ham, and bacon. The Tuna salad sandwich was fresh and filled with a giant scoop layered on tomato and lettuce between super soft bread. The other star of the meal was the fresh pasta salad. This is definitely someone's mom's recipe. In all, I really liked this place and can recommend it for a great sandwich to eat in or take out. I didn't try the ice cream but next time, for sure. read more

See all

It's great to have healthy options to order at Farrell's. My go-to option - a Greek salad - add chicken. read more

See all

Sandwich and salad was very plain. Portions were good, but very pricey for the quality.

I'll be honest, I initially stopped in here just because of the University of Miami flags in the windows! But I'm so glad I did, because their ice cream was awesome. I'm a proud Hurricanes fan and alum -- it feels like I'm one of the few in Tampa. So when I saw the UM decor (and was in the mood for ice cream), I figured it was just meant to be. I walked in to see an impressive amount of Canes memorabilia on the walls and in display cases. Might not mean much to most of the people in Tampa, but I sure got a kick out of it. In fact, the owner told me he put the flag up when he first took over the location, only to have a man stick his head in the door and tell him he'd never stay in business with the UM flag on display. So naturally, the owner went and bought another flag to put up on the other window, haha. Okay, so the ice cream! They have a good selection to choose from, and you can try as many flavors as you like. You can even combine flavors in their smallest size. I tried the chocolate fudge brownie and the toasted coconut -- and even though I didn't think the two would go together, I got a small cup with those two flavors. Turns out it tastes like a Mounds bar! The ice cream is great quality and much better than some other places around town I've tried. I can't wait to come back and try their food -- and naturally have more ice cream for dessert! read more

See all

Great place to stop by for breakfast. The western sandwich on a croissant was the best I ever had. Friendly service reasonable prices Will definitely be returning read more

The younger looking lady with the black hair and tattoos is extremely rude and arrogant giving extra attitude at the cash register and eventually leaving don't know if someone pissed in her cereal this morning but she was completely unprofessional and rode I will never come back here because of this lady and the older taller white gentleman who was also rude. Completely unexceptionable read more

always a tradition in getting icecream during a trip to davis islands. most of the usual icecream shops i went to as a kid are no longer there so i was surprised that this place had icecream along with lunch like sandwiches. the icecream was very creamy and was perfect on a nice fl summer hot day. not a bad price too for a good scoop. read more

Farrell's On the Island - Sandwiches Near Me - Tampa, Florida

See all

This place is my go-to for Greek salad in all of Tampa bay. The potato salad is a wonderful addition and I don't care that it's not authentic. Service can be a little on the slow side but the food is worth the wait. read more

I like that I can walk and order a yummy sandwich. Love the service and The Italian melt is my favorite.

Each time I've come here, the front and back staffers have been the most congenial and professional young adults. It really feels like they have a purpose and fulfill it willingly. A big pro is having scoops available at the same counter so we can prepay for ice cream sundaes while they bring out dinner...effectively killing two birds and all. It all feels like Americana defined by millennials who are run by folks keeping it decidedly old school. Prices are great for the area and if you can stomach Don Shula or Dan Marino, let's sit streetside and wait for Derek Jeter to walk by. Would be 5-star if they just didn't run out of menu items. read more

Farrell's On the Island - Menu 1/27/20 - Sandwiches Near Me - Tampa, Florida

See all

I eat here every day I can it's so good. Owner, even though he's a die hard Miami fan, is very nice, along with the rest of the staff. Give their "Lil 'B" a try if you like loaded bagels. read more

Man, it's just plain slow. I'm on lunch break coming to a local restaurant and it took 40 minutes to get my 1 sandwich out. The place was not busy, the food itself is fine but nothing special. People who came in after me and ordered got their food sooner but no visible reason. Not coming here again. I don't recommend if you value your time at all. read more

Prices were insanely low for how amazing it is! Bagel egg and cheese is a must here. Place is decorated really cool with a bunch of Miami Hurricane memorabilia. read more

Been here a few times. This last time was definitely lacking in friendly service. I came to order and sit outside with my small dog. From the dog beach. Immediately instead of a hello "can I ask you to keep the dog outside mam" mind you, there are no signs on this business that's say animals not allowed...asked if I could order first and with attitude said okay.I ordered and sat. When the employee brought my order out, he dropped it with no words and walked away. I doubt I'll re visit. Food is decent read more

This is such a great, casual place for breakfast and lunch. My favorite is the veggie melt. The service is always friendly and quick. Prices are very good. Don't forget to treat yourself to some ice cream before you leave. read more

