Mi Zarape is one of only a few 'authentic' Mexican restaurants in Livingston County. Located at the back of a strip style shopping center off Grand River in Brighton, there is a surprising amount of character inside. The walls are each a different bright color, as are the tables and they play Mexican music at a slightly louder than necessary volume. Parking is plentiful and convenient.
They have a large menu with typical Mexican offerings: burritos, chimichangas, tacos etc. They offer seafood options of most types of food, which is different than many of the other local Mexican places.
My husband and I have been to Mi Zarape 3 times. The first time was perfect - we went at dinner time on a Sunday evening. There was no wait, it wasn't crowded, our food came quickly and our service was great. The food tasted fresh and the portions were large.
The second time we came was for lunch. It was a Saturday afternoon and we ordered from the lunch menu. Our server was very brief with us, initially, so the service right away left something to be desired, though I assumed it was a language-barrier issue.
I ordered a shrimp quesadilla, and when they brought it out it was HUGE. The server sat both of our meals down and then looked at me and said 'you ordered the lunch portion, didn't you?' and I said yes. He proceeded to pick my plate up and walk away. No explanation, nothing. My husband was finished with his food before the server returned with a smaller version of mine, which was poorly put together and had only 3 shrimp in it. I was not thrilled with this experience, obviously, and would have been fine with never returning.
Unfortunately, my husband loves their Taquitos, so we went again last night, which was a Tuesday. We were greeted by a friendly person at the door, sat and ordered quickly. They brought us chips and salsa, which we nibbled while we waited for our entrées. The salsa is quite good, the chips are too thick and too bland for me. Not convinced that they are homemade.
Our food came quickly and was accurate. The food was flavorful and plentiful. My husband ordered his favorite, Taquitos Mexicanos, which is 2 beef and 2 chicken taquitos and couldn't have been happier. He rated it 8/10. I tried for the shrimp quesadilla again and swapped the rice for refried beans. I give it a 5. Again, the flavors were good, but it wasn't really a quesadilla - it was more like an unwrapped burrito or a fajita - lots of tomatoes and onions and peppers. There were only a few shrimp in it, and almost no cheese. Also, the refried beans were gray and pasty.
We'll probably end up coming again, but only when my husband picks the place. read more