Krystina Did an amazing job making my vision into reality. I explained I wanted a express MTA bus with certain details added to the bus. The cake was beyond what I expected. I absolutely loved the cake. My guest couldn't stop talking about how real the bus looked. It also was so delicious! Krystina is very professional and quick to respond to any messages I sent. I highly recommend her services. read more

Amazing! The cake was better than ever even imagined. My son absolutely loved it. Thank you for making my sons 21st birthday so special read more

Fancy Cakes - Bakeries Near Me - Freehold, New Jersey

See all

I had a 60th birthday for my wife and didn't realize how long in advance I needed to order a cake. I called Fancy Cake and in 4 days they were able to make the most beautiful delicious cake. It was definitely the highlight of the party that she will never forget. I would definitely recommend Fancy Cakesin Freehold. read more

Look no further than this review. Fancy Cakes is a team of extremely talented and dedicated bakers. They provided desserts for my engagement party and bridal shower - and both times knocked it out of the park. Everyone has said it was not only the best cake they've ever had, but the most beautiful one as well. Krystina and her team made my dreams come true with the dessert display at my bridal shower. From macaroons, cake pops, cupcakes, cookies, and chocolate covered Oreos - rounded out with the most gorgeous cake I've ever seen! I will forever be using Fancy Cakes for every occasion moving forward. read more

See all

My first experience wasn't great here but the owner reached out and asked if she can remake the cupcakes for me. She let me taste the Oreo and cannoli icing in store and it was night and day from what I had my first time. The cupcakes were so delicious. The icing is fluffy and the cake is dense. The red velvet cupcake has raspberry preserves in it which is such a nice touch. The Saturday I came in was just a bad batch, and the actual cupcakes are delicious. Happily will be ordering cakes from here! Especially since the pricing is so reasonable for cakes. If you prefer brownies over cake, their iced brownies are massive and addicting. Genuinely a hidden gem of a small business that really cares about their customers and product! read more

Fancy Cakes - Oreo cupcake - Bakeries Near Me - Freehold, New Jersey

See all

Krystina made me a beautiful and delicious 50th birthday cake. Everyone was so impressed. She was so easy to work with and the cake was exactly what I had in mind. read more

Fancy Cakes - a cake on a table in a restaurant - Bakeries Near Me - Freehold, New Jersey

Review on the cupcakes only. I came in to pick some cupcakes and got a bunch. There were a few creative flavors and they were decent. I found the cake part to be a little dry. There is a good amount of frosting on it and you can see they know how to decorate. Seems to be more of a custom cake type place so I would give it a try for that. read more

we were extreme pleased with Fancy Cakes and would highly recommend. communication was swift and easy. Kristina was a pleasure to work with and made our dream come to life. Besides the cake looking amazing - it tasted terrific read more

We love Fancy Cakes! Our daughter is allergic to tree nuts and their cakes are nut-free. All of our cakes, including for large family events have come from there. They even have cupcakes if you want a quick treat. read more

From getting the quote to delivering the cake they were responsive and professional. They worked with my budget and the cake not only looked fabulous, it was delicious. Everyone complimented ms and wanted the name. I highly recommend them! read more

Fancy Cakes - Beautiful bridal shower cake - Bakeries Near Me - Freehold, New Jersey

Hands down, best tasting fondant cake for our daughter's Sweet 16! Fondant cakes tend to only look good so I was pleasantly surprised when guests were telling me how good the cake tasted. I don't normally eat cake but I had to try it for myself! The raspberry mousse filling was delicious. I will definitely be placing future orders! Thank you again for your professionalism, delicious cake and making our daughter's sweet that much sweeter! read more

Fancy Cakes - Bakeries Near Me - Freehold, New Jersey

We are from out of town and planning our daughter's 3rd birthday in NJ. After reading all the terrific reviews for Fancy Cakes we decide to get her cake through them. Initially she wanted a unicorn cake, but when she then decided she wanted a mermaid cake I was hopeful they could help with this wishy washy toddler! They did not disappoint!!! Not only was her mermaid themed unicorn cake beautiful, it tasted amazing!!! I highly recommend using them for any occasion. They were great to work with and made payment and pick up very convenient. Thank you so much for making our little girl's day extra special! read more

Fancy Cakes - a unicorn cake with pastel decorations - Bakeries Near Me - Freehold, New Jersey

See all

Great cake made for our 50th birthday party. Everyone said how fully and declines the strawberry filing was. I also had tons of people asking me where I got it from. read more

Fancy Cakes - Bakeries Near Me - Freehold, New Jersey

Krystina did an amazing job with my cake!!! I needed a Kosher two tiered cake last minute for a special client, and she made it happen with zero hassle. The cake was absolutely gorgeous. I will be hiring her again soon. read more

Fancy Cakes - Two tier cake. - Bakeries Near Me - Freehold, New Jersey

Incredible cake designer! I worked with this bakery for my sister's bridal shower and they exceeded my expectations! Beyond stunning is how I would describe the cake and beyond delicious! I loved working with the team - they listened to what I wanted to accomplish for the shower and showed them pictures and Krystina blew me and all the guests away! Best experience and I can't say thank you enough! Highly recommend - you will not be disappointed! read more

See all

Krystina and her team were a pleasure to work with for our Nov. 11, 2017 wedding. Our venue was strictly kosher, and did not offer wedding cakes through their in-house caterer, but it was our wedding, and we just couldn't give up the idea of cutting into a big, beautiful, tiered cake. Enter Fancy Cakes! Krystina went out of her way to accommodate a complimentary cake tasting at a location near us, and then provided a second round of tasting for a few additional flavors we were interested in trying. There were a number of yummy flavor options available, and we were able to select two different cake/filling combinations for our three-tiered cake. She did a really lovely job of bringing our vision to life with a simple, three-tiered square cake, with edible succulents and branches to match our floral decor. And most importantly, we've heard not-so-great things about pareve (dairy-free) cakes in general, but hers was delish! She coordinated drop off with our venue manager, and everything was stress-free and taken care of on our big day. Would definitely recommend Fancy Cakes for your special event (and everyday) cake needs! read more

Fancy Cakes - Bakeries Near Me - Freehold, New Jersey

So embarrassed for a friend who came for dinner last night and brought beautiful cupcakes from Fancy Cakes. Unfortunately they looked good but tasted awful. We have never had drier cupcakes. All four were inedible and went in the trash. Surely these were not cheap, we felt so bad for her. read more

I stopped in to pick up a ready made cake for my daughters birthday. The staff were super helpful and accommodating. The cake was decorated absolutely beautifully! I was very excited until we ate the cake. It was dry and crumbly and overly sweet. $45 and no one ate it other than a first bite or two. I won't be going back read more

Service was great but the cupcakes were dry. My kids asked if I got them from Walmart. Ugh money wasted

I got my son's birthday cake from Fancy Cakes. Not only did the cake absolutely look amazing, with all the details done to perfection, the cake was one of the best tasting cakes I have ever have. As someone that is new to the area, I now have my go to person for any cake. I would highly recommend Fancy Cakes to anyone. Absolutely amazing! read more

Fancy Cakes - Disney's Coco Themed Birthday Cake - Bakeries Near Me - Freehold, New Jersey

Krystina is so nice and makes the prettiest and most delicious cakes. I've gone back several times for her to make a cake whenever I have a special event. read more

upon, ordering cookies from Fancy Cakes of Freehold NJ the staff was exceptional and the cookies we received were absolutely awesome and fit the theme perfectly. Krystina and her team paid attention to detail and the cookies tasted great. I highly recommend this bake shop. read more

Beautiful and delicious custom cake for graduation. Big personalized cookie take-aways were also perfect. This is a wonderful bakery run by professionals. Thrilled with the results. read more