Great spot for yummy breakfast or lunch sandwiches and delicious ice cream. Been coming here for nearly a decade and they never disappoint. The owner is a nice guy Oh and for people complaining about not being able to bring their dogs INSIDE, you do know the health department takes that seriously right? I used to work at a restaurant and those inspectors can come at any time. I see dogs outside all the time with no problems. read more

I've been here a few times. I find the food to be very greasy, so I won't eat their hot sandwiches again. However, they have Working Cow ice cream. So if I'm in the area and want dessert, this is as good a choice as any. read more

EXCELLENT if you looking for a good Cuban stop here! Just driving by to the beach and decided to stop here so glad we did!! Clean atmosphere, and they're open all day!! Bathrooms kept great and the blonde man behind the counter super respectful and sweet!! Will be coming back !! read more

We just stumbled on this very cute restaurant on Davis Island while exploring. They have a wide selection of beverages, from coffee to milk shakes. The salads are huge. The sandwiches are hand made to order. There are high top, regular tables and comfy chairs. you can even eat outside. There is a selection of ice creams that I will have to try when I return here in 2 weeks. read more

The worst customer service! Watch out for the up-charges! They made a mistake, and they asked me to pay.

The food is good, the go-to for a sandwich or ice cream on DI, reliable place. If you're a UMiami fan and enjoy Fox News being blasted into your ears as you wait the 15-45 minutes for your order, it's the jam. read more

Farrell's is definitey a staple on DI, and I've been there plenty of times. I can't say its bad, but I also can't say its one of my favorites. Its serves the basics of ice cream (which is all you need sometimes) and sandwhiches. Its simple, which is good. The staff is always friendly and the service is always fast. read more

Farrell's is great! Everyone goes crazy for their bagels and hot breakfast sandwiches, which means they're typically sold out of their top bagel choices by 11am, since they keep them fresh. Also, their bacon is the best I've ever had. Everyone there is really friendly and it's well priced (ahem, looking at you DI coffee). It's got a solid menu, but the Greek salad is exceptional for a deli. Plus, they have the best ICE CREAM. It's the same brand at the Don Cesar and it's decadent. read more

I was surprised that I was the only one in the restaurant. I like the white variety of things I saw on the menu. And the food arrived surprisingly fast. I thought because the size of my order was large that it will take them some time. But it didn't. The service there was congenial and professional and fast. The food was top-notch. The serving sizes were generous. The atmosphere was pleasant. I will be back. read more

Casey Melt and the Italian Melt!!!! Best French fries in the world. Quick and efficient service!

Great bagels early in the morning good coffee staff is very nice. Good place to have breakfast with family.

Perfect spot to grab some homemade ice cream on Davis island. After a visit to the dog park, the kids and I like to make a quick stop here to grab some delicious treats. They have so many flavors to choose from and the prices are reasonable. During my last visit I noticed that I was overcharged for our desserts and management was kind enough to give a future credit for our next visit. read more

Decided to stop by here after having dinner and walking to our car. From the sports decor to the "average" ice cream shop feel, didn't look like it would be a frequent stop. Buy hold the cone,... Thaler ice cream is awesome! Hubs and I were full from dinner so decided to get only 1 cup. But we wanted to try different flavors. Not thinking they'd accommodate, I asked if we could have two different flavors in one cup...they said yes! Good price for the cup too. So we decided to eat it outside as it was a gorgeous night, and we LOVED both our flavors. This little gem may not be a lot to look at, but I'm coming back for the ice cream. They had other sandwich shop items on the menu but I can't speak to those as this was an impromptu ice cream visit. I'm rating on deliciousness, price and friendliness... 5 stars for this little homey sporty ice cream shop =) read more

Farrell's is an institution. I've been coming here since I first lived on Davis Island years ago. I have since moved away; but I will continue to come back to Farrell's for quickly served comfort food. They always get my order correct, hot, and fast! read more

My husband and I stopped by for ice cream to go while on a walk with our little dog. I had him in my arms but was scolded by a man washing windows. We are DI residents but will not return. You'd expect a little place like this in a dog friendly area to have more flexibility. Every other venue on the island is accepting of dogs, especially when they're harmlessly in someone's arms. I wasn't even going to touch anything. Also the food is sub-par but we go sometimes just out of convenience due to its close proximity. read more

Took my family for a nice Saturday lunch and I've never watched a sandwich made with such spite. Throwing meat and bread on the counter. Some of the food was burnt. Waited 20 -30 minutes for burnt food to come out. Owner or manager was understanding but customer service and care was lacking. I'm sure it's not that bad regularly and I hope this nice small town place has some employees that care and take pride in their job. read more