Fancy Cakes - Fancy Cakes - Bakeries Near Me - Freehold, New Jersey

See all

The cake turned out amazing. So much better then what I thought it would. Not only did it look awesome but it tasted great. I got so many compliments on it. I will never go any place else for a cake. Thank you Fancy Cakes. read more

Fancy Cakes - Bakeries Near Me - Freehold, New Jersey

Hi all! I just wanted to share photos of this amazing creation with you and rave about the wonder that is Fancy Cakes in Freehold. About a week ago my family celebrated 6 occasions in one party (once and done!) and I needed a cake to represent all that. I met with owner/artist Krystina Gianaris a few weeks ahead to talk about each person and event being celebrated (sweet 16, HS Graduation and 18th bday, 25th Anniversary, 50th and 75th bdays, housewarming) and she designed this wonderful 4-tiered cake for us! In no way did she sacrifice taste for style: every cake was different, the flavors were amazing. My family was stunned, and I could not have been more thrilled. I'm still wow-ing about it and had to post If you need a special occasion cake -- please call Fancy Cakes!! read more

See all

Krystin worked within our budget and quite frankly when we saw the cake I could not believe we only spent that much! It looked alot more expensive! Plus it was absolutely beautiful and the cake was delicious. It id not taste frozen at all! I am glad the other bakery we were going to with were not accepting orders. Fancy Cakes really out did our expectations. I would definitely recommend. read more

I've known Krystina for years and trusted her from day one. I can throw out a ton of ideas at her and she knows exactly what visions I'm looking for and the style of cake or dessert I want. I never have to worry because I know that whatever I order is going to look amazing and taste even better! Without a doubt one of the best cake shops in NJ - Krystina and team are creative and talented and stay in tune with trends and know how to provide delicious classic desserts! I just recently had a Beyonce themed first birthday for my daughter and guests are still talking about the cookies and cake- so good! Stress free service too! read more

See all

Just bought cupcakes...they look amazing!! We can't wait to try them!! Also, they were so kind!!

I love everything I ordered-flavor wedding cake and bridal shower baby shower yum yum

Krystina and her team created a one of a kind confectioners masterpiece of a cake for our wedding at the Crystal Plaza. We planted a seed of a. Idea and they ran with it. Perfectly executed, very detail oriented. Cake tasting was delightful and thorough. They actually take the time to go through every flavor combo out there. We froze our cake and will be indulging in it next year!! Best cake shop out there. read more

The cake looked very nice but it was tasteless dry and old and it wasn't worth the money we paid.

I ordered cupcakes, cake pops, favor cookies and a custom two tiered cake for my sister's bridal shower. All Harry Potter themed and with specific designs in mind that I sent to the baker and she printed to add to the order. I will start with what was good: the cookies and cupcakes looked perfect! However, the cake was extremely less detailed than what I asked for and the castle was completely different than the design we discussed. In the consultation when I asked if she could do the bottom two tiers of a design she looked up the exact mold for the castle and said bc it was a mold she did not need to charge extra. Therefore, I never thought that would change at all! We even discussed a flower detail that is in the photo and I indicated I wanted it. The cake had no flower detail at all. The snitch cake pops l showed her, she said she could make were completely different than what I received. In fact the design I received was one that caused me to not hire a different shop. I could make that on my own and would not have purchased them from her if I knew that was what I was receiving. There was no point in complaining because she can't make new cake pops or a cake day of the shower. I will say this as a positive for customer service: when we realized she did not make any gluten free cupcakes or cake pops as ordered, she did return with some gluten free cupcakes with normal frosting. I wish I could add photos to show the disparity between what I ordered and what I received for the cake and cake pops. I will not be purchasing a cake from here again. It's a shame because the taste was very good. read more

Fancy cakes makes the most amazing desserts! They are second to none! From custom cakes to cupcakes and cookies plus more you should not miss the opportunity to delve into the world of fancy cakes deliciousness. read